Court expenses, not able to claim if defendant!
Court expenses, not able to claim if defendant!
Author
Discussion

shocker-z

Original Poster:

554 posts

249 months

Tuesday 25th March 2008
quotequote all
Hi All,

Sopme of you mnay have read my latest posts with regards to attending court to contest 3 points for having alledgedly stopped on zigzag lines.

Post: http://www.pistonheads.com/gassing/topic.asp?h=0&t=508235 

I wrote a letter to the court asking about expenses and they wrote this:

"I have enclosed the appropriate claim form for expenses. I have to inform you, however, that you are not entitled to loss of earnings."


So what they are saying is that any officer in the UK can say, Hey you were on zigzag lines or any other offence, give you a FPN. Natuarally like myself you take it to court and win as they decide they have nothing to go with (23 hours before my trial!!!) and then just let you cope with the £150 loss of earnings from taking 2 days off work.

How can this be that nothing is done about it!? This is proberly costing tens of thousands in loss of earnings from officers not doing their jobs correctly! and we're then ones that pay them to do their job and the ones that pay for them doing their jobs incorrectly!

Do you think as mentioned in previouse post by tigger1 i should write to the paperes about this? Do you think i will get anywhere?

What are your views? Just think what if it happened to yourself? would you be happy at paying for a mistake?

Regards
Liam

SS2.

14,712 posts

269 months

Tuesday 25th March 2008
quotequote all
shocker-z said:
What are your views?
If a defendant's costs order has been awarded, you will find it fairly straightforward to be recompensed for mileage (45p / mile, IIRC), parking at cost, printing / photocopying (of your defence documents, case law etc..wink) at High Street rates..

You will find it much harder / impossible to claim litigant in person preparation time at £9.25 per hour of work done.

You will have no luck whatsoever being reimbursed with loss of earnings as a result of time away from work - it is specifically excluded from being paid.

Edited by SS2. on Tuesday 25th March 12:39

NobleGuy

7,133 posts

246 months

Tuesday 25th March 2008
quotequote all
shocker-z said:
So what they are saying is that any officer in the UK can say, Hey you were on zigzag lines or any other offence, give you a FPN. Natuarally like myself you take it to court and win as they decide they have nothing to go with (23 hours before my trial!!!) and then just let you cope with the £150 loss of earnings from taking 2 days off work.
Yep. Absolutely pathetic. Yet another stick to encourage us not to contest. If they have taken you down that route falsely then they should be made to pay for your incurred losses.

shocker-z

Original Poster:

554 posts

249 months

Tuesday 25th March 2008
quotequote all
It just seems so rediculas that they can give a FPN to anyone for anything even if they didnt do it and make them pay to defend themselves!

Is there no route to go to argue the case as per the officer even stating that i was in a place with no zigzag lines!


EDIT:
NobleGuy said:
shocker-z said:
So what they are saying is that any officer in the UK can say, Hey you were on zigzag lines or any other offence, give you a FPN. Natuarally like myself you take it to court and win as they decide they have nothing to go with (23 hours before my trial!!!) and then just let you cope with the £150 loss of earnings from taking 2 days off work.
Yep. Absolutely pathetic. Yet another stick to encourage us not to contest. If they have taken you down that route falsely then they should be made to pay for your incurred losses.
yes exacly, even more so when they are the ones that say there not pressing charges and therefore admit they are incorrect!

Regards
Liam

Edited by shocker-z on Tuesday 25th March 13:47

SS2.

14,712 posts

269 months

Tuesday 25th March 2008
quotequote all
shocker-z said:
Is there no route to go to argue the case..
Depends how pi55ed off you are..wink

For instance, you could write to the Chief Constable of the force in question and detail that which you think you are owed - and why you think you are owed it..

If / when payment is not forthcoming (and after reminders have been sent), you could choose to commence proceedings against the CC using a debt recovery service (ie www.moneyclaim.gov.uk)..evil

I wouldn't like to predict the odds of success of the above tactic (I suspect it would depend upon the CC contesting the claim or not), but I can't see much by way of other options open to you if you are intent on seeking 'lost' earnings or out of pocket expenses (aside from those listed in my previous post).

Edited by SS2. on Tuesday 25th March 14:13

JustinP1

13,364 posts

261 months

Tuesday 25th March 2008
quotequote all
shocker-z said:
Hi All,

Sopme of you mnay have read my latest posts with regards to attending court to contest 3 points for having alledgedly stopped on zigzag lines.

Post: http://www.pistonheads.com/gassing/topic.asp?h=0&t=508235 

I wrote a letter to the court asking about expenses and they wrote this:

"I have enclosed the appropriate claim form for expenses. I have to inform you, however, that you are not entitled to loss of earnings."


So what they are saying is that any officer in the UK can say, Hey you were on zigzag lines or any other offence, give you a FPN. Natuarally like myself you take it to court and win as they decide they have nothing to go with (23 hours before my trial!!!) and then just let you cope with the £150 loss of earnings from taking 2 days off work.

How can this be that nothing is done about it!? This is proberly costing tens of thousands in loss of earnings from officers not doing their jobs correctly! and we're then ones that pay them to do their job and the ones that pay for them doing their jobs incorrectly!

Do you think as mentioned in previouse post by tigger1 i should write to the paperes about this? Do you think i will get anywhere?

What are your views? Just think what if it happened to yourself? would you be happy at paying for a mistake?

Regards
Liam
Last time I heard you are entitled to a maximum of £50 per day. Not surprisingly though, they don't actually let you know this and seemingly some of the court staff don't actually know this...

Noger

7,117 posts

280 months

Tuesday 25th March 2008
quotequote all
Misfeasance in Public Office ?

DPX

1,027 posts

231 months

Tuesday 25th March 2008
quotequote all
Heads they win , tails you lose .
I guess this is why so many people just take the cheaper option and pay up.
It is just a tax on demand now.

shocker-z

Original Poster:

554 posts

249 months

Tuesday 25th March 2008
quotequote all
DPX said:
Heads they win , tails you lose .
I guess this is why so many people just take the cheaper option and pay up.
It is just a tax on demand now.
Yeah, i would have paid it if it were just a fine but didnt want the points! just one of them things! needing a car for my job and all!

Do you reckon people know that they are not entitled? do you think the papers is a good idea to get word out and see if people pick up on it and come to any kind of agreement.

I can understand you not being entitled to claim if you loose the battle as you were in the wrong but the whole thing of having to goto court, producing un arguable evidence then being told you still need to reappear in court followed by a letter less than 24hours before the trial advising that I am no longer needed (did they really not speak with the officer until the day before the court hearing!?)

It's really rattled my cage and pcensoredssed on my strawberries!

Liam

Edited by shocker-z on Tuesday 25th March 17:28

JustinP1

13,364 posts

261 months

Tuesday 25th March 2008
quotequote all
shocker-z said:
DPX said:
Heads they win , tails you lose .
I guess this is why so many people just take the cheaper option and pay up.
It is just a tax on demand now.
Yeah, i would have paid it if it were just a fine but didnt want the points! just one of them things! needing a car for my job and all!

Do you reckon people know that they are not entitled? do you think the papers is a good idea to get word out and see if people pick up on it and come to any kind of agreement.

I can understand you not being entitled to claim if you loose the battle as you were in the wrong but the whole thing of having to goto court, producing un arguable evidence then being told you still need to reappear in court followed by a letter less than 24hours before the trial advising that I am no longer needed (did they really not speak with the officer until the day before the court hearing!?)

It's really rattled my cage and pcensoredssed on my strawberries!

Liam

Edited by shocker-z on Tuesday 25th March 17:28
If you are not entitled to £50 per day then I am wrong.

I will willingly stand to be corrected, but I really would suggest going back to them and quoting the £50 and see what they say. You are entitled to out of pocket expenses. The only caveat I know of is that the maximum for loss of earnings is £50 per day.

SS2.

14,712 posts

269 months

Tuesday 25th March 2008
quotequote all
JustinP1 said:
If you are not entitled to £50 per day then I am wrong.
Hmm. I have personal experience of chasing payment of a costs' order after a case against me was dismissed and I have to say that payments in lieu of loss of earnings to a successful defendant (or a defendant where a case is not proceeded) is a new one on me..

In fact, everything I have read on the subject seems unequivocal - loss of earnings are not payable.

Practice Direction Costs: Criminal Proceedings 2004 2 All ER 1070 said:
2.1 Defence Costs from the Central Funds

An order in favour of a defendant for payment of his costs may be made under section 16 of the 1985 Act (‘a Defendant’s Costs Order). A Defendant’s Costs Order may be made in favour of an accused:

(a) In a Magistrates’ Court where: an information laid before a Justice of the Peace for any area charging any person with an offence is not proceeded with; a Magistrates’ Court determines not to transfer for trial proceedings for an indictable offence; or the Magistrates’ Court dealing summarily with an offence dismisses the information.
and...

Practice Direction Costs: Criminal Proceedings 2004 2 All ER 1070 said:
2.4 Amount of costs payable

The amount of the costs shall be ‘such amount as the court considers reasonably sufficient to compensate him for any expenses properly incurred by him in the proceedings’. The effect of section 21(4A) of the 1985 Act is that the amount of any costs payable under the representation order is not taken into account in the determination of the amount payable out of Central Funds under the defendant’s Costs Order. Thus the amount payable out of Central Funds in such cases will reflect only the defendant’s out of pocket expenses.

Where a defendant has been represented privately he will be personally liable to discharge the relevant costs and would therefore benefit from such an order. A defendant who is acquitted is entitled to an allowance for travelling and subsistence as if he had been a witness. An allowance which he would not receive if no defendant’s costs order was made. He is not entitled to be paid his loss of earnings. The solicitors acting for a CDS-funded defendant may, in certain circumstances, charge him, pursuant to Regulation 22 of the Criminal Defence Service (General) (No.2) Regulations 2001 [http://www.legislation.hmso.gov.uk/si/si2001/20011437.htm], for the expenses or fees incurred in preparing, obtaining or considering any report, opinion or further evidence provided by an expert witness or otherwise or obtaining any transcripts or recordings where an application for an authority to incur such fees or expenses has been refused by the Costs Committee. Those expenses would be covered by a defendant’s costs order. The Judge should therefore make a defendant’s costs order in favour of an acquitted defendant, whether legally assisted or not, in every case when it is appropriate to do so.
Witnesses - now that's a different matter. They can claim somewhere around £33.50 (half day) or £67 (full day) against loss of earnings. As well as overnight allowances, subsistence, travel etc etc..

JustinP1

13,364 posts

261 months

Tuesday 25th March 2008
quotequote all
SS2. said:
JustinP1 said:
If you are not entitled to £50 per day then I am wrong.
Hmm. I have personal experience of chasing payment of a costs' order after a case against me was dismissed and I have to say that payments in lieu of loss of earnings to a successful defendant (or a defendant where a case is not proceeded) is a new one on me..

In fact, everything I have read on the subject seems unequivocal - loss of earnings are not payable.

Practice Direction Costs: Criminal Proceedings 2004 2 All ER 1070 said:
2.1 Defence Costs from the Central Funds

An order in favour of a defendant for payment of his costs may be made under section 16 of the 1985 Act (‘a Defendant’s Costs Order). A Defendant’s Costs Order may be made in favour of an accused:

(a) In a Magistrates’ Court where: an information laid before a Justice of the Peace for any area charging any person with an offence is not proceeded with; a Magistrates’ Court determines not to transfer for trial proceedings for an indictable offence; or the Magistrates’ Court dealing summarily with an offence dismisses the information.
and...

Practice Direction Costs: Criminal Proceedings 2004 2 All ER 1070 said:
2.4 Amount of costs payable

The amount of the costs shall be ‘such amount as the court considers reasonably sufficient to compensate him for any expenses properly incurred by him in the proceedings’. The effect of section 21(4A) of the 1985 Act is that the amount of any costs payable under the representation order is not taken into account in the determination of the amount payable out of Central Funds under the defendant’s Costs Order. Thus the amount payable out of Central Funds in such cases will reflect only the defendant’s out of pocket expenses.

Where a defendant has been represented privately he will be personally liable to discharge the relevant costs and would therefore benefit from such an order. A defendant who is acquitted is entitled to an allowance for travelling and subsistence as if he had been a witness. An allowance which he would not receive if no defendant’s costs order was made. He is not entitled to be paid his loss of earnings. The solicitors acting for a CDS-funded defendant may, in certain circumstances, charge him, pursuant to Regulation 22 of the Criminal Defence Service (General) (No.2) Regulations 2001 [http://www.legislation.hmso.gov.uk/si/si2001/20011437.htm], for the expenses or fees incurred in preparing, obtaining or considering any report, opinion or further evidence provided by an expert witness or otherwise or obtaining any transcripts or recordings where an application for an authority to incur such fees or expenses has been refused by the Costs Committee. Those expenses would be covered by a defendant’s costs order. The Judge should therefore make a defendant’s costs order in favour of an acquitted defendant, whether legally assisted or not, in every case when it is appropriate to do so.
Witnesses - now that's a different matter. They can claim somewhere around £33.50 (half day) or £67 (full day) against loss of earnings. As well as overnight allowances, subsistence, travel etc etc..
I hear what you are saying, but I am pretty sure I did not dream up about the £50.

The important thing in the paragraph you have quoted is that it starts:

'Where a defendant has been represented privately...' before the section you highlighted with regard to loss of earnings. That would of course make sense as the solicitor would have been spending the time coming to court and doing the legwork for which he will be paid for with a costs order.

If nothing else, the OP should be able to claim the costs as he was standing as a witness?

Edited by JustinP1 on Tuesday 25th March 20:03

SS2.

14,712 posts

269 months

Tuesday 25th March 2008
quotequote all
JustinP1 said:
If nothing else, the OP should be able to claim the costs as he was standing as a witness?
Except that he wasn't a witness, he was the defendant.

JustinP1

13,364 posts

261 months

Tuesday 25th March 2008
quotequote all
SS2. said:
JustinP1 said:
If nothing else, the OP should be able to claim the costs as he was standing as a witness?
Except that he wasn't a witness, he was the defendant.
He was going to take the stand as far as I am aware?

Just because he is also the defendant, I don't think prevents him being classed as a witness?

Derek Smith

50,023 posts

279 months

Tuesday 25th March 2008
quotequote all
It's an interesting point. However the magistrates court is not responsbile for the ineptitude of the CPS. Neither, I would say, are the police. I believe that the CPS as an institution cannot be sued although I have no idea where this nugget of information came from so I would suggest it is not dependable.

However, I have glanced through the other threads and it would appear that the CPS have behaved poorly and have failed to comply with their own guidelines. One option might be to write to the head of the CPS in the area detailing the loss of earnings and our of pocket expenses incurred and asking for recompense, pointing out that you were at all times willing to proceed but that they were unable to do so for reasons of their own.

Another consideration might be your employers pointing out that they had lost your services for that length of time and are a bit miffed (on the assumption they know you exist).

I've found that if you ask pertinent questions (that you already know the answer to of course) that put them in a bad light then this can help.

It is often said that a polite intial enquiry can be beneficial and you can always up the tempo later. At one time I had to deal with minor claims against my division for damages often by offenders who had got off for whatever reason. If it was a reasonable request worded politely, I'd normally pay without problem. We were normally liable and it didn't come out of my pocket. If it contained a threat or was offensive then I would refuse. After all, if the money was paid six months later then we'd got some interest from it.

However the law is a law unto itself. Be prepared to have to let it go. The system has the upper hand and is not reluctant to use it. You might have to be satisfied with having pissed them off.

But emphasise that you are innocent of the offence but, despite this, you have been forced to pay out many times what you would have been fined because of errors they have made. Tell them that you expect people to make mistakes. No one is perfect. You make mistakes in your job and your firm has to foot the bill. The same should go for them.

SS2.

14,712 posts

269 months

Tuesday 25th March 2008
quotequote all
JustinP1 said:
Just because he is also the defendant, I don't think prevents him being classed as a witness?
The relevant legislation would suggest otherwise. The Costs in Criminal Cases (General) Regulations 1986 detail that which can be claimed by defendants and that which can be claimed by witnesses. They are not the same..

Subject to the court granting a Defence Costs' Order under s.16 of Prosecution of Offences Act 1985, an aquitted defendant is entitled to travel and subsistence allowances plus any other reasonable out of pocket expenses. This is entirely the same as if the defendant had actually been an ordinary witness.

But whilst an ordinary witness is entitled to be recompensed for loss of earnings, the same regulations specifically preclude the defendant from doing the same.

shocker-z

Original Poster:

554 posts

249 months

Wednesday 26th March 2008
quotequote all
Where would i find an address for the CPS?

Would it be localised or a general sorting office of what they want to burn or keep?

Liam

SS2.

14,712 posts

269 months

Wednesday 26th March 2008
quotequote all
shocker-z said:
Where would i find an address for the CPS?
Contact details