Car dealer responsibilities
Discussion
Jasandjules said:
Does the clutch need replacing?
Did nothing come up on any inspection?
The clutch almost certainly needs replacing, and no-nothing came up on inspection (I don't believe inspections examine clutches?)Did nothing come up on any inspection?
Haven't spoken to the dealer yet, I wanted to know what his responsibilities were before I rang him.
I would say if[/if] the clutch was not slipping at the time of purchase, (You say it has only become apparent after six weeks), and a clutch plate is an expendable wearing part, like tyres or brake shoes, I would imagine it's [b]not covered, unless the dealer offers to make a goodwill contribution to the cost of replacement.
Good luck......
Good luck......

paoloh said:
You come in threatening to sue me and quoting trading standards= No help.
I bet you're in court a lot then......Last car dealer I dealt with due to defects I tried to be nice, then I moved up a gear and pointed out the law, then I sued him, and then I got a nice CCJ put on him.
Jasandjules said:
paoloh said:
You come in threatening to sue me and quoting trading standards= No help.
I bet you're in court a lot then......Last car dealer I dealt with due to defects I tried to be nice, then I moved up a gear and pointed out the law, then I sued him, and then I got a nice CCJ put on him.
I was answering for this situation.
EU_Foreigner said:
No warranty on the car purchase then? If not then you bought it "as seen".
There is no such thing when a consumer buys from a trader.I'm not 100% sure the dealer would be in the right as I said, I rather think it may well fall to a judge to determine, however I'd certainly be inclined to argue that a part which should be good for X thousand miles and years going wrong within 6 weeks isn't great.
The other factors would relate to the value of the vehicle..
Wacky Racer said:
I would say if the clutch was not slipping at the time of purchase, (You say it has only become apparent after six weeks), and a clutch plate is an expendable wearing part, like tyres or brake shoes, I would imagine it's not covered, unless the dealer offers to make a goodwill contribution to the cost of replacement.
Good luck......
Good luck......

Jasandjules said:
It's a very tricky one.
The fact that it needs replacing now only 6 weeks on indicates that it wasn't of suitable quality at the time it was sold, as clearly a clutch of sufficient quality would last more than a few thousand miles and more than two months.
But the vendor would not know that. And even though deemed a 'professional', I don't think could be expected to know that.The fact that it needs replacing now only 6 weeks on indicates that it wasn't of suitable quality at the time it was sold, as clearly a clutch of sufficient quality would last more than a few thousand miles and more than two months.
Of course, they'll have given a 3-month (min) warranty, but it depends what that says...
Of course, is does depend on the condition of the car when you purchased it. If you paid £50 and it had a full tank of petrol I'd be happy if the only problem was a slipping clutch!
If the car hasn't done many miles and the clutch could not reasonably be expected to go after that many miles then I would say there is some responsibility on the dealer. That said, if you've covered 6k miles in those 6 weeks, I'd say not.
If the clutch slipping is unexpected at the mileage the car's covered the first thing I would do is go back and speak to the dealer.
Karl
If the car hasn't done many miles and the clutch could not reasonably be expected to go after that many miles then I would say there is some responsibility on the dealer. That said, if you've covered 6k miles in those 6 weeks, I'd say not.
If the clutch slipping is unexpected at the mileage the car's covered the first thing I would do is go back and speak to the dealer.
Karl
Gassing Station | Speed, Plod & the Law | Top of Page | What's New | My Stuff



