R.T.A Question - DVD types!!!
R.T.A Question - DVD types!!!
Author
Discussion

cptsideways

Original Poster:

13,896 posts

283 months

Saturday 22nd March 2008
quotequote all
One for the Road Traffic act Boffins

Previous advise from Trafpol has told me a vehicle on an export certificate (not necessarily a UK one so an import) is exempt from an MOT, displaying reg plates etc, so long as the vehicle is going from its port of entry to its destination. Obviously it still needs to be insured.

Obviously trade plates help, but technically its under the same rules as the car would not have been mot'd or registered. Having spoken only a couple of weeks ago to a friendly Trafpol at Southampton docks doing checks it would appear to be the case.

A friend has been pulled in Wales on its way from Docks to Destination, sans trade plates, vehicle was on an export cert from Japan, had export & insurance papers with him. All legit just local plod in wales appear to not have a clue & have issued a summons. Will try & find out for exactly what.



Now I've looked everywhere in the RTA & can't find anything thats remotely usefull, would anyone care to advise biggrin


One would have thought that there might be a "citizens request button" to find out if one could be breaking the law or not on any matter since they've introduced so many new laws - or is there such a thing?

Dwight VanDriver

6,583 posts

275 months

Saturday 22nd March 2008
quotequote all
Thats a Saturday night crap on TV question.......

Complex but as far as I can make out:

Motor Vehicles(Tests) Regulations 1981
Reg 6 (2) (c) - exemptions from Section 47 RTA 88 (Test certificate)

where the vehicle has been imported into Great Britain, for the purpose of its being driven after arrival in Great Britain on the journey from the place where it has arrived in Great Britain to a place of residence of the owner or driver of the vehicle;

There is a further exemption from MOT in relation to a vehicle proceedings by prior arrangement to a
test centre for the purposes of being tested.

Under Vehicles Excise and Registration Act, 1994 a vehicle only is entered on The Register when application made for first Licence has been made at which point VRM is allocated and which has to be displayed. I am not aware of any exemption in relation to the use on a road immediately on import without VRM.

Under Schedule 2 of that Act which deals with exemption from Excise Licence, whilst a vehicle going for export is covered one being imported is not.

But there is an exemption, like Test Certificate, whilst vehicle proceedings to a pre-arranged test.

DVLA in their site state:

A vehicle that is permanently imported for use in Great Britain (GB) must be registered and taxed as soon as possible after it arrives in the country. The vehicle should not be used or kept on public roads until the registration and vehicle tax formalities have been completed.
However, if the vehicle needs to have a single vehicle approval (SVA) or MOT test in order to be registered, the vehicle may be driven to and from the pre-arranged test appointment. Thereafter, the vehicle must be kept off the road until the registration formalities have taken place.
Application for registration should be made to your nearest Driver and Vehicle Licensing Agency (DVLA) local office. It is not possible to offer an 'over the counter service', registration usually takes between 48 to 72 hours.

UK law requires a vehicle to be UK taxed and registered for road use. To avoid difficulties, importers are advised to transport, rather than drive their vehicles from the port to home or first destination and to keep them off the road until they have been properly licensed and registered.

Part II, Schedule 6 Motor Vehicles (Reg and Licensing) Regs 2002 covers the issue and permitted use of a vehicle on Trade Plates.

Trade Plate is a substitute for Excise Licence. Covered are persons in the Motor Trade . i.e. involved in dealing and the repair of vehicles or valeting and are covered in moving a vehicle to premises where it is to be kept. There are certian other permissions which are not relevant in this case. This only excuses no Excise Licence not the failure to display VRM's.

Be interested to learn just what offences you were reported for and how you fit in as a 'Motor Trader'

dvd


Edited by Dwight VanDriver on Sunday 23 March 07:33

cptsideways

Original Poster:

13,896 posts

283 months

Saturday 22nd March 2008
quotequote all
Cheers for that, as I thought there appears to be no actual exemption or actual law that states you can't? Now the car was technically on its way to be MOT'd as it was a couple of days later & subequently registered. Technically the car was still registered in Japan although as Exported at that time. The chap is a trader & does have trade plates though they were in use on another vehicle at the time.

Hence why I asked the friendly trafpol only last week what the situation was, as even with trade plates the rules still apply. He said not a problem if it was on route to its destiantion, but thats Trafpol they know the score & generally locally at the docks will only check for insurance & legit trade plates etc. Though I'm thinking the law is different & to non trafpols an unknown quantity

He has had a summons for "Failure to display" a registration mark, which the summons gives the reg number of, though at the at the time it was'nt even reg'd! They obviously dug it out via the chassis number & subsequent reg'ing I'm assuming.

Am I correct that the offence is non endorsable at the roadside, is it the same for going to court?


Many thanks DVD always a star when it comes to the finer workings of the R.T.A

Dwight VanDriver

6,583 posts

275 months

Sunday 23rd March 2008
quotequote all
If it does go to Court (why no FPN ??? maybe he was not too sure???) then for failing to display just a nominal fine no points.

But is there No vehicle Excise Licence as well?

dvd

Edited by Dwight VanDriver on Sunday 23 March 13:47

Richard C

1,685 posts

288 months

Sunday 23rd March 2008
quotequote all
cptsideways said:
Cheers for that, as I thought there appears to be no actual exemption or actual law that states you can't? Now the car was technically on its way to be MOT'd as it was a couple of days later & subequently registered. Technically the car was still registered in Japan although as Exported at that time. The chap is a trader & does have trade plates though they were in use on another vehicle at the time.

Hence why I asked the friendly trafpol only last week what the situation was, as even with trade plates the rules still apply. He said not a problem if it was on route to its destiantion, but thats Trafpol they know the score & generally locally at the docks will only check for insurance & legit trade plates etc. Though I'm thinking the law is different & to non trafpols an unknown quantity

He has had a summons for "Failure to display" a registration mark, which the summons gives the reg number of, though at the at the time it was'nt even reg'd! They obviously dug it out via the chassis number & subsequent reg'ing I'm assuming.

Am I correct that the offence is non endorsable at the roadside, is it the same for going to court?


Many thanks DVD always a star when it comes to the finer workings of the R.T.A
You cannot commit an offence of 'Failing to display' a VRN which had not been issued at the time of the offence. One cannot obtain a VRN in advance as DVLA local offices will only supply it from their available sequence of VRNs when the registration fee is paid. Which needs all the documents including SVA test to be in order before they can accept the fee.

I have done this twice on personally importing Evo Lancers from Japan. Driven from Southampton to Chester. Trafpol followed briefly and drove on.

DVLA Chester insisted on me attending to enable them to inspect the car. Inspection consisted of humourless lady looking blankly at the underbonnet and then asking why the odometer did not read zero; " delivery mileage" She accepted it. They had previously agreed I had to drive it VRNless to their offices as I did not have a trailer.

Dwight VanDriver

6,583 posts

275 months

Sunday 23rd March 2008
quotequote all
The Road Vehicles (Display of Registration Marks) Regulations 2001 Stipulates plates have to be displayed front and rear of vehicle. No exemptions as far as I can see for imports. If on a road plates to be displayed.

Section 42 VERA 94 creates the offence of not fixing a VRM but has a defence

(a) he had no reasonable opportunity to register the vehicle under this Act, and

(b) the vehicle was being driven for the purpose of being so registered.

which does not seem to be the case as no mention of contact with DVLA to Reg start of the current journey or being driven to a DVLA Office.

Obligation to register a vehicle with Sec of State (S 23 VERA) who will then issue VRM when application made for RFL.

This case no application made to register so no VRM issued (which could had been if done right), vehicle on the road without plates and Excise licence for a purpose not exempt so I argue that if things had been done right all would have been hunky dory which they weren't so as no offence of failing to register exists one has to go to VERA for non display of plates and possible Excise offence.

The notes of DVLA would tend to agree as they say it should have been trailed in,sorted and then used on a road.

dvd

vonhosen

40,597 posts

248 months

Sunday 23rd March 2008
quotequote all
"I didn't have a trailer" doesn't sound much of a defence.

cptsideways

Original Poster:

13,896 posts

283 months

Sunday 23rd March 2008
quotequote all
Ahh but you can't reg a vehicle until it's MOT'd !! which it was some 3 days after import (it'll need a fog light fitting for starters to pass its mot)


To be honest this is a very regular "offence" if it is one coming out of the docks, and as I said if you have export papers & proof of insurance the local Trafpol despite stopping let you go. Its a very frequent occurance that the plod & vosa are at the gates.

vonhosen

40,597 posts

248 months

Sunday 23rd March 2008
quotequote all
cptsideways said:
Ahh but you can't reg a vehicle until it's MOT'd !! which it was some 3 days after import (it'll need a fog light fitting for starters to pass its mot)


To be honest this is a very regular "offence" if it is one coming out of the docks, and as I said if you have export papers & proof of insurance the local Trafpol despite stopping let you go. Its a very frequent occurance that the plod & vosa are at the gates.
Still no reason why it can't be on a trailer, other than you don't want to pay for one of course & that's not a great excuse.

cptsideways

Original Poster:

13,896 posts

283 months

Sunday 23rd March 2008
quotequote all
The Road Vehicles (Display of Registration Marks) Regulations 2001 Stipulates plates have to be displayed front and rear of vehicle. No exemptions as far as I can see for imports. If on a road plates to be displayed.

Section 42 VERA 94 creates the offence of not fixing a VRM but has a defence

(a) he had no reasonable opportunity to register the vehicle under this Act, and

(b) the vehicle was being driven for the purpose of being so registered.

So driving the vehicle to its place of repair/preparation for its MOT would come under this part? Would appear to be the case. Obviously (a) would apply because (b) as you can't have a chicken before an egg or can you?

Yes it would appear a grey area, hence why I've asked the Trafpol at the docks doing VOSA checks, they would'nt be giving you trouble, but is it the law!! Having trade plates "technically" does'nt make any difference but it IS the norm!!! & yes I have been stopped on my trade plates as per this sitaution and allowed to proceed unhindered.



cptsideways

Original Poster:

13,896 posts

283 months

Sunday 23rd March 2008
quotequote all
vonhosen said:
"I didn't have a trailer" doesn't sound much of a defence.
But please advise exactly which bit of law we are breaking officer...... Especially considering the DVLA suggest otherwise

vonhosen

40,597 posts

248 months

Sunday 23rd March 2008
quotequote all
cptsideways said:
vonhosen said:
"I didn't have a trailer" doesn't sound much of a defence.
But please advise exactly which bit of law we are breaking officer...... Especially considering the DVLA suggest otherwise
No mention that it was being driven for the purpose of being registered, the exemption isn't just to get it to it's destination (ie somewhere else)

Richard C

1,685 posts

288 months

Sunday 23rd March 2008
quotequote all
Dwight VanDriver said:
The Road Vehicles (Display of Registration Marks) Regulations 2001 Stipulates plates have to be displayed front and rear of vehicle. No exemptions as far as I can see for imports. If on a road plates to be displayed.

Section 42 VERA 94 creates the offence of not fixing a VRM but has a defence

(a) he had no reasonable opportunity to register the vehicle under this Act, and

(b) the vehicle was being driven for the purpose of being so registered.

which does not seem to be the case as no mention of contact with DVLA to Reg start of the current journey or being driven to a DVLA Office.

Obligation to register a vehicle with Sec of State (S 23 VERA) who will then issue VRM when application made for RFL.

This case no application made to register so no VRM issued (which could had been if done right), vehicle on the road without plates and Excise licence for a purpose not exempt so I argue that if things had been done right all would have been hunky dory which they weren't so as no offence of failing to register exists one has to go to VERA for non display of plates and possible Excise offence.

The notes of DVLA would tend to agree as they say it should have been trailed in,sorted and then used on a road.

dvd
The journey to the SVA station for statutorily required SVA is part of that registration process. The DVLA will simply not accept an application to register without the SVA certificate.

The woolly language they use such as 'to avoid problems' and 'should be' (trailered) is indicative of the complexities their procedures have created. And the interlocking difficulties that they have created for the average person who wants to comply with the law

Vonhosen: I cannot see the need to use a trailer. 'Should' is not 'must'

vonhosen

40,597 posts

248 months

Sunday 23rd March 2008
quotequote all
Richard C said:
Dwight VanDriver said:
The Road Vehicles (Display of Registration Marks) Regulations 2001 Stipulates plates have to be displayed front and rear of vehicle. No exemptions as far as I can see for imports. If on a road plates to be displayed.

Section 42 VERA 94 creates the offence of not fixing a VRM but has a defence

(a) he had no reasonable opportunity to register the vehicle under this Act, and

(b) the vehicle was being driven for the purpose of being so registered.

which does not seem to be the case as no mention of contact with DVLA to Reg start of the current journey or being driven to a DVLA Office.

Obligation to register a vehicle with Sec of State (S 23 VERA) who will then issue VRM when application made for RFL.

This case no application made to register so no VRM issued (which could had been if done right), vehicle on the road without plates and Excise licence for a purpose not exempt so I argue that if things had been done right all would have been hunky dory which they weren't so as no offence of failing to register exists one has to go to VERA for non display of plates and possible Excise offence.

The notes of DVLA would tend to agree as they say it should have been trailed in,sorted and then used on a road.

dvd
The journey to the SVA station for statutorily required SVA is part of that registration process. The DVLA will simply not accept an application to register without the SVA certificate.

The woolly language they use such as 'to avoid problems' and 'should be' (trailered) is indicative of the complexities their procedures have created. And the interlocking difficulties that they have created for the average person who wants to comply with the law

Vonhosen: I cannot see the need to use a trailer. 'Should' is not 'must'
Let the court decide, that's what they are there for.

Edited by vonhosen on Sunday 23 March 23:28

Richard C

1,685 posts

288 months

Sunday 23rd March 2008
quotequote all
vonhosen said:
Richard C said:
Dwight VanDriver said:
The Road Vehicles (Display of Registration Marks) Regulations 2001 Stipulates plates have to be displayed front and rear of vehicle. No exemptions as far as I can see for imports. If on a road plates to be displayed.

Section 42 VERA 94 creates the offence of not fixing a VRM but has a defence

(a) he had no reasonable opportunity to register the vehicle under this Act, and

(b) the vehicle was being driven for the purpose of being so registered.

which does not seem to be the case as no mention of contact with DVLA to Reg start of the current journey or being driven to a DVLA Office.

Obligation to register a vehicle with Sec of State (S 23 VERA) who will then issue VRM when application made for RFL.

This case no application made to register so no VRM issued (which could had been if done right), vehicle on the road without plates and Excise licence for a purpose not exempt so I argue that if things had been done right all would have been hunky dory which they weren't so as no offence of failing to register exists one has to go to VERA for non display of plates and possible Excise offence.

The notes of DVLA would tend to agree as they say it should have been trailed in,sorted and then used on a road.

dvd
The journey to the SVA station for statutorily required SVA is part of that registration process. The DVLA will simply not accept an application to register without the SVA certificate.

The woolly language they use such as 'to avoid problems' and 'should be' (trailered) is indicative of the complexities their procedures have created. And the interlocking difficulties that they have created for the average person who wants to comply with the law

Vonhosen: I cannot see the need to use a trailer. 'Should' is not 'must'
Let the court decide, that's what they are there for.

Edited by vonhosen on Sunday 23 March 23:28
Let the local police report it if they are insufficiently knowledegable of the law. In theory the CPS could prosecute if they consider an offence has been committed AND it is in the public interest to do so. But Hey....why let common sense get in the way of a motorist prosecution....theres targets to be met.....senior officers' salaries depend on it.....and political agendas to be satisfied

vonhosen

40,597 posts

248 months

Sunday 23rd March 2008
quotequote all
Richard C said:
vonhosen said:
Richard C said:
Dwight VanDriver said:
The Road Vehicles (Display of Registration Marks) Regulations 2001 Stipulates plates have to be displayed front and rear of vehicle. No exemptions as far as I can see for imports. If on a road plates to be displayed.

Section 42 VERA 94 creates the offence of not fixing a VRM but has a defence

(a) he had no reasonable opportunity to register the vehicle under this Act, and

(b) the vehicle was being driven for the purpose of being so registered.

which does not seem to be the case as no mention of contact with DVLA to Reg start of the current journey or being driven to a DVLA Office.

Obligation to register a vehicle with Sec of State (S 23 VERA) who will then issue VRM when application made for RFL.

This case no application made to register so no VRM issued (which could had been if done right), vehicle on the road without plates and Excise licence for a purpose not exempt so I argue that if things had been done right all would have been hunky dory which they weren't so as no offence of failing to register exists one has to go to VERA for non display of plates and possible Excise offence.

The notes of DVLA would tend to agree as they say it should have been trailed in,sorted and then used on a road.

dvd
The journey to the SVA station for statutorily required SVA is part of that registration process. The DVLA will simply not accept an application to register without the SVA certificate.

The woolly language they use such as 'to avoid problems' and 'should be' (trailered) is indicative of the complexities their procedures have created. And the interlocking difficulties that they have created for the average person who wants to comply with the law

Vonhosen: I cannot see the need to use a trailer. 'Should' is not 'must'
Let the court decide, that's what they are there for.

Edited by vonhosen on Sunday 23 March 23:28
Let the local police report it if they are insufficiently knowledegable of the law. In theory the CPS could prosecute if they consider an offence has been committed AND it is in the public interest to do so. But Hey....why let common sense get in the way of a motorist prosecution....theres targets to be met.....senior officers' salaries depend on it.....and political agendas to be satisfied
Why do you assume they aren't knowledgeable ?
I don't see anything in the original post to say that it was being specifically driven for the purpose of being registered. Perhaps the officer who stopped him asked the pertinent questions & the right answers weren't forthcoming so he's been reported. I'm sure they aren't going to worry about reporting him too much.

Edited by vonhosen on Sunday 23 March 23:54

Richard C

1,685 posts

288 months

Monday 24th March 2008
quotequote all
vonhosen said:
Richard C said:
vonhosen said:
Richard C said:
Dwight VanDriver said:
The Road Vehicles (Display of Registration Marks) Regulations 2001 Stipulates plates have to be displayed front and rear of vehicle. No exemptions as far as I can see for imports. If on a road plates to be displayed.

Section 42 VERA 94 creates the offence of not fixing a VRM but has a defence

(a) he had no reasonable opportunity to register the vehicle under this Act, and

(b) the vehicle was being driven for the purpose of being so registered.

which does not seem to be the case as no mention of contact with DVLA to Reg start of the current journey or being driven to a DVLA Office.

Obligation to register a vehicle with Sec of State (S 23 VERA) who will then issue VRM when application made for RFL.

This case no application made to register so no VRM issued (which could had been if done right), vehicle on the road without plates and Excise licence for a purpose not exempt so I argue that if things had been done right all would have been hunky dory which they weren't so as no offence of failing to register exists one has to go to VERA for non display of plates and possible Excise offence.

The notes of DVLA would tend to agree as they say it should have been trailed in,sorted and then used on a road.

dvd
The journey to the SVA station for statutorily required SVA is part of that registration process. The DVLA will simply not accept an application to register without the SVA certificate.

The woolly language they use such as 'to avoid problems' and 'should be' (trailered) is indicative of the complexities their procedures have created. And the interlocking difficulties that they have created for the average person who wants to comply with the law

Vonhosen: I cannot see the need to use a trailer. 'Should' is not 'must'
Let the court decide, that's what they are there for.

Edited by vonhosen on Sunday 23 March 23:28
Let the local police report it if they are insufficiently knowledegable of the law. In theory the CPS could prosecute if they consider an offence has been committed AND it is in the public interest to do so. But Hey....why let common sense get in the way of a motorist prosecution....theres targets to be met.....senior officers' salaries depend on it.....and political agendas to be satisfied
Why do you assume they aren't knowledgeable ?
I don't see anything in the original post to say that it was being specifically driven for the purpose of being registered. Perhaps the officer who stopped him asked the pertinent questions & the right answers weren't forthcoming so he's been reported. I'm sure they aren't going to worry about reporting him too much.
vonhosen said:
Richard C said:
vonhosen said:
Richard C said:
Dwight VanDriver said:
The Road Vehicles (Display of Registration Marks) Regulations 2001 Stipulates plates have to be displayed front and rear of vehicle. No exemptions as far as I can see for imports. If on a road plates to be displayed.

Section 42 VERA 94 creates the offence of not fixing a VRM but has a defence

(a) he had no reasonable opportunity to register the vehicle under this Act, and

(b) the vehicle was being driven for the purpose of being so registered.

which does not seem to be the case as no mention of contact with DVLA to Reg start of the current journey or being driven to a DVLA Office.

Obligation to register a vehicle with Sec of State (S 23 VERA) who will then issue VRM when application made for RFL.

This case no application made to register so no VRM issued (which could had been if done right), vehicle on the road without plates and Excise licence for a purpose not exempt so I argue that if things had been done right all would have been hunky dory which they weren't so as no offence of failing to register exists one has to go to VERA for non display of plates and possible Excise offence.

The notes of DVLA would tend to agree as they say it should have been trailed in,sorted and then used on a road.

dvd
The journey to the SVA station for statutorily required SVA is part of that registration process. The DVLA will simply not accept an application to register without the SVA certificate.

The woolly language they use such as 'to avoid problems' and 'should be' (trailered) is indicative of the complexities their procedures have created. And the interlocking difficulties that they have created for the average person who wants to comply with the law

Vonhosen: I cannot see the need to use a trailer. 'Should' is not 'must'
Let the court decide, that's what they are there for.

Edited by vonhosen on Sunday 23 March 23:28
Let the local police report it if they are insufficiently knowledegable of the law. In theory the CPS could prosecute if they consider an offence has been committed AND it is in the public interest to do so. But Hey....why let common sense get in the way of a motorist prosecution....theres targets to be met.....senior officers' salaries depend on it.....and political agendas to be satisfied
Why do you assume they aren't knowledgeable ?
I don't see anything in the original post to say that it was being specifically driven for the purpose of being registered. Perhaps the officer who stopped him asked the pertinent questions & the right answers weren't forthcoming so he's been reported. I'm sure they aren't going to worry about reporting him too much.
VH, please read
OP said:
A friend has been pulled in Wales on its way from Docks to Destination....

vonhosen

40,597 posts

248 months

Monday 24th March 2008
quotequote all
Richard C said:
VH, please read
OP said:
A friend has been pulled in Wales on its way from Docks to Destination....
Destination can mean anything, home can be destination.

Edited by vonhosen on Monday 24th March 00:14

Dwight VanDriver

6,583 posts

275 months

Monday 24th March 2008
quotequote all
Like many posts on here Richard we are only privy to what we are told with little or no chance to interrogate the poster/person involved in the incident.

I, rightly or wrongly, read that CPT's friend had imported a vehicle and was taking it it home/garage from Docks and had been stopped, reported for No VRM (and possible Excise offence).

From that one tries to come up with the pertinent pieces of law and as VH states without being able to question more deeply.

So if what we state does not meet your perception then don't blame Plod as he cannot allow vehicles here and there running around without VRM's.

I think we would agree that the current state is somewhat wooly and a better system could(should) be brought in but until such time as it is

the law is the law.....amen

dvd

Edited by Dwight VanDriver on Monday 24th March 07:52

cptsideways

Original Poster:

13,896 posts

283 months

Monday 24th March 2008
quotequote all
Thanks for this guys, so were agreed it's a woolly area then biggrin

VH would pull & report for the offence & the let the court decide what the law is 6 months down the line, to great expense to all I expect. For an offence that possibly does'nt exist.

Local Trafpol to the docks stop you check your doc's & wave you on, perhaps in the wrong or not who knows.

Noddy the officer in Wales pulls you, has'nt got a clue, issues a 7 day wonder, then later issues a FPN for no number plates weeks after the incident having indirectly obtained the VRM from DVLA after it was issued. Which then has to go court wasting everbody's time & at great expense for an offence that possibly does'nt exist.


So who in our great government can I ask such a question regards the statute law & receive a confirmed answer, is it the job of the courts post possible offence? surely not