parking ticket - not council and completly innocent
Discussion
Last night i drove around to see some friends (Derby), parked outside their house as i was planning on drinking, and walking home.
Well today i went to pick up my car, and afixed to the windscreen is a parking penalty notice.
The road i was parked in has no "private road signs" however about halfway down the road is a notice saying parking for visitors only.
The parking charge notice is from a company called VEHICLE CONTROL SERVICES LTD, P.O. BOX 686, SHEFFIELD, S11 8XR
NOT the council. (bit strange as they are registered in Sheffield but this happened in DERBY)
I have apparently Contraviened Code 81; Parking in a restricted area of a car park and have been fined £80
This is not the case, as my car was parked on the road (no road markings/private road markings) dirrectly parralel to my friends house.
What do i do? they have a website www.wheel-clamping.co.uk
are they allowed to do this as a private company? do i have to pay it at all seeing as though they are not the council?
I'm irate as i was visiting a friends house, quite clearly not parked in any private car park. I have taken photos/video as evidence.
Where do i stand if i do not pay it?
any help appreciated!
thanks guys,
Rhys
Well today i went to pick up my car, and afixed to the windscreen is a parking penalty notice.
The road i was parked in has no "private road signs" however about halfway down the road is a notice saying parking for visitors only.
The parking charge notice is from a company called VEHICLE CONTROL SERVICES LTD, P.O. BOX 686, SHEFFIELD, S11 8XR
NOT the council. (bit strange as they are registered in Sheffield but this happened in DERBY)
I have apparently Contraviened Code 81; Parking in a restricted area of a car park and have been fined £80
This is not the case, as my car was parked on the road (no road markings/private road markings) dirrectly parralel to my friends house.
What do i do? they have a website www.wheel-clamping.co.uk
are they allowed to do this as a private company? do i have to pay it at all seeing as though they are not the council?
I'm irate as i was visiting a friends house, quite clearly not parked in any private car park. I have taken photos/video as evidence.
Where do i stand if i do not pay it?
any help appreciated!
thanks guys,
Rhys
miggy man 3 said:
Check with the local council in the first instance as to whether this is a public or private road and to see if the council let this company issue tickets.
will do, however there are no road signs on the road i was parked, and google maps does not show any road names for the road.The ticket says "seen in: Rebecca House" i was parked directly outside my friends house! which is not rebecca house and is about 200m away from rebecca house.
ask your mate if it is a private road. Sounds like it might be as the ticket is from a private company rather than the council themselves. (AFAIK councils tend not to outsource parking enforcement as it cuts into a big stream of free money for them)
If it is private, its the bin for that ticket. ignore away.
If it is private, its the bin for that ticket. ignore away.

rhys27 said:
miggy man 3 said:
Check with the local council in the first instance as to whether this is a public or private road and to see if the council let this company issue tickets.
will do, however there are no road signs on the road i was parked, and google maps does not show any road names for the road.The ticket says "seen in: Rebecca House" i was parked directly outside my friends house! which is not rebecca house and is about 200m away from rebecca house.
Then completely ignore all further contact as it will be empty threats of action.
Even if they do take you to court, you show them the letter and state on oath that you have not been near Rebecca House, and ask them for proof. There will be none and your case will be dismissed, hopefully covering your costs.
cheers guys!
what do i do if i ignore it and they send me letters asking for final payments etc? (car is registered to my aunts house...)
can they legally do anything?
i like that "i have never parked in Rebecca House" approach.
There ARE several (ticket says 8) signs saying "VEHICLE CONTROL SERVICES - WARNING..etc etc) however these are all in the area around "Rebecca House", none on the wall of my mates house where my car was directly next to...
NO signs at the begining of the road saying its a private road, or outside my mates house.
what do i do if i ignore it and they send me letters asking for final payments etc? (car is registered to my aunts house...)
can they legally do anything?
i like that "i have never parked in Rebecca House" approach.
There ARE several (ticket says 8) signs saying "VEHICLE CONTROL SERVICES - WARNING..etc etc) however these are all in the area around "Rebecca House", none on the wall of my mates house where my car was directly next to...
NO signs at the begining of the road saying its a private road, or outside my mates house.
If it is a road open to the public (whether it's maintained by the council or privately) then it's a "road" in terms of the Highways Act 1980 (presuming you're in England).
If you ask the Council if it's public or private, they normally take that to mean "is it maintained at public or private expense". While that's relevant to them, it's not the same question as "is it a road open to the public," which is the legal definition of "road", and THEN "is it maintained by the council or privately".
Also ask if any street lighting is adopted - sometimes councils adopt lighting but not the road itself. They never adopt lighting on private accesses. It could still be a "road" if the lighting isn't adopted. It can't be a "private access" if the lighting is adopted.
Now, parking on any public road (whether it's publicly or privately maintained) can only be controlled by the correct signs to Traffic Signs Regulations and General Directions 2002 and the Traffic Signs Manual (ie the yellow lines that we all know and love so well). Those signs can only be erected under the regulations, to give effect to a Traffic Regulation Order made by the local highway authority (the Council).
No TRO = unenforceable.
No signs = unenforceable
Wrong signs = unenforceable.
If it's a private access (ie no public access) then the owner can control parking privately. The penalty then is a CIVIL penalty against the driver (not the registered keeper) so just to be sure, DO NOT admit anywhere, even by implication, that you were driving at the time. There is no obligation on the RK to disclose who the driver was - if they can't work it out, they're double-stuffed.
If you ask the Council if it's public or private, they normally take that to mean "is it maintained at public or private expense". While that's relevant to them, it's not the same question as "is it a road open to the public," which is the legal definition of "road", and THEN "is it maintained by the council or privately".
Also ask if any street lighting is adopted - sometimes councils adopt lighting but not the road itself. They never adopt lighting on private accesses. It could still be a "road" if the lighting isn't adopted. It can't be a "private access" if the lighting is adopted.
Now, parking on any public road (whether it's publicly or privately maintained) can only be controlled by the correct signs to Traffic Signs Regulations and General Directions 2002 and the Traffic Signs Manual (ie the yellow lines that we all know and love so well). Those signs can only be erected under the regulations, to give effect to a Traffic Regulation Order made by the local highway authority (the Council).
No TRO = unenforceable.
No signs = unenforceable
Wrong signs = unenforceable.
If it's a private access (ie no public access) then the owner can control parking privately. The penalty then is a CIVIL penalty against the driver (not the registered keeper) so just to be sure, DO NOT admit anywhere, even by implication, that you were driving at the time. There is no obligation on the RK to disclose who the driver was - if they can't work it out, they're double-stuffed.
tvrgit said:
...If it's a private access (ie no public access) then the owner can control parking privately. The penalty then is a CIVIL penalty against the driver (not the registered keeper) so just to be sure, DO NOT admit anywhere, even by implication, that you were driving at the time. There is no obligation on the RK to disclose who the driver was - if they can't work it out, they're double-stuffed.
Thats an important point. Never admit who was driving!If you feel like writing, make it simple. "I have never parked in a car park at Rebecca House.". Or just ignore it completely, with the knowledge that without knowing who the driver was they won't be able to prove the case in court.
JustinP1 said:
If you feel like writing, make it simple. "I have never parked in a car park at Rebecca House.". Or just ignore it completely, with the knowledge that without knowing who the driver was they won't be able to prove the case in court.
Agree. And there's little chance of it reaching court - they can't afford to risk a court ruling that blows their scam out of the water.tvrgit said:
Also ask if any street lighting is adopted - sometimes councils adopt lighting but not the road itself. They never adopt lighting on private accesses. It could still be a "road" if the lighting isn't adopted. It can't be a "private access" if the lighting is adopted.
thanks mate!! this might just be the bit i need! there is a street lamp right next to where i was parked.i'm presuming all i need to do is ring the council, give them the number for the street lamp that should tell me wether its private or not.
Hopefully its not private.
Even so, there is no signs at the entrance to the road saying that it is a "private - access only" road. Surely this would be needed?
thanks guys
rhys27 said:
tvrgit said:
Also ask if any street lighting is adopted - sometimes councils adopt lighting but not the road itself. They never adopt lighting on private accesses. It could still be a "road" if the lighting isn't adopted. It can't be a "private access" if the lighting is adopted.
thanks mate!! this might just be the bit i need! there is a street lamp right next to where i was parked.i'm presuming all i need to do is ring the council, give them the number for the street lamp that should tell me wether its private or not.
Hopefully its not private.
Even so, there is no signs at the entrance to the road saying that it is a "private - access only" road. Surely this would be needed?
thanks guys
If the street lamp has a number on it then it's almost certain to be adopted by the Council. Ask them and make sure.
Then ask if the road is adopted for maintenance by the Council.
If they are both adopted then the only people who can control parking are the council, and it has to be signed properly.
The coumcil don't light private accesses. If they have adopted the lighting then by default, it's a "road over which there is public access" in terms of the Act (whether they maintain the road surface or not). Again, only the council can control parking and it has to be signed and marked properly.
Only if nothing is maintained by the council does it get a bit "grey". It could still be a "road over which there is public access" (albeit privately maintained) and so should be signed and marked properly.
So far, only the council or the cops can enforce, not a private company (unless they are clearly acting as agents for the council)
Alternatively it could be a private access - but they don't normally have full spec street lamps. Only the completely private access can be enforced by these "civil penalty" comedians if appointed by the owners - and then only if they can prove who the driver was and also if they are brave enough (or stupid enough) to go to court and risk losing, with the attendant publicity that would show how tenuous their demands are...
Ignore the f
king thing. Or go down this road courtesy of another PHer:
To whom it may concern
[Add their title and address, Miss Jones}
I am in receipt of your letter dated [insert the date Miss Jones] alleging that a vehicle registered to me overstayed an arbitrary duration in a vehicle park attached to one of your stores.
As I am sure you will be aware, it is the driver of the vehicle with whom any contract to park was made, not the Registered Keeper. You will also be aware that the terms of any such contract must be set out in such a manner as to be obvious to anyone with whom you wished to make the contract. These terms must comply with all applicable contract law, such as the Unfair Contract Terms Act 1977.
Should you wish to pursue this claim, please supply evidence that the person parking the vehicle you allege to have overstayed the set duration would have had the opportunity to read the contract terms. Such evidence must be, as a minimum:
• a detailed route and timings of the vehicle's travel into and through the vehicle park;
• a detailed route of the driver's passage out of the vehicle and into the store - this and the evidence listed immediately above are to show that the driver had reasonable opportunity to see and read the contract terms;
• photographs of all relevant signage in situ in locus in quo at the time of the alleged overstaying so as to show that the signs were actually readable;
• an accurately-drawn, scaled, map showing the location of each sign and indicating which you believe the driver would have had the easy opportunity to read (the routes of the vehicle and driver should be superimposed upon the map);
• details of the weather conditions at the time, in particular the visibility (all to be confirmed by the Meteorological Office);
• sufficient details of the driver with whom you claim to have made a contract to enable their unique identification;
• a detailed description of the processes followed to record and analyse the evidence of the alleged overstaying; and
• a notarised statement from a senior manager at the store to the effect that your recording and analytical systems were working normally at the time of the alleged overstaying.
Without the above, I cannot entertain your claim and any further demands for payment will be considered harassment and will be reported to the police with a view to your criminal prosecution under s1 of the Malicious Communications Act 1998, s85 of the Postal Services Act 2000, s127 of the Communications Act 2003, and/or s2 of the Protection from Harrassment Act 1997 - this last with a view to the court issuing a Restraining Order against you. Additionally, civil action will be taken against you personally and your employer to cease and desist and for the recovery of all costs, together with a substantial payment in compensation for the mental pain and suffering caused.
I expect your reply by return, either providing the evidence requested above or indicating simply your termination of this correspondence.
king thing. Or go down this road courtesy of another PHer: To whom it may concern
[Add their title and address, Miss Jones}
I am in receipt of your letter dated [insert the date Miss Jones] alleging that a vehicle registered to me overstayed an arbitrary duration in a vehicle park attached to one of your stores.
As I am sure you will be aware, it is the driver of the vehicle with whom any contract to park was made, not the Registered Keeper. You will also be aware that the terms of any such contract must be set out in such a manner as to be obvious to anyone with whom you wished to make the contract. These terms must comply with all applicable contract law, such as the Unfair Contract Terms Act 1977.
Should you wish to pursue this claim, please supply evidence that the person parking the vehicle you allege to have overstayed the set duration would have had the opportunity to read the contract terms. Such evidence must be, as a minimum:
• a detailed route and timings of the vehicle's travel into and through the vehicle park;
• a detailed route of the driver's passage out of the vehicle and into the store - this and the evidence listed immediately above are to show that the driver had reasonable opportunity to see and read the contract terms;
• photographs of all relevant signage in situ in locus in quo at the time of the alleged overstaying so as to show that the signs were actually readable;
• an accurately-drawn, scaled, map showing the location of each sign and indicating which you believe the driver would have had the easy opportunity to read (the routes of the vehicle and driver should be superimposed upon the map);
• details of the weather conditions at the time, in particular the visibility (all to be confirmed by the Meteorological Office);
• sufficient details of the driver with whom you claim to have made a contract to enable their unique identification;
• a detailed description of the processes followed to record and analyse the evidence of the alleged overstaying; and
• a notarised statement from a senior manager at the store to the effect that your recording and analytical systems were working normally at the time of the alleged overstaying.
Without the above, I cannot entertain your claim and any further demands for payment will be considered harassment and will be reported to the police with a view to your criminal prosecution under s1 of the Malicious Communications Act 1998, s85 of the Postal Services Act 2000, s127 of the Communications Act 2003, and/or s2 of the Protection from Harrassment Act 1997 - this last with a view to the court issuing a Restraining Order against you. Additionally, civil action will be taken against you personally and your employer to cease and desist and for the recovery of all costs, together with a substantial payment in compensation for the mental pain and suffering caused.
I expect your reply by return, either providing the evidence requested above or indicating simply your termination of this correspondence.
Sounds like VCS Parking Control, who have been mentioned a few times on PePiPoo's parking forum, just ignore them and they will go away. On the off-chance you get a letter from a debt collection agency (who are often connected to the parking company) just reply saying you dispute the existence of the debt and they should refer it back to VCS.
If it gets to court (highly unlikely), read this and duplicate their arguments:
http://www.chad.co.uk/news/Judge-says-Excel-parkin...
If it gets to court (highly unlikely), read this and duplicate their arguments:
http://www.chad.co.uk/news/Judge-says-Excel-parkin...
please see my threads on this issue and the same company.....
http://www.pistonheads.com/gassing/topic.asp?h=0&a...
http://www.pistonheads.com/gassing/topic.asp?h=0&a...
http://www.pistonheads.com/gassing/topic.asp?h=0&a...
http://www.pistonheads.com/gassing/topic.asp?h=0&a...
Right, i have just got off the phone to Derby City Council.
The road in question IS a private road.. despite lack of signage at the entrance to the road.
Where do i take it from now? Apparently the lamp post may well be council maintained but as Rebecca House is owned by the council housing agency, it gets a bit complicated.. as the housing development owns the private road..
What is the likelyhood of VCS chasing me for the fine if i ignore it?
whats the worst scenario that could happen if i do not pay up?
Thanks for all your help guys!
Rhys
The road in question IS a private road.. despite lack of signage at the entrance to the road.
Where do i take it from now? Apparently the lamp post may well be council maintained but as Rebecca House is owned by the council housing agency, it gets a bit complicated.. as the housing development owns the private road..
What is the likelyhood of VCS chasing me for the fine if i ignore it?
whats the worst scenario that could happen if i do not pay up?
Thanks for all your help guys!
Rhys
Gassing Station | Speed, Plod & the Law | Top of Page | What's New | My Stuff


