DNA base for 5-12yr children-- future criminals?
DNA base for 5-12yr children-- future criminals?
Author
Discussion

paranha

Original Poster:

633 posts

273 months

Tuesday 18th March 2008
quotequote all

Don

28,378 posts

315 months

Tuesday 18th March 2008
quotequote all
paranha said:
I want my Minority Report...

FishFace

3,790 posts

239 months

Tuesday 18th March 2008
quotequote all
It'll never happen. Quite right too.

streaky

19,311 posts

280 months

Tuesday 18th March 2008
quotequote all
FishFace said:
It'll never happen. Quite right too.
This will come as a surprise to you, but the earth is not flat - Streaky

parapaul

2,828 posts

229 months

Tuesday 18th March 2008
quotequote all
I don't know enough about genetic engineering and research to comment on the whole 'criminal DNA trait' suggestion, but I wholeheartedly agree with a DNA register.

If every baby had DNA sampled and registered at birth, not only would authorities be able to identify criminal DNA but also that of victims left in an unidentifiable condition. If you've nothing to hide, surely you've nothing to fear?

  • Stands back waiting for flaming from the "But that's an infringement of Civil Rights" crew*
biggrin

HRG

72,863 posts

270 months

Tuesday 18th March 2008
quotequote all
parapaul said:
I don't know enough about genetic engineering and research to comment on the whole 'criminal DNA trait' suggestion, but I wholeheartedly agree with a DNA register.

If every baby had DNA sampled and registered at birth, not only would authorities be able to identify criminal DNA but also that of victims left in an unidentifiable condition. If you've nothing to hide, surely you've nothing to fear?

  • Stands back waiting for flaming from the "But that's an infringement of Civil Rights" crew*
biggrin
jesus H Christ, you haven't been here long, have you?

Flamed, there won't even be carbon cinders left when we've finished with you hehe

Peter Ward

2,097 posts

287 months

Tuesday 18th March 2008
quotequote all
parapaul said:
I don't know enough about genetic engineering and research to comment on the whole 'criminal DNA trait' suggestion, but I wholeheartedly agree with a DNA register.

If every baby had DNA sampled and registered at birth, not only would authorities be able to identify criminal DNA but also that of victims left in an unidentifiable condition. If you've nothing to hide, surely you've nothing to fear?

  • Stands back waiting for flaming from the "But that's an infringement of Civil Rights" crew*
biggrin
Even though everyone's DNA is unique, the DNA tests are performed on a very small amount of it (I think it's just 8 short sections). Because of this, you might find that you match a criminal's DNA. So even though you have nothing to hide, you're up in court with "irrefutable" evidence against you. Is that what you want?

Of course, DNA tests may improve in future. Court processes might improve such that the CPS's view that DNA tests cannot lie is corrected.

If we ever get to the point where DNA tests guarantee no false positives then I could see there being little reason to object. Until then, don't go there.

streaky

19,311 posts

280 months

Tuesday 18th March 2008
quotequote all
parapaul said:
... If you've nothing to hide, surely you've nothing to fear?
1) Show me someone who has "nothing to hide".
2) As Peter Ward indicates, the potential for false positives exists and DNA 'evidence' is relatively easier for a criminal to plant at the scene than fingerprints.

Streaky

Deltaf01

1,512 posts

228 months

Tuesday 18th March 2008
quotequote all
parapaul said:
If you've nothing to hide, surely you've nothing to fear?

  • Stands back waiting for flaming from the "But that's an infringement of Civil Rights" crew*
biggrin
Can i come search your house?

How about can i install a camera in your bedroom and watch while you bang your girl/boyfriend/wife/dog etc?

Can i have a log of all your movements for the next 60 years of your life?

Can i have access to your accounts, business affairs and phone records?

If not, why not? Nothing to hide have you? Surely?

Another muppet down in flames, someone put him out will ya? rolleyes

havoc

33,509 posts

266 months

Tuesday 18th March 2008
quotequote all
Ah...thoughtcrime. Not a new concept, but still just as scary as when first proposed.

W****rs, the lot of 'em. Sociopath, socialist, lying, control-freak weasels!!!

Maybe if they took all of the people employed (at taxpayers expense) by these think-tanks, and put them to work building more prisons, then, just maybe, quality of life would improve in this country.

parapaul

2,828 posts

229 months

Tuesday 18th March 2008
quotequote all
Didn't realise DNA testing was infallible. My bad.

Deltaf01 said:
Can i come search your house?
For what reason? If you suspect me of something, then by all means. If you just want to see what my living room looks like and what colour I decorated the bathroom, then no. You might be jealous wink

Deltaf01 said:
How about can i install a camera in your bedroom and watch while you bang your girl/boyfriend/wife/dog etc?
If that's what floats your boat, feel free biggrin

Deltaf01 said:
Can i have a log of all your movements for the next 60 years of your life?

Can i have access to your accounts, business affairs and phone records?
Again, why?

Deltaf01 said:
If not, why not? Nothing to hide have you? Surely?

Another muppet down in flames, someone put him out will ya? rolleyes
Nope, nothing to hide. Give me even half a reason why I'd want to let you though....

bluepolarbear

1,666 posts

277 months

Tuesday 18th March 2008
quotequote all
FishFace said:
It'll never happen. Quite right too.
Why never? We have already inched away from core rights, with more and more people being happy to sacrifice a few innocents in the pursuit of a higher clear up right. What's the rot starts, what stops it? It is the "how to boil a frog" principle.

bluepolarbear

1,666 posts

277 months

Tuesday 18th March 2008
quotequote all
parapaul said:
Nope, nothing to hide. Give me even half a reason why I'd want to let you though....
Significant crinimal activity is planned in advance and this planning is done in private. By monitoring the actions of people while in private through CCTV etc you will detect those naughty people and be able to prevent / solve a crime. The privacy of the innocent masses is lost but that is a small price to pay after all if you have nothing to hide you have nothing to fear.

C.f

Criminal activity tends to leave traces of DNA which can be used to detect the crinimal. By storing the DNA of all UK subjects you will be able to detect those naughty people and be able to prevent / solve a crime. THe privacy of hte innocent masses is lost but that is a small price to pay after all if you have nothing to hide you nothing fear.


In fact it is worse because it is not just your DNA profile but the orginal organic sample that is stored. That sample can then be used for anything that future science may invent.

If you really believe that DNA of everyone is accepting on the basis that "if you have nothing to hide" then by logically extension you have to be willing to open your entire private life to the authority. If as you suggest you are not (give me a good reason) then you fail to understand your own argument.

bcnrml

2,107 posts

241 months

Tuesday 18th March 2008
quotequote all
parapaul said:
I don't know enough about genetic engineering and research to comment on the whole 'criminal DNA trait' suggestion, but I wholeheartedly agree with a DNA register.

biggrin
It is better to be thought a fool than to open your mouth and remove all doubt.

I'm surprised you haven't volunteered yours (and your nearest and dearest).

But I'm not surprised that you even have the temerity to admit your ignorance, at least twice, in this thread.

Quite remarkable.

Deltaf01

1,512 posts

228 months

Tuesday 18th March 2008
quotequote all
Deltaf01 said:
Can i come search your house?
parapaul said:
For what reason?
For whatever reason.

parapaul said:
If you suspect me of something, then by all means.
I suspect you of criminality, terrorism, abduction...basically whatever i think might yield a result.

parapaul said:
If you just want to see what my living room looks like and what colour I decorated the bathroom, then no. You might be jealous wink
Yeah that wallpaper is criminal....:P

Deltaf01 said:
How about can i install a camera in your bedroom and watch while you bang your girl/boyfriend/wife/dog etc?
parapaul said:
If that's what floats your boat, feel free biggrin
Fine, ill then put it on youtube or maybe in a file marked "deviant behaviour".Whatever i as a state minion decide at the time.


Deltaf01 said:
Can i have a log of all your movements for the next 60 years of your life?

Can i have access to your accounts, business affairs and phone records?
parapaul said:
Again, why?
Im asking the questions. Comply or else.

Deltaf01 said:
If not, why not? Nothing to hide have you? Surely?
parapaul said:
Nope, nothing to hide. Give me even half a reason why I'd want to let you though....
Because i represent the state. Therefore I own you, i own your life. I own the ID card you paid for, i can do as i wish whilst legally empowered by the state. Refusal to comply is a crime.

Getting the jist yet?

Red Devil

13,534 posts

239 months

Tuesday 18th March 2008
quotequote all
I have three words for the "nothing to hide" merchants. Pastor Martin Niemöller.
If you don't know who he was or his relevance to this debate then you really do not understand how dangerous these proposals are.
The more power the state grabs for itself the worse things will be should it cease to be benign.
And don't for one minute imagine that 'this is Britain, it couldn't happen here'.
Nor should anyone be fooled by the fighting crime argument.
This government has a well rehearsed strategy of steady erosion of people's freedom by incremental stages which in themselves seem plausible.
All of it wrapped up in sugar coated pills to make it seem palatable.
If you don't wake up and smell the coffee soon you may find that when you finally do so it will be far too late.

havoc

33,509 posts

266 months

Tuesday 18th March 2008
quotequote all
Red Devil said:
And don't for one minute imagine that 'this is Britain, it couldn't happen here'.
yes

Weimar Germany was one of the most liberal nations in Europe at the time. Sadly, national pride was badly dented following Versailles, and the populace let themselves be led around by scaremongering (xenophobia mainly...sound familiar) and their emotions...

WildCat

8,369 posts

274 months

Tuesday 18th March 2008
quotequote all
parapaul said:
Didn't realise DNA testing was infallible. My bad.

Deltaf01 said:
Can i come search your house?
For what reason? If you suspect me of something, then by all means. If you just want to see what my living room looks like and what colour I decorated the bathroom, then no. You might be jealous wink
Nein - but we could use your choice of avocado bath tub colour with rubber duck und a toy submarine within as telling us something about yourself. Your wallpaper with the mermaids might also give insight into personality und then there ist the content of your bathroom cabinet yikes I did not know you used a fake tan und teeth whitener .. und yoour choice of floss.. tell us all about your habits wink - spending consumer ones whistle not winktongue out

parapaul said:
Deltaf01 said:
How about can i install a camera in your bedroom and watch while you bang your girl/boyfriend/wife/dog etc?
If that's what floats your boat, feel free biggrin
It ist the cam in the bathroom which more worrying.. winkyikes

paparpaul said:
Deltaf01 said:
Can i have a log of all your movements for the next 60 years of your life?

Can i have access to your accounts, business affairs and phone records?
Again, why?
Because we need to put it on your ID card und check how you spend your money Liebchen... und monitor who you see.. who you talk to.. what your innermost thought are.. und if we do not like anyone you meet .. yikes und it matter to the government if you think they are idiots.. as they can then send you to camp .. or you disappear yikes


(It did happen in GDR.. whistle Und Moscow und 1940s Germany rolleyes


papapaul said:
Deltaf01 said:
If not, why not? Nothing to hide have you? Surely?

Another muppet down in flames, someone put him out will ya? rolleyes
Nope, nothing to hide. Give me even half a reason why I'd want to let you though....
Because ist the law now .. und an ID card or DNA register like this one give the right to interfere in your life.. for the fun of it rolleyeswhistle


But DNA trace ist like finger print. It prove you left trace of self somewhere.. und lead to line of enquiry - but it not prove who dunnit. rolleyes

It also take time for that match to trace .. millions of records - even best computer take time to search und sift for it all rolleyes

I do not actually have anything to hide .. nor my husband .. nor our kittens..but we object to these records being held anyway as it make us feel "criminal"

By the way.. I did live in Moscow in late 80s. I had idea of learning Russian as elective option "options were supposed to broaden horizons und develop the student" rolleyes apparently rolleyes Never did learn to speak it as became a bit self conscious of lack of command on the one hand und the natives scared of talking to "sassy Westerner" on the other.. as they listened into everything. It un-nerving to be und feel so much obeserved. Likewise when I spent a short (but endless seeming time) in Leipzig when GDR rolleyes

It not a nice feeling to feel "observed" all the time. I speak from the experience. Anyone who experience this would be averse to any such nonsense - especially when a Cold War as well as a Real War was fought over preserving our freedoms rolleyes

Deltaf01

1,512 posts

228 months

Tuesday 18th March 2008
quotequote all
Resistance via subversion, sabotage and ultimately destruction of their plans for us; Its the only way.

Notice another piece of state legislation wending its way through the murky regions of morality?
Specifically, the presumption of consent to donate your organs.
The clear statement theyre making is:
WE OWN YOU. BODY, MIND AND SOUL. IN LIFE AND IN DEATH.

Live on your knees or die on your feet, your choice, but make it soon.

Edited by Deltaf01 on Tuesday 18th March 22:41

Scraggles

7,619 posts

255 months

Tuesday 18th March 2008
quotequote all
when the entire plod force, MP's and all their families volunteer for them to go on the database "as we have nothing to fear" then might be convinced, until then....