Magna Carta
Author
Discussion

ypauly

Original Poster:

15,137 posts

231 months

Tuesday 25th March 2008
quotequote all
My understanding was that this is still law
http://www.statutelaw.gov.uk/content.aspx?activeTe...

yet reading this on the net i notice sections have been repealed this leaves me with two questions

1)How can this happen to rights that were given (FOR EVER)?

2)Could it be used to avoid congestion charge
in the fact that we are free men and as such can enter the city of london (as it is a liberty to which we were used to)



Jasandjules

72,686 posts

260 months

Tuesday 25th March 2008
quotequote all
No Parliament can bind it's successor... Therefore any law can be rescinded... And Parliament Trumped the King....

ypauly

Original Poster:

15,137 posts

231 months

Tuesday 25th March 2008
quotequote all
Jasandjules said:
No Parliament can bind it's successor... Therefore any law can be rescinded... And Parliament Trumped the King....
but this was an agreement to which parliament was formed and if breaching that agreement shouldn't the crown take power back?

and it was given forever


ETA many parliaments have sat inbetween its writing and 1969 if it was only relevant for one term why would parliament repeal a section in 1969???

Edited by ypauly on Tuesday 25th March 19:11

Chrispy Porker

17,761 posts

259 months

Tuesday 25th March 2008
quotequote all
ypauly said:
My understanding was that this is still law
http://www.statutelaw.gov.uk/content.aspx?activeTe...

yet reading this on the net i notice sections have been repealed this leaves me with two questions

1)How can this happen to rights that were given (FOR EVER)?

2)Could it be used to avoid congestion charge
in the fact that we are free men and as such can enter the city of london (as it is a liberty to which we were used to)
No-one is stopping you entering London.
They are charging you to drive there.

ypauly

Original Poster:

15,137 posts

231 months

Tuesday 25th March 2008
quotequote all
Chrispy Porker said:
ypauly said:
My understanding was that this is still law
http://www.statutelaw.gov.uk/content.aspx?activeTe...

yet reading this on the net i notice sections have been repealed this leaves me with two questions

1)How can this happen to rights that were given (FOR EVER)?

2)Could it be used to avoid congestion charge
in the fact that we are free men and as such can enter the city of london (as it is a liberty to which we were used to)
No-one is stopping you entering London.
They are charging you to drive there.
yes but driving there is a liberty i have had for years before red ken did the deed

ATG

23,865 posts

303 months

Tuesday 25th March 2008
quotequote all
Here's a translation of the original: http://www.britannica.com/eb/article-9116848/Magna...

Doesn't quite read like a statement of the fundamental rights of man, but there are some goods bits in there.

A daft bit:
[33] Henceforth all fish-weirs shall be cleared completely from the Thames and the Medway and throughout all England, except along the sea coast.

A good bit:
[40] To no one will we sell, to no one will we refuse or delay right or justice.

Jasandjules

72,686 posts

260 months

Tuesday 25th March 2008
quotequote all
ATG][40 said:
To no one will we sell, to no one will we refuse or delay right or justice.
Say hello to S172....And the inhabitants of Guantanamo Bay.

flemke

23,515 posts

268 months

Tuesday 25th March 2008
quotequote all
Chrispy Porker said:
No-one is stopping you entering London.
They are charging you to drive there.
But if your only practicable way to get there is to drive, and you cannot afford to pay the charge, doesn't it amount to the same thing?

ATG

23,865 posts

303 months

Tuesday 25th March 2008
quotequote all
flemke said:
Chrispy Porker said:
No-one is stopping you entering London.
They are charging you to drive there.
But if your only practicable way to get there is to drive, and you cannot afford to pay the charge, doesn't it amount to the same thing?
No more so than raising the price of a train or bus ticket.

Chrispy Porker

17,761 posts

259 months

Tuesday 25th March 2008
quotequote all
flemke said:
Chrispy Porker said:
No-one is stopping you entering London.
They are charging you to drive there.
But if your only practicable way to get there is to drive, and you cannot afford to pay the charge, doesn't it amount to the same thing?
Not really.

It is no different from being charged to go across a bridge.

ypauly

Original Poster:

15,137 posts

231 months

Tuesday 25th March 2008
quotequote all
anyway the point was if given for ever how can it be changed

ATG

23,865 posts

303 months

Tuesday 25th March 2008
quotequote all
Chrispy Porker said:
flemke said:
Chrispy Porker said:
No-one is stopping you entering London.
They are charging you to drive there.
But if your only practicable way to get there is to drive, and you cannot afford to pay the charge, doesn't it amount to the same thing?
Not really.

It is no different from being charged to go across a bridge.
More daft bits:
[23] No vill or individual shall be compelled to make bridges at river banks, except those who from of old are legally bound to do so.

Jasandjules

72,686 posts

260 months

Tuesday 25th March 2008
quotequote all
ypauly said:
anyway the point was if given for ever how can it be changed
Because Parliament decided that IT had power to do what it wanted.

ypauly

Original Poster:

15,137 posts

231 months

Tuesday 25th March 2008
quotequote all
this definatly does not state it's for 1 parlimentary term it was forever



[63] Wherefore we wish and firmly enjoin that the English church shall be free, and that the men in our kingdom shall have and hold all the aforesaid liberties, rights and concessions well and peacefully, freely and quietly, fully and completely, for themselves and their heirs from us and our heirs, in all matters and in all places for ever, as is aforesaid. An oath, moreover, has been taken, as well on our part as on the part of the barons, that all these things aforesaid shall be observed in good faith and without evil disposition. Witness the above-mentioned and many others. Given by our hand in the meadow which is called Runnymede between Windsor and Staines on the fifteenth day of June, in the seventeenth year of our reign.

flemke

23,515 posts

268 months

Tuesday 25th March 2008
quotequote all
Chrispy Porker said:
flemke said:
Chrispy Porker said:
No-one is stopping you entering London.
They are charging you to drive there.
But if your only practicable way to get there is to drive, and you cannot afford to pay the charge, doesn't it amount to the same thing?
Not really.

It is no different from being charged to go across a bridge.
Quite. There are still private toll bridges in this country. So long as they're private, one can understand why the public would not be "free", that is, "at liberty", to cross them without the owner's permission.
The other form of bridge toll is to pay for the cost of constructing the bridge itself. This too has a logic to it - someone has to pay for it to be created, so why shouldn't that be those who benefit most from it?

The great city of London is not private property, nor does London's road network have to be built from scratch. It is public property, and was built decades and centuries ago.

In the case of car access to London, the issue is only partly the principle of a fee per se. Livingstone intends to raise the stakes to the point where the levy would be extortionate and arbitrary, absurdly disproportionate to any realistic estimate of the actual incremental cost to society of driving a 3 litre car in London.

The proposed 25 pound levy has nothing to do with congestion, as there are many 3 litre cars with physical footprints no bigger than sub-3 litre cars.
The proposed levy also has nothing to do with carbon footprints. If we use the carbon trading market as a guide to the "cost" of carbon emissions, we see that the carbon cost of a Chelsea Tractor's driving around London is pennies a day - not 8 pounds, and nothing even remotely like 25 pounds.
The proposed 25 pound charge is about one thing - Livingstone's perverse wish to punish certain people. Yet many of the people whom he hopes to punish need to travel by private vehicle, and many of them cannot afford to give up their old larger displacement cars and buy something shiny and new that meets with the approval of London's mayor without a driving licence.

In effect, Livingstone would make it impossible for some people to come into London. His purpose is not based on the rights of a private property holder, and it is not based on a need to fund a utility that was built for the benefit of his intended victims.


ypauly

Original Poster:

15,137 posts

231 months

Tuesday 25th March 2008
quotequote all
Jasandjules said:
ypauly said:
anyway the point was if given for ever how can it be changed
Because Parliament decided that IT had power to do what it wanted.
yes but rights given by the crown if changed/removed
shouldn't they require ratification from the crown?

ATG

23,865 posts

303 months

Tuesday 25th March 2008
quotequote all
ypauly said:
Jasandjules said:
ypauly said:
anyway the point was if given for ever how can it be changed
Because Parliament decided that IT had power to do what it wanted.
yes but rights given by the crown if changed/removed
shouldn't they require ratification from the crown?
They have ... royal assent

vonhosen

40,597 posts

248 months

Tuesday 25th March 2008
quotequote all
ypauly said:
Jasandjules said:
ypauly said:
anyway the point was if given for ever how can it be changed
Because Parliament decided that IT had power to do what it wanted.
yes but rights given by the crown if changed/removed
shouldn't they require ratification from the crown?
Law Bills become Acts by Royal assent.

ypauly

Original Poster:

15,137 posts

231 months

Tuesday 25th March 2008
quotequote all
vonhosen said:
ypauly said:
Jasandjules said:
ypauly said:
anyway the point was if given for ever how can it be changed
Because Parliament decided that IT had power to do what it wanted.
yes but rights given by the crown if changed/removed
shouldn't they require ratification from the crown?
Law Bills become Acts by Royal assent.
didn't know that(learn something new everyday)

but still forever should be forever

Derek Smith

50,023 posts

279 months

Tuesday 25th March 2008
quotequote all
Magna Carta is a very over-rated piece of parchment. It is by no means a bill of rights and all it did was to give conditional authority to people called Norman. The dregs of the population of England - that's everyone with a sensible name - were slaves in all but name, that name being serf.

Much of the constitution of this country goes back to 1066. Most of the heredity lords reckon they can trace their ancestry to the invasion although for many it stops around the time of James 1 who sold off a load of titles to fill his coffers. In fact I think Liz dropped the total number of parasites to 2-300. Many school history books that were in use immediately post war started the list of monarchs at Bill Conqueror. I suppose that's considered racist nowadays.

The Magna Carta was rather like the agreement between the heads of the families in Godfather.