Speed Cameras: What are the facts?
Discussion
I've only ever come across very specific statistics concerning speed cameras, that seem to be designed to obscure the facts or present a particular picture.
To my mind it should be simple to see whether speed cameras have been effective in reducing accidents, or if that isn't possible, reducing fatalaties.
Does anyone know of an independent source for statistics on the number of (obviously reported) RTAs, or RTAs involving a fatality over the period that cameras have been in place, or the number of road deaths.
Presumably if you compare the statistics above to the amount of cars on the road, or perhaps the amount of fuel sold (should be available to government for revenue purposes?) applied to an average mpg, to give you an RTA per car on the road, or per average mile driven, that should give you a clear idea of whether speed cameras have been effective in actually preventing accidents?
Or is that too simplistic a comparison?
To my mind it should be simple to see whether speed cameras have been effective in reducing accidents, or if that isn't possible, reducing fatalaties.
Does anyone know of an independent source for statistics on the number of (obviously reported) RTAs, or RTAs involving a fatality over the period that cameras have been in place, or the number of road deaths.
Presumably if you compare the statistics above to the amount of cars on the road, or perhaps the amount of fuel sold (should be available to government for revenue purposes?) applied to an average mpg, to give you an RTA per car on the road, or per average mile driven, that should give you a clear idea of whether speed cameras have been effective in actually preventing accidents?
Or is that too simplistic a comparison?
It's been known for some time that the overall national figures from government sources show a stark halt to the since-records-began year on year improvements around the same time the "speed kills" mantra was adopted. Local camera company figures talk of extrordinary improvements in the order of 40/50/60% reductions (at camera sites, lol).
Why is this?
Well it seems logical -- especially in the light of vast improvements to car design and medical technology -- that it shows a failed road safety policy, but some say that the number of vehicle kilometers per year has increased steadily over the same time.
Of course the vehicle kilometers per year has increased since the very first car rolled out of the factory 100 years ago, and it's hard to know whether that's changed over the same period to exactly outweigh the other improving factors, but I would suggest not.
Logic dictates that since hardly any accidents are caused by exceeding the posted limit, photographing people in the act of exceeding the speed limit can't have a big impact on accident rates.
A better plan is something like the Green Cross Code which came about when someone discovered that children getting run over and killed were almost exclusively found to have been walking about in the road in front of a car. In this case they thought that by educating children such that they had a better plan for crossing the road (in schools etc) they could remove the cause of the accident and it worked. Sensationally well.
The green gross code man was on the radio recently passionately slating the speed kills plan as undoing a load of the fabulous work he'd done 20+ years ago.
SM
Why is this?
Well it seems logical -- especially in the light of vast improvements to car design and medical technology -- that it shows a failed road safety policy, but some say that the number of vehicle kilometers per year has increased steadily over the same time.
Of course the vehicle kilometers per year has increased since the very first car rolled out of the factory 100 years ago, and it's hard to know whether that's changed over the same period to exactly outweigh the other improving factors, but I would suggest not.
Logic dictates that since hardly any accidents are caused by exceeding the posted limit, photographing people in the act of exceeding the speed limit can't have a big impact on accident rates.
A better plan is something like the Green Cross Code which came about when someone discovered that children getting run over and killed were almost exclusively found to have been walking about in the road in front of a car. In this case they thought that by educating children such that they had a better plan for crossing the road (in schools etc) they could remove the cause of the accident and it worked. Sensationally well.
The green gross code man was on the radio recently passionately slating the speed kills plan as undoing a load of the fabulous work he'd done 20+ years ago.
SM
Have a look at http://www.safespeed.org.uk/
This site and the late Paul Smith who started it often got a mention in the national papers. His facts and figures are all well-researched and have been checked and double-checked.
This site and the late Paul Smith who started it often got a mention in the national papers. His facts and figures are all well-researched and have been checked and double-checked.
To be fair, I was looking for completely impartial raw statistics.
I've seen the sites that publish the various statistics on speed, but none of them are independent, and most have an agenda.
I'll double check on the sites suggested though and see if I can find the source data from there.
I've seen the sites that publish the various statistics on speed, but none of them are independent, and most have an agenda.
I'll double check on the sites suggested though and see if I can find the source data from there.
youngsyr said:
To be fair, I was looking for completely impartial raw statistics.
I've seen the sites that publish the various statistics on speed, but none of them are independent, and most have an agenda.
I'll double check on the sites suggested though and see if I can find the source data from there.
I support your approach to this, but I imagine it will be difficult to really get back to the raw data, which to me requires access to the detailed accident reports. With regard to certain accidents in my own part of the country, I have tried to get a look at the accident reports, but I've been told they are not available to members of the public.I've seen the sites that publish the various statistics on speed, but none of them are independent, and most have an agenda.
I'll double check on the sites suggested though and see if I can find the source data from there.
By the time you get to the statistics that supposedly stem from those reports, you're already into the area where distortions and fiddles can be taking place.
This is why, apart from my inability to understand statistics and arrive at safe conclusions from them, I base my views on long experience, continuing observation of road user behaviour as I travel around, and general feel for what seems right. Of course I may be wrong at times, but that's how I approach it, and I've yet to be convinced that I'm any less plausible than the people armed with what may well be dodgy statistics.
Best wishes all,
Dave.
youngsyr said:
To be fair, I was looking for completely impartial raw statistics.
I've seen the sites that publish the various statistics on speed, but none of them are independent, and most have an agenda.
I'll double check on the sites suggested though and see if I can find the source data from there.
Have you tried wikipedia. Lots of references there:I've seen the sites that publish the various statistics on speed, but none of them are independent, and most have an agenda.
I'll double check on the sites suggested though and see if I can find the source data from there.
http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Car_accident
youngsyr said:
To be fair, I was looking for completely impartial raw statistics.
I've seen the sites that publish the various statistics on speed, but none of them are independent, and most have an agenda.
I'll double check on the sites suggested though and see if I can find the source data from there.
You may have a problem there. I think you are looking for an ideal which does not exist.I've seen the sites that publish the various statistics on speed, but none of them are independent, and most have an agenda.
I'll double check on the sites suggested though and see if I can find the source data from there.
The problem is that studies and research costs serious money. For a company or body to invest serious money they have a serious vested interest!
Even the government statistics are produced to an agenda. Things like what constitutes a serious injury and what factors contribute and whether they count have changed over the years depending on what the body is trying to prove.
I do think Paul Smith's site does cut through a lot of the fudging and does present the statistics as the government has presented them whilst adding his own caveats which I guess you can take or leave!
I had a long look at this over a speed ticket I got on a Camera on the A303.
I spent quite a bit of time trying to get information on traffic stats, reasoning behind camera sites and why they were sited at particular spots.
The long and short of it was...a camera has to be sited at a place where there has been I think it was 4 or 6) a number of Road Death or Severe Accident within a 2 or 3 year period.
So in my particular instance.... there are on average 22,000 cars a day travelling on the A303. So take out a few days like new years day and Christmas day where traffic is lower, and things like Glastonbury and bank holidays where it's higher... you still get something like nearly 8 million cars travelling on this bit of road a year....and you only need 4 or 6 accidents to put a speed camera...
strikes me as being 'statiscally' a very low number of accidents...
So like the OP, it's just a cash generating cow with bugger all real world impact.. I also discovered that since they put the camera in, it had made very little difference in the acccident rate. And for the county of Wiltshire, accidents went up one year, not down...
Not that I would advocate blowing the f
kers up on a public forum.... 
I spent quite a bit of time trying to get information on traffic stats, reasoning behind camera sites and why they were sited at particular spots.
The long and short of it was...a camera has to be sited at a place where there has been I think it was 4 or 6) a number of Road Death or Severe Accident within a 2 or 3 year period.
So in my particular instance.... there are on average 22,000 cars a day travelling on the A303. So take out a few days like new years day and Christmas day where traffic is lower, and things like Glastonbury and bank holidays where it's higher... you still get something like nearly 8 million cars travelling on this bit of road a year....and you only need 4 or 6 accidents to put a speed camera...
strikes me as being 'statiscally' a very low number of accidents...
So like the OP, it's just a cash generating cow with bugger all real world impact.. I also discovered that since they put the camera in, it had made very little difference in the acccident rate. And for the county of Wiltshire, accidents went up one year, not down...
Not that I would advocate blowing the f
kers up on a public forum.... 
There will always be invisible stats, too - yet these are highly relevant.
For example, how many accidents are caused by drivers stressing so much over cameras, they are not watching the road ahead?
How many accidents are caused on 'B' roads due to drivers feeling relieved at winding through a town full of cameras, then speeding from 30-60 before they are ready?
Actually, I would imagine we do have stats on the so called ' driver error' or ' single driver accident', and if they have increased?
For example, how many accidents are caused by drivers stressing so much over cameras, they are not watching the road ahead?
How many accidents are caused on 'B' roads due to drivers feeling relieved at winding through a town full of cameras, then speeding from 30-60 before they are ready?
Actually, I would imagine we do have stats on the so called ' driver error' or ' single driver accident', and if they have increased?
Even if someone did tally up some statistics, they will be irrelevent.
For example, accidents happen near point A on a road, so speed cameras are allowed to operate at that area (under the old netting off scheme - now they can operate anywaere, but statistics you look at now will be from then though). Mobile camera does not necesserily operate at the accident site, but on ajoining roads miles away. If accidednt rates are changed, how is it relative to the camera, they would have to only target the accident site - say 100m either side - for any statistics to be relevent.
For example, accidents happen near point A on a road, so speed cameras are allowed to operate at that area (under the old netting off scheme - now they can operate anywaere, but statistics you look at now will be from then though). Mobile camera does not necesserily operate at the accident site, but on ajoining roads miles away. If accidednt rates are changed, how is it relative to the camera, they would have to only target the accident site - say 100m either side - for any statistics to be relevent.
youngsyr said:
I've only ever come across very specific statistics concerning speed cameras, that seem to be designed to obscure the facts or present a particular picture.
To my mind it should be simple to see whether speed cameras have been effective in reducing accidents, or if that isn't possible, reducing fatalaties.
Does anyone know of an independent source for statistics on the number of (obviously reported) RTAs, or RTAs involving a fatality over the period that cameras have been in place, or the number of road deaths.
Presumably if you compare the statistics above to the amount of cars on the road, or perhaps the amount of fuel sold (should be available to government for revenue purposes?) applied to an average mpg, to give you an RTA per car on the road, or per average mile driven, that should give you a clear idea of whether speed cameras have been effective in actually preventing accidents?
Or is that too simplistic a comparison?
I think you'll find that if you add up all the improvements in rta statistics that the scamerati claim, you'll end up with a negative figure.To my mind it should be simple to see whether speed cameras have been effective in reducing accidents, or if that isn't possible, reducing fatalaties.
Does anyone know of an independent source for statistics on the number of (obviously reported) RTAs, or RTAs involving a fatality over the period that cameras have been in place, or the number of road deaths.
Presumably if you compare the statistics above to the amount of cars on the road, or perhaps the amount of fuel sold (should be available to government for revenue purposes?) applied to an average mpg, to give you an RTA per car on the road, or per average mile driven, that should give you a clear idea of whether speed cameras have been effective in actually preventing accidents?
Or is that too simplistic a comparison?
Certainly, if you compare the numbers of lives that the scamerati claim have been saved, and compare that with the actual year on year rta fatality figures, there's a hell of discrepancy.
I've studied the facts for each camera in Dorset on the SCP web site. In most instances there were no fatalities at all at the camera site in the years preceeding the camera or indeed afterwards. The serious injury figures tell you nothing e.g 2000 = 1, 2001 = 5, 2002 = 1..The 2001 figure is used to justify the camera which is installed in 2003.
2003=2, 2004 =1, 2005=0, 2006=2 etc.
It's easy to prove that serious injuries at the site have fallen to below the 2001 figure - of course they would have done anyway if they had reverted to the 2000 or 2002 figures.
2003=2, 2004 =1, 2005=0, 2006=2 etc.
It's easy to prove that serious injuries at the site have fallen to below the 2001 figure - of course they would have done anyway if they had reverted to the 2000 or 2002 figures.
Cheeky Jim said:
So like the OP, it's just a cash generating cow with bugger all real world impact..
In the bigger picture, a couple of millionmotorists a year get fined and the number
of folks dying on UK roads per year hasn't even
changed by as much as ten per cent per year.
Draw your own conclusions, but maybe the
120 million quid or more collected
per year has something to do with it.
If you want a second opinion, many or most
car insurance companies now ignore the first
speeding ticket, so they don't think they
have much to do with road safety either, and
let's not forget that the car insurance
companies are professionally required to assess risk.
Driving slowly isn't the same as driving
carefully.
[quote=youngsyr]To be fair, I was looking for completely impartial raw statistics.
[quote]
TBH - ALL the facts on safespeed have been checked /double checked with a guarantee that if anyone could dispute them ,the information would be removed .
Add to this ,if ,as you username suggests ,you are a new driver - you wont get raw statistics - you'll get driving tips / advanced driving info and more . Analysis of driving safety techniques - all for the asking - and there are some very knowledgeable blokes on there , including seniour police drivers .No question too silly .Go look- won't do you're driving technique any harm --might even save an accident .
[quote]
TBH - ALL the facts on safespeed have been checked /double checked with a guarantee that if anyone could dispute them ,the information would be removed .
Add to this ,if ,as you username suggests ,you are a new driver - you wont get raw statistics - you'll get driving tips / advanced driving info and more . Analysis of driving safety techniques - all for the asking - and there are some very knowledgeable blokes on there , including seniour police drivers .No question too silly .Go look- won't do you're driving technique any harm --might even save an accident .
Thanks (on behalf of Claire - Paul Smith's partner - and everyone else on Safe Speed) - it's been a very hard few months since Paul's untimely demise but we are all determined to keep his work going and get the campaign really moving again
Edited by Prof Beard on Thursday 10th April 20:38
Prof Beard said:
Thanks (on behalf of Claire - Paul Smith's partner - and everyone else on a Safe Speed) - it's been a very hard few months since Paul's untimely demise but we are all determined to keep his work going and get the campaign really moving again
No need -Prof - like you I believe in Paul's message , doing what little I can to spread the gospel .More backing we (as SS members can get ) ---more we might get listened to . Edited by Prof Beard on Thursday 10th April 20:33
Edited by Prof Beard on Thursday 10th April 20:37
Gassing Station | Speed, Plod & the Law | Top of Page | What's New | My Stuff



