legal advice required .
Author
Discussion

T350cTVR

Original Poster:

110 posts

226 months

Monday 31st March 2008
quotequote all
hi ,my daughter has just reversed her car and hit building materials on a public foot path.Can anyone help, where do we stand ? should the building materials be on a public highway thanks `stuart

Prof Beard

6,669 posts

258 months

Monday 31st March 2008
quotequote all
Er - were they on the footpath or the highway? If they overlapped onto the highway I would assume they should be surrounded by a warning barrier? If they were on the footpath, surely your daughter has not done anything different from reversing into a lamp-post (in the footpath).

Jasandjules

72,686 posts

260 months

Monday 31st March 2008
quotequote all
Was the item lit (I think if it's a skip or good etc they have to be lit)?

T350cTVR

Original Poster:

110 posts

226 months

Monday 31st March 2008
quotequote all
hi sorry on a footpath , unlit concrete blocks

Prof Beard

6,669 posts

258 months

Monday 31st March 2008
quotequote all
In that case, I can't see how it is different from reversing into a (unlit) bollard in the footpath (or even an unlit pedestrian wink )

T350cTVR

Original Poster:

110 posts

226 months

Monday 31st March 2008
quotequote all
rolleyes looks like dads got to put his hand in his pocket again then.
Unless anybody knows the law in these matters.

Edited by T350cTVR on Monday 31st March 21:16

Jasandjules

72,686 posts

260 months

Monday 31st March 2008
quotequote all
Trouble is hitting a stationary object is usually a fairly automatic fault..

Even if the other object was placed in a dangerous place.. But if it's a skip or similar and not lit I think the liability splits... Sadly not the case here it seems.

T350cTVR

Original Poster:

110 posts

226 months

Tuesday 1st April 2008
quotequote all
well ok thanks for all your help , stuart

Noger

7,117 posts

280 months

Tuesday 1st April 2008
quotequote all
Prof Beard said:
In that case, I can't see how it is different from reversing into a (unlit) bollard in the footpath (or even an unlit pedestrian wink )
Er, because bollards are a foreseeable risk ? And you should expect there to be pedestrians on a pavement. But not a pile of bricks ?

I would be going after the Public Liability insurers of the builders who left them there. There is at least a chance they were negligent.

Crashing into stationary objects is not always fault.

JustinP1

13,364 posts

261 months

Tuesday 1st April 2008
quotequote all
Noger said:
Prof Beard said:
In that case, I can't see how it is different from reversing into a (unlit) bollard in the footpath (or even an unlit pedestrian wink )
Er, because bollards are a foreseeable risk ? And you should expect there to be pedestrians on a pavement. But not a pile of bricks ?

I would be going after the Public Liability insurers of the builders who left them there. There is at least a chance they were negligent.

Crashing into stationary objects is not always fault.
I agree with this.

If materials have been placed on of near a highway where it could be foreseen that someone may drive and not be able to immediately see, then especially if it is a professional company leaving the stuff, then you could argue that this is an act of negligence.

After all, when they dig up the road they could argue that an observant driver would be able to see a hole in the road and avoid it... but isnt it best practice to put warning fences around it just to make sure!?

Prof Beard

6,669 posts

258 months

Tuesday 1st April 2008
quotequote all
Noger said:
Prof Beard said:
In that case, I can't see how it is different from reversing into a (unlit) bollard in the footpath (or even an unlit pedestrian wink )
Er, because bollards are a foreseeable risk ? And you should expect there to be pedestrians on a pavement. But not a pile of bricks ?

I would be going after the Public Liability insurers of the builders who left them there. There is at least a chance they were negligent.

Crashing into stationary objects is not always fault.
You may have a point, but assuming you are talking a sizeable stack of bricks, wholly situated off the road, I would have thought that "you should have looked where you were reversing" was a plausable come-back? ie if you are reversing in such a way that your vehicle "penetrates" the footpath area, you should be sure what is there - or if you like, it is reasonable to expect there might be objects on a footpath? Still, perhaps worth a punt then? - I don't claim legal expertise, just reasonableness!

Mind you if a PEDESTRIAN had fallen over the pile of bricks that would a whole different kettle of expensive sardines!

Edited by Prof Beard on Tuesday 1st April 16:22

Jasandjules

72,686 posts

260 months

Tuesday 1st April 2008
quotequote all
JustinP1 said:
After all, when they dig up the road they could argue that an observant driver would be able to see a hole in the road and avoid it... but isnt it best practice to put warning fences around it just to make sure!?
Yes, or lamps as I said, but I'm not sure if that's simply on the highway. Yet these objects were on the pavement, which begs the question as to what the vehicle was doing on the pavement... If it was an unlit child for example.....

T350cTVR

Original Poster:

110 posts

226 months

Tuesday 1st April 2008
quotequote all


Does this photo make it more clear? Appreciate your help.

Noger

7,117 posts

280 months

Tuesday 1st April 2008
quotequote all
Did she hit the far set of bricks ? In which case was not mounting the pavement, but legitimate (?) use of a drive.

Was the skip lit ?

Seems fairly understandable that you reverse between a skip and a set of blocks, only to discover another lower and out of sight set there already.

Dunno, worth a punt at them I would suggest. They should have public liabilty insurance.

drum4it2

658 posts

280 months

Tuesday 1st April 2008
quotequote all
yes, go on, sue the builder... it's only his insurers that pay out... don't worry that he may not be able to get insured the following year & may go out of business & don't worry that he'll probably lose a few days pissing around with paperwork on the subject... did I mention stress? No, just go & claim & don't worry about being careless in future, just look for someone to blame blame blame...

T350cTVR

Original Poster:

110 posts

226 months

Tuesday 1st April 2008
quotequote all
yes, go on, sue the builder... it's only his insurers that pay out... don't worry that he may not be able to get insured the following year & may go out of business & don't worry that he'll probably lose a few days pissing around with paperwork on the subject... did I mention stress? No, just go & claim & don't worry about being careless in future, just look for someone to blame blame blame...



I,m in the building trade myself and self employed but i dont leave crap all over the street thanks for your comment it was a great help NOT

Jasandjules

72,686 posts

260 months

Tuesday 1st April 2008
quotequote all
Like I said, if she'd hit that skip I reckon she'd have a damn fine reason to get at least some liability established BUT hitting bricks on the pavement, the bottom line is what would have happened in that was a push chair? She shouldn't be on the pavement, unless that's actually your own driveway she was trying to reverse onto.

Prof Beard

6,669 posts

258 months

Tuesday 1st April 2008
quotequote all
Frankly, from that picture, my reaction is now that she should have paid proper attention when reversing - there are LOTS of things that are VERY visible to indicate the potential for hitting something - sorry.

JustinP1

13,364 posts

261 months

Tuesday 1st April 2008
quotequote all
Jasandjules said:
Like I said, if she'd hit that skip I reckon she'd have a damn fine reason to get at least some liability established BUT hitting bricks on the pavement, the bottom line is what would have happened in that was a push chair? She shouldn't be on the pavement, unless that's actually your own driveway she was trying to reverse onto.
Agreed.

She would have a tough time explaining how she is not liable for hitting an object on the pavement!

Noger

7,117 posts

280 months

Wednesday 2nd April 2008
quotequote all
Hence some split liabilty. However the bricks are unlikely to claim damages smile