Interesting Speeding Defence
Discussion
Here's a novel defence for a speeding fine taken from the letters page of the Cambridge Evening News yesterday. The letter was in response to a previous article which suggested that this guy was trying to avoid taking the points and fine having been nabbed for 41 mph in a 30 mph limit in Peterborough. It's a journey he does regularly with his wife, and they share the driving from one day to the next. His response (below) is truly marvelous:
"I am not trying to avoid a speeding ticket as you suggest - we were doing 41mph in a 30mph limit, for which we are sorry (we thought it was a 40mph area); I have admitted this. The point you seem unable to grasp is that I have also offered to pay the fine and take the points. Anita (my Wife) is willing to do the same - it is the Cambridgeshire Constabulary - yes that's right, the one that claims to be short of money and resources, that is wasting both time and money by refusing to accept our offer of payment and points.
I did not plead "not guilty" to speeding as you suggest - I was unable to plead because the Cambridgeshire police could not, or would not, tell me who was driving the car. And please note that it was over a month and 3,000 driven miles (sharing the driving) before the police contacted us about the 41mph. So the police broke their own time limit - a fact of little interest to the magistrates.
I pleaded "not guilty" to withholding the name of the driver - I did not withhold the name of the driver, I gave them both our names as possibilities - which is apparently a crime. So now I have to go for "trial" apparently, can you believe it?
You will be aware, of course, that all this is called "the rule of law". Doesn't it make you proud to be British?
PS: Please ask your readers to ensure they keep a record of who was driving whenever they go to Peterborough."
"I am not trying to avoid a speeding ticket as you suggest - we were doing 41mph in a 30mph limit, for which we are sorry (we thought it was a 40mph area); I have admitted this. The point you seem unable to grasp is that I have also offered to pay the fine and take the points. Anita (my Wife) is willing to do the same - it is the Cambridgeshire Constabulary - yes that's right, the one that claims to be short of money and resources, that is wasting both time and money by refusing to accept our offer of payment and points.
I did not plead "not guilty" to speeding as you suggest - I was unable to plead because the Cambridgeshire police could not, or would not, tell me who was driving the car. And please note that it was over a month and 3,000 driven miles (sharing the driving) before the police contacted us about the 41mph. So the police broke their own time limit - a fact of little interest to the magistrates.
I pleaded "not guilty" to withholding the name of the driver - I did not withhold the name of the driver, I gave them both our names as possibilities - which is apparently a crime. So now I have to go for "trial" apparently, can you believe it?
You will be aware, of course, that all this is called "the rule of law". Doesn't it make you proud to be British?
PS: Please ask your readers to ensure they keep a record of who was driving whenever they go to Peterborough."
Lugs said:
Here's a novel defence for a speeding fine taken from the letters page of the Cambridge Evening News yesterday. The letter was in response to a previous article which suggested that this guy was trying to avoid taking the points and fine having been nabbed for 41 mph in a 30 mph limit in Peterborough. It's a journey he does regularly with his wife, and they share the driving from one day to the next. His response (below) is truly marvelous:
"I am not trying to avoid a speeding ticket as you suggest - we were doing 41mph in a 30mph limit, for which we are sorry (we thought it was a 40mph area); I have admitted this. The point you seem unable to grasp is that I have also offered to pay the fine and take the points. Anita (my Wife) is willing to do the same - it is the Cambridgeshire Constabulary - yes that's right, the one that claims to be short of money and resources, that is wasting both time and money by refusing to accept our offer of payment and points.
I did not plead "not guilty" to speeding as you suggest - I was unable to plead because the Cambridgeshire police could not, or would not, tell me who was driving the car. And please note that it was over a month and 3,000 driven miles (sharing the driving) before the police contacted us about the 41mph. So the police broke their own time limit - a fact of little interest to the magistrates.
I pleaded "not guilty" to withholding the name of the driver - I did not withhold the name of the driver, I gave them both our names as possibilities - which is apparently a crime. So now I have to go for "trial" apparently, can you believe it?
You will be aware, of course, that all this is called "the rule of law". Doesn't it make you proud to be British?
PS: Please ask your readers to ensure they keep a record of who was driving whenever they go to Peterborough."
I do hope your comment about his reply being truly marvelous is said with a considerable amount of irony. I feel that his response is perfectly reasonable. Both of our cars are insured for both myself and my wife to drive, we often share the driving, and if you asked me to state who was driving one of our cars, at a particular time, over a month ago, I may not be able to tell you with any certainty."I am not trying to avoid a speeding ticket as you suggest - we were doing 41mph in a 30mph limit, for which we are sorry (we thought it was a 40mph area); I have admitted this. The point you seem unable to grasp is that I have also offered to pay the fine and take the points. Anita (my Wife) is willing to do the same - it is the Cambridgeshire Constabulary - yes that's right, the one that claims to be short of money and resources, that is wasting both time and money by refusing to accept our offer of payment and points.
I did not plead "not guilty" to speeding as you suggest - I was unable to plead because the Cambridgeshire police could not, or would not, tell me who was driving the car. And please note that it was over a month and 3,000 driven miles (sharing the driving) before the police contacted us about the 41mph. So the police broke their own time limit - a fact of little interest to the magistrates.
I pleaded "not guilty" to withholding the name of the driver - I did not withhold the name of the driver, I gave them both our names as possibilities - which is apparently a crime. So now I have to go for "trial" apparently, can you believe it?
You will be aware, of course, that all this is called "the rule of law". Doesn't it make you proud to be British?
PS: Please ask your readers to ensure they keep a record of who was driving whenever they go to Peterborough."
A colleague of mine informed me of this defence being used a few years ago in our area.
As I recall it ended with both husband and wife going to court and swearing that both believed it was them and that both wished to plead guilty.
The local Magistrates let them both off as could not convict both of the offence and no evidence to support which was the guilty party.
I am surprised this loophole had not been closed, or maybe it has. I see it hasn't been fully heard yet.
As I recall it ended with both husband and wife going to court and swearing that both believed it was them and that both wished to plead guilty.
The local Magistrates let them both off as could not convict both of the offence and no evidence to support which was the guilty party.
I am surprised this loophole had not been closed, or maybe it has. I see it hasn't been fully heard yet.
Lugs said:
Here's a novel defence for a speeding fine taken from the letters page of the Cambridge Evening News yesterday. The letter was in response to a previous article which suggested that this guy was trying to avoid taking the points and fine having been nabbed for 41 mph in a 30 mph limit in Peterborough. It's a journey he does regularly with his wife, and they share the driving from one day to the next. His response (below) is truly marvelous:
"I am not trying to avoid a speeding ticket as you suggest - we were doing 41mph in a 30mph limit, for which we are sorry (we thought it was a 40mph area); I have admitted this. The point you seem unable to grasp is that I have also offered to pay the fine and take the points. Anita (my Wife) is willing to do the same - it is the Cambridgeshire Constabulary - yes that's right, the one that claims to be short of money and resources, that is wasting both time and money by refusing to accept our offer of payment and points.
I did not plead "not guilty" to speeding as you suggest - I was unable to plead because the Cambridgeshire police could not, or would not, tell me who was driving the car. And please note that it was over a month and 3,000 driven miles (sharing the driving) before the police contacted us about the 41mph. So the police broke their own time limit - a fact of little interest to the magistrates.
I pleaded "not guilty" to withholding the name of the driver - I did not withhold the name of the driver, I gave them both our names as possibilities - which is apparently a crime. So now I have to go for "trial" apparently, can you believe it?
You will be aware, of course, that all this is called "the rule of law". Doesn't it make you proud to be British?
PS: Please ask your readers to ensure they keep a record of who was driving whenever they go to Peterborough."
If you wrote the original letter and happen to read this please PM me and i'll happily buy you a pint!"I am not trying to avoid a speeding ticket as you suggest - we were doing 41mph in a 30mph limit, for which we are sorry (we thought it was a 40mph area); I have admitted this. The point you seem unable to grasp is that I have also offered to pay the fine and take the points. Anita (my Wife) is willing to do the same - it is the Cambridgeshire Constabulary - yes that's right, the one that claims to be short of money and resources, that is wasting both time and money by refusing to accept our offer of payment and points.
I did not plead "not guilty" to speeding as you suggest - I was unable to plead because the Cambridgeshire police could not, or would not, tell me who was driving the car. And please note that it was over a month and 3,000 driven miles (sharing the driving) before the police contacted us about the 41mph. So the police broke their own time limit - a fact of little interest to the magistrates.
I pleaded "not guilty" to withholding the name of the driver - I did not withhold the name of the driver, I gave them both our names as possibilities - which is apparently a crime. So now I have to go for "trial" apparently, can you believe it?
You will be aware, of course, that all this is called "the rule of law". Doesn't it make you proud to be British?
PS: Please ask your readers to ensure they keep a record of who was driving whenever they go to Peterborough."
Lugs said:
What's novel? Simple - I've never come across anyone using this defence before. I've certainly seen a number claiming they don't know who was driving, but never seen a defence where two people are arguing they should each take the points!
It happned to a friends parents once. Drove from Newcastle to Bristol and got nabbed doing 90 ish by a camera on a bridge on the motorway. They swapped driving twice on the journey, and couldn't say who was driving - because the police wouldn't say where the camera was (they knew where they had swapped drivers). Went to court and was thrown out due to lack of evidence on the side of the Camera people.Edited by Lugs on Tuesday 11th March 20:10
bluepolarbear said:
What's novel about it? Standard process. If you don't know who was driving you don't but it will always go to court as only a judge can decide whether you really don't know.
You are missing the point here.This is not standard process, neither is it a defence. How can it be a defence when both the registered keeper and the alternative driver have admitted the offence and are willing to pay the penalty?
The case should never have been near a court of law; the system is flawed as there is no allowance for this kind of dilemna, a dilemna brought about by the mere existence of enforcement using cameras, and entities like the CJU refusing to acknowledge the sheer injustice in such a system.
If the evidence is unclear or does not exist, the case should automatically be dropped.
Hidden in there is the point that it was a month before he received the NIP "but the magistrates don't care". Really don't care? Or was it a company car? Either this is sufficient in itself to annul the case, or he's being disingenuous about it. If the latter, then I wonder how true the rest of his case is?
Nevertheless, it's fun and if he can honestly state in court that he doesn't know who was driving then he ought to be found NG.
Nevertheless, it's fun and if he can honestly state in court that he doesn't know who was driving then he ought to be found NG.
Guybrush said:
The law isn't daft and it isn't a loophole. Think of the alternative, which of course the government would like very much. ... a fine and points "just in case you were the driver".
I disagree - of course the law is daft. How on earth can you argue otherwise when two people accept they broke the law; accept that one of them is due fines and points; and accept one of them was driving at the time, yet the prosecuting authority will not say who they will prosecute so they'll both be dragged through the court? In their own time and at their own expense too! To paraphrase -'the law, sir, is an ass'.Whatsmore, the alternative you refer to is already in place. If you don't know who was driving then the registered keeper automatically gets the points and fine 'just in case'! In the case of a Company Car then the default is that the Company secretary gets the fine and points!! So go on, tell me how that's not daft (I'm tempted to replace 'daft' with 'corrupt')
Lugs said:
Guybrush said:
The law isn't daft and it isn't a loophole. Think of the alternative, which of course the government would like very much. ... a fine and points "just in case you were the driver".
I disagree - of course the law is daft. How on earth can you argue otherwise when two people accept they broke the law; accept that one of them is due fines and points; and accept one of them was driving at the time, yet the prosecuting authority will not say who they will prosecute so they'll both be dragged through the court? In their own time and at their own expense too! To paraphrase -'the law, sir, is an ass'.Whatsmore, the alternative you refer to is already in place. If you don't know who was driving then the registered keeper automatically gets the points and fine 'just in case'! In the case of a Company Car then the default is that the Company secretary gets the fine and points!! So go on, tell me how that's not daft (I'm tempted to replace 'daft' with 'corrupt')
Cases like this where it is honestly not known who is driving highlight the flaw of automated speed enforcement, if you exceed the speedlimit by mistake then chances are you don't know exactly where you are in relation to whatever local road or landmarks they use to define the location, bare in mind the location has to be fairly accurately defined otherwise a vague locus defense is possible.
Lugs said:
Guybrush said:
The law isn't daft and it isn't a loophole. Think of the alternative, which of course the government would like very much. ... a fine and points "just in case you were the driver".
I disagree - of course the law is daft. How on earth can you argue otherwise when two people accept they broke the law; accept that one of them is due fines and points; and accept one of them was driving at the time, yet the prosecuting authority will not say who they will prosecute so they'll both be dragged through the court? In their own time and at their own expense too! To paraphrase -'the law, sir, is an ass'.Whatsmore, the alternative you refer to is already in place. If you don't know who was driving then the registered keeper automatically gets the points and fine 'just in case'! In the case of a Company Car then the default is that the Company secretary gets the fine and points!! So go on, tell me how that's not daft (I'm tempted to replace 'daft' with 'corrupt')
What the law says is :
[i]S172 (2) Where the driver of a vehicle is alleged to be guilty of an offence to which this section applies—
(a) the person keeping the vehicle shall give such information as to the identity of the driver as he may be required to give by or on behalf of a chief officer of police, and.......
(b) any other person shall if required as stated above give any information which it is in his power to give and may lead to identification of the driver.
(3) Subject to the following provisions, a person who fails to comply with a requirement under subsection (2) above shall be guilty of an offence.
(4) A person shall not be guilty of an offence by virtue of paragraph (a) of subsection (2) above if he shows that he did not know and could not with reasonable diligence have ascertained who the driver of the vehicle was. [/i]
If the registered keeper can persuade the court that he used reasonable diligence really did not know who was driving but it was one of 2, 3 or more people, all named, and the Scumera partnership/Police cannot come up with any evidence to narrow this down then a conviction cannot be automatic. I have a couple of mags of my acquaintance who truly believe that no-one could not have known who was driving at any time. I have pointed out that they lead err simple lives and have little else to occupy their memories and that one of them was not even aware of the Scumera van when she was cought exceeding a 30 limit but ....there we are.
as for a Company section 5 applies which says
(5) Where a body corporate is guilty of an offence under this section and the offence is proved to have been committed with the consent or connivance of, or to be attributable to neglect on the part of, a director, manager, secretary or other similar officer of the body corporate, or a person who was purporting to act in any such capacity, he, as well as the body corporate, is guilty of that offence and liable to be proceeded against and punished accordingly
So basically consent or connivance or neglect has to be proved beyond reasonable doubt before any director or officer gets the points !
Edited by Richard C on Thursday 13th March 12:44
Engineer1 said:
Lugs said:
Guybrush said:
The law isn't daft and it isn't a loophole. Think of the alternative, which of course the government would like very much. ... a fine and points "just in case you were the driver".
I disagree - of course the law is daft. How on earth can you argue otherwise when two people accept they broke the law; accept that one of them is due fines and points; and accept one of them was driving at the time, yet the prosecuting authority will not say who they will prosecute so they'll both be dragged through the court? In their own time and at their own expense too! To paraphrase -'the law, sir, is an ass'.Whatsmore, the alternative you refer to is already in place. If you don't know who was driving then the registered keeper automatically gets the points and fine 'just in case'! In the case of a Company Car then the default is that the Company secretary gets the fine and points!! So go on, tell me how that's not daft (I'm tempted to replace 'daft' with 'corrupt')
Cases like this where it is honestly not known who is driving highlight the flaw of automated speed enforcement, if you exceed the speedlimit by mistake then chances are you don't know exactly where you are in relation to whatever local road or landmarks they use to define the location, bare in mind the location has to be fairly accurately defined otherwise a vague locus defense is possible.
Gassing Station | Speed, Plod & the Law | Top of Page | What's New | My Stuff



