MOT vesus C&U regs
Author
Discussion

andmole

Original Poster:

1,594 posts

242 months

Sunday 23rd March 2008
quotequote all
I have noticed on several threads lately the stated difference between the MOT test and the C&U regs for motor vehicles, and to illustrate I include the following:

another poster elsewhere when discussing number plates said:
They can fail you on illegal spacing but the special notice you are thinking of was rescinded.
We are still at the "it has to be readable and obviously not illegally spaced stage" as far as spacing goes.
Don't forget that the MOT bears no resemblance to C&U regs which the police will use.
I ask you, what chance does the ordinary motorist face given this apparent contradiction? Most people won't have even heard of C&U regs, and will rely on the MOT to give them an indication that their car is legal. Views please, should the MOT be toughened up to more accurately reflect the C&U regs, or should the state stop being so bloody anal with respect to some of the exact petty specifications for motor vehicles? Or is this just another example of the current climate of persecution faced by the motorist?

Please note, I am not suggesting that all of the C&U regs are bad, I realise that many of them are vitally important for safety, I just happen to think that some of them are a far too convenient stick with which to beat the motorist

herewego

8,814 posts

244 months

Sunday 23rd March 2008
quotequote all
Widening the scope of the MOT would increase the costs considerably. the government were looking into reducing the frequency of the MOT in order to reduce costs, particularly for business. I don't know where that went. I suppose it would be better for people who have innocently bought a car with illegal window tints, or exhaust, to have this corrected at MOT time. At least it's much more likely to be picked up by the MOT than by the police.

Dwight VanDriver

6,583 posts

275 months

Sunday 23rd March 2008
quotequote all
If a vehicle had to be checked against every aspect of the Con and Use then that's going to be an all day job surely.

MOT to concentrate on basic safety factors such as brake, steering, tyres and the like in my book.

dvd

Hooli

32,278 posts

231 months

Sunday 23rd March 2008
quotequote all
most of the public dont need to know about C&U regs. if your car is standard then it complies with them. its only when you want to modify it in someway you need to worry about them.

esselte

14,626 posts

298 months

Sunday 23rd March 2008
quotequote all
Hooli said:
most of the public dont need to know about C&U regs. if your car is standard then it complies with them. its only when you want to modify it in someway you need to worry about them.
How do you know it's standard though?Wasn't there an item a while ago where cars, direct from the manufacturers, were failing the window tint allowance?

andmole

Original Poster:

1,594 posts

242 months

Sunday 23rd March 2008
quotequote all
esselte said:
Hooli said:
most of the public dont need to know about C&U regs. if your car is standard then it complies with them. its only when you want to modify it in someway you need to worry about them.
How do you know it's standard though?Wasn't there an item a while ago where cars, direct from the manufacturers, were failing the window tint allowance?
And of course if you buy a car from someone who has modified it, perhaps only slightly, and it has an MOT certificate, then surely you would imagine it to be OK?

Hooli

32,278 posts

231 months

Sunday 23rd March 2008
quotequote all
yes i think i remember that one about window tint now you mention it.

as to buying cars, id say most cars on the road are standard except for say a new stereo/wheeltrims so its unlikely you'd get one that doesnt comply.

sultanbrown

5,740 posts

262 months

Sunday 23rd March 2008
quotequote all
And what about the thread on here at the mo' about the chap getting fined for his number plates being spaced wrongly by 2mm?
Would you notice?

andmole

Original Poster:

1,594 posts

242 months

Sunday 23rd March 2008
quotequote all
sultanbrown said:
And what about the thread on here at the mo' about the chap getting fined for his number plates being spaced wrongly by 2mm?
Would you notice?
That was where I got the original quote from.

How's about this for an idea? If a vehicle has a current MOT, but fails one of the C&U regs, then no points or fine as long as it is fixed within 7 days, (the 7 day idea exists already in some form IIRC).

Richard C

1,685 posts

288 months

Sunday 23rd March 2008
quotequote all
andmole said:
sultanbrown said:
And what about the thread on here at the mo' about the chap getting fined for his number plates being spaced wrongly by 2mm?
Would you notice?
That was where I got the original quote from.

How's about this for an idea? If a vehicle has a current MOT, but fails one of the C&U regs, then no points or fine as long as it is fixed within 7 days, (the 7 day idea exists already in some form IIRC).
Nahhh !

Too logical

Tahere are convictions to be had to meet targets here etc.

Dwight VanDriver

6,583 posts

275 months

Monday 24th March 2008
quotequote all
>>>>How's about this for an idea? If a vehicle has a current MOT, but fails one of the C&U regs, then no points or fine as long as it is fixed within 7 days, (the 7 day idea exists already in some form IIRC). <<<<<

To some degree this is already in being under the Vehicle Defect Rectification Scheme.

dvd

Derek Smith

50,023 posts

279 months

Monday 24th March 2008
quotequote all
herewego said:
Widening the scope of the MOT would increase the costs considerably. the government were looking into reducing the frequency of the MOT in order to reduce costs, particularly for business. I don't know where that went. I suppose it would be better for people who have innocently bought a car with illegal window tints, or exhaust, to have this corrected at MOT time. At least it's much more likely to be picked up by the MOT than by the police.
If anything it looks likely that costs will increase for MoTs when (probably) they are changed to biannually. A lot of the test will be automated but the intention is for it to be more thorough. It is unlikely that the Con & Use Regs will be part of it but it seems that it will go a long way to bridging that gap.

However, testing stations will have to invest heavily in new equipment and training so it will have to be recouped somehow. There will be far fewer testing stations as well.

I can't help thinking this is a retrograde step. If you stop five cars, three of them will have faults. One car will be in a dangerous condition. Space the MoT two years apart and this will got up to five will have faults, three in dangerous condition.

There was a fair bit of publicity about this 18 months ago but it's ll gone quiet at the moment so that would suggest it's about to be brought in under enabling legislation, like the Dog and Cats, Tattooing Act, 1324.

jith

2,752 posts

246 months

Monday 24th March 2008
quotequote all
Dwight VanDriver said:
If a vehicle had to be checked against every aspect of the Con and Use then that's going to be an all day job surely.

MOT to concentrate on basic safety factors such as brake, steering, tyres and the like in my book.

dvd
Yes DVD, theoratically that's how it should work. In practice however it's a different ball game.

The classic example of this is the current MOT benchmark for the thickness of brake pads to pass. They should be the thickness of a fifty pence piece; of course on a heavy car like a Jag or Merc, you could devour this thickness in only a day causing metal to metal contact and seriously degraded braking.
The cost of the MOT is now so high, that it should carry a warranty of some sort with it and should definitely be in harmony with the RTA.

andmole

Original Poster:

1,594 posts

242 months

Monday 24th March 2008
quotequote all
Dwight VanDriver said:
>>>>How's about this for an idea? If a vehicle has a current MOT, but fails one of the C&U regs, then no points or fine as long as it is fixed within 7 days, (the 7 day idea exists already in some form IIRC). <<<<<

To some degree this is already in being under the Vehicle Defect Rectification Scheme.

dvd
That's what it's called, thanks dvd. Unfortunately it's only "to some degree" as you say.