Undertaking vs passing on the left
Undertaking vs passing on the left
Author
Discussion

erdnase

Original Poster:

1,963 posts

232 months

Wednesday 12th March 2008
quotequote all

Sorry to bring this old one up again. A few situations I've been in recently had me wondering if I was passing on the left or undertaking.

A blatant undertake is obvious and well defined, but I know there are a few situations where passing on the left is a grey area, and hope someone can help.

When in a queue of traffic, and the outside lane is moving at a slower speed than your inside lane, it's acceptable to pass on the left, rather than weave. That's fine in slow moving motorway traffic (say, 30mph or so), but sometimes the traffic can be nose-to-tail in both lanes, and lane one moving faster than lane two. I've seen this happen at 60/70mph, and in that case I tend to just stay in lane one if that's where I am. How does the law view this?

Another situation is when a vehicle is ahead of me in lane one, and I move left into one of those dedicated exit lanes (What are they called? Not quite a slip road, and defined with the shorter white lines). If the vehicle in lane one is traveling, say, 50mph, can I pass on the left in this exit lane?

Thanks in advance... smile

vonhosen

40,597 posts

248 months

Wednesday 12th March 2008
quotequote all
erdnase said:
Sorry to bring this old one up again. A few situations I've been in recently had me wondering if I was passing on the left or undertaking.

A blatant undertake is obvious and well defined, but I know there are a few situations where passing on the left is a grey area, and hope someone can help.

When in a queue of traffic, and the outside lane is moving at a slower speed than your inside lane, it's acceptable to pass on the left, rather than weave. That's fine in slow moving motorway traffic (say, 30mph or so), but sometimes the traffic can be nose-to-tail in both lanes, and lane one moving faster than lane two. I've seen this happen at 60/70mph, and in that case I tend to just stay in lane one if that's where I am. How does the law view this?

Another situation is when a vehicle is ahead of me in lane one, and I move left into one of those dedicated exit lanes (What are they called? Not quite a slip road, and defined with the shorter white lines). If the vehicle in lane one is traveling, say, 50mph, can I pass on the left in this exit lane?

Thanks in advance... smile
Just my opinion here, but I don't recognise what you are describing as undertaking.
If you are on the slip road then you are not undertaking, those in the live lanes.

Dracoro

9,038 posts

276 months

Wednesday 12th March 2008
quotequote all
Here's another:

Join motorway, lane 1 is clear so drive in lane 1 at 70 mph.

However there is a car in lane 2 going at 50mph.

Should you slow down to 50mph? what if the car was in lane 3/4/5?

Boosted LS1

21,200 posts

291 months

Wednesday 12th March 2008
quotequote all
Dracoro said:
Here's another:

Join motorway, lane 1 is clear so drive in lane 1 at 70 mph.

However there is a car in lane 2 going at 50mph.

Should you slow down to 50mph? what if the car was in lane 3/4/5?
Think bib would expect you to overtake especially if MLM was in an adjacent lane. I usually overtake but not always. Sometimes I like to see the MLM get a rude awakening. That said they often continue their journey in the middle lane. Why oh why don't we see them getting pulled over? They clog up the roads and are a hazard.

shocker-z

554 posts

249 months

Wednesday 12th March 2008
quotequote all
I've been pipped for comming off a slip-road and undertaking and going into the outside lane so many times and it's like weel what have i done wrong? people are justa big eager.

duno what the law on this is though?

also what's the laws about using bus lanes when allowd and passing on the left lane?

Liam

Edited by shocker-z on Wednesday 12th March 19:51

Dracoro

9,038 posts

276 months

Wednesday 12th March 2008
quotequote all
Boosted LS1 said:
Dracoro said:
Here's another:

Join motorway, lane 1 is clear so drive in lane 1 at 70 mph.

However there is a car in lane 2 going at 50mph.

Should you slow down to 50mph? what if the car was in lane 3/4/5?
Think bib would expect you to overtake especially if MLM was in an adjacent lane. I usually overtake but not always. Sometimes I like to see the MLM get a rude awakening. That said they often continue their journey in the middle lane. Why oh why don't we see them getting pulled over? They clog up the roads and are a hazard.
for the sake of argument, lets say it's a 2 lane motorway. What if he was driving at 30mph? should you still just sit at 30mph behind him until he decides to speed up?

JonRB

80,209 posts

303 months

Wednesday 12th March 2008
quotequote all
There is no such thing as "undertaking". There is overtaking on the right and overtaking on the left.

Boosted LS1

21,200 posts

291 months

Wednesday 12th March 2008
quotequote all
Dracoro said:
Boosted LS1 said:
Dracoro said:
Here's another:

Join motorway, lane 1 is clear so drive in lane 1 at 70 mph.

However there is a car in lane 2 going at 50mph.

Should you slow down to 50mph? what if the car was in lane 3/4/5?
Think bib would expect you to overtake especially if MLM was in an adjacent lane. I usually overtake but not always. Sometimes I like to see the MLM get a rude awakening. That said they often continue their journey in the middle lane. Why oh why don't we see them getting pulled over? They clog up the roads and are a hazard.
for the sake of argument, lets say it's a 2 lane motorway. What if he was driving at 30mph? should you still just sit at 30mph behind him until he decides to speed up?
I wouldn't. If he was doing 30 I'd know I was behind an absolute numpty in which case I'd blast past him on whichever side I preferred. Nothing like seeing a numpty in a state of panic after you've blown his doors inside out smile fk sitting at 30 behind an ignorant tt, oopps incompotant driver.

jondude

2,441 posts

248 months

Wednesday 12th March 2008
quotequote all
Dracoro said:
Here's another:

Join motorway, lane 1 is clear so drive in lane 1 at 70 mph.

However there is a car in lane 2 going at 50mph.

Should you slow down to 50mph? what if the car was in lane 3/4/5?
I think the argument from the police here would be you were not driving with full awareness to the situation. I have seen the above many, many times - and it looks real dangerous to me.

What also happens more and more is another car is legally and correctly overtaking the 50 mph middle laner, then they will, legally and nicely, wish to get back over to the left....but who is that coming at them on their inside at 70 mph!!! If you haven't noticed the 50mph er, you won't notice ( or care about is perhaps more apt ) the driver blocked a little from your vision as he is overtaking and pulling back to a lane he has every right to expect is clear.

I agree the 50 mph middle laner should be policed, but they are not - and you could easily take a good and correct driver down with you....then read how the 50mph driver was a star witness and received honours in Parliament for being the one to call the ambulance in time and offer first aid....

So I say plan ahead, slip behind the 50 mph er, then overtake normally. Let the police be the police.

parapaul

2,828 posts

229 months

Thursday 13th March 2008
quotequote all
jondude said:
Dracoro said:
Here's another:

Join motorway, lane 1 is clear so drive in lane 1 at 70 mph.

However there is a car in lane 2 going at 50mph.

Should you slow down to 50mph? what if the car was in lane 3/4/5?
I think the argument from the police here would be you were not driving with full awareness to the situation. I have seen the above many, many times - and it looks real dangerous to me.

What also happens more and more is another car is legally and correctly overtaking the 50 mph middle laner, then they will, legally and nicely, wish to get back over to the left....but who is that coming at them on their inside at 70 mph!!! If you haven't noticed the 50mph er, you won't notice ( or care about is perhaps more apt ) the driver blocked a little from your vision as he is overtaking and pulling back to a lane he has every right to expect is clear.

I agree the 50 mph middle laner should be policed, but they are not - and you could easily take a good and correct driver down with you....then read how the 50mph driver was a star witness and received honours in Parliament for being the one to call the ambulance in time and offer first aid....

So I say plan ahead, slip behind the 50 mph er, then overtake normally. Let the police be the police.
Who said anything about not seeing the 50mph guy?

havoc

33,505 posts

266 months

Thursday 13th March 2008
quotequote all
Von's point is that in the eyes of the law you could be deemed not to have seen them, as you continued in the LH lane rather than 'overtake' them properly.

My big problem isn't with MLM's (3-lane road), it's with OLMs, esp. on a 2-lane road (where you see it most often). Because then you can't pass without breaking the law.


...and I see it every day on my way to work. People who will sit (often at 60/65 in the dry) in the RH lane because:-
- They want to turn right at the r'bout 1 mile (or more) ahead. In some cases at the roundabout AFTER!!!; or
- There's a truck 500 yards ahead that they're barely gaining on; or
- They're just arrogant muppets (most often this category is populated by women in 'exec' or near-exec cars).


Von...say I was to get frustrated with one of these idiots, and pass on the inside, who would in your eyes be the greater offender?

shocker-z

554 posts

249 months

Thursday 13th March 2008
quotequote all
I see it all the time too.

My best undertake was for about 2 miles of traffic! every car was in the right hand lane doing bout 40mph and nothing was in left so i went down expecting road works or somthing... but nothing for nearly 2 miles! not a single car! i did 70mph all the way and just saw a stream of cars behind me!

Weird how some people decide that the RH lane must be faster even although there are no cars in the LH lane!

Liam

Bing o

15,184 posts

250 months

Thursday 13th March 2008
quotequote all
shocker-z said:
I see it all the time too.

My best undertake was for about 2 miles of traffic! every car was in the right hand lane doing bout 40mph and nothing was in left so i went down expecting road works or somthing... but nothing for nearly 2 miles! not a single car! i did 70mph all the way and just saw a stream of cars behind me!

Weird how some people decide that the RH lane must be faster even although there are no cars in the LH lane!

Liam
That's because it's the FAST LANE.

smile

shocker-z

554 posts

249 months

Thursday 13th March 2008
quotequote all
Bing o said:
shocker-z said:
I see it all the time too.

My best undertake was for about 2 miles of traffic! every car was in the right hand lane doing bout 40mph and nothing was in left so i went down expecting road works or somthing... but nothing for nearly 2 miles! not a single car! i did 70mph all the way and just saw a stream of cars behind me!

Weird how some people decide that the RH lane must be faster even although there are no cars in the LH lane!

Liam
That's because it's the FAST LANE.

smile
haha

I dotn get why people on motorways who are not confident go slow. surely you feel more confident with a car infront and behind you than 2 great bloody lorries!?

Women heh! (JOKE!! ish)

jith

2,752 posts

246 months

Thursday 13th March 2008
quotequote all
shocker-z said:
I see it all the time too.

My best undertake was for about 2 miles of traffic! every car was in the right hand lane doing bout 40mph and nothing was in left so i went down expecting road works or somthing... but nothing for nearly 2 miles! not a single car! i did 70mph all the way and just saw a stream of cars behind me!

Weird how some people decide that the RH lane must be faster even although there are no cars in the LH lane!

Liam
This is one of my pet hates, and experience has shown that there are several traffic BiBs who really have blinkers on when it comes to dealing with this.
Firstly, as another poster pointed out, in driving terms there is no such thing as undertaking; this is an extreme abuse of the word and has obvious sinister connotations: i.e Undertaking :- 1)The preparation and disposal of cadavers after death and the organisation of a burial. 2) The commitment to a task.

Secondly and most importantly, it is absolutely, categorically NOT against the law to overtake on the left hand side of a vehicle.

I have driven all over the world, and this is the worst country for total disregard of lane discipline; and this is further compounded by the confusion caused to motorist by the total absence of statute law that would clarify what you should or should not do in the various lanes, particularly on a motorway.
If, as a Traffic Officer, you stand by the notion that there should be no overtaking on the left hand on a motorway, you should be pulling every single joker who clearly deliberately impedes the progress of following traffic by refusing to pull in; THAT is far more potentially dangerous than overtaking on the left. Few of them do.
We need statutes to cement this principle instead of a vague note in the Highway Code that is ambiguous and unenforceable as a statute.
Impeding following traffic causes massive congestion, inconvenience and raises emission levels considerably. On the safety front it causes frustration and bunching of traffic hence seriously elevating the likelyhood of a pile up.

havoc

33,505 posts

266 months

Thursday 13th March 2008
quotequote all
jith said:
Impeding following traffic causes massive congestion, inconvenience and raises emission levels considerably. On the safety front it causes frustration and bunching of traffic hence seriously elevating the likelyhood of a pile up.
But they're slowing all those nasty speeders down, and everyone knows: "Speed Kills"!!! rolleyes

jaf01uk

1,943 posts

227 months

Friday 14th March 2008
quotequote all
I get quite wound up by these middle laners as well, so what your saying is if i'm doin 70 in lane 1 I have to change to lane 2 then to lane 3 to overtake the 50mph hogger then back to lane 1 after the muppet has been passed - 4 lane changes!! No chance, if they are oblivious to the other traffic as they obviously are they are unlikely to all of a sudden realise theyre a numpty and pull in on me as i cruise past?

LeoSayer

7,861 posts

275 months

Friday 14th March 2008
quotequote all
jaf01uk said:
so what your saying is if i'm doin 70 in lane 1 I have to change to lane 2 then to lane 3 to overtake the 50mph hogger then back to lane 1 after the muppet has been passed - 4 lane changes!! No chance
Why not?

smallgun

258 posts

264 months

Friday 14th March 2008
quotequote all
Dracoro said:
Boosted LS1 said:
Dracoro said:
Here's another:

Join motorway, lane 1 is clear so drive in lane 1 at 70 mph.

However there is a car in lane 2 going at 50mph.

Should you slow down to 50mph? what if the car was in lane 3/4/5?
Think bib would expect you to overtake especially if MLM was in an adjacent lane. I usually overtake but not always. Sometimes I like to see the MLM get a rude awakening. That said they often continue their journey in the middle lane. Why oh why don't we see them getting pulled over? They clog up the roads and are a hazard.
for the sake of argument, lets say it's a 2 lane motorway. What if he was driving at 30mph? should you still just sit at 30mph behind him until he decides to speed up?
What does Von think of the last part of this senario regarding the two lane motorway and a driver in the outer lane of the two at 30mph?

Hooli

32,278 posts

231 months

Friday 14th March 2008
quotequote all
the ones that really get my goat is when they know they are doing it. i come up behind them on the motorbike. they notice me & signal RIGHT then hug the barrier WTF????? you know your in the way, you know you should let me past so MOVE LEFT RETARD!




& breathe