Discarding a fag butt from the window
Discarding a fag butt from the window
Author
Discussion

porkswordsman

Original Poster:

41 posts

289 months

Monday 31st March 2008
quotequote all
Afternoon all,

Just after a bit of advice really - apparently one of our local councils has "reason to believe" that I committed an offence under the Environmental Protection Act 1990, by depositing a cigarette end out of the window of my Elise on a local rural dual carriageway.

Given the time and location, it is certainly possible I did, and yes I am a smoker.

I have to either pay a £75 fine or be interviewed under caution and go to court and face upto a £2500 fine.

Now, I realise this may turn into a smoker vs non-smokers row, but I'll just say that I have been brought up to not litter and never do; but being a smoker I guess I overlook the odd fag whilst I'm in the car (and no I don't drop them on the street either).

So I can applaud the anti-litter sentiment, but the penalty seems rather draconian, and to be honest, another £75 out of pocket is the last thing I need this month.

Has anybody else received the same and can offer advice? Do I contest it?

2 sMoKiN bArReLs

32,049 posts

266 months

Monday 31st March 2008
quotequote all
Pay up!

Davel

8,982 posts

289 months

Monday 31st March 2008
quotequote all
Well as a motorcylist, who has been hit from time to time by flying fag ends, I have little sympthy.

As a motorist, albeit non-smoker, who is prosecuting you?

Did the police spot it or some do-gooder?

- or do they now have anti-smoking cameras?

Do they have evidence to prosecute through the court?

streaky

19,311 posts

280 months

Monday 31st March 2008
quotequote all
You have admitted that you were there, driving your Elise and that you smoke in the car. Those statements are damning in combination. If you do 'appeal' you'd better hope the 'prosecutors' are not PH readers!

Nevertheless, you need to be sure of the evidence against you. Is there a photograph or CCTV imagary? Do they have the butt (for DNA comparison?) - and can they show that it was a butt you discarded that day, from a vehicle?

Or is this someone's (maybe a petty bureaucrat) word against yours?

Streaky

porkswordsman

Original Poster:

41 posts

289 months

Monday 31st March 2008
quotequote all
Davel said:
Well as a motorcylist, who has been hit from time to time by flying fag ends, I have little sympthy.

As a motorist, albeit non-smoker, who is prosecuting you?

Did the police spot it or some do-gooder?

- or do they now have anti-smoking cameras?

Do they have evidence to prosecute through the court?
I do see your point from a motorcyclist's view, and in my defence I do "check before I flick" for any cars / bikes following close behind.

I can only assume it was a council employee, or a member of the public with nothing more important to do. Although we are talking North Wales here, so it wouldn't surprise me if they've installed anti-smoking cameras in those roadside grit bins.

Don

28,378 posts

315 months

Monday 31st March 2008
quotequote all
Didn't we discuss this just a few weeks back? Deja Vu...

Pony up the loot if you're guilty...

john_r

8,354 posts

302 months

Monday 31st March 2008
quotequote all
And how do they know this fag-butt didn't just flick up from your wheels?

I would politely write to them and ask for the evidence to prove the offence as you have no recollection of committing the suggested offence on the exact day in question or any other day?

So personally I would ask to be interviewed under caution and tell the truth, i.e. you have no idea who was driving or if you dropped a cigarette. If under caution they can show you an affidavit from a Policeman, a photograph or physical evidence, then it’s a fair cop and you pay the fine.

I am a smoker but I don’t smoke in my car. However, this is ludicrous - the DVLA gave out your details to a council on the basis of an alleged littering offence?

What’s next?

“A car passed my house officer and I estimate he was doing 40mph in a 30 limit – would you like his registration?”

“Right then, I’ll issue a NIP and we’ll have him, your estimate will be fine sir as he drives a car and we can fk him up the arse for anything we like!”

bad company

21,920 posts

297 months

Monday 31st March 2008
quotequote all
Sorry I have no sympathy at all - I have been throwing ciggy butts back through car windows for a while now (the reaction can be fantastic).

Pay up and learn from it. The car has an ash tray and when you stop for fuel their are bins available to empty it.

porkswordsman

Original Poster:

41 posts

289 months

Monday 31st March 2008
quotequote all
bad company said:
Sorry I have no sympathy at all - I have been throwing ciggy butts back through car windows for a while now (the reaction can be fantastic).

Pay up and learn from it. The car has an ash tray and when you stop for fuel their are bins available to empty it.
Not wishing to wind you up here, but an Elise doesn't have an ash tray smile

T_Pot

2,542 posts

228 months

Monday 31st March 2008
quotequote all
the council will follow this up all the way, and it will cost you a lot more if you dont pay in the time im afraid.

i work for the council, and they are so keen on this, its the council version of a speed camera as regards revenue making

john_r

8,354 posts

302 months

Monday 31st March 2008
quotequote all
T_Pot said:
the council will follow this up all the way, and it will cost you a lot more if you dont pay in the time im afraid.

i work for the council, and they are so keen on this, its the council version of a speed camera as regards revenue making
Out of interest then, what proof do they need to issue a fine? Council official, Police, Public, photo?

T_Pot

2,542 posts

228 months

Monday 31st March 2008
quotequote all
john_r said:
T_Pot said:
the council will follow this up all the way, and it will cost you a lot more if you dont pay in the time im afraid.

i work for the council, and they are so keen on this, its the council version of a speed camera as regards revenue making
Out of interest then, what proof do they need to issue a fine? Council official, Police, Public, photo?
Just the witness statement from the official who saw it, and as they tend to work in pairs, then the passenger would also be witness. also, if they were behind you in a car, they may well have a picture or video evidence, as they know if your smoking with the window wide open, the butt is going to be coming out soon

its the same as your word against a policeman

FishFace

3,790 posts

239 months

Monday 31st March 2008
quotequote all
Who's going to interview you under caution? The council? I don't think so! So are they really going to pass this on to the police? I can't imagine them touching that.


T_Pot

2,542 posts

228 months

Monday 31st March 2008
quotequote all
FishFace said:
Who's going to interview you under caution? The council? I don't think so! So are they really going to pass this on to the police? I can't imagine them touching that.
they have the power to interview under caution yes.

they also, WILL take it directly to court, they dont ask police to get involved, the same as they dont ask them to to chase unpaid parking tickets

odyssey2200

18,650 posts

240 months

Monday 31st March 2008
quotequote all
As you are a smoker and a motorist you are obviously not paying enough other stealth taxes so that's why you are being targeted.

On the other hand, as a biker I say GOOD!

I have been hit a few times by flying fag butts and its a worry especially at night whe glowing ash flies everywhere!

Nail 'em up I say!!

leicesterboy15

151 posts

230 months

Monday 31st March 2008
quotequote all
I am a smoker but I don't smoke in my car so I don't have this problem, it annoys me when people flick their fag butts out of the window without looking back to ensure its clear and I have been known to dodge them in the past knowing full well that they are highly unlikely to do any damage. So if I was a biker I can imagine it would annoy me even more.

However I can't believe some of the comments on this thread, does nobody think this is excessive? There are far worse things that don't get punished by a £2500 fine like DUI or TWOC. Talk about nanny state, its a joke really that there are people out there who think the public need to be controlled at such a low level and whats more sad is its happening on so many issues the general public have been beaten down into surrender and are starting to turn, beginning to think that this is actually good idea and not draconian in any way.

£2500 for some little st who is terrorising a neighbourhood? Nah forget that, we'll give him an ankle bracelet instead but woe-betide anyone who throws a cigarette out of their car window. There was the case with the Tesco lorry driver who was smoking in his cab and threw the butt out of the window so a dog warded reported him for smoking in a public place AND littering, I believe he got done. Utter utter madness, I wonder how much money we are paying for this do-gooder and how many stting dogs owners she actually caught that day.

qooqiiu

753 posts

228 months

Monday 31st March 2008
quotequote all
How were you caught?

Ive never heard of this thing before. Discarding fag butts out of the window is a bit gross, but to be walloped with a fine.......thats outrageous!

tybo

2,284 posts

248 months

Monday 31st March 2008
quotequote all
How are they going to prove it ?

odyssey2200

18,650 posts

240 months

Monday 31st March 2008
quotequote all
Good point!

Could it be proven beyond a reasonable doubt that it was your car, that you were the driver at the time and that you did the deed?

Some debris being thrown up by your car may have looked like you threw something out when it was already in the road.

Not that I condone throwing fag butts out of the car but I also hate this culture of grassing people up and fining people on the basis of heresay.

If we still have the presumtion of innocence it would be for the prosectution to present a jury with PROOF that you commited the offence.

I would like to see that!
Also if you fight it the prosecttion would have to disclose their evidence before trial.

PPPPPP

1,140 posts

262 months

Monday 31st March 2008
quotequote all
qooqiiu said:
Discarding fag butts out of the window is a bit gross, but to be walloped with a fine.......thats outrageous!
It's too generous in my view. It's the OP's privilege to smoke, but to discard a lit butt out of a car is completely unacceptable.

Would it be Ok to throw faeces out of a car?