these 15MPH eco towns and carbon footprint etc
these 15MPH eco towns and carbon footprint etc
Author
Discussion

bryan35

Original Poster:

1,906 posts

272 months

Sunday 6th April 2008
quotequote all
It seems these days that the phrase 'lower speed = smaller carbon footprint' whatever a carbon footprint is. I think they mean CO2 emmisions, as though CO2 was some sort of poison gas.

So, I've been doing a few speed/MPG/gear/revs tests, so see what MPG you get at various speeds/revs etc with a look on the net to find the power/torque curves for my particular car.

It's a Golf TDI PS150, tuning boxed for another 22%, and with the PD165 kindly donated by the dealers mechanics - who are damn fine chaps - taking it to, I don't know, about 200BHP or so, not bad out of a 1.9 diesel!

What i've found is that if you can keep it between 1700 and 2800 where all the torque is, it does much better on fuel, which is probably no surprise to most.
The absolute best MPG I've had was at 31 MPH in 4th gear which gave 73MPG

At 65MPH 4th gear gave 47.8, 5th gear 49.3, 6th gear 60.8
At 70MPH 4th gear gave 46.0, 5th gear 46.2, 6th gear 56.5

I 'estimate' that 76MPH in 6th gives 49, 82MPH gives 43.5, 87MPH gives 39MPG

20MPH was interesting.
1st gear was just daft, reving high and very jerky. Turbo in and out.
2nd gear was also daft, jerks you all about as cruise control tries to keep it steady
3rd gear was the only gear you could really use, and it pulled 49MPG.

So, 20MPH in 3rd gear uses as much fuel as 76MPH in 6th gear, and much much more than at 30MPH

Sorry for the long anorak post, but this 'slower, less CO2' statement just isn't true as far as I can see.


It would seem that the car simply isn't designed to go at 20MPH, as best fuel economy is between 30 and 70, which seems pretty sensible to me.




thewurzel

287 posts

225 months

Sunday 6th April 2008
quotequote all
I believe the idea is more to encourage more walking, cycling and other non car use of the streets, rather than having the same number of people driving with a lower carbon output.

Richard C

1,685 posts

288 months

Monday 7th April 2008
quotequote all
thewurzel said:
I believe the idea is more to encourage more walking, cycling and other non car use of the streets, rather than having the same number of people driving with a lower carbon output.
In that case the concept of 'encouragement' seems a misnomer doesn't it.

Sounds more like discouragement by control and interference with doublespeak to justify them.

In that case it doesn't matter that the end result is as you say - same number of people driving with a higher " carbon footprint".


fluffnik

20,156 posts

258 months

Monday 7th April 2008
quotequote all
The problem, mostly, is that the innumerate are allowed to vote.

dirkgently

2,160 posts

262 months

Monday 7th April 2008
quotequote all
fluffnik said:
The problem, mostly, is that the innumerate are allowed to vote.
They are also allowed to become M.P`s

streaky

19,311 posts

280 months

Monday 7th April 2008
quotequote all
fluffnik said:
The problem, mostly, is that the innumerate are allowed to vote.
Not just the innumerate! - Streaky

streaky

19,311 posts

280 months

Monday 7th April 2008
quotequote all
thewurzel said:
I believe the idea is more to encourage more walking, cycling and other non car use of the streets, rather than having the same number of people driving with a lower carbon output.
Look at their proposed sitings. Then look at the road and rail connections to towns with employment opportunities. Then ask whether they'll reduce car use scratchchin . Hmm, I wonder whether the one 'sponsored' by Tesco will dispense with a car park by the store scratchchin - Streaky

Jasandjules

72,688 posts

260 months

Monday 7th April 2008
quotequote all
To house enough people, the town will need to be large. It will therefore I assume need say schools and shops etc.. all within the town, thus increasing it's size. Not every house will be within walking distance of a school/shop I assume, therefore you'll need a car? I certainly can't see how people can do a weekly supermarket food shop on their bikes, or on foot (Well, not without really long arms).

thewurzel

287 posts

225 months

Monday 7th April 2008
quotequote all
streaky said:
thewurzel said:
I believe the idea is more to encourage more walking, cycling and other non car use of the streets, rather than having the same number of people driving with a lower carbon output.
Look at their proposed sitings. Then look at the road and rail connections to towns with employment opportunities. Then ask whether they'll reduce car use scratchchin . Hmm, I wonder whether the one 'sponsored' by Tesco will dispense with a car park by the store scratchchin - Streaky
I like the concept of them (of course, there would be no obligation to live in them, and I probably wouldn't), but would agree with that, they just wouldn't work in this country.

Bing o

15,184 posts

250 months

Monday 7th April 2008
quotequote all
thewurzel said:
I believe the idea is more to encourage more walking, cycling and other non car use of the streets, rather than having the same number of people driving with a lower carbon output.
So you'd have localised community services, like a post office, a butchers, a grocers, a paper shop, a village school, pub and church? That's a great idea - why did no-one think of this before????

scratchchin

10 Pence Short

32,880 posts

248 months

Monday 7th April 2008
quotequote all
I have no problem with the concept of new towns, assuming they'd be created anyway, being built with the idea of keeping people out of their cars as often as possible.

Nothing to do with climate change or any of that rubbish, though; much more to do with making people more active and cutting down on congestion.

At 29 I don't like using the 'when I was a lad' routine, but at primary school age, even though we had a car, Mum used to walk me the mile to school and the mile back every day, and I don't see the harm in encouraging people to lead healthier lives.

Negative Creep

26,146 posts

258 months

Monday 7th April 2008
quotequote all
10 Pence Short said:
I have no problem with the concept of new towns, assuming they'd be created anyway, being built with the idea of keeping people out of their cars as often as possible.

Nothing to do with climate change or any of that rubbish, though; much more to do with making people more active and cutting down on congestion.

At 29 I don't like using the 'when I was a lad' routine, but at primary school age, even though we had a car, Mum used to walk me the mile to school and the mile back every day, and I don't see the harm in encouraging people to lead healthier lives.
At the risk of sounding old I walked or got the bus to school almost every single day and never had a problem with it. What I do have a problem with is the 15mph limit; I tried it in my car and it was a joke. Besides finding it very hard to tell what 15 was on the speedo and keep to it, I was out of the powerband in 2nd. So if I were near a hill or incline, I'd have to drive around in 1st. Surely there is nobody stupid enough to think dirving around in 1st is good for the planet?

fluffnik

20,156 posts

258 months

Tuesday 8th April 2008
quotequote all
streaky said:
fluffnik said:
The problem, mostly, is that the innumerate are allowed to vote.
Not just the innumerate!
I reckon disenfranchising the innumerate - I consider an understanding of statistical analysis and risk assessment as necessary for basic numeracy - would solve a great many problems whilst being easy to administer and potentially universal for a population that attends to the education it is offered...

10 Pence Short

32,880 posts

248 months

Tuesday 8th April 2008
quotequote all
Negative Creep said:
10 Pence Short said:
I have no problem with the concept of new towns, assuming they'd be created anyway, being built with the idea of keeping people out of their cars as often as possible.

Nothing to do with climate change or any of that rubbish, though; much more to do with making people more active and cutting down on congestion.

At 29 I don't like using the 'when I was a lad' routine, but at primary school age, even though we had a car, Mum used to walk me the mile to school and the mile back every day, and I don't see the harm in encouraging people to lead healthier lives.
At the risk of sounding old I walked or got the bus to school almost every single day and never had a problem with it. What I do have a problem with is the 15mph limit; I tried it in my car and it was a joke. Besides finding it very hard to tell what 15 was on the speedo and keep to it, I was out of the powerband in 2nd. So if I were near a hill or incline, I'd have to drive around in 1st. Surely there is nobody stupid enough to think dirving around in 1st is good for the planet?
I agree entirely that a 15mph limit would at best be a waste of time and at worst totally counter productive.

herewego

8,814 posts

244 months

Tuesday 8th April 2008
quotequote all
10 Pence Short said:
Negative Creep said:
10 Pence Short said:
I have no problem with the concept of new towns, assuming they'd be created anyway, being built with the idea of keeping people out of their cars as often as possible.

Nothing to do with climate change or any of that rubbish, though; much more to do with making people more active and cutting down on congestion.

At 29 I don't like using the 'when I was a lad' routine, but at primary school age, even though we had a car, Mum used to walk me the mile to school and the mile back every day, and I don't see the harm in encouraging people to lead healthier lives.
At the risk of sounding old I walked or got the bus to school almost every single day and never had a problem with it. What I do have a problem with is the 15mph limit; I tried it in my car and it was a joke. Besides finding it very hard to tell what 15 was on the speedo and keep to it, I was out of the powerband in 2nd. So if I were near a hill or incline, I'd have to drive around in 1st. Surely there is nobody stupid enough to think dirving around in 1st is good for the planet?
I agree entirely that a 15mph limit would at best be a waste of time and at worst totally counter productive.
Isn't it just a way of saying please drive really slowly through the village?

rs1952

5,247 posts

290 months

Tuesday 8th April 2008
quotequote all
Negative Creep said:
Surely there is nobody stupid enough to think dirving around in 1st is good for the planet?
Politicians rarely allow common sense and practicalities to gt in the way of policy rolleyes

streaky

19,311 posts

280 months

Tuesday 8th April 2008
quotequote all
rs1952 said:
Negative Creep said:
Surely there is nobody stupid enough to think dirving around in 1st is good for the planet?
Politicians rarely allow common sense ... to gt in the way of policy rolleyes
Mostly because they ably demonstrate the modern-day malaise that there's nothing common about sense - Streaky