Lying To The Police
Author
Discussion

GPSHead

Original Poster:

657 posts

272 months

Thursday 10th April 2008
quotequote all
On Traffic Cops yesterday, there was an Italian who kept lying to the officers about who he was, whether he had a licence, where he lived...everything basically.

As usual, they eventually found out the truth, and punished him for the initial offences. However, it annoys me when I see something like this, because these people are never punished for the lying in itself. When I have been pulled over by the police, I have always been totally honest, and I expect that applies to most others here. The people that lie, as well as "trying it on", are wasting the police's valuable time, which in turn is a waste of public money, and it may even mean that the officers aren't in a position to save someone's life when they otherwise would have been.

I'm left wondering what the point of being honest to the police is. Why not try it on and lie about who I am next time, just in case it works? I wouldn't of course, but many people must make a conscious decision to do so on the basis that they have nothing to lose.

Can people that lie at the roadside about who they are and similar be charged with obstruction or something? If they can be, why aren't they, and if they can't be, surely this is wrong? If these people had an incentive to tell the truth, surely they'd be more likely to. In most other areas of life, people are penalised one way or another for lying (anything from perjury convictions to being sacked to getting a reputation as a liar among friends or family), and this is just as well, because regrettably there are many people that would do it without thinking twice if they couldn't see a downside to it.

Another annoying thing which a lot of suspects do when they're arrested on police reality-type shows is put up a fight. It seems that, as long as they avoid actually assaulting an officer or committing criminal damage, they usually get away with this and don't face any extra charges. Surely they should get done for resisting arrest as a matter of course? Again there doesn't otherwise seem to be a downside to struggling and thus wasting the officers' time. It's especially frustrating when the police aren't able to charge them with the initial offence for some reason (e.g. a person who was assaulted doesn't make a complaint); they get off completely scot free, despite being thoroughly obnoxious, violent scrotes who have no respect for the law.

grumbledoak

32,571 posts

264 months

Thursday 10th April 2008
quotequote all
Crazy! It's almost as if they don't want to get caught!

mmm-five

12,399 posts

315 months

Thursday 10th April 2008
quotequote all
It's not lying - it's 'spin'.

It's what the government and top coppers have been doing to us for years!

Parrot of Doom

23,075 posts

265 months

Thursday 10th April 2008
quotequote all
So what happens when the police lie to the person they're questioning?

Because it's happened to me (although I understand why).

Dwight VanDriver

6,583 posts

275 months

Thursday 10th April 2008
quotequote all
You will miost probably find that they put in a summons under Section 165 RTA 88 - fail to give name and address = £1,000 fine.

dvd

Chrispy Porker

17,761 posts

259 months

Thursday 10th April 2008
quotequote all
Dwight VanDriver said:
You will miost probably find that they put in a summons under Section 165 RTA 88 - fail to give name and address = £1,000 fine.

dvd
Or obstruct PC.
We used that quite a lot for people who dicked around in custody.

quyen

592 posts

225 months

Thursday 10th April 2008
quotequote all
GPSHead
"many people must make a conscious decision to do so on the basis that they have nothing to lose."

That's the point though isn't it. Criminals have a lot less to lose than someone who's reputation, job, home, relationship may be put at risk by lying to the police on such a trivial matter.

Derek Smith

50,027 posts

279 months

Thursday 10th April 2008
quotequote all
All part of the job.

If someone does lie then it puts them on the back foot and you’ve got a good reason for delaying them, doing checks and generally irritating them.

It is a sort of cultural thing. I’ve found that most criminals will lie about whether they have committed an offence – most serve their time whilst completely innocent ,at lest to their mum – but generally are quite straightforward. I’ve found middle class men only too willing not only to lie but to get others to lie for them.

When in CID I lost around eight hours because I took on face value what a witness had told me as, he being Asian, the signals were not that apparent to me. When I went back with ample evidence to show he had told me porkies, he said, “That was yesterday’s truth.” Without any sign of embarrassment. When I spoke with an Asian friend of mine he asked what room I had been taken into when I first interviewed him and I told him it was the kitchen and I was forced to stand. That, evidently, was a sign that I could not believe anything he said. The second visit I was taken into their family room and allowed to sit. I was told I could believe everything he said.

I found at Gatwick that most people from a certain country will lie even when you can produce evidence that totally contradicts them. Really odd. Not worth speaking I would have thought.

Historically, police officers when nicked for any offence will confess everything except if it’s a motoring offence.

I looked upon suspects telling lies as the norm and, as I said, part of the job. Witnesses doing the same thing or worse, guessing, used to irritate me no end.

One sergeant brought in a punter who was playing music very loudly on the seafront deliberately winding up those listening to a concert by a string quartet – Brighton Festival, well worth a visit. The sergeant went up to him, asked him to turn his radio down but the chap play-acted that he couldn’t hear. So the sergeant asked him for his name and address in normal conversational level, and, when the chap did not reply because he couldn’t hear, nicked him for failing to give an address suitable for service of a summons.

Once he gave his address to the sergeant, and it was verified, he came into the front office to make a complaint. When I asked him why he couldn’t hear the sergeant you can guess his reply. I pointed out that this was a confession of the offence he was first arrested for and he blushed.

Antz_Pants

182 posts

231 months

Thursday 10th April 2008
quotequote all
"I found at Gatwick that most people from a certain country will lie even when you can produce evidence that totally contradicts them. Really odd. Not worth speaking I would have thought".


Nigeria per chance?????????

supermono

7,464 posts

279 months

Thursday 10th April 2008
quotequote all
Lying Italian said:
One third of all accidents are caused by speed
That really is low.

SM

Jasandjules

72,688 posts

260 months

Thursday 10th April 2008
quotequote all
As the officers have pointed out, loads of people lie to them.. Hence the whole need to go to court and prove a matter beyond a reasonable doubt....

Homicidal maniac

177 posts

223 months

Thursday 10th April 2008
quotequote all
supermono said:
Lying Italian said:
One third of all accidents are caused by speed
That really is low.

SM
You think it's more than one third? maybe you're right

Brett928S2

1,504 posts

246 months

Thursday 10th April 2008
quotequote all
Hi smile

I have always wondered what would happen in court if I actually told the truth ...in these circumstances...

Lets say I was taken to court for speeding and The Bib/CPS proved to the court that there equipment clocked me at say...120 mph....

Then I pipe up and say , Ummm I am sorry but that not true as actually I was doing over 180....(with a passenger witness to prove it)

The way I look at it is that OBVIOUSLY I am telling the truth which SHOULD disprove the CPS case....etc...

Will I be found not guilty of 120 mph ????

All the best Brett smile

hifihigh

590 posts

232 months

Thursday 10th April 2008
quotequote all
I guess technically you must have been doing 120 at some point in order to reach 180 so they could get you like that wink

Homicidal maniac

177 posts

223 months

Thursday 10th April 2008
quotequote all
Brett928S2 said:
Hi smile

I have always wondered what would happen in court if I actually told the truth ...in these circumstances...

Lets say I was taken to court for speeding and The Bib/CPS proved to the court that there equipment clocked me at say...120 mph....

Then I pipe up and say , Ummm I am sorry but that not true as actually I was doing over 180....(with a passenger witness to prove it)

The way I look at it is that OBVIOUSLY I am telling the truth which SHOULD disprove the CPS case....etc...

Will I be found not guilty of 120 mph ????

All the best Brett smile
What evidence will you provide (apart from somebody elses word, who isn't a credible witness so it won't count) to prove you were doing 180?

Brett928S2

1,504 posts

246 months

Thursday 10th April 2008
quotequote all
Hi smile

I have various meters in the car that can prove it (by GPS) and just for arguments sake lets say I had a video camera recording the meters...

And lets say they recorded 180 mph at the precise point that the CPS says I was doing 120 mph.....

Therefore the 120 charge should be dropped or me found not guilty ..no ???

Why do I get the feeling its not going to that easy lol smile ??

All the best Brett smile

Pickled Piper

6,452 posts

266 months

Thursday 10th April 2008
quotequote all
Derek Smith said:
When in CID I lost around eight hours because I took on face value what a witness had told me as, he being Asian, the signals were not that apparent to me. When I went back with ample evidence to show he had told me porkies, he said, “That was yesterday’s truth.” Without any sign of embarrassment. When I spoke with an Asian friend of mine he asked what room I had been taken into when I first interviewed him and I told him it was the kitchen and I was forced to stand. That, evidently, was a sign that I could not believe anything he said. The second visit I was taken into their family room and allowed to sit.
I've never heard that before. Has this been your experience on other occasions?

pp

Homicidal maniac

177 posts

223 months

Thursday 10th April 2008
quotequote all
Brett928S2 said:
Hi smile

I have various meters in the car that can prove it (by GPS) and just for arguments sake lets say I had a video camera recording the meters...

And lets say they recorded 180 mph at the precise point that the CPS says I was doing 120 mph.....

Therefore the 120 charge should be dropped or me found not guilty ..no ???

Why do I get the feeling its not going to that easy lol smile ??

All the best Brett smile
Hi smile

What a rediculous argument

All the very best, have a wonderful day Brett smile

catso

16,567 posts

298 months

Thursday 10th April 2008
quotequote all
Politicians lie all the time and usually get away with it, (Bliar has made that his legacy) if they are caught they normally just deny/make excuses and generally show no shame - what sort of example does that set to the rest of us. frown




JustinP1

13,364 posts

261 months

Thursday 10th April 2008
quotequote all
Brett928S2 said:
Hi smile

I have various meters in the car that can prove it (by GPS) and just for arguments sake lets say I had a video camera recording the meters...

And lets say they recorded 180 mph at the precise point that the CPS says I was doing 120 mph.....

Therefore the 120 charge should be dropped or me found not guilty ..no ???

Why do I get the feeling its not going to that easy lol smile ??

All the best Brett smile
So,

The CPS say you are doing 120, you openly admit in court that you were doing 180?

The offence is breaking the speed limit. I am guessing that you would be thus pleading guilty and somehow in mitigation 'owning up'. No, you would not get off.

The same concept would be for example, lets say you smack someone round the head three times and are accused of assault. Just because the BiB evidence says you hit him twice, and in court you say that is wrong you actually hit him three times, according to your concept you would be found not guilty?

(Thats rhetorical BTW smile)