"Private Road" - is it really?
Discussion
I just had a chat with a nice lady who stopped to talk to me while I was messing around with my car - apparently the road I was parked on, and have been parking on for the last year is a private road. She politely asked me not to park there tomorrow as they have a skip coming. She said that the road is private and owned by the two houses at the end (there are four houses on this road).
Funnily she didn't directly ask me not to park there at all.
Interesting I thought - now given that there are no signs saying "private road" etc and the road is not obviously private, I decided to do a bit of research.
So £6 to get the title plan and register from the land registry - there is no mention of ownership of the road. The plan does not show the road within the boundary.
Is there anywhere else I need to look, things I need to find out before I decide to ignore her? I don't want to park on the road if it IS private, but I also don't want to not park there because some monkey was trying their luck.
Ideas?
Funnily she didn't directly ask me not to park there at all.
Interesting I thought - now given that there are no signs saying "private road" etc and the road is not obviously private, I decided to do a bit of research.
So £6 to get the title plan and register from the land registry - there is no mention of ownership of the road. The plan does not show the road within the boundary.
Is there anywhere else I need to look, things I need to find out before I decide to ignore her? I don't want to park on the road if it IS private, but I also don't want to not park there because some monkey was trying their luck.
Ideas?
BMWBen said:
She politely asked me not to park there tomorrow as they have a skip coming.
Funnily she didn't directly ask me not to park there at all.
Is there anywhere else I need to look, things I need to find out before I decide to ignore her?
Since she asked politely and didn't suggest that you should never park in the road, why don't you simply park elsewhere whilst the skip is there ?Funnily she didn't directly ask me not to park there at all.
Is there anywhere else I need to look, things I need to find out before I decide to ignore her?
vonhosen said:
Council will tell you if it's theirs, because they'll be liable for it's upkeep.
Ah but even if it's not publicly-maintained, it might still be a public road (even although it's privately maintained).Public means simply a road over which there is a public right of passage - it doesn't mean (as many council officers often interpret it) "a road maintained by the council at public expense".
There are 3 possible positions:
1. It's a public road, adopted by the Council for maintenance at public expense. The Council's records will show this as an adopted road;
2. A road, still open to the public, but maintained privately (either by adjacent frontagers or a landowner). For most purposes (including the OP's) this type is exactly the same as No 1 in that if you want to prohibit parking or access then you have to make an Order in exactly the same way and use the signs as prescribed in Traffic Signs Regulations and General Directions. In other words, it's still a "public road" regardless of who maintains it;
3. A private lane - normally would be gated and would serve only a small number of houses - effectively a driveway or estate road. The essential difference is that there is no public right of passage. On this, the owner can stop people parking or just lock them out.
On the first 2, ownership is irrelevant: you might well find that your land title includes part of the adopted road (mine does) or part of a private road - that gives you no more right to decide who uses it or who parks there, than anybody else.
Your neighbour would only be right if it was the third type - ie no public right of passage. As to what constitutes "public" well that's been argued for years! Are there street lights? Is it gated? Is it a through road to anywhere else? Do people use it who don't live there (even if they walk along it)? All of these answers (and more) can make a difference.
The last place I lived at had a private road. In our case it's when the council do not adopt it for maintenance/salting, so the houses on the development formed a maintenance company to look after it. It didn't show it's ownership on our deeds, but it was private because the council didn't adopt it.
BMWBen said:
So £6 to get the title plan and register from the land registry - there is no mention of ownership of the road. The plan does not show the road within the boundary.
That doesn't mean that the road isn't private.We live at the end of a private road - which is essentially one unadopted by the council.
The whole road itself does not appear on our title plan, but was flagged up on the solictiors searches when we bought the property. Basically it was detailed in the search that all the properties served by the 'private' road are responsible for its upkeep, so its collectively owned by all of us that live down it.
The section that is directly outside our house IS detailed on our plan however as our freehold land - subject to rights of way for our two neighbours further along.
We recently had an issue with non residents parking on parts of the road essentially blocking people in, we initially politely pointed out that they were parking on private land and asked them to refrain from doing so as it was causing inconvenience to a few of us. We were met with an unsavory response which gave us no alternative but to take legal action.
At the end of the day, if someone is being fairly reasonable and polite about it, it is up to you to act in the same way.
Edited by photo_ed on Monday 17th March 15:31
tvrgit said:
Public means simply a road over which there is a public right of passage - it doesn't mean (as many council officers often interpret it) "a road maintained by the council at public expense".
A right of way is just that, the right is limited to passing and repassing. There is no express right to park a vehicle, or anything come to that.A bridleway is a public right of way on foot or horseback which is often across privately owned land. The owners of the land still retain all rights to that land, which they can restrict or permit use of, apart from the right of way. In certain cases, and the law relating to it is very woolly, landowners can alter and restrict rights of way. I was involved in a right of way dispute where a farmer had restricted the right of way on a bridleway to foot passengers only and the cycling group I was with had a difficult job to challenge it and in the end had to accept a detour.
Derek Smith said:
tvrgit said:
Public means simply a road over which there is a public right of passage - it doesn't mean (as many council officers often interpret it) "a road maintained by the council at public expense".
A right of way is just that, the right is limited to passing and repassing. There is no express right to park a vehicle, or anything come to that.A bridleway is a public right of way on foot or horseback which is often across privately owned land. The owners of the land still retain all rights to that land, which they can restrict or permit use of, apart from the right of way. In certain cases, and the law relating to it is very woolly, landowners can alter and restrict rights of way. I was involved in a right of way dispute where a farmer had restricted the right of way on a bridleway to foot passengers only and the cycling group I was with had a difficult job to challenge it and in the end had to accept a detour.
Edited by tvrgit on Monday 17th March 16:00
photo_ed said:
BMWBen said:
So £6 to get the title plan and register from the land registry - there is no mention of ownership of the road. The plan does not show the road within the boundary.
That doesn't mean that the road isn't private....snip...
The section that is directly outside our house IS detailed on our plan however as our freehold land - subject to rights of way for our two neighbours further along.
...snip...
At the end of the day, if someone is being fairly reasonable and polite about it, it is up to you to act in the same way.
Edited by photo_ed on Monday 17th March 15:31
The road is not gated, it's not a private estate, but a continuation of a line or georgian houses that happens to have a road in front of it.
It is a through route for pedestrians, but not for cars.
For the period I have lived here - 2 years - people have parked on that road as if it's public.
I've put the plan from the land registry on for clarification.
My query is simple I guess - if it's not shown on here, can I assume that no part of the road belongs to that house?
What I am trying to determine is if they were being reasonable. If they were, so will I. Which is why I'm trying to research this


BMWBen said:
I've put the plan from the land registry on for clarification.
My query is simple I guess - if it's not shown on here, can I assume that no part of the road belongs to that house?

From that plan, it is quite a different scenario to the one I related regarding my own property, which as well as being up an unadopted lane, each section infront of our houses is detailed on the title plan. I'd say that in your scenario the cul-de-sac bit is still part of the public highway therefore I'd say you were well within your rights to park there.
Well that looks to me like part of the public road, albeit (maybe) privately maintained - type 2 in my post earlier. Whether their title extends into it or not, is not relevant - it's a road, not a private lane. The only people who can control access to that road, or can control parking, are the local highway authority who would have to make a TRO, exactly as if it was a road they maintained themselves. The only difference is that they would probably only think about doing that if the residents asked them to.
It might be worth visiting the local highways office - under the Highways Act they must maintain a register of roads in their area, which must be available for free public inspection. That will at least confirm whether or not they maintain it - although even if they don't, as I say, it still looks like a "road".
It might be worth visiting the local highways office - under the Highways Act they must maintain a register of roads in their area, which must be available for free public inspection. That will at least confirm whether or not they maintain it - although even if they don't, as I say, it still looks like a "road".
Edited by tvrgit on Monday 17th March 16:26
If this is it, I am not so sure.
http://maps.google.co.uk/maps?f=q&hl=en&ge...
The entrance has some curious yellow hatchings and the yellow line on the main road seems to cut right across the entrance, neither are things associated with roads with any public right of way.
However if they don't specifically sign the state of affairs it would be difficult to enforce anything against stray parked cars.
Who owns/looks after the trees and shrubs in the island section?
http://maps.google.co.uk/maps?f=q&hl=en&ge...
The entrance has some curious yellow hatchings and the yellow line on the main road seems to cut right across the entrance, neither are things associated with roads with any public right of way.
However if they don't specifically sign the state of affairs it would be difficult to enforce anything against stray parked cars.
Who owns/looks after the trees and shrubs in the island section?
Looks suspiciously private to me on Googlemap - the line of it follows the line of the gardens of the houses adjacent. I'd suggest it was built to give access to those houses as for some reason (obscured by trees) the last houses couldn't be accessed off the road.
What land registry entry and plan are you looking at? For one of the houses presumably? Have you done an index map search over the whole of the roadway? What is the yellow hatched area? Does it have any wording on it?
The fact that it isn't on the title to whichever house you looked at means very little, it might not be registered land in which case you won't be able to find reference to it.
It's worth looking at the title for the house at the far end of the run - they might own it.
Personally seeing it on Googlemap I'd be pissed off if I lived in one of those houses and you parked outside my door.
What land registry entry and plan are you looking at? For one of the houses presumably? Have you done an index map search over the whole of the roadway? What is the yellow hatched area? Does it have any wording on it?
The fact that it isn't on the title to whichever house you looked at means very little, it might not be registered land in which case you won't be able to find reference to it.
It's worth looking at the title for the house at the far end of the run - they might own it.
Personally seeing it on Googlemap I'd be pissed off if I lived in one of those houses and you parked outside my door.
Yes that's the road - the yellow hatchings mark the area in front of an entrance to an underground car park that belongs to the house closest to the main road. The yellow line does extend over the end, but then it also extends over the lone parking bay just past the entrance, and every single bay on the main road is incorrectly marked - hence I haven't read anything into that!
I don't know who maintains the shrubbery.
I'll get the title docs for the house at the end.
The reason the road exists is because the level of the houses and the footpath is higher than that of the road from the point of the entrance to the road - i'd say that makes it more likely to be public if anything.
Like I said - if it is private I don't want to park there, but there are lots of private roads around here, all clearly marked as such, so why isn't this one? If it isn't private then I DEFINITELY want to park there - cars don't last long out on the main road.
I don't know who maintains the shrubbery.
I'll get the title docs for the house at the end.
The reason the road exists is because the level of the houses and the footpath is higher than that of the road from the point of the entrance to the road - i'd say that makes it more likely to be public if anything.
Like I said - if it is private I don't want to park there, but there are lots of private roads around here, all clearly marked as such, so why isn't this one? If it isn't private then I DEFINITELY want to park there - cars don't last long out on the main road.
Edited by BMWBen on Monday 17th March 17:36
Piglet said:
Personally seeing it on Googlemap I'd be pissed off if I lived in one of those houses and you parked outside my door.
Yep so would I - but I don't think there's a thing you can do about it (legally). It still looks to me like a privately maintained road with "public" access (if it's not adopted anyway - we still haven't established that bit). The box junction marking is TSRGD standard. The yellow line over the end isn't that unusual...BMWBen said:
OK, the house on the end has a similar boundary, and the deeds do not mention anything about the road. I could get the deeds for the other 2 houses but... 6 quid a pop :P
What do we reckon - keep parking there?
Deeds are irrelevant. Just in case you missed that - deeds are irrelevant. Did I mention that the deeds are irrelevant? If I didn't, then I'll say it again.What do we reckon - keep parking there?
It doesn't matter who owns the road. If it's a road, whether privately or publicly maintained (types 1 or 2 in my first post) then parking can only be controlled by a TRO (and the appropriate TSRGD signage - ie yellow lines). If there are no yellow lines then park where you like. You're not on "private land" you're on a public road (as far as I can see) albeit one that might be privately maintained (or might be maintained by the council, we still don't know do we?)
Of course, if she asked you nicely not to park there for a bit because of the skip, then it might be seen as extremely churlish to continue. That's up to you though.
Gassing Station | Speed, Plod & the Law | Top of Page | What's New | My Stuff


