Is it Really this black and white?
Is it Really this black and white?
Author
Discussion

maverick25

Original Poster:

166 posts

274 months

Monday 24th March 2008
quotequote all
Hi all,

On Friday I was behind a car stopped at traffic lights on a 3 lane roundabout leading onto a dual carriageway. The lights went green and the guy didn't move for some time. Whilst the lights were still green however he proceeded ahead. I continued through the green light, looked to my right (natural reaction on a roundabout) and BANG. The guy had just stopped halfway around the roundabout and I hit the back of him. There was no way I could have seen him, He literally stopped because as he said "he was confused".

Now I am faced with the accident being "my Fault" and therefore have to claim on insurance and pay my £1400 excess!
My insurance company said that even if I had a load of witnesses and the other driver admitted fault, I would still be at fault. is it really this black and white? There really was nothing I could have done and the guy admitted blame.

Many thanks in advance for any advice.

RobDickinson

31,343 posts

285 months

Monday 24th March 2008
quotequote all
Think so. Doesn't sound like they were driving dangerous (no court will say driving too slow & being cautious is wrong I think).

You were not looking, you didnt have enough distance, I doubt you'd win the argument.

Fort Jefferson

8,237 posts

253 months

Monday 24th March 2008
quotequote all
maverick25 said:
is it really this black and white?
Yes, it's your fault. The only exception, is if the other driver is drunk.

FishFace

3,790 posts

239 months

Monday 24th March 2008
quotequote all
It's not an exception if he's drunk.


RobDickinson

31,343 posts

285 months

Monday 24th March 2008
quotequote all
Rule (1) - dont drive into the car ahead.

HarryW

16,079 posts

300 months

Monday 24th March 2008
quotequote all
My one and only accident as a 17 year old was exactly this. I still to this day maintain the guy in front wanted a rear end respray/insurance claim. Bottom line 100% my fault but I do understand where you are coming from.

maverick25

Original Poster:

166 posts

274 months

Monday 24th March 2008
quotequote all
I see. So I can travel along a road, slam on the brakes because I was "confused" (like the driver I went into) and everyone who piles into the back of me is to blame?

I'm being pedantic i know, but Im so angry. This guy literally stopped on a 3 lane roundabout and admitted it was his fault.

Negative Creep

26,145 posts

258 months

Monday 24th March 2008
quotequote all
What if the car in front has no brake lights (as often happens)? Is it still your fault then?

maverick25

Original Poster:

166 posts

274 months

Monday 24th March 2008
quotequote all
I guess so as you you "wouldnt have had enough distance"

RobDickinson

31,343 posts

285 months

Monday 24th March 2008
quotequote all
maverick25 said:
I see. So I can travel along a road, slam on the brakes because I was "confused" (like the driver I went into) and everyone who piles into the back of me is to blame?

I'm being pedantic i know, but Im so angry. This guy literally stopped on a 3 lane roundabout and admitted it was his fault.
You should always be at a distance and rpepaired to stop - what if they have to slam on due to something in the road, a kid running out etc?

As for brake lights - if there not working then I assume your OK to crash into them....

Flintstone

8,644 posts

278 months

Monday 24th March 2008
quotequote all
Very, very rarely in a rear end shunt will insurers not place the blame on the driver of the car behind. Expect the worst of idiots like this and you'll rarely be disappointed.

Derek Smith

50,023 posts

279 months

Tuesday 25th March 2008
quotequote all
It is a clear case of without due care. It is up to you as the driver of the following car not to run into the car in front. There are no arguments - brake lights are of no account. You hit him, you pay.

There are other 'general rules'. The stationary car is not to blame, even if parked in a dangerous position as, if there is danger, all cars should be stationary.

The car on the 'wrong' side of the road is at fault, although this one is more conditional.

And, although I don't want to start another argument, the driver who is speeding and texting whilst driving through a traffic light controlled junction is always at fault as (s)he would be driving dangerously.

Someone raised the point that you should leave sufficient gap between you and the car in front so that if the other car brakes suddenly you can stop. I know this means that you will be overtaken and end up going backwards in a forward gear, but that's the way the insurance companies regard it.

heebeegeetee

30,257 posts

279 months

Tuesday 25th March 2008
quotequote all
maverick25 said:
I see. So I can travel along a road, slam on the brakes because I was "confused" (like the driver I went into) and everyone who piles into the back of me is to blame?

I'm being pedantic i know, but Im so angry. This guy literally stopped on a 3 lane roundabout and admitted it was his fault.
You have my upmost sympathy, but i think the thing for us all to think is, that there are some really ste drivers out there. Its up to us not to get involved in their crap.

TallPaul

1,524 posts

289 months

Tuesday 25th March 2008
quotequote all
This is a very common scam, wait for the claims for whiplash to roll in. If you think his brakelights were defective, the police can test the bulbs to see if they were lit when the crash occured (assuming the lights are broken). Although the insurance companies are well aware if this type of fraud, it can be very difficult to prove it.

Mahatma Bag

27,595 posts

310 months

Tuesday 25th March 2008
quotequote all
He was probably brake testing you...

This happened to me years ago; easy mistake to make. You have to be ABSOLUTELY sure that the car in front is out of the way before you move off.

Derek Smith

50,023 posts

279 months

Tuesday 25th March 2008
quotequote all
I was waiting to pull onto the roundabout at the Royal Standard at Blackheath from Old Dover Road, this in the late 60s. The view to my right was very restricted. I waited until there was a gap then eased forwards only to see a chap coming at some speed from Charlton Way and I had to brake. I then felt quite a bump and my car, a P4 Rover, was knocked forwards a couple of feet, scaring the life out of the bloke I had braked for.

A middle-aged chap in an Austin A35 had driven into the nearside corner of my rear bumper, pushing the front wing onto his offside front wheel. I wnet up to him only to find that he was being nagged by his wife. She was saying how bad a driver he was and at one time also criticised the trousers he was wearing. His explanation, when he was allowed to speak, was that as soon as I moved forward, he looked to the right to look for a gap. He saw the other car late although he did manage to brake.

My passenger and I levered his front wing out enough so that it did not foul the wheel and as I had no damage, he went on his way - still being nagged by his missus. I could here her saying how lucky he was that he'd driven into the back of such nice people as they could have sued him.

So the front seat passenger of an Austin A35 also thinks that the person responsible in a rear end shunt is the one behind. I wouldn't argue with her.

marlinmunro

3,071 posts

236 months

Tuesday 25th March 2008
quotequote all
heebeegeetee said:
maverick25 said:
I see. So I can travel along a road, slam on the brakes because I was "confused" (like the driver I went into) and everyone who piles into the back of me is to blame?

I'm being pedantic i know, but Im so angry. This guy literally stopped on a 3 lane roundabout and admitted it was his fault.
You have my upmost sympathy, but i think the thing for us all to think is, that there are some really ste drivers out there. Its up to us not to get involved in their crap.
My only shunt in 40 years was as you described also my wife who is as sharp as a pin, got caught out by a silly old fker. You pay they Know its their fault but never admit it. Some will at the incident but later will always back track. It takes a long time before you start trusting that a car in front has actually gone. Your concentration is very much on traffic coming at you at a rate of knots. Because roundabouts are a place that you have to go like fk and prevent anybody getting on to them.

Jasandjules

72,686 posts

260 months

Tuesday 25th March 2008
quotequote all
Isn't it an offence to stop on a roundabout without a good reason? Or to stop suddenly at all? (i.e. brake testing)

Bottom line is you'll struggle to get any reduction in this one from your insurance co. but it doesn't hurt to try.

DucatiGary

7,765 posts

256 months

Tuesday 25th March 2008
quotequote all
FishFace said:
It's not an exception if he's drunk.
what if its some goon testing their brakes?

Tunku

7,703 posts

259 months

Tuesday 25th March 2008
quotequote all
maverick25 said:
Hi all,

On Friday I was behind a car stopped at traffic lights on a 3 lane roundabout leading onto a dual carriageway. The lights went green and the guy didn't move for some time. Whilst the lights were still green however he proceeded ahead. I continued through the green light, looked to my right (natural reaction on a roundabout) and BANG. The guy had just stopped halfway around the roundabout and I hit the back of him. There was no way I could have seen him, He literally stopped because as he said "he was confused".

Now I am faced with the accident being "my Fault" and therefore have to claim on insurance and pay my £1400 excess!
My insurance company said that even if I had a load of witnesses and the other driver admitted fault, I would still be at fault. is it really this black and white? There really was nothing I could have done and the guy admitted blame.

Many thanks in advance for any advice.
I've seen a few close calls on roundabouts with lights, the car in front starts off because the light is green, sees another set that is red, but are not for him, gets confused and stops quickly. Unfortunately it's still your fault, you took your eye off the ball. I do sympathise though, it is hard to check right to make sure no one is running their red light whilst you go through your green light as the chump in front misreads the red light for the next bit as his and bangs all on. Hang back is all I can suggest.
I live in Dunfermline where the major roundabout in town has been revamped to include traffic lights. I've seen people stop at the exit of this roundabout thinking the red light stopping traffic at the entrance to their left is for them. It's a bloody stupid design.