Bus lanes and empty buses
Author
Discussion

supermono

Original Poster:

7,464 posts

279 months

Monday 17th March 2008
quotequote all
Has anyone done a FOI request for the percentage occupancy of buses? I've started looking into every bus I see and it's astonishing how most of them are virtually empty -- Norwich for example on a Saturday is totally awash with empty buses -- buses which have priority roads for them to trundle about on.

It honestly looks like Norwich City Council is running an emormous logistical exercise every Saturday involving moving empty buses from one depot to another.

It's obvious how it's happened. The pastafarians have infiltrated the councils and because they're a bit hard-of-thinking they reckon that people don't use buses because there aren't enough of them, so the answer (rather than to discover the truth) is to lay on hundreds of the damned things.

I'd sure like to start a bit of letter writing but it'd be nice to back that up with some official statistics to confirm (or otherwise) my observations.

SM

gozomark

167 posts

259 months

Monday 17th March 2008
quotequote all
along the lines of the suggestion of allowing cars with more than 1 passenger (or was it more) to use bus lanes, how about NOT allowing buses to use bus lanes unless they have atleast 10 passengers......

Fort Jefferson

8,237 posts

253 months

Monday 17th March 2008
quotequote all
It was pointed out a few months ago that bus passengers had the biggest carbon footprint of anyone on the road.

bigdods

7,175 posts

258 months

Monday 17th March 2008
quotequote all
Kind off off topic (well its a tangent at least) Bus travel is incredibly expensive hence empty buses. Case in point, my 8 year old is going on a school trip to the local museum. To add some 'life experience' to this they will be taking the kids on the bus (I think this is an excellent idea) instead of hiring a coach. So how much would a child return be to the local town (12 miles away). A few pounds ? nope. £7.10. THe school are paying the teachers fares, god only knows how much they are !

I was tempted to suggest that my Mrs take her car - 3 in the back, one in the front and charge them £5 a head as shes going on the trip as a helper....


EU_Foreigner

2,838 posts

257 months

Monday 17th March 2008
quotequote all
same as the train, the most expensive in the world.

bryan35

1,906 posts

272 months

Monday 17th March 2008
quotequote all
Same in Hull,

But not so much trundling around as thundering around.

infact, just going to do a quick survey......................

please wait....................

woof

8,456 posts

308 months

Monday 17th March 2008
quotequote all
London's the same
Peak times the buses are pretty full - however outside of 8-9.30am and 5-7pm - most buses are empty and chucking out 10 times the Gband CO2 output, not to mention all the really nasty cancerogens that diesels spit out


KB_S1

5,967 posts

260 months

Monday 17th March 2008
quotequote all
The thing that annoys me in Glasgow is that on several routes 2,3 or 4 different companies operate simultaneously.
So 3 buses with 10 people all going the same route when 1 bus could do it fine.

Some of the buses from the smaller firms look like furnaces going down the road.

flemke

23,515 posts

268 months

Monday 17th March 2008
quotequote all
Fort Jefferson said:
It was pointed out a few months ago that bus passengers had the biggest carbon footprint of anyone on the road.
You don't say...scratchchin
Any recollection of the source?

bryan35

1,906 posts

272 months

Monday 17th March 2008
quotequote all
9 busses gone past, which had

single deck - 3 people
double deck - 0 people
double deck - 1 people
double deck - 2 people
double deck - 1 people
single deck - 4 people
double deck - 5 people
double deck - 0 people
single deck - 0 people

not exactly efficient that is it!




bryan35

1,906 posts

272 months

Monday 17th March 2008
quotequote all
single deck - 3 people
double deck - 0 people
double deck - 1 people
double deck - 2 people
double deck - 1 people
single deck - 4 people
double deck - 5 people
double deck - 0 people
single deck - 0 people

so we have 9 busses carrying 16 people. Busses do about 3 MPG, there's 9 of em so thats 3 gallons to the mile. carrying 16 people that's about 5 MPG per person.

My car was doing 55 MPG this morning driving to work. That's 11 times less fuel than the bus, and as it's a new car and not a smoke belching pile of rust I reckon much better emmisions too.


Parrot of Doom

23,075 posts

265 months

Monday 17th March 2008
quotequote all
supermono said:
Has anyone done a FOI request for the percentage occupancy of buses? I've started looking into every bus I see and it's astonishing how most of them are virtually empty -- Norwich for example on a Saturday is totally awash with empty buses -- buses which have priority roads for them to trundle about on.

It honestly looks like Norwich City Council is running an emormous logistical exercise every Saturday involving moving empty buses from one depot to another.

It's obvious how it's happened. The pastafarians have infiltrated the councils and because they're a bit hard-of-thinking they reckon that people don't use buses because there aren't enough of them, so the answer (rather than to discover the truth) is to lay on hundreds of the damned things.

I'd sure like to start a bit of letter writing but it'd be nice to back that up with some official statistics to confirm (or otherwise) my observations.

SM
Buses are run by private companies, I'm not sure they have an obligation to tell you anything at all.

simonrockman

7,136 posts

286 months

Monday 17th March 2008
quotequote all
Remember that even at peak periods in the morning a bus running from where people live to where they work has to be matched by an empty one going the other way.

The TfL figure for peak bus occupancy is 30%. They don't give an off-peak figure, and even that would not allow for buses running empty to and from the depot and other not-in-service movements.

The official fuel consuption might be 11mpg, but that's not an in-service consumption. Think about 3 tonnes of bus with 2 tonnes of people on board. Accelerate to 30mph. Brake to zero so that little old lady can get off with her tartan trolley while the buse idles then accelerate back up to 30mph to brake back down at the next stop and you get a service consumption of less than 1mpg.

Of course the empty ones with no passengers and stopping are much more fuel efficient.

Simon

chevy-stu

5,392 posts

259 months

Monday 17th March 2008
quotequote all
London buses are surely owned and operated by TFL so their figures would surely be available to the public..

Unless of course Ken Theivingscum 'massaged' these figures to fit his plan...

it's been amazing me for a long time how many empty buses are allowed to travel around, with no-one at the DOT apparently bothered..

Kevin 996C4

13,891 posts

311 months

Monday 17th March 2008
quotequote all
simonrockman said:
Remember that even at peak periods in the morning a bus running from where people live to where they work has to be matched by an empty one going the other way.

The TfL figure for peak bus occupancy is 30%. They don't give an off-peak figure, and even that would not allow for buses running empty to and from the depot and other not-in-service movements.

The official fuel consuption might be 11mpg, but that's not an in-service consumption. Think about 3 tonnes of bus with 2 tonnes of people on board. Accelerate to 30mph. Brake to zero so that little old lady can get off with her tartan trolley while the buse idles then accelerate back up to 30mph to brake back down at the next stop and you get a service consumption of less than 1mpg.

Of course the empty ones with no passengers and stopping are much more fuel efficient.

Simon
A bit off on your weights, a single decker weighs from about 10 tonnes, a double decker much more....

The Tea Boy

4,129 posts

266 months

Monday 17th March 2008
quotequote all
on the subject of busses i was well hacked off that on a bus lane in nottingham it has its own set of traffic lights just after a stop, they were on red but ours were on green the bus then decideds to not bother with his set of lights and pulls out infront of me as mine were on green!! Not happy!! if i used there lights when mine were on red id be expecting £££'s fine and points for doing a red light and using a bus lane!!

matt

thewurzel

287 posts

225 months

Monday 17th March 2008
quotequote all
The Tea Boy said:
on the subject of busses i was well hacked off that on a bus lane in nottingham it has its own set of traffic lights just after a stop, they were on red but ours were on green the bus then decideds to not bother with his set of lights and pulls out infront of me as mine were on green!! Not happy!! if i used there lights when mine were on red id be expecting £££'s fine and points for doing a red light and using a bus lane!!

matt
Bus drivers aren't above the law. He will be punished in exactly the same way you would have been.


As simonrockman said, a full bus at rush hour quickly becomes an empty bus for it's return journey.

When you see an empty bus, it may be about to fill up at the next stop, it still needs a bus lane to get to that stop on time. Buses that don't run to timetable don't get used, people get in their cars, and the roads are more congested than before, even without the bus lane.

Edited by thewurzel on Monday 17th March 13:15

Davi

17,153 posts

251 months

Monday 17th March 2008
quotequote all
thewurzel said:
The Tea Boy said:
on the subject of busses i was well hacked off that on a bus lane in nottingham it has its own set of traffic lights just after a stop, they were on red but ours were on green the bus then decideds to not bother with his set of lights and pulls out infront of me as mine were on green!! Not happy!! if i used there lights when mine were on red id be expecting £££'s fine and points for doing a red light and using a bus lane!!

matt
Bus drivers aren't above the law. He will be punished in exactly the same way you would have been.


As simonrockman said, a full bus at rush hour quickly becomes an empty bus for it's return journey.

When you see an empty bus, it may be about to fill up at the next stop, it still needs a bus lane to get to that stop on time. Buses that don't run to timetable don't get used, people get in their cars, and the roads are more congested than before, even without the bus lane.

Edited by thewurzel on Monday 17th March 13:15
A few weeks back I was forced to use public transport for a week. Of the 5 days I tried to use it, I was only successful 4 times (3rd day I gave up waiting after an hour and twenty minutes for the "every 20 minutes" service and walked home in 50 minutes...) Of those 4 times I did succeed, it arrived within 20 minutes of the allotted time once, the other three times it was between 20 and 40 minutes late (again impressive for a service that runs every 20 minutes), I was charged a different amount every time for the same single ticket - £1.30 being the cheapest, £2.70 the most expensive) and the greatest number of people on the bus was no more than 8. Despite the bus lane it still took 5 times longer than the same journey by car!

Oh and I still had a 5 minute walk in the pissing rain at both the beginning and end of the journey.

supermono

Original Poster:

7,464 posts

279 months

Monday 17th March 2008
quotequote all
Parrot of Doom said:
Buses are run by private companies, I'm not sure they have an obligation to tell you anything at all.
A-ha. I imagine this is how empty buses are being moved about all the time. Subsidies. I'll bet if I run a bus company privately I can get some sort of handout for moving buses -- even buses that nobody needs to use. I'll bet it's made worth my while to lay on far more buses than necessary.

And about those full commuter buses and the other ones going the other way... Do me a favour, even at rush hour I see half empty buses, and off peak they're mostly empty wherever I see them. Surely I'd see full buses some of the time?

Besides, if I was running a haulage firm I'd sure as hell not have empty lorries running about the place -- I'd plan it so I could collect a load from the other end and bring it back.

SM

thewurzel

287 posts

225 months

Monday 17th March 2008
quotequote all
supermono said:
Besides, if I was running a haulage firm I'd sure as hell not have empty lorries running about the place -- I'd plan it so I could collect a load from the other end and bring it back.
And how would you do that with buses? Buses can't wait at the stop until they're full - they have a timetable.