Average Speed Cameras - do they work
Average Speed Cameras - do they work
Author
Discussion

robm3

Original Poster:

4,930 posts

258 months

Wednesday 2nd April 2008
quotequote all
Anyone been 'done' by an average speed camera?
I see a lot of people going pretty quick through these monitored stretches.

Boosted LS1

21,200 posts

291 months

Wednesday 2nd April 2008
quotequote all
The quick people will change lanes and or tailgate to hide their plate if need be. Or may be exiting the road before the next camera. So, yes they do work if you're unaware of how they work.

streaky

19,311 posts

280 months

Wednesday 2nd April 2008
quotequote all
They work in pairs: A>B, B>C, C>D, etc., but only for the same lane. So, AFAIK, if you travel through the scameras:

A1 > B1 - speed computed;
A1 > B2 - speed not computed.

Type approval states that a scamera can only cover the lane underneath it or the one to the side (either side). As many gantries do not even extend to the centre lane (of three), I believe the outermost scamera cannot cover the outside lane.

Streaky

supermono

7,464 posts

279 months

Wednesday 2nd April 2008
quotequote all
robm3 said:
Anyone been 'done' by an average speed camera?
I'd like to see an answer to this though.

SM

Vaux

1,558 posts

247 months

Wednesday 2nd April 2008
quotequote all
streaky said:
They work in pairs: A>B, B>C, C>D, etc., but only for the same lane. So, AFAIK, if you travel through the scameras:

A1 > B1 - speed computed;
A1 > B2 - speed not computed.

Type approval states that a scamera can only cover the lane underneath it or the one to the side (either side). As many gantries do not even extend to the centre lane (of three), I believe the outermost scamera cannot cover the outside lane.
Reading this:
"Inspector Johnson added: "There has been speculation about the ability to cheat the cameras through lane swapping which is not the case.

"Not only is it dangerous keep changing lanes to avoid the cameras it is also extremely unlikely to stop you being caught speeding.

"The cameras can be synchronised in any order which would make it impossible to work out the entry and exit gates, this can be changed at any time." "

from here:

http://www.cambs.police.uk/camops/safetycameras/ne...

Is Insp. Johnson correct?


spikeyhead

20,646 posts

228 months

Wednesday 2nd April 2008
quotequote all
Vaux said:
streaky said:
They work in pairs: A>B, B>C, C>D, etc., but only for the same lane. So, AFAIK, if you travel through the scameras:

A1 > B1 - speed computed;
A1 > B2 - speed not computed.

Type approval states that a scamera can only cover the lane underneath it or the one to the side (either side). As many gantries do not even extend to the centre lane (of three), I believe the outermost scamera cannot cover the outside lane.
Reading this:
"Inspector Johnson added: "There has been speculation about the ability to cheat the cameras through lane swapping which is not the case.

"Not only is it dangerous keep changing lanes to avoid the cameras it is also extremely unlikely to stop you being c

aught speeding.

"The cameras can be synchronised in any order which would make it impossible to work out the entry and exit gates, this can be changed at any time." "

from here:

http://www.cambs.police.uk/camops/safetycameras/ne...

Is Insp. Johnson correct?
Yes, they only have approval for use in pairs, but that restriction doesn't stop the first camera being set up to note vehicles in lane 2 and the second camera in the pair covering lane 3.

eldar

25,360 posts

227 months

Wednesday 2nd April 2008
quotequote all
spikeyhead said:
Vaux said:
streaky said:
They work in pairs: A>B, B>C, C>D, etc., but only for the same lane. So, AFAIK, if you travel through the scameras:

A1 > B1 - speed computed;
A1 > B2 - speed not computed.

Type approval states that a scamera can only cover the lane underneath it or the one to the side (either side). As many gantries do not even extend to the centre lane (of three), I believe the outermost scamera cannot cover the outside lane.
Reading this:
"Inspector Johnson added: "There has been speculation about the ability to cheat the cameras through lane swapping which is not the case.

"Not only is it dangerous keep changing lanes to avoid the cameras it is also extremely unlikely to stop you being c

aught speeding.

"The cameras can be synchronised in any order which would make it impossible to work out the entry and exit gates, this can be changed at any time." "

from here:

http://www.cambs.police.uk/camops/safetycameras/ne...

Is Insp. Johnson correct?
Yes, they only have approval for use in pairs, but that restriction doesn't stop the first camera being set up to note vehicles in lane 2 and the second camera in the pair covering lane 3.
You'd need lots of pairs of cameras to cover all the possibilities on a 3 or 4 lane road?

Apache

39,731 posts

315 months

Wednesday 2nd April 2008
quotequote all
I don't know of anyone who has been caught by these things.

streaky

19,311 posts

280 months

Wednesday 2nd April 2008
quotequote all
spikeyhead said:
Vaux said:
streaky said:
They work in pairs: A>B, B>C, C>D, etc., but only for the same lane. So, AFAIK, if you travel through the scameras:

A1 > B1 - speed computed;
A1 > B2 - speed not computed.

Type approval states that a scamera can only cover the lane underneath it or the one to the side (either side). As many gantries do not even extend to the centre lane (of three), I believe the outermost scamera cannot cover the outside lane.
Reading this:
"Inspector Johnson added: "There has been speculation about the ability to cheat the cameras through lane swapping which is not the case.

"Not only is it dangerous keep changing lanes to avoid the cameras it is also extremely unlikely to stop you being c

aught speeding.

"The cameras can be synchronised in any order which would make it impossible to work out the entry and exit gates, this can be changed at any time." "

from here:

http://www.cambs.police.uk/camops/safetycameras/ne...

Is Insp. Johnson correct?
Yes, they only have approval for use in pairs, but that restriction doesn't stop the first camera being set up to note vehicles in lane 2 and the second camera in the pair covering lane 3.
indeed not, but this would then only catch lane-changers from 2 to 3, not from 3 to 2 and not those who stay in lane 2. And, although this might catch more speeders, it would be more hit-or-miss than setting up to monitor one lane only.

Inspector Johnson has a vested interest in pedalling his tale ... which cannot be entirely accurate because of the type approval. Here on PH we have no vested interest and give our opinions freely but with the caveat that it is (frequently) a lay opinion. The Inspector Johnsons of this world do not concern themselves with caveats, stating (or being reported as stating) things that they know are not wholly correct, on the basis that very few can categorically and entirely disprove their statements (even a grain of truth makes attacking such statements difficult, ask any 'investigative' journalist).

Streaky

rewc

2,187 posts

264 months

Wednesday 2nd April 2008
quotequote all
What's the point of average cameras? I want good ones.

Hooli

32,278 posts

231 months

Wednesday 2nd April 2008
quotequote all
rewc said:
What's the point of average cameras? I want good ones.
employs more workmen putting them up
employs more penpushing numpties in the offices
makes tosspot council officals feel important


oh you wanted road safety related ones? sorry there arent any.

Vaux

1,558 posts

247 months

Wednesday 2nd April 2008
quotequote all
Hooli said:
oh you wanted road safety related ones? sorry there arent any.
Slowing people through roadworks?
(Assuming there are some workers out....)

EU_Foreigner

2,838 posts

257 months

Wednesday 2nd April 2008
quotequote all
Hooli said:
rewc said:
What's the point of average cameras? I want good ones.
employs more workmen putting them up
employs more penpushing numpties in the offices
makes tosspot council officals feel important


oh you wanted road safety related ones? sorry there arent any.
He was joking smile Average as in bad/average/good ...

streaky

19,311 posts

280 months

Wednesday 2nd April 2008
quotequote all
Quinny said:
Apache said:
I don't know of anyone who has been caught by these things.
I'm almost certain my sister was caught by Average Speed Cams on the M56 last year.

The cams were in use on the bridge where you exit for Runcorn, Frodsham etc.

And she came through late at night when no one was working.

Failed to adjust her speed and got a ticket.
If they were SPECS, they must have been in use over a wider stretch than just on the bridge - Streaky

SS2.

14,712 posts

269 months

Wednesday 2nd April 2008
quotequote all
Apache said:
I don't know of anyone who has been caught by these things.
I do..

And I've also heard a whisper (as yet unsubstantiated but FOI request submitted wink) that the conditions of type approval of SVDD (SPECS) were amended ealier this year to cope with lane changing and also enforcement of lanes other than those immediately below or adjacent to the camera..

Funk

27,814 posts

240 months

Wednesday 2nd April 2008
quotequote all
The average speed ones are dangerous. People spend the whole time with eyes glued to their speedo and wandering around in their lane when they should be paying attention to the narrower lanes, workmen, plant vehicles, broken down cars etc...

Terrible invention, and easily circumvented.

ALawson

8,056 posts

282 months

Wednesday 2nd April 2008
quotequote all
I was working on the M25 widening tender during the summer last year and had several meeting with Mr SPEC's (they are based in Camberley).

At the moment they only have type approval for same lane to same lane monitoring. So an entry camera covering a car in lane 1 has to compare it with an exit camera in lane 1 (not 2 or 3 etc). If there are more than 2 sets of gantries down the scheme then they can monitor points A-B,B-C or A-C as the number of gantries increase so do the combinations.

Normally there are only two working cameras on the whole scheme, but it could be more so its all about playing the averages game. The cameras are normally set to speed limit +10%+2mph but with the majority of traffic adhering to the limit most traffic stays below 57 mph in a 50 for example.

Contactors also have to use SPECS on all major road works as instructed by the HA, also they have to pay the safe partnerships a "fee" to process the tickets this is normally somewhere between 30-60 quid. So the contractors on the road may raise the limit to reduce the number of tickets issued to reduce there direct costs.

eccles

14,415 posts

253 months

Wednesday 2nd April 2008
quotequote all
Funk said:
The average speed ones are dangerous. People spend the whole time with eyes glued to their speedo and wandering around in their lane when they should be paying attention to the narrower lanes, workmen, plant vehicles, broken down cars etc...

Terrible invention, and easily circumvented.
i'd have said the complete opposite.

when they were put in on the A14 between Cambridge and Huntingdon, replacing the older gatsos, they made the road much easier to drive.
instead of everyone stamping on the brakes at the sight of a gatso and creating the dreaded ripple effect (and quite often accidents), now the traffic flows a lot more smoothly.

Poledriver

29,624 posts

225 months

Wednesday 2nd April 2008
quotequote all
This thread is of no practical use! It leaves us wide open to ze 5th column. Either:-
1) We can be convinced that they have 100% coverage, so we will slow down and be controlled totally. or
2) We can be fed the "they don't work" line and we would all ignore them and give uncle Gordon a huge boost to his coffers!
So whichever way, we lose, they win!

What me? Paranoid!

HRG

72,863 posts

270 months

Wednesday 2nd April 2008
quotequote all
eccles said:
Funk said:
The average speed ones are dangerous. People spend the whole time with eyes glued to their speedo and wandering around in their lane when they should be paying attention to the narrower lanes, workmen, plant vehicles, broken down cars etc...

Terrible invention, and easily circumvented.
i'd have said the complete opposite.

when they were put in on the A14 between Cambridge and Huntingdon, replacing the older gatsos, they made the road much easier to drive.
instead of everyone stamping on the brakes at the sight of a gatso and creating the dreaded ripple effect (and quite often accidents), now the traffic flows a lot more smoothly.
Agree completely.... Although it might be the eggect of removing the old Gatso's that caused the problems in the first place.