whilst waiting for BiB
Author
Discussion

sir_lurk_alot

Original Poster:

316 posts

226 months

Friday 28th March 2008
quotequote all
There have been various occasions where it has taken officers a long time (sometimes hours, sometimes days) to turn up to an incident. Without wanting to throw mud at the police for any delays in turning up to the incident. Would you be prosecutable for any offenses that happened in the time between calling the police and them turning up?

say a hypothetical situation was:

you came home from a meal with your wife to find someone robbing your house. You detain the burglar whilst your wife calls the police. If the police took a long time to turn up and the burglar had an 'accident' which made it easier for him to be detained, would you be prosecutable for causing the accident?

DucatiGary

7,765 posts

256 months

Friday 28th March 2008
quotequote all
you would be looking at a jail term, minimum 2 years i recon.

the law basically states your in the wrong for not letting them steal stuff from your house.


supermono

7,464 posts

279 months

Friday 28th March 2008
quotequote all
DucatiGary said:
you would be looking at a jail term, minimum 2 years i recon.

the law basically states your in the wrong for not letting them steal stuff from your house.
Just like the laws of English states the contraction of you are is you're not your...

wink

SM

EU_Foreigner

2,838 posts

257 months

Friday 28th March 2008
quotequote all
Probably the same excemption that applies that you can not deduct council tax money for bad performance. In other words, their failure does not allow you to take the law in your own hands.

Very tempting though, isn't it ...

thinfourth2

32,414 posts

235 months

Friday 28th March 2008
quotequote all
DucatiGary said:
you would be looking at a jail term, minimum 2 years i recon.

the law basically states your in the wrong for not letting them steal stuff from your house.
i'm still waiting for a scrote to sue someone for loss of earnings due to them having locked their door

EU_Foreigner

2,838 posts

257 months

Friday 28th March 2008
quotequote all
All that glass is a Health and Safety hazzard as well.

7db

6,060 posts

261 months

Friday 28th March 2008
quotequote all
sir_lurk_alot said:
Would you be prosecutable for any offenses that happened in the time between calling the police and them turning up?
What do you think?

I was detaining the burglar waiting for Police so I committed 12 counts of fraud, which I'd like to be excused.

Of course you're prosecutable. Once you detain / restrain the burglar you are responsible for his well-being. If he struggles you can use reasonable force, but if you put yourself in the place of the Police, expect to shoulder their responsibility too.

Taita

8,020 posts

234 months

Friday 28th March 2008
quotequote all
Regardless of the law, once you are in my house against my wishes, you get to play by my rules.

If that involves all of your fingers somehow mysteriously breaking, diddums.

edmundo

203 posts

277 months

Friday 28th March 2008
quotequote all
At what point would that become holding someone against their will?
What if the BiB couldn't pop by until the next morning, can you keep someone 'tied to a chair' for an hour, 4 hours, a day??

sir_lurk_alot

Original Poster:

316 posts

226 months

Friday 28th March 2008
quotequote all
does the fact that you have called the police and reported the incident as an emergency not count as due diligence? You have taken all reasonable steps, you have caught the burglar in the act, detained him with reasonable force and informed the authorities of the emergency. The fact they havent shown up isnt your fault so why should you be prosecuted if something untoward happened to the little scrote, who took it upon himself to break into your house and steal your belongings, without invitation.

as for:

7db said:
I was detaining the burglar waiting for Police so I committed 12 counts of fraud, which I'd like to be excused.
after I had handcuffed the little scrote to the radiator, the police still hadnt turned up so i decided to start using his credit card on ebay to recoup the cost of my broken windows as I was unsure if the police would turn up at all. If the police didnt turn up I wouldnt be able to claim the windows on the insurance so i was making sure i got the money back.

Ok that may not stick with a judge but how are you going to commit 12 acts of fraud whilst using reasonable force to detain the burglar in the first place?

FishFace

3,790 posts

239 months

Friday 28th March 2008
quotequote all
The point was that if you commit a crime you commit a crime.


Taita

8,020 posts

234 months

Friday 28th March 2008
quotequote all
I commit crimes every day, I use my own moral gauge of whats right and wrong usually.

Mg6b

6,649 posts

294 months

Friday 28th March 2008
quotequote all
DucatiGary said:
you would be looking at a jail term, minimum 2 years i recon.

the law basically states your in the wrong for not letting them steal stuff from your house.
No it doesn't. The law allows you to use reasonable force to arrest and detain anyone who is committing an indictable offence or to defend themselves and their property. Section3 Criminal Law Act 1967.

Once again, 'your', not you're posted opinion is wrong DucatiGary wink

Edited by Mg6b on Friday 28th March 15:40

Mg6b

6,649 posts

294 months

Friday 28th March 2008
quotequote all
Taita said:
I commit crimes every day, I use my own moral gauge of whats right and wrong usually.
Hope you are so philosophical when you are dealt with for doing so wink

sir_lurk_alot

Original Poster:

316 posts

226 months

Friday 28th March 2008
quotequote all
so what constitutes reasonable force (when talking time frames)?

as edmundo says,

edmundo said:
At what point would that become holding someone against their will?
What if the BiB couldn't pop by until the next morning, can you keep someone 'tied to a chair' for an hour, 4 hours, a day??
what if you have the scrote handcuffed to the radiator for 2 days (wasnt there a post on ph where the BiB didnt make it round for 2 days), in which time someone reports them as a missing person?

FishFace said:
The point was that if you commit a crime you commit a crime.
if you are committing a crime by holding the person against their will, albeit waiting for the BiB, does this negate the burglary as they are both criminal offenses?

stepej

445 posts

271 months

Friday 28th March 2008
quotequote all
Mg6b said:
The law allows you to use reasonable force to arrest and detain anyone who is committing an indictable offence or to defend themselves and their property. Section3 Criminal Law Act 1967.
But detain them for how long?... until the police arrive?.... which as we've seen can be anything from 5 minutes to 2 days...

Reasonable force... Does that include tying them up?, or handcuffing them (be they fur lined or not)?

Do you have to allow them use of your toilet?, or feed them while you're waiting?

Taita

8,020 posts

234 months

Friday 28th March 2008
quotequote all
Mg6b said:
Taita said:
I commit crimes every day, I use my own moral gauge of whats right and wrong usually.
Hope you are so philosophical when you are dealt with for doing so wink
Me too, but my sense of right and wrong, and a decent set of parents, stop be me a tt.

Taita

8,020 posts

234 months

Friday 28th March 2008
quotequote all
stepej said:
Mg6b said:
The law allows you to use reasonable force to arrest and detain anyone who is committing an indictable offence or to defend themselves and their property. Section3 Criminal Law Act 1967.
But detain them for how long?... until the police arrive?.... which as we've seen can be anything from 5 minutes to 2 days...

Reasonable force... Does that include tying them up?, or handcuffing them (be they fur lined or not)?

Do you have to allow them use of your toilet?, or feed them while you're waiting?
As long as it takes.

Tying them up / handcuffs / anything I feel is appropriate to make sure he isn't going anywhere or a risk.

No. No food. Maybe a bit of water. If that.

vonhosen

40,597 posts

248 months

Friday 28th March 2008
quotequote all
Taita said:
Regardless of the law, once you are in my house against my wishes, you get to play by my rules.

If that involves all of your fingers somehow mysteriously breaking, diddums.
Statute trumps your self imposed rules anywhere, including in your house.

Taita

8,020 posts

234 months

Friday 28th March 2008
quotequote all
vonhosen said:
Taita said:
Regardless of the law, once you are in my house against my wishes, you get to play by my rules.

If that involves all of your fingers somehow mysteriously breaking, diddums.
Statute trumps your self imposed rules anywhere, including in your house.
Officially yes, but find a Bib who would care that a housebreaker had a broken finger or 8.