Speed limit repeater signs?
Discussion
I'm sure I've seen it stated on here before that if you are driving in a built up area, with no indication to the contrary, then you assume that it is a 30 limit, AND that 30 limits do not require repeater signs, only the terminal speed limit signs. If this is the case, if you are in a 20 limit area, is there a requirement for repeater signs, because you might otherwise assume that it is a 30 limit? I only ask because I drive through one every day, and there is about 1 mile of 20 limit with no repeaters. There are speed humps, but there is also a 30 limit area round here that has them, so that cannot be taken as an indication of the limit, (can it?). Please advise, contributions from our knowledgeable BiB posters more than welcome.
Thanks for the link VH, sort of makes sense. I must say though the road modifications on the main bit of 20 limit in no way make the limit self enforcing. The speed humps are not big enough to seriously impede progress, actually the number of parked cars have more influence on speed, and they are not a permanent fixture. I only use this route to avoid traffic on my morning commute, and can only sensibly do so to avoid particular choke point because I am going in the opposite direction to most people. God bless Lancasters wonderful one way system, (usually a no way system at rush hour).
I will do a bit more digging about the road in question given the chance.
I will do a bit more digging about the road in question given the chance.
andmole said:
I'm sure I've seen it stated on here before that if you are driving in a built up area, with no indication to the contrary, then you assume that it is a 30 limit, AND that 30 limits do not require repeater signs, only the terminal speed limit signs. If this is the case, if you are in a 20 limit area, is there a requirement for repeater signs, because you might otherwise assume that it is a 30 limit? I only ask because I drive through one every day, and there is about 1 mile of 20 limit with no repeaters. There are speed humps, but there is also a 30 limit area round here that has them, so that cannot be taken as an indication of the limit, (can it?). Please advise, contributions from our knowledgeable BiB posters more than welcome.
Non-BIB here, speaking from position of near-ignorance.First, I think you will find that there are not that many absolute rules for repeater signs. Rather, there are guidelines that an authority is expected to follow. Failure by the LA to follow those guidelines is not, however, guaranteed to mitigate a speeding allegation.
The requirements for repeater signs are far from being straightforward. They vary depending on, amongst other things, the limit itself and whether there are side roads leading into the road in question. Then there is the question of on which side of the road the repeater is located.
Btw, I believe that there is no requirement for 30 repeaters only when there is a system of street lighting. For a country village without street lighting, I think you will find that repeaters are required.
This:
http://www.dft.gov.uk/pgr/roads/tpm/tal/signsandsi...
suggests that there is no "requirement" for 20 repeaters. If it came down to a prosecution, however, I would hire Richard Bentley.
andmole said:
I'm sure I've seen it stated on here before that if you are driving in a built up area, with no indication to the contrary, then you assume that it is a 30 limit, AND that 30 limits do not require repeater signs,
Its not just that repeaters are not required, they are specifically prohibited from 30mph limits with a system of street lighting, as detailed below..Direction 11 TSRGD 2002 said:
(4) The sign shown in diagram 670 (except when displayed on a variable message sign in the manner mentioned in regulation 58(7)(b)) shall not be placed along;
(a) a road on which there is provided a system of carriageway lighting furnished by lamps lit by electricity placed not more than 183 metres apart in England and Wales or not more than 185 metres apart in Scotland and which is subject to a speed limit of 30mph;
I understand that three or more street (as opposed to footway) lamps are deemed to represent a 'system'..(a) a road on which there is provided a system of carriageway lighting furnished by lamps lit by electricity placed not more than 183 metres apart in England and Wales or not more than 185 metres apart in Scotland and which is subject to a speed limit of 30mph;
andome said:
If this is the case, if you are in a 20 limit area, is there a requirement for repeater signs,
The quick answer is that a road subject to a 20mph limit requires repeater signs at regular intervals; 20mph zones do not require repeater signs (although such signs are not specifically prohibited, as is suggested by Bucks CC's website from the link in post #2).Edited by SS2. on Friday 21st March 05:13
Vonhosen and SS2 are correct.
Flemke, these are not "guidelines" - the requirements are set out in the Traffic Signs Regulations and General Directions and in the appropriate chapters of the Traffic Signs Manual. Not only does that tell you where you MUST have repeater signs (for the limit to be enforceable) but also where you MUST NOT use them (for example repeater 30 signs within a system of street lights, or repeater NSL where there are no street lights).
Flemke, these are not "guidelines" - the requirements are set out in the Traffic Signs Regulations and General Directions and in the appropriate chapters of the Traffic Signs Manual. Not only does that tell you where you MUST have repeater signs (for the limit to be enforceable) but also where you MUST NOT use them (for example repeater 30 signs within a system of street lights, or repeater NSL where there are no street lights).
Edited by tvrgit on Friday 21st March 08:08
tvrgit said:
Flemke, these are not "guidelines" - the requirements are set out in the Traffic Signs Regulations and General Directions and in the appropriate chapters of the Traffic Signs Manual. Not only does that tell you where you MUST have repeater signs (for the limit to be enforceable) but also where you MUST NOT use them (for example repeater 30 signs within a system of street lights, or repeater NSL where there are no street lights).
You may well be correct, although that is not what R. Bentley and one of the top UK motoring solicitors told me when an allegation was made against me. The issue was signs that were so wildly outside the "requirements" that I genuinely believed that the limit was different from what it allegedly was. We ultimately won the case, but only after a lot of hard work. All along they told me that - in practice - the LA did not have an inviolable obligation to heed the requirements (which they sometimes called 'guidelines'), although the fact that they had not heeded them could have a strong mitigating influence on the outcome of the case.
One of them even told me that, according to the strictest reading of the law, the LA does not even have an obligation to post speed limit signs in the first place. The idea seemed to be that there had never been any bulletproof legislation that absolutely required the posting of signs, whilst there is bulletproof legislation that requires a vehicle operator to obey whatever speed limit has been properly established for a piece of road.
In practice the LA could not get away with no signs. It is certainly true, however, that citizens are generally expected to obey regulations even when they are no signs reminding them of those regulations, so one could see why such a legal anomaly as no speed-limit-sign-requirement could exist.
As I say, tvr, you could well be correct. I claim to have not a shred of expertise on these matters, which I tried to make clear above. It was quite interesting what these two guys who are experts told me, which I wanted to share with the OP.
Cheers.
Well you have to choose to listen to the experts I suppose.
TSRGD and TSM are clear on how speed limits (and all other regulations) must be signed. There is a particular expertise involved in that, which unfortunately not all local authorities always get right.
I have no expertise in the legal issue of whether any regulation needs to be signed at all - must admit I've never heard that before but there may be some technicality that could, under one expert interpretation, lead to that conclusion. I don't know and I don't pretend to know.
It's up to a court, of course, to decide which of two "expert" interpretations is right.

TSRGD and TSM are clear on how speed limits (and all other regulations) must be signed. There is a particular expertise involved in that, which unfortunately not all local authorities always get right.
I have no expertise in the legal issue of whether any regulation needs to be signed at all - must admit I've never heard that before but there may be some technicality that could, under one expert interpretation, lead to that conclusion. I don't know and I don't pretend to know.
It's up to a court, of course, to decide which of two "expert" interpretations is right.

>>>>>>>>
One of them even told me that, according to the strictest reading of the law, the LA does not even have an obligation to post speed limit signs in the first place. The idea seemed to be that there had never been any bulletproof legislation that absolutely required the posting of signs
>>>>>>>>>>>>
Baloney Flemke.
What about these pieces of legislation:
Traffic Signs and general Directioon 2002
Direction 8
In accordance with the following provisions of this direction and the provisions of direction 9, appropriate signs to which this direction applies shall be placed to indicate the point at which a restriction, requirement, prohibition or speed limit applying to traffic on a road (in this direction and in direction 9 called "the relevant road"
begins
Direc tion 10.
10. - (1) When the sign is placed to indicate the point at which traffic on a road ceases to be subject to a restriction, requirement, prohibition or speed limit, the sign shall be placed on the road as near as practicable to that point.
(2) Where a length of road ceases to be subject to a speed limit and becomes subject to a national speed limit, the sign shown in diagram 671 shall be placed at or as near as practicable to the point where the speed limit ends and the national speed limit begins.
Particlar in relation to speed limits:
Road Traffic Regulation Act 1984
85.
(1) For the purpose of securing that adequate guidance is given to drivers of motor vehicles as to whether any, and if so what, limit of speed is to be observed on any road, it shall be the duty of the Secretary of State, [F1 in the case of a road for which he is the traffic authority, to] erect and maintain F2 . . . traffic signs in such positions as may be requisite for that purpose.
dvd
One of them even told me that, according to the strictest reading of the law, the LA does not even have an obligation to post speed limit signs in the first place. The idea seemed to be that there had never been any bulletproof legislation that absolutely required the posting of signs
>>>>>>>>>>>>
Baloney Flemke.
What about these pieces of legislation:
Traffic Signs and general Directioon 2002
Direction 8
In accordance with the following provisions of this direction and the provisions of direction 9, appropriate signs to which this direction applies shall be placed to indicate the point at which a restriction, requirement, prohibition or speed limit applying to traffic on a road (in this direction and in direction 9 called "the relevant road"
beginsDirec tion 10.
10. - (1) When the sign is placed to indicate the point at which traffic on a road ceases to be subject to a restriction, requirement, prohibition or speed limit, the sign shall be placed on the road as near as practicable to that point.
(2) Where a length of road ceases to be subject to a speed limit and becomes subject to a national speed limit, the sign shown in diagram 671 shall be placed at or as near as practicable to the point where the speed limit ends and the national speed limit begins.
Particlar in relation to speed limits:
Road Traffic Regulation Act 1984
85.
(1) For the purpose of securing that adequate guidance is given to drivers of motor vehicles as to whether any, and if so what, limit of speed is to be observed on any road, it shall be the duty of the Secretary of State, [F1 in the case of a road for which he is the traffic authority, to] erect and maintain F2 . . . traffic signs in such positions as may be requisite for that purpose.
dvd
Dwight VanDriver said:
>>>>>>>>
One of them even told me that, according to the strictest reading of the law, the LA does not even have an obligation to post speed limit signs in the first place. The idea seemed to be that there had never been any bulletproof legislation that absolutely required the posting of signs
>>>>>>>>>>>>
Baloney Flemke.
What about these pieces of legislation:
Traffic Signs and general Directioon 2002
Direction 8
In accordance with the following provisions of this direction and the provisions of direction 9, appropriate signs to which this direction applies shall be placed to indicate the point at which a restriction, requirement, prohibition or speed limit applying to traffic on a road (in this direction and in direction 9 called "the relevant road"
begins
Direc tion 10.
10. - (1) When the sign is placed to indicate the point at which traffic on a road ceases to be subject to a restriction, requirement, prohibition or speed limit, the sign shall be placed on the road as near as practicable to that point.
(2) Where a length of road ceases to be subject to a speed limit and becomes subject to a national speed limit, the sign shown in diagram 671 shall be placed at or as near as practicable to the point where the speed limit ends and the national speed limit begins.
Particlar in relation to speed limits:
Road Traffic Regulation Act 1984
85.
(1) For the purpose of securing that adequate guidance is given to drivers of motor vehicles as to whether any, and if so what, limit of speed is to be observed on any road, it shall be the duty of the Secretary of State, [F1 in the case of a road for which he is the traffic authority, to] erect and maintain F2 . . . traffic signs in such positions as may be requisite for that purpose.
dvd
dvd,One of them even told me that, according to the strictest reading of the law, the LA does not even have an obligation to post speed limit signs in the first place. The idea seemed to be that there had never been any bulletproof legislation that absolutely required the posting of signs
>>>>>>>>>>>>
Baloney Flemke.
What about these pieces of legislation:
Traffic Signs and general Directioon 2002
Direction 8
In accordance with the following provisions of this direction and the provisions of direction 9, appropriate signs to which this direction applies shall be placed to indicate the point at which a restriction, requirement, prohibition or speed limit applying to traffic on a road (in this direction and in direction 9 called "the relevant road"
beginsDirec tion 10.
10. - (1) When the sign is placed to indicate the point at which traffic on a road ceases to be subject to a restriction, requirement, prohibition or speed limit, the sign shall be placed on the road as near as practicable to that point.
(2) Where a length of road ceases to be subject to a speed limit and becomes subject to a national speed limit, the sign shown in diagram 671 shall be placed at or as near as practicable to the point where the speed limit ends and the national speed limit begins.
Particlar in relation to speed limits:
Road Traffic Regulation Act 1984
85.
(1) For the purpose of securing that adequate guidance is given to drivers of motor vehicles as to whether any, and if so what, limit of speed is to be observed on any road, it shall be the duty of the Secretary of State, [F1 in the case of a road for which he is the traffic authority, to] erect and maintain F2 . . . traffic signs in such positions as may be requisite for that purpose.
dvd
I tried to make clear that I was only relating what I was told by two different people whose profession is representing the public in allegations of motoring offences. I know for a fact that each of them has been on the winning side in numerous court cases, and not merely on the basis of whether the constable had calibrated his speedo that morning, worn the right reflective clothing, or other officious trivia. Thus they both have professional credibility. It may be that I misunderstood what I was told, although at the time there seemed to be no ambiguity.
What I would say, dvd, (again, from my layman's viewpoint of almost total ignorance) is that the legislation that you cited seems to cover terminal signs, but does not mention repeater signs - is that right?
Also, it refers to the responsibilities of the Secretary of State for the roads that are within his(her) purview. Is it not the case that, for portions of the UK road system, the SoS is not the traffic authority?
Cheers.
flemke said:
What I would say, dvd, (again, from my layman's viewpoint of almost total ignorance) is that the legislation that you cited seems to cover terminal signs, but does not mention repeater signs - is that right?
Also, it refers to the responsibilities of the Secretary of State for the roads that are within his(her) purview. Is it not the case that, for portions of the UK road system, the SoS is not the traffic authority?
Cheers.
Those particular parts cover terminal signs, but the requirements for repeater signs are set out elsewhere in the same regulations.Also, it refers to the responsibilities of the Secretary of State for the roads that are within his(her) purview. Is it not the case that, for portions of the UK road system, the SoS is not the traffic authority?
Cheers.
You're absolutely right that that particular part of the Act covers roads maintained by the SoS - ie motorways and trunk roads. Local Authorities are bound by the same requirements (I think in the next section of the Act but I don't have it to hand so can't be sure) for other roads within their area.
ETA - found it!
RTRA84 Section 85 in its entirety said:
85. Traffic signs for indicating speed restrictions.— (1) For the purpose of securing that adequate guidance is given to drivers of motor vehicles as to whether any, and if so what, limit of speed is to be observed on any road, it shall be the duty of the Secretary of State, in the case of a road for which he is the traffic authority, to erect and maintain traffic signs in such positions as may be requisite for that purpose.
(2) In the case of any other road, it is the duty of the local traffic authority—
(a)to erect and maintain traffic signs in such positions as may be requisite in order to give effect to general or other directions given by the Secretary of State for the purpose mentioned in subsection (1) above, and
(b)to alter or remove traffic signs as may be requisite in order to give effect to such directions, either in consequence of the making of an order by the Secretary of State or otherwise.
(2) In the case of any other road, it is the duty of the local traffic authority—
(a)to erect and maintain traffic signs in such positions as may be requisite in order to give effect to general or other directions given by the Secretary of State for the purpose mentioned in subsection (1) above, and
(b)to alter or remove traffic signs as may be requisite in order to give effect to such directions, either in consequence of the making of an order by the Secretary of State or otherwise.
Edited by tvrgit on Friday 21st March 15:28
tvrgit said:
flemke said:
What I would say, dvd, (again, from my layman's viewpoint of almost total ignorance) is that the legislation that you cited seems to cover terminal signs, but does not mention repeater signs - is that right?
Also, it refers to the responsibilities of the Secretary of State for the roads that are within his(her) purview. Is it not the case that, for portions of the UK road system, the SoS is not the traffic authority?
Cheers.
Those particular parts cover terminal signs, but the requirements for repeater signs are set out elsewhere in the same regulations.Also, it refers to the responsibilities of the Secretary of State for the roads that are within his(her) purview. Is it not the case that, for portions of the UK road system, the SoS is not the traffic authority?
Cheers.
You're absolutely right that that particular part of the Act covers roads maintained by the SoS - ie motorways and trunk roads. Local Authorities are bound by the same requirements (I think in the next section of the Act but I don't have it to hand so can't be sure) for other roads within their area.
ETA - found it!
RTRA84 Section 85 in its entirety said:
85. Traffic signs for indicating speed restrictions.— (1) For the purpose of securing that adequate guidance is given to drivers of motor vehicles as to whether any, and if so what, limit of speed is to be observed on any road, it shall be the duty of the Secretary of State, in the case of a road for which he is the traffic authority, to erect and maintain traffic signs in such positions as may be requisite for that purpose.
(2) In the case of any other road, it is the duty of the local traffic authority—
(a)to erect and maintain traffic signs in such positions as may be requisite in order to give effect to general or other directions given by the Secretary of State for the purpose mentioned in subsection (1) above, and
(b)to alter or remove traffic signs as may be requisite in order to give effect to such directions, either in consequence of the making of an order by the Secretary of State or otherwise.
(2) In the case of any other road, it is the duty of the local traffic authority—
(a)to erect and maintain traffic signs in such positions as may be requisite in order to give effect to general or other directions given by the Secretary of State for the purpose mentioned in subsection (1) above, and
(b)to alter or remove traffic signs as may be requisite in order to give effect to such directions, either in consequence of the making of an order by the Secretary of State or otherwise.
At the same, I am bound to say that I (and no doubt thousands of other drivers) was made to go through an enormous and costly palaver with the CPS to establish what, on the face of your and dvd's citations, apparently should have been a black-and-white case of speed limit signage falling far below the "required" standard.
Cheers.
Gassing Station | Speed, Plod & the Law | Top of Page | What's New | My Stuff


