Lawyers: Unfair contract term?
Discussion
My phone broke a couple of weeks ago due to water damage, I've been on holiday and the phone still operates, I just can't see the screen properly, so I only just phoned my insurance company, who insure me against all accidental damage. I went through the whole process of describing the damage and how it happened, telling them when it happened first. After I'd finished, I was told they were rejecting my claim on the grounds that I hadn't notified them of the damage within 48 hours, and that this was in my contract, which I subsequently found out it was. I immediately cancelled my insurance as a result. I can't understand why I would have to notify them within 48 hours, other than as a clause to catch me out, so I was wondering where I stand legally on this, seems a bit unfair if I don't have a leg to stand on!
You may have a case. The relevant bit to look at are the Unfair Terms in Consumer Contracts Regulations.
In a nutshell a clause is invalid if it causes a significant imbalance of your rights against you and/or is not in good faith.
I think we both know that the reason that the term is there is so they don't have to pay out! Its the most common clause in these type of agreements. This is why on the phone they probably asked a load of questions each trying to get the 'right' answer from you. Thats the primary job of the claims department - reduce the amount of claims.
In my book and knowing both sides of the coin I tend to agree with you. A couple of well worded letters from a solicitor way make them change their mind however the cost of bringing a case would be more than a new phone so maybe not worth the risk or effort.
In a nutshell a clause is invalid if it causes a significant imbalance of your rights against you and/or is not in good faith.
I think we both know that the reason that the term is there is so they don't have to pay out! Its the most common clause in these type of agreements. This is why on the phone they probably asked a load of questions each trying to get the 'right' answer from you. Thats the primary job of the claims department - reduce the amount of claims.
In my book and knowing both sides of the coin I tend to agree with you. A couple of well worded letters from a solicitor way make them change their mind however the cost of bringing a case would be more than a new phone so maybe not worth the risk or effort.
BJG1 said:
Cost of the same handset is £500, was thinking of writing to them issuing a 7 day ultimatum to replace the phone/repair it, or I would purchase a new phone and issue a county court claim against them.
You would need to give them the opportunity to fulfill their obligations, usually a couple of letters, then a clearly worded letter warning immediate legal action before the court summons.They may back down, they may not. They may back down after they receive the summons, they may not.
Before you proceed, I should warn compared to a standard 'small claims' case, this is more complicated, as you will need to quote the UTCCRs as mentioned above, and reference it properly. Even then, it is no guaranteed win if they defend it with decent solicitors. So if you are wanting to push it, you will need to push it properly.
I would say though that my guesstimate of this being settled before court is 80%. I shall leave it up to you to decide whether it is worth the effort and risk. I might be inclined to give it a try.
Having read reviews on the internet about the company's practises, such as refusing to pay out when people have left a phone in a staff room or put it through the washing machine because they believe this is due to carelessness and not taking enough precaution, despite supposedly insuring against loss or accidental damage (which surely is always caused by some form of oversight), I think I will give it a try, even if it's only on principal. They appear to be a despicable company out to rob their customers.
ETA: Forgot my manners, thanks a lot for the help and advice!
ETA: Forgot my manners, thanks a lot for the help and advice!
Edited by BJG1 on Thursday 3rd April 01:06
streaky said:
You were unable to report the damage within 48 hours as you were on holiday with a broken 'phone (I assume out of the country and that it was a mobile 'phone) - Streaky
Their contract terms still state that if whilst out of the country you're phone is damaged, you must report it. Pretty sure that's not legal though.I was in Scotland on holiday.
BJG1 said:
streaky said:
You were unable to report the damage within 48 hours as you were on holiday with a broken 'phone (I assume out of the country and that it was a mobile 'phone) - Streaky
Their contract terms still state that if whilst out of the country you're phone is damaged, you must report it. Pretty sure that's not legal though.I was in Scotland on holiday.
There is no physical reason I can see why their interests would not be protected if they gave you say, a week or two weeks. They could easily state that the rule is that if damage occurs you must switch off the phone to prevent further damage if they are worried about this issue.
It may be the case that the claims department send packing 90% of claims in the first instance due to this and claiming that any accident which cause the accidental damage is through a negligence they don't cover. Probably 90% of this 90% don't take it further. IMHO the amounts that push it further than this with a legal challenge is way less than 1% and they will probably just pay out.
In 10 years I've had to claim 3 times for accidental damage or loss of skiing gear.
In each case - no matter what documentation I've sent, or how quickly I've sent it - I've had a refusal reply within a week stating I haven't provided the correct reference number, police statement, hotel statement, rep statement, etc.
In one instance I lost a ski that was obviously not properly in it's binding (didn't know that of course) when on a chair-lift. Unfortunately where it dropped was virtually inaccessible on foot/ski and I wouldn't have been able to find it in 200 acres of forest, hence there was no way to retrieve it. I got a report from the area management company stating that had I lost a ski there, it would be unwise to try and recover it. The insurance company dismissed this and said I should have asked the police to recover it and then got a police report - even though their own insurance policy only stated that a police report was needed if an item was stolen.
After a bit of written/phone communication I tend to get to the stage of we'll pay 50% of the claim as you've only lost 50% of the item (i.e. pay for one shoe as the other is fine).
Finally I get to a level where I believe that I am offered enough to cover the cost of getting a new set of the original item or something similar and I agree to the offer.
Persistence is the key - and don't rely on the telephone as they tend to ignore communications made that way, keep it all written with proof of delivery and try to use the same contact each time, even if it means waiting a bit longer.
In each case - no matter what documentation I've sent, or how quickly I've sent it - I've had a refusal reply within a week stating I haven't provided the correct reference number, police statement, hotel statement, rep statement, etc.
In one instance I lost a ski that was obviously not properly in it's binding (didn't know that of course) when on a chair-lift. Unfortunately where it dropped was virtually inaccessible on foot/ski and I wouldn't have been able to find it in 200 acres of forest, hence there was no way to retrieve it. I got a report from the area management company stating that had I lost a ski there, it would be unwise to try and recover it. The insurance company dismissed this and said I should have asked the police to recover it and then got a police report - even though their own insurance policy only stated that a police report was needed if an item was stolen.
After a bit of written/phone communication I tend to get to the stage of we'll pay 50% of the claim as you've only lost 50% of the item (i.e. pay for one shoe as the other is fine).
Finally I get to a level where I believe that I am offered enough to cover the cost of getting a new set of the original item or something similar and I agree to the offer.
Persistence is the key - and don't rely on the telephone as they tend to ignore communications made that way, keep it all written with proof of delivery and try to use the same contact each time, even if it means waiting a bit longer.
As you've already surmised the majority of such claims are dealt with in such a way as to put you off. It's easy for them to say no, a major effort for you to fight them but frankly they rely on this.
Take my recent motor claim as an example. Car written off, independent valuation from the specialists who worked on it a few weeks before the crash £14,000. Insurers offered £9000! A phone call with the manager (desk monkey had told me he wasn't increasing his offer so I hopped over his head much to his annoyance) led to an increase to £13,600, just like that. As an enticement they keep sending me cheques and I think the missing £400 is to save them some face which is a pity because I'm not letting it drop.
Now the fact that I have 12 years experience as a loss adjuster (previous career) may have something to do with it but only in that I know how they think. Anyone reading this now knows as well so there's no reason for anyone to accept an unreasonable decision.
Take my recent motor claim as an example. Car written off, independent valuation from the specialists who worked on it a few weeks before the crash £14,000. Insurers offered £9000! A phone call with the manager (desk monkey had told me he wasn't increasing his offer so I hopped over his head much to his annoyance) led to an increase to £13,600, just like that. As an enticement they keep sending me cheques and I think the missing £400 is to save them some face which is a pity because I'm not letting it drop.
Now the fact that I have 12 years experience as a loss adjuster (previous career) may have something to do with it but only in that I know how they think. Anyone reading this now knows as well so there's no reason for anyone to accept an unreasonable decision.
Gassing Station | Speed, Plod & the Law | Top of Page | What's New | My Stuff


