Next door Neighbour Dispute - Advice
Next door Neighbour Dispute - Advice
Author
Discussion

Chrispy Porker

Original Poster:

17,761 posts

259 months

Thursday 27th March 2008
quotequote all
My next door neighbour, who has been living there some years but I have never met, has taken it upon himself to reach over the garden wall and cut down a small damson tree which is (was) in my garden.
He has left a stump about 2 feet high, and has the remains of the tree on his lawn!!!.

I am aware that he is entitled to trim branches that overhang his property (there may have been a few small ones ) but he has cut the whole fecking tree off!!!

The tree was productive and we used to enjoy the fruit in pies.

I would like to ask 3 questions

1. What is my legal redress ?
2. What would you do ?
3. How much of the tree is it reasonable to insert once I have caught him?

Seriously, I am a trifle peeved that he has done this without even as much as speaking to me.

Glassman

25,100 posts

246 months

Thursday 27th March 2008
quotequote all
Nuke his garden.

SS2.

14,712 posts

269 months

Thursday 27th March 2008
quotequote all
Chrispy Porker said:
1. What is my legal redress ?
2. What would you do ?
3. How much of the tree is it reasonable to insert once I have caught him?
1. In reality, other than a small claim for damages, probably very little - but try here.

2. Much as I'd be tempted to feed my German Shepherd a three day old curry and then let him loose in the neighbour's garden for a couple of hours, I'd probably ask the neighbour (in a civil manner) why he took it upon himself to cut down my tree. Perhaps it would be wise to ascertain his reasons for cutting the tree before considering the next move (if any)..

3. Unless he had very good reason for his actions, then all of it - sideways and without lube..biggrin

And no 'issues' at all with this neighbour in the past ?


Edited by SS2. on Thursday 27th March 15:49

Chrispy Porker

Original Poster:

17,761 posts

259 months

Thursday 27th March 2008
quotequote all
SS2. said:
Chrispy Porker said:
1. What is my legal redress ?
2. What would you do ?
3. How much of the tree is it reasonable to insert once I have caught him?
1. In reality, other than a small claim for damages, probably very little - but try here.

2. Much as I'd be tempted to feed my German Shepherd a three day old curry and then let him loose in the neighbour's garden for a couple of hours, I'd probably ask the neighbour (in a civil manner) why he took it upon himself to cut down my tree. Perhaps it would be wise to ascertain the reasons the tree was cut before considering the next move.

3. Unless he had very good reason for his actions, then all of it - sideways and without lube.

And no 'issues' at all with this neighbour in the past ?

Edited by SS2. on Thursday 27th March 15:12
I have never met him.
He moved in about 4 Years ago.
Our garden is half an acre or so and I haven't been down the far end ( where this happened) for months.
I am tempted to dig up the rest, attach a note saying 'you missed a bit' and throw it through his kitchen window. However I value my career too much.

Vesuvius 996

35,829 posts

302 months

Thursday 27th March 2008
quotequote all


To be honest just leave it.

The tree's gone. And the last thing you need is a neigbour dispute, especially now you have to declare it if you sell.


Andy Zarse

10,870 posts

278 months

Thursday 27th March 2008
quotequote all
Agree with SS2, there's not much you can do in reality, other than wave your warrant card at him and mention criminal damage to a productive fruit tree. Ask him to replace it with a new young damson tree, at least he won't get off scot free.

Vesuvius 996

35,829 posts

302 months

Thursday 27th March 2008
quotequote all
Andy Zarse said:
Agree with SS2, there's not much you can do in reality, other than wave your warrant card at him and mention criminal damage to a productive fruit tree. Ask him to replace it with a new young damson tree, at least he won't get off scot free.
To the OP - if you're a police officer can't you arrange to hve his details put on the kiddie fiddler register by accident?


pdV6

16,442 posts

292 months

Thursday 27th March 2008
quotequote all
IIRC doesn't he first have to ask you to prune the tree if it encroaches?
Then, if you don't, he has the right to prune any overhanging branches but must return the wood (and any fruit) to you.
He certainly doesn't have the right to lop the tree down

Dwight VanDriver

6,583 posts

275 months

Thursday 27th March 2008
quotequote all
As I understand it then if you lop someone elses overhangs then you are under a moral duty to return the clippings otherwise it is theft.

get in there and chalk up a detected........

For an easy life and existence remember what Churchill said
......jaw, jaw better than war, war.

dvd

dougc

8,241 posts

296 months

Thursday 27th March 2008
quotequote all
Buy and plant a new tree in the same place and stick a bill through his front door.

timf

369 posts

275 months

Thursday 27th March 2008
quotequote all
1st thing he cut your tree down criminal dammage
2nd he has the remnants in his garden theft

take hime down the cells to explain what he has done

MK4 Slowride

10,028 posts

239 months

Thursday 27th March 2008
quotequote all
Vesuvius 996 said:
Andy Zarse said:
Agree with SS2, there's not much you can do in reality, other than wave your warrant card at him and mention criminal damage to a productive fruit tree. Ask him to replace it with a new young damson tree, at least he won't get off scot free.
To the OP - if you're a police officer can't you arrange to hve his details put on the kiddie fiddler register by accident?
hehe

Failing that, on the register for beastiality?

hidetheelephants

36,436 posts

224 months

Thursday 27th March 2008
quotequote all
Chrispy Porker said:
I would like to ask 3 questions

1. What is my legal redress ?
2. What would you do ?
3. How much of the tree is it reasonable to insert once I have caught him?
1. Price of a replacement mature Damson tree, a gardener to plant it plus costs; I'm not a gardener, but I bet it would be the sunny side of 200 beertokens as mature plants cost loads. Don't think SCC awards money for the embuggerance factor. Is there not a council mandarin available to referee such neighbourhood spats? They normally get excited when people cut down trees without their permission, although this is perhaps not big enough for them.

2. Rectal insertion is pushing my buttons if the beak won't give satisfaction, or if the local council can't help.shootjudge

3. All of it definitely; I would garnish with your prefered chilli sauce for added deterent effect. I'm a Tabasco man myself, although Encona is pretty good.punch

Munter

31,331 posts

272 months

Thursday 27th March 2008
quotequote all
Pop around for a chat. In uniform after work. (No not the one you wear on a friday night with the french nickers rolleyes )

Start with a civil conversation. Find out why he did it. Then find a solution. E.g. he pays for a new tree to be planted somewhere else in your garden that everybody is happy with.

My brother had similar recently. When he was moving in his wife noticed next door drilling a hole into a tree in her garden by leaning over the fence. They agreed the tree needed pruning rather than killing. This was done. 2 weeks later a piece of copper appeared in the tree.

Solution: My brother removed the copper. Walked around to next door and rang the bell. When the door was answered he said "I think you left this in my tree". Had a nice chat and a cup of tea. Bro then cut the now very mangled tree down. And planted 2 plum trees 8 feet away from the fence. Lots of plums and shade. Lovely. hehe

red glow

430 posts

224 months

Thursday 27th March 2008
quotequote all
RIGHT If the branches of your tree interfere with his "enjoyment of his property, it may ammount to a nuisance
The usual way of tackling a legal nuisance is to take the matter to court and ask for dameges and/or an order that the offending item be removed. This is an unnecessarily complicated procedure for so small a matter as an over hanging branch.and expensive .
Now if you had refused to prune the tree, then he would have been able to resort to "self help" and cut off the branches himself.However, the branches do not belong to him,and are not his property, so legally he should have put them in your garden. If the branches did not over hang his property, but merely block the light, there is nothing he can do, unless he had right to light

Deltaf01

1,512 posts

228 months

Thursday 27th March 2008
quotequote all
Chuck a bag of the white stuff over his fence then call the drug squad....

Rusty Moskvitch

22 posts

229 months

Thursday 27th March 2008
quotequote all
I think Munter is right here.
You have to hope your neighbour is a normal, half-decent person who will respond to civil discussion.
I once had a neighbour who was a asshole! There were many incidents of him banging on our walls for no real reason and muttered insults from him. On one occasion I was wondering why the edge of my lawn against his fence was dieing off and then the neighbour from two doors away told me he had seen the one between us "watering" my lawn, which he thought a bit strange at the time.
Following that incident I would occasionally, late at night spray his front garden plants selectively with a glyfostate weed killer. It takes several weeks to work and the plant just withers away. It gave me much pleasure to watch him digging in heaps of manure and fertiliser as he replaced them. He never twigged what had happened but then again he was a bit dim to say the least.

crazypav

295 posts

239 months

Thursday 27th March 2008
quotequote all
I would suggest that your neighbour has harrassed you regarding this and had a look here http://www.askthe.police.uk/content/Q153.htm
and found this

The word harassment is deliberately not defined in the legislation so can cover a wide range of activities (see Related Information). The behaviour must cause alarm, distress or torment. The incidents must be related and must not be two isolated incidents. The further apart the incidents are, the less likely there is to be an offence of harassment. However, all the circumstances of the incident will be taken into account when determining if an offence has been committed.

The law takes into account the "reasonable person" test. Basically this means that if it was felt that a person of reasonable firmness (i.e. the average person on the street) would not be alarmed or distressed by the behaviour, the offence is not committed. The offender must also be aware that the course of conduct they are pursuing would cause the victim to be alarmed or distressed.

If you don't want to involve the police, you could see a solicitor who may begin civil proceedings, if your claim succeeds you may be awarded damages and/or an injunction.

Example: A lives at number 2 and B lives at number 4, there is a dispute over a fence. A keeps going round to B's house to complain about this every night for a fortnight. B is fed up and is beginning to feel distressed about A's constant visits. A is aware that his behaviour will cause distress to B as he is hoping to wear him down into removing the fence.
The above is for harassment without fear of violence. Harassment with fear of violence is a person whose cause of conduct causes another to fear on at least two occasions, that violence will be used against him/her and who knows that his/her behaviour will cause fear of violence on each of the occasions is guilty of an offence.

The incidents must be related (i.e. a course of conduct) and must not be two isolated incidents. The further apart the incidents are, the less likely there is to be an offence of harassment.

The law takes into account the "reasonable person" test. Basically this means that if it was felt that a person of reasonable firmness (i.e. the average person on the street) would not fear violence, the offence is not committed.

Example: A and B are neighbours and A is upset over a fence. A goes round to B's house every night for a week threatening violence to B and damage to the fence if B does not take the fence down. B fears violence, as A is very aggressive in manner. A is aware that his behaviour is aggressive and is hoping to intimidate B into taking the fence down.
If you feel that you are being harassed and you want to involve the police then you should contact your local police force who will take details. If there are any threats of violence towards you, you should inform the police who will treat the matter as a higher priority.

fish

4,064 posts

313 months

Thursday 27th March 2008
quotequote all
Trespass and damage

Civil offenwse?

I'd go for drop round have a chat and agree he pays for a new tree in a different location. If not plant it and send bill then claim through money claim .

SplatSpeed

7,491 posts

282 months

Thursday 27th March 2008
quotequote all
whats the betting the neighbour gets 3 points when his volvo is running slicks