Undue Care and Attention
Author
Discussion

944porsche944

Original Poster:

5,995 posts

246 months

Sunday 30th March 2008
quotequote all
I was involved in a car crash last night, I'll explain it the best I can.

Odd cross road junction, I am still not 100% sure who had the right of way though am 90% sure I did and will be visiting the scene again the estabilish in my own mind what happened.

Anyway I was driving along and a Renualt was driving the opposite way, I did an emergency stop but was not good enough and ended up crashing into the Renault. The couple in the car got out and started shouting that I rang the police as I crashed into them, they got rather agressive I was concerned about my car.

I rang the police on their orders and was told to move the car away from the scene as they where blocking the road, I didn't know 100% where I was as I had been following SatNav and let the other people explain where we were.

The Police came out and spoke to the couple who said that my car was basically unroadworthy, they also said I had failed to see them, which was not true, I didn't stop in time, no due to the weather conditions being very wet.

I went through what I thought happened and after many questions (including asking three times if the was mine!!) they said they were going to do me for Undue Care and Attention and are going to reccommend I attend some course.

I didn't react very well to the whole thing and seemed to just be agreeing, I did manage to tell my side to the story, though it seems I've been placed with the blame.

What can I expect?

Today I spoke to my insurance who are coming to look at my car, they say it maybe written off! Though the damage is just the front bumper, light needs re-allining and front wing has a dent in it, thats all I can see, I drove the car home and it drives OK. How can they value an old car like mine? I suspect they'll give me next to nothing if they write it off. The best I can hope for is them repairing it.

Mactac

645 posts

224 months

Sunday 30th March 2008
quotequote all
Might be jumping the gun in advice here, but I yesterday completed jst such a course, which was indeed for people who amongst other things had been put forward for a driver improvement course,

Its a day and a half, cost (me) £170 for the privelige of listening to some half-baked theories spouted by a couple of dhead jobsworths masquerading as road safety staff,

Its a doddle don't sweat it honestly.


If you can use any more detail contact me through profile....

Mactac

645 posts

224 months

Sunday 30th March 2008
quotequote all
Also; having now studied your profile, your car (like mine) will have given you an express jump-the-queue ticket.

I have some useful info in the light of your chosen car which you will find helpful if a course is on the cards

vincenz

697 posts

263 months

Sunday 30th March 2008
quotequote all
So you had a head on? Or pulled out from a junction into the path of the renault?

Hooli

32,278 posts

231 months

Sunday 30th March 2008
quotequote all
vincenz said:
So you had a head on? Or pulled out from a junction into the path of the renault?
yeah ive got no idea what you mean happened either.

randlemarcus

13,646 posts

262 months

Sunday 30th March 2008
quotequote all
Nicola, deep breath and try again wink

Small ding on my 944 set me back a couple of grand to sort outside insurance, so they are terribly easy to have written off.

Write down exactly what happened, and keep this as contemporaneous notes. If you were at fault, and you know this after you revisit the scene, bite their hands off for the awareness course.

Mactac

645 posts

224 months

Sunday 30th March 2008
quotequote all
Totally agree Randal,
Porsche are too readilly written off over pretty insignificant (seemingly) damage.

Adjusters would appear to look no further than the badge before passing judgement.

And you already know that feeling
Dont'cha

944porsche944

Original Poster:

5,995 posts

246 months

Sunday 30th March 2008
quotequote all
Mactac said:
Also; having now studied your profile, your car (like mine) will have given you an express jump-the-queue ticket.

I have some useful info in the light of your chosen car which you will find helpful if a course is on the cards
YHM

Munter

31,331 posts

272 months

Sunday 30th March 2008
quotequote all
I cant quite see how you hit a car coming the otherway at a crossroads. Did they turn in front of you? Or you in front of them?

Still heres hoping the car isn't written off. smile

Mactac

645 posts

224 months

Sunday 30th March 2008
quotequote all
Nicola hi
Take a look at this evenings threads by me especially


'driver improvement course'

on the other thing, they are utterly biased on Porsche,
its the actual driving instructor who will enquire after your accident during the driving part of courses and not in front of the group,

in fact when asked what I drove during the introduction section in class I told them it was the Hilux I arrived in, and they seemed happy with that,

They don't apparently know what to expect of their pupils and their accident/incident background.


As I say, if the course is offered in exchange for not going to court, to press some pathetic prosecution just take it at Once.

30 quid deposit balance just before course begins, take your licence with you......






Got your message & more than happy to expand on course details while its fresh in my mind, when your ready

regards
Mac

944porsche944

Original Poster:

5,995 posts

246 months

Sunday 30th March 2008
quotequote all
Munter said:
I cant quite see how you hit a car coming the otherway at a crossroads. Did they turn in front of you? Or you in front of them?

Still heres hoping the car isn't written off. smile
Its a very odd crossroads, I'm not sure who had right of way, there was no Give Way signs facing me.

I really am quite worried my car is going to be written off, felt sick ever since it happened for worrying about my car frown

944porsche944

Original Poster:

5,995 posts

246 months

Sunday 30th March 2008
quotequote all
Mactac said:
Nicola hi
Take a look at this evenings threads by me especially


'driver improvement course'

on the other thing, they are utterly biased on Porsche,
its the actual driving instructor who will enquire after your accident during the driving part of courses and not in front of the group,

in fact when asked what I drove during the introduction section in class I told them it was the Hilux I arrived in, and they seemed happy with that,

They don't apparently know what to expect of their pupils and their accident/incident background.


As I say, if the course is offered in exchange for not going to court, to press some pathetic prosecution just take it at Once.

30 quid deposit balance just before course begins, take your licence with you......






Got your message & more than happy to expand on course details while its fresh in my mind, when your ready

regards
Mac
Thanks you mean they like Porsche? or don't like Porsche?

What happens do you go on a little drive and talk about it?

Holst

2,468 posts

252 months

Sunday 30th March 2008
quotequote all
944porsche944 said:
Munter said:
I cant quite see how you hit a car coming the otherway at a crossroads. Did they turn in front of you? Or you in front of them?

Still heres hoping the car isn't written off. smile
Its a very odd crossroads, I'm not sure who had right of way, there was no Give Way signs facing me.

I really am quite worried my car is going to be written off, felt sick ever since it happened for worrying about my car frown
Even if it is written off you can ask to buy it from the insurers then use the pay out to repair it yourself.

Mactac

645 posts

224 months

Sunday 30th March 2008
quotequote all
Its no secret,

so...

They leap on the Porsche angle, AND a BMW driver who was silly enough to own up.

Your car is touched on during the 'Hi my names Andrew and I drive a Ford Mondeo 16 Valve POS' (I kid you not, I heard more than One bloke go into quite detailed model description of his Lexus then)

I said I arrived in the Hilux outside in the car-park and they moved on, to the next victim.

Only during the driving assesment in an instructors car during a tea break in the local cafe, did the question get asked,
so why are you here?
they said at the outset, they were unaware of an individuals case, but I was slightly dubious of this statement but can't prove it.



Anyway very little of anyones case history was mentioned, not that it would have bothered me.

streaky

19,311 posts

280 months

Monday 31st March 2008
quotequote all
A mixed bag of comment:

944porsche944 said:
The couple in the car got out and started shouting that I rang the police as I crashed into them, ...
How and why did the couple think you were calling the police at the time you crashed into them?



944porsche944 said:
I rang the police on their orders
Who were they to give you orders? If no-one was injured, there was no need to involve the police.



944porsche944 said:
I didn't know 100% where I was as I had been following SatNav ...
Oops! Were you perhaps paying attention to the SatNav and not to the road?



944porsche944 said:
The Police came out and spoke to the couple who said that my car was basically unroadworthy, ...
Assuming it was the couple who said this, what criteria were they using and what were their qualifications for saying it?



944porsche944 said:
... they also said I had failed to see them, which was not true, I didn't stop in time, no due to the weather conditions being very wet.
Was it wet or not? Regardless, by saying this you have admitted you were driving without due care and attention.



944porsche944 said:
I didn't react very well to the whole thing and seemed to just be agreeing, ...
Generally better to say as little as possible and to consider carefully what you do say ... albeit, in the immediate aftermath of an accident (involving damage to your P&J) and with the police called. that is not always easy to remember.



944porsche944 said:
I did manage to tell my side to the story, though it seems I've been placed with the blame.
As I said above, you appear to have admitted you were unable to stop (in the wet), therefore you were driving too fast for the conditions and your and your car's abilities ... regardless, BTW, of whether you were travelling at less that the prevailing speed limit at the time.

Streaky

Edited by streaky on Monday 31st March 16:39

HRG

72,863 posts

270 months

Monday 31st March 2008
quotequote all
Mactac said:
Nicola hi
Take a look at this evenings threads by me especially


'driver improvement course'

on the other thing, they are utterly biased on Porsche,
its the actual driving instructor who will enquire after your accident during the driving part of courses and not in front of the group,

in fact when asked what I drove during the introduction section in class I told them it was the Hilux I arrived in, and they seemed happy with that,

They don't apparently know what to expect of their pupils and their accident/incident background.


As I say, if the course is offered in exchange for not going to court, to press some pathetic prosecution just take it at Once.

30 quid deposit balance just before course begins, take your licence with you......






Got your message & more than happy to expand on course details while its fresh in my mind, when your ready

regards
Mac
Not necessarily... I turned up in a 911!

http://www.pistonheads.com/gassing/topic.asp?h=0&a...

If you're offered a Driver Improvement course it's a total no-brainer, just do it and go into it with an open mind, you may learn something. Even if you know the material they teach there's no harm in having a refresher.

Mactac

645 posts

224 months

Monday 31st March 2008
quotequote all
Fair point Rob I can only say the level of professionalism is not then the same nationally.
there was a lot of inuendo;

"Oo er Dennis did you hear that, A BMW driver using his indictors whate ever next"
and
"lets imagine a younger driver in his Vauxhall' (looks in direction of sole course member under age of Twenty)
he's got the Music booming out, his hat on back-to-front"



I nearly went to course in the 2CV but for its MOT having run out that Morning, imagine the hilarity

phillvr6

3,785 posts

291 months

Tuesday 8th April 2008
quotequote all
Any news?