CCTV to be used to issue parking tickets: Act now
CCTV to be used to issue parking tickets: Act now
Author
Discussion

bcnrml

Original Poster:

2,107 posts

241 months

Friday 4th April 2008
quotequote all
From Timesonline:
“In London, where councils are already allowed to use CCTV to monitor parking, we have seen tickets issued to motorists stopping to read maps or dropping off passengers. And how CCTV will pick up blue disabled badges we do not know.”

There is also concern about allowing councils to use CCTV to fine motorists for minor traffic offences. Paul Watters, head of roads and transport policy at the AA, expects there to be an increase in the number of cameras monitoring bus lanes. He says: “Using CCTV for moving traffic offences is not flexible enough. Traffic flow is not black and white, there are grey areas. For example, a CCTV still will not show that the reason a driver pulled into a bus lane was to let an ambulance through. In London we have already had cases where drivers have been fined for turning across a bus lane to enter their own premises.”
http://business.timesonline.co.uk/tol/business/mon...

As a nation, we allow things in some parts of the country because they don't directly affect us (to begin with). Now that this is being expanded, would PHers please now write to their local authorities and MPs letting them know that elections are not far off, and that there will be career consequences for those who supported this change in the law?

Or will Blighty's residents simply roll over and pay as usual.....?



Moderators, if this has been posted elsewhere already, please delete, move or lock.

thewurzel

287 posts

225 months

Friday 4th April 2008
quotequote all
I love scaremongering, therefore I like this thread.

Hedders

24,460 posts

278 months

Friday 4th April 2008
quotequote all
thewurzel said:
I love scaremongering, therefore I like this thread.
Just wait, it won't be long before this technology makes it to your part of the country :P


streaky

19,311 posts

280 months

GPSHead

657 posts

272 months

Friday 4th April 2008
quotequote all
Hedders said:
thewurzel said:
I love scaremongering, therefore I like this thread.
Just wait, it won't be long before this technology makes it to your part of the country :P
Why should he care? He hates motorists. Oh no sorry, he doesn't hate motorists, he just happens to support every anti-motorist and motorist-restricting measure and instance of enforcement, no matter how petty, draconian, unnecessary, unreasonable and/or disproportionate it is. Silly me, assuming that something's a duck just because it looks like one and quacks.

(Interesting though isn't it? Car-haters undoubtedly exist, yet I've never seen anyone on a forum admitting to being one. Some of them must have found their way onto forums. Why would they lie? Are they ashamed? If so, why don't they do something that they're not ashamed of instead?)

Andy Zarse

10,870 posts

278 months

Friday 4th April 2008
quotequote all
thewurzel said:
I love scaremongering, therefore I like this thread.
That is likely because you are also a slimey, oily obsequious individual.

Robatr0n

12,362 posts

247 months

Friday 4th April 2008
quotequote all
I've already received a parking ticket by way of these pesky CCTV cameras. frown

thewurzel

287 posts

225 months

Friday 4th April 2008
quotequote all
GPSHead said:
support every anti-motorist and motorist-restricting measure
Stopping people from parking in places which could be dangerous, hold up traffic etc is hardly anti motorist. Quite the opposite, in fact.

Hedders

24,460 posts

278 months

Friday 4th April 2008
quotequote all
thewurzel said:
GPSHead said:
support every anti-motorist and motorist-restricting measure
Stopping people from parking in places which could be dangerous, hold up traffic etc is hardly anti motorist. Quite the opposite, in fact.
I think you will find that we all agree with that.

That is not what is happening though, and you know it.

bcnrml

Original Poster:

2,107 posts

241 months

Friday 4th April 2008
quotequote all
thewurzel said:
GPSHead said:
support every anti-motorist and motorist-restricting measure
Stopping people from parking in places which could be dangerous, hold up traffic etc is hardly anti motorist. Quite the opposite, in fact.
I respectfully describe your responses as remarkably naive. Would you care to respond to the following two scenarios?

Scenario 1. You're in Camden, London. Phone rings, you know you cannot answer it. You stop on a single yellow or red line, ensuring you are blocking nothing. It is a Saturday morning, no traffic. Should you get a ticket?

Scenario 2. You are in part of Central London where you turn left (or right - you choose, and adjust the rest accordingly) before you get to the point where there is a sign stating no-left-turn. You turned to avoid a hazard behind you (such as a skidding vehicle, or an emergency response vehicle, neither of which are caught on camera). Should you get a ticket?

Now what should you do if you get tickets for both events?

Finally, do a search online to find out what percentage of tickets are (a) issued falsely, and (b) successfully contested in the different London Boroughs.

Then extrapolate the data to the rest of the UK, making sure you add up the amounts of person-hours spent resolving said errors. Then, when you've finished, ask yourself whether this is the kind of "productive" work befitting an OECD country like the UK.

Finally, If you are unable to provide a balanced, considered response, based on evidence, rest assured that I shall make no further responses to any of your postings.



Consider this for Scenario 1: Should you instead stop in the middle of the road, not on any lines, and feign a breakdown whilst you return the phone call? Which of the two options is eminently sensible and more likely to get a ticket? What if you needed to read a map?
Consider this for Scenario 2: Should you allow the accident, thus creating an obstruction, or prevent the emergency response vehicle from getting past with all that this entails?


Edited by bcnrml on Friday 4th April 15:30

bcnrml

Original Poster:

2,107 posts

241 months

Friday 4th April 2008
quotequote all
streaky said:
Thank you Streaky. I had not seen that thread.
thumbup

F i F

49,022 posts

282 months

Friday 4th April 2008
quotequote all
bcnrml said:
streaky said:
Thank you Streaky. I had not seen that thread.
thumbup
and while about it then take a look at this one

New parking rules apply from today

I do recall there was another "just park legally" wallah on that thread who didn't understand the consequences of what is happening.

thewurzel

287 posts

225 months

Friday 4th April 2008
quotequote all
bcnrml said:
Scenario 1. You're in Camden, London. Phone rings, you know you cannot answer it. You stop on a single yellow or red line, ensuring you are blocking nothing. It is a Saturday morning, no traffic. Should you get a ticket?
You would get a ticket from a traffic warden in that situation, it should be no different if it's issued because of CCTV. Why is your phone call so important to stop right there? (Here's a clue, it isn't)

bcnrml said:
Scenario 2. You are in part of Central London where you turn left (or right - you choose, and adjust the rest accordingly) before you get to the point where there is a sign stating no-left-turn. You turned to avoid a hazard behind you (such as a skidding vehicle, or an emergency response vehicle, neither of which are caught on camera). Should you get a ticket?
Perhaps not, but my responses in this thread have been related to the subject title, parking.

bcnrml said:
Now what should you do if you get tickets for both events?

Finally, do a search online to find out what percentage of tickets are (a) issued falsely, and (b) successfully contested in the different London Boroughs.
The answers to all these things are in the article linked to in the OP.

Also linked to from that article: http://timesbusiness.typepad.com/money_weblog/2008...
People get tickets in situations as you described from traffic wardens, hence why I consider the fuss being made about CCTV to be pure scaremongering.

bcnrml

Original Poster:

2,107 posts

241 months

Friday 4th April 2008
quotequote all
thewurzel said:
bcnrml said:
Scenario 1. You're in Camden, London. Phone rings, you know you cannot answer it. You stop on a single yellow or red line, ensuring you are blocking nothing. It is a Saturday morning, no traffic. Should you get a ticket?
You would get a ticket from a traffic warden in that situation, it should be no different if it's issued because of CCTV. Why is your phone call so important to stop right there? (Here's a clue, it isn't)

bcnrml said:
Scenario 2. You are in part of Central London where you turn left (or right - you choose, and adjust the rest accordingly) before you get to the point where there is a sign stating no-left-turn. You turned to avoid a hazard behind you (such as a skidding vehicle, or an emergency response vehicle, neither of which are caught on camera). Should you get a ticket?
Perhaps not, but my responses in this thread have been related to the subject title, parking.

bcnrml said:
Now what should you do if you get tickets for both events?

Finally, do a search online to find out what percentage of tickets are (a) issued falsely, and (b) successfully contested in the different London Boroughs.
The answers to all these things are in the article linked to in the OP.

Also linked to from that article: http://timesbusiness.typepad.com/money_weblog/2008...
People get tickets in situations as you described from traffic wardens, hence why I consider the fuss being made about CCTV to be pure scaremongering.
Your response to Scenario 1: You made the same error of judgement as a Camden CCTV ticket issuer. This happened to me and the ticket was overturned. Time and money were, meanwhile, wasted. I stopped, I was in my car, I did not park per se, and I was not obstructing traffic. Whenever I have stopped to take calls legally, wardens have accepted and moved on, not moved me on. They have NEVER issued me with a ticket.

Further, you are in no position to determine whether my call is important or not. If I were reading a map, presumably I should continue to drive round n circles getting lost, or stop to ask Joe Public for directions and still be issued with a ticket?

Thus, by your own response, your judgement is flawed.

Your response to Scenario 2: The use of CCTV is for more than parking offences. Camden also have cameras for such offences, said cameras not being trained fully on lengths of road that ensure teh full picture is captured. A ticket would be issued. And you no doubt would pay it, I suggest.

So you've clearly missed that point, suggesting a need on your part for wider reasoning beyond the obvious (see my comments to follow).

You avoided my questions on what you'd do if you got tickets for both events.

You have avoided my pointer to the evidence (which I continue to encourage you to seek out, beyond the original article,) on the number of false positives, and their outcomes.

You ignored my point about what counts as the best use of productive time for an OECD country's employees and business owners. Y'see, I've received a few and contested them all with 100% success. Have you?

In conclusion, if you cannot speak from a position of knowledge, nor of experience with respect to the matters concerned, I suggest you desist (because it is better to be thought a fool than to open your mouth and remove all doubt).

Your unwelcome use of the phrase accompanying the word clue, coupled with your selective responses to my post referring to evidence, have encouraged me to suggest you probably need lessons in functional literacy, followed by practical lessons on the use of technology to abuse civil liberties (starting with tickets issued to you). The latter just might help with moving your callow views expressed here to a state of greater maturity.

In your case, I live in hope, but have no expectations that said hope would be fulfilled.

Good luck. No more responses to you, as you have proven that I would be wasting my time. byebye

Andy Zarse

10,870 posts

278 months

Saturday 5th April 2008
quotequote all
bcnrml said:
thewurzel said:
bcnrml said:
Scenario 1. You're in Camden, London. Phone rings, you know you cannot answer it. You stop on a single yellow or red line, ensuring you are blocking nothing. It is a Saturday morning, no traffic. Should you get a ticket?
You would get a ticket from a traffic warden in that situation, it should be no different if it's issued because of CCTV. Why is your phone call so important to stop right there? (Here's a clue, it isn't)

bcnrml said:
Scenario 2. You are in part of Central London where you turn left (or right - you choose, and adjust the rest accordingly) before you get to the point where there is a sign stating no-left-turn. You turned to avoid a hazard behind you (such as a skidding vehicle, or an emergency response vehicle, neither of which are caught on camera). Should you get a ticket?
Perhaps not, but my responses in this thread have been related to the subject title, parking.

bcnrml said:
Now what should you do if you get tickets for both events?

Finally, do a search online to find out what percentage of tickets are (a) issued falsely, and (b) successfully contested in the different London Boroughs.
The answers to all these things are in the article linked to in the OP.

Also linked to from that article: http://timesbusiness.typepad.com/money_weblog/2008...
People get tickets in situations as you described from traffic wardens, hence why I consider the fuss being made about CCTV to be pure scaremongering.
Your response to Scenario 1: You made the same error of judgement as a Camden CCTV ticket issuer. This happened to me and the ticket was overturned. Time and money were, meanwhile, wasted. I stopped, I was in my car, I did not park per se, and I was not obstructing traffic. Whenever I have stopped to take calls legally, wardens have accepted and moved on, not moved me on. They have NEVER issued me with a ticket.

Further, you are in no position to determine whether my call is important or not. If I were reading a map, presumably I should continue to drive round n circles getting lost, or stop to ask Joe Public for directions and still be issued with a ticket?

Thus, by your own response, your judgement is flawed.

Your response to Scenario 2: The use of CCTV is for more than parking offences. Camden also have cameras for such offences, said cameras not being trained fully on lengths of road that ensure teh full picture is captured. A ticket would be issued. And you no doubt would pay it, I suggest.

So you've clearly missed that point, suggesting a need on your part for wider reasoning beyond the obvious (see my comments to follow).

You avoided my questions on what you'd do if you got tickets for both events.

You have avoided my pointer to the evidence (which I continue to encourage you to seek out, beyond the original article,) on the number of false positives, and their outcomes.

You ignored my point about what counts as the best use of productive time for an OECD country's employees and business owners. Y'see, I've received a few and contested them all with 100% success. Have you?

In conclusion, if you cannot speak from a position of knowledge, nor of experience with respect to the matters concerned, I suggest you desist (because it is better to be thought a fool than to open your mouth and remove all doubt).

Your unwelcome use of the phrase accompanying the word clue, coupled with your selective responses to my post referring to evidence, have encouraged me to suggest you probably need lessons in functional literacy, followed by practical lessons on the use of technology to abuse civil liberties (starting with tickets issued to you). The latter just might help with moving your callow views expressed here to a state of greater maturity.

In your case, I live in hope, but have no expectations that said hope would be fulfilled.

Good luck. No more responses to you, as you have proven that I would be wasting my time. byebye
Fantastic! You've hung drawn and quartered the little creep. He is a fellow of the lowest acumen is he not?

Deltaf01

1,512 posts

228 months

Saturday 5th April 2008
quotequote all
He's a dick.

thewurzel

287 posts

225 months

Saturday 5th April 2008
quotequote all
bcnrml said:
Your response to Scenario 1: You made the same error of judgement as a Camden CCTV ticket issuer. This happened to me and the ticket was overturned. Time and money were, meanwhile, wasted. I stopped, I was in my car, I did not park per se, and I was not obstructing traffic. Whenever I have stopped to take calls legally, wardens have accepted and moved on, not moved me on. They have NEVER issued me with a ticket.
Traffic wardens may issue a ticket in that situation, CCTV may issue a ticket in that situation - so we're in the same situation we were in before, but without our tax being wasted on unnecessary traffic wardens.

See http://timesbusiness.typepad.com/money_weblog/2008...

bcnrml said:
Further, you are in no position to determine whether my call is important or not.
Yes I am, there is no such call that is that important.

bcnrml said:
If I were reading a map, presumably I should continue to drive round n circles getting lost, or stop to ask Joe Public for directions and still be issued with a ticket?
As a traffic warden would. See above link.

bcnrml said:
Your response to Scenario 2: The use of CCTV is for more than parking offences.
But all my responses have been parking related, you're simply trying to change the subject to make me say "CCTV is bad" biggrin

bcnrml said:
You avoided my questions on what you'd do if you got tickets for both events.
Pay the first one, probably appeal the second one if I really thought I *had* to move out of the way at the time.

Real answer: Not park illegally in the first place, not get a ticket smile

bcnrml said:
You have avoided my pointer to the evidence (which I continue to encourage you to seek out, beyond the original article,) on the number of false positives, and their outcomes.
The original article mentions the statistics you reference (and goes some way to supporting the point you were making, perhaps you should read it)

bcnrml said:
You ignored my point about what counts as the best use of productive time for an OECD country's employees and business owners.
Making it easier to get around for law abiding tax payers is pretty productive. You don't get much done sat in traffic because some idiot has parked in your way.

bcnrml said:
In conclusion, if you cannot speak from a position of knowledge, nor of experience with respect to the matters concerned, I suggest you desist
Are you suggesting that the only people allowed to comment on these things should be people who have received parking tickets previously? Should we roll that out for all laws?

bcnrml said:
Your unwelcome use of the phrase accompanying the word clue, coupled with your selective responses to my post referring to evidence, have encouraged me to suggest you probably need lessons in functional literacy, followed by practical lessons on the use of technology to abuse civil liberties (starting with tickets issued to you). The latter just might help with moving your callow views expressed here to a state of greater maturity.
It's a shame you had to resort to childish insults when you realised that your point was fundamentally flawed frown

Maybe one county will repeal all parking laws, and you can go and join other people who think like you in sitting in traffic for hours at a time biggrin

Andy Zarse

10,870 posts

278 months

Saturday 5th April 2008
quotequote all
Wurzel, you have absolutely no sense of perspective whatsoever do you?

And that, in case you'd not woked it out for yourself, is a rhetorical question which does not require an answer from you.

bcnrml

Original Poster:

2,107 posts

241 months

Saturday 5th April 2008
quotequote all
Andy Zarse said:
Fantastic! You've hung drawn and quartered the little creep. He is a fellow of the lowest acumen is he not?
Broadly speaking, I'm inclined to agree..... wink

Oh, and I'd suggest ignoring further posts from said person. Said person can then exercise the option of monologues on PH (and we can all get on with debating to the required high standard). biglaugh


Edited by bcnrml on Saturday 5th April 21:00

bluepolarbear

1,666 posts

277 months

Sunday 6th April 2008
quotequote all
thewurzel said:
bcnrml said:
Your response to Scenario 1: You made the same error of judgement as a Camden CCTV ticket issuer. This happened to me and the ticket was overturned. Time and money were, meanwhile, wasted. I stopped, I was in my car, I did not park per se, and I was not obstructing traffic. Whenever I have stopped to take calls legally, wardens have accepted and moved on, not moved me on. They have NEVER issued me with a ticket.
Traffic wardens may issue a ticket in that situation, CCTV may issue a ticket in that situation - so we're in the same situation we were in before, but without our tax being wasted on unnecessary traffic wardens.
What about blue badge holders wurzel? They can legally stop where others can't. A traffic warden can see the blue badge and walk on knowing the car is legally parked. A CCTV camera can't and will issue an invalid ticket. The official response from the government when this point was raised on the TV interview - "well we have made the appeals process easier so they can challenge the ticket". Or how about the individual who moved over to let oncoming traffic pass and was given a ticket via CCTV in London? An argument of don't park illegally while convincing to those with little upstairs doesn't really hold water as the camera's are being used to issue illegal tickets in circumstances where traffic wardens would not because the the technology is unable to make a distinction between legal and illegal parking.

This is why it is wrong, another step down the guilty until proved innocent slipperly slope. If you are to use CCTV use them in a way in which the technology supports the law for example their use should be designated for specific routes (where restrictions are common to all users say red routes) and not blanket, enfringement should be proved by clearly time delinated evidence, I would suggest min. 5 mins. to clearly show the vehicle is parked and not merely stationary.

If it is easier to understand in pictures then you can't do better then this

http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=5GQ5Ns3zezo