Lying to your insurance firm about a claim.
Lying to your insurance firm about a claim.
Author
Discussion

mechsympathy

Original Poster:

58,921 posts

286 months

Friday 11th April 2008
quotequote all
I was T-boned this morning when someone pulled out of a junction into the side of me as they tried to turn right, hitting both my nearside doors and the rear arch. It's annoying but I thought straightforward...

Apparently they are claiming that I was behind them and tried to pull round them to turn left (rolleyesfurious etc etc) and as a consequence their front offside hit my nearside.

Thankfully I took some pictures, so I can prove that the damage is to the middle of their bumper, but will there be any comeback against them? Or will they gat away with it even if they are proved to be lying stsfurious

TonyHetherington

32,091 posts

281 months

Friday 11th April 2008
quotequote all
A friend of mine is currently 16 months car-less because of an accident (not same circumstances but similar level of guilt to other party) and they are trying to claim the opposite happened. It goes to court in a few months where they will decide.

Sorry to be the bearer of bad news (though this may not be the case for you).

mechsympathy

Original Poster:

58,921 posts

286 months

Friday 11th April 2008
quotequote all
TonyHetherington said:
Sorry to be the bearer of bad news (though this may not be the case for you).
eekfrown The damage isn't that bad thankfully.

Guam said:
Moral of the story get pictures on your mobile phone of the positions of the vehicles right after impact smile
It didn't occur to me that it was anything other than cut and driedbanghead

JustinP1

13,364 posts

261 months

Friday 11th April 2008
quotequote all
mechsympathy said:
I was T-boned this morning when someone pulled out of a junction into the side of me as they tried to turn right, hitting both my nearside doors and the rear arch. It's annoying but I thought straightforward...

Apparently they are claiming that I was behind them and tried to pull round them to turn left (rolleyesfurious etc etc) and as a consequence their front offside hit my nearside.

Thankfully I took some pictures, so I can prove that the damage is to the middle of their bumper, but will there be any comeback against them? Or will they gat away with it even if they are proved to be lying stsfurious
I think if you make it clear to your insurance company that they are lying, you have photos, and what they are saying makes no physical sense (that if you were turning left, you would be turning around them into the opposite side of the road...) that your insurance company can have a quiet word with theirs.

In this type of situation if you are persistent enough with this, their insurance company should smell a rat and 'advise' them to accept liability.

mechsympathy

Original Poster:

58,921 posts

286 months

Friday 11th April 2008
quotequote all
JustinP1 said:
In this type of situation if you are persistent enough with this, their insurance company should smell a rat and 'advise' them to accept liability.
Here's hoping. The icing on the cake is that both driver and passenger apparently work for their insurer's claims department.rolleyes

havoc

33,516 posts

266 months

Friday 11th April 2008
quotequote all
Short answer is: No.

When I was rear-ended the chap the whole way through maintained I joined at a slip-road and pulled straight-out in front of him. His testimony managed to contradict itself thankfully, and the Mag essentially said in summing up that he was lying.

But nothing happened to him. He paid his excess same as he would if it went 50:50...

JustinP1

13,364 posts

261 months

Friday 11th April 2008
quotequote all
mechsympathy said:
JustinP1 said:
In this type of situation if you are persistent enough with this, their insurance company should smell a rat and 'advise' them to accept liability.
Here's hoping. The icing on the cake is that both driver and passenger apparently work for their insurer's claims department.rolleyes
Whoah...

Do you have the legal assistance cover?

Now is a time to call on it. That said, I would have thought that it would be company policy for them not to have any contact whatsoever with their claim.

mechsympathy

Original Poster:

58,921 posts

286 months

Friday 11th April 2008
quotequote all
JustinP1 said:
Whoah...

Do you have the legal assistance cover?

Now is a time to call on it. That said, I would have thought that it would be company policy for them not to have any contact whatsoever with their claim.
I've got Anniesdad on the casethumbup

JustinP1

13,364 posts

261 months

Friday 11th April 2008
quotequote all
mechsympathy said:
JustinP1 said:
Whoah...

Do you have the legal assistance cover?

Now is a time to call on it. That said, I would have thought that it would be company policy for them not to have any contact whatsoever with their claim.
I've got Anniesdad on the casethumbup
Then my friend, you are sorted. smile

black-k1

12,813 posts

260 months

Friday 11th April 2008
quotequote all
I had something similar a couple of years ago. I was in the left lane approaching a roundabout on a two lane road arrowed left only (left lane) and right only (right lane). The left lane was full but the right was pretty empty. As I got to the round about and pulled on to go left a car came up the right lane and then cut across to go left (and avoid sitting in the queue). As he cut in front of me, even though I braked hard, my front bumper caught his rear wheel arch and cause a perfect PITT manoeuvre, spinning him into a barrier in the middle of the road and (I later discovered) writing is car off. It seemed very straight forward to me that it was his fault (witnessed by the person in the car behind me) so we exchanged details and, as I had nothing more than a very slight scratch on the front of my bumper (10 year old car with 150k miles so no big shakes) I said his car, his problem.

A couple of weeks later I discovered that the other driver (via his insurance company) was claiming it was my fault and was going for the full value of the car along with personal injury. Luckily, I had reported the details to my insurance company so it was no surprise but I then spent 6 months with my insurance company challenging all the claims made by the other driver and repeatedly asking how, with a witness agreeing with me, anyone could think that it was my fault. I got the correct result in the end but it took a lot of effort but it showed me that you need to get as many details as you can at the time and you need to sit on your insurance company as they seem to find it easier to ‘roll over’ and accept liability even though there is no way your are at fault.

streaky

19,311 posts

280 months

Friday 11th April 2008
quotequote all
black-k1 said:
... you need to sit on your insurance company as they seem to find it easier to ‘roll over’ and accept liability even though there is no way your are at fault.
Of course it's easier and cheaper for them to settle 50:50. (1) It reduces their claims processing costs. (2) They sting you with loss of your NCB and an increased premium. - Streaky

mechsympathy

Original Poster:

58,921 posts

286 months

Friday 11th April 2008
quotequote all
JustinP1 said:
Then my friend, you are sorted. smile
smile

So, back to my original question: If it goes my way, do they get done for attempted fraud (or similar)?



ETA: Much as I appreciate the empathy, that thread's herebiggrin

Edited by mechsympathy on Friday 11th April 13:08

dearboy

145 posts

226 months

Friday 11th April 2008
quotequote all
I am having a similar problem. Guy ran into the back of me in december. We exchanged details, i let my legal cover take care of things and thought it was cut and dried. However a few weeks back i got a call from my legal team/insurance to say the guy is denying any collision and the fact that he was there at all.
My only hope is the hand written deatils he gave me at the scene which have been forwarded to my team.
How these tts sleep at night is beyond me.
A good flogging in a market place seems like a good trade off in my opinion!

Pork_n_Beem

1,164 posts

256 months

Friday 11th April 2008
quotequote all
Car pulled out of a side road and i ran into her rear door with my motorbike.

I was carted off to casualty, police took detailed statements from witnesses and measurements including photos etc with a view of prosecuting the driver of the car.

Her insurance co. still tried to claim i pulled out in front of her, to which i replied "was she riding the bike then or what"

Appears standard practice, i don't believe it was the driver that actually made up such a ridiculous story, in my case, she was not the type and she knew she was being pursued by the CPS.

JustinP1

13,364 posts

261 months

Friday 11th April 2008
quotequote all
mechsympathy said:
JustinP1 said:
Then my friend, you are sorted. smile
smile

So, back to my original question: If it goes my way, do they get done for attempted fraud (or similar)?



ETA: Much as I appreciate the empathy, that thread's herebiggrin

Edited by mechsympathy on Friday 11th April 13:08
Didn't see the other thread. The sneaky sods.

IMHO the problem is proof. Fraud is a serious thing which needs serious proof. A civil case is on the balance of probability, so even if it goes further the outcome is that they believe your version of events over theirs. That doesn't prove that they intended to lie.



Noger

7,117 posts

280 months

Friday 11th April 2008
quotequote all
streaky said:
Of course it's easier and cheaper for them to settle 50:50. (1) It reduces their claims processing costs. (2) They sting you with loss of your NCB and an increased premium. - Streaky
So what Claim Handler hours/hourly rate are you putting on instructing the solicitor ? And which fixed fee are we assuming for this ? Pre-Trial settlement or post ? Just property damage or PI as well ? UK, Scotland or Northern ireland ? Which underwriting year are we taking the average claims costs from ?

Fag packet calculations would suggest anything over a couple of grand and this isn't the case. Solicitors work on a delegated authority basis, it is just fire and forget.




mechsympathy

Original Poster:

58,921 posts

286 months

Friday 11th April 2008
quotequote all
JustinP1 said:
IMHO the problem is proof. Fraud is a serious thing which needs serious proof. A civil case is on the balance of probability, so even if it goes further the outcome is that they believe your version of events over theirs. That doesn't prove that they intended to lie.
frown VBRJ with a donkey it is then biggrin

JustinP1

13,364 posts

261 months

Friday 11th April 2008
quotequote all
Noger said:
streaky said:
Of course it's easier and cheaper for them to settle 50:50. (1) It reduces their claims processing costs. (2) They sting you with loss of your NCB and an increased premium. - Streaky
So what Claim Handler hours/hourly rate are you putting on instructing the solicitor ? And which fixed fee are we assuming for this ? Pre-Trial settlement or post ? Just property damage or PI as well ? UK, Scotland or Northern ireland ? Which underwriting year are we taking the average claims costs from ?

Fag packet calculations would suggest anything over a couple of grand and this isn't the case. Solicitors work on a delegated authority basis, it is just fire and forget.
I thing he is just saying in general.

And to that, I also agree. I think you mentioned in another thread that there were situations that were already agreed upon which are 50/50?

Surely that is a financially cheaper option than a claim taking a couple of years and solicitor's costs?

Noger

7,117 posts

280 months

Friday 11th April 2008
quotequote all
<fag packet>
£5000 claim

50/50 - you are down £2500

Fast track claim, so say £1000 fixed fee. Appoint Solicitor. They go to court and get 80/20 - not a great result. But you are STILL £500 up on the deal compared to 50/50. And that is with a fairly low value claim.

The claims costs that you are trying to reduce are upfront costs, so not affected by this apparently miraculous new way of agreeing liabilty AFTER your investigations.

What you want to do is be able to automate this early on. And in fact that is how French motor insurance works. They have a big book with pictures of car positions and road layouts in it, each with a liabilty %. Pragmatic, but not always fair. But "siwngs and roundabouts" I guess.

JustinP1

13,364 posts

261 months

Friday 11th April 2008
quotequote all
Noger said:
<fag packet>
£5000 claim

50/50 - you are down £2500

Fast track claim, so say £1000 fixed fee. Appoint Solicitor. They go to court and get 80/20 - not a great result. But you are STILL £500 up on the deal compared to 50/50. And that is with a fairly low value claim.

The claims costs that you are trying to reduce are upfront costs, so not affected by this apparently miraculous new way of agreeing liabilty AFTER your investigations.

What you want to do is be able to automate this early on. And in fact that is how French motor insurance works. They have a big book with pictures of car positions and road layouts in it, each with a liabilty %. Pragmatic, but not always fair. But "siwngs and roundabouts" I guess.
I think there you are missing some parts of the equation.

Looking at it from an economists prospective, it explains the macro situation better.

Assuming that the ratio of drivers whose 'fault' a claim is don't congregate to a certain insurance company, they are spread equally throughout all companies. Therefore the 'perfect' business model would be for each insurance company to make every claim 50:50.

Over the course of the year, regardless of whose fault it actually was in a claim, the Direct Line vs Norwich Union cases statistically will end up with them both paying out an equal amount anyway even if they did go into the finest detail about fault and come up with the absolutely most legally correct decision.

Therefore it would make sense that the perfect business model would be for every case to be settled 50/50 ASAP, so there would be no solicitor's costs and little admin costs. Less costs, more margin. Every case which is not settled in this way comes away from the most efficient business model, therefore they are highly reluctant to do this.

Indeed, the 50:50 claim is the de facto way of increasing future premiums by reducing no claims bonus. Any short term losses by not trying to spend £1000 making a 50:50 claim into an 80:20 claim are covered by not only another case later on being decided 50:50 when it should be 80:20 against them with the added bonus of increased future premiums. Happy days.

To an extent, that is what we have. Even 9 months into a claim I assisted my other half with, the claim handlers still seemed to be telling us despite the fact that from the start we have protested it was non fault, and the third party had still not completed his accident report, that for some reason "This case is going to be 50:50, shall I proceed with that for you, sir?". It took 9 months for us to force them into getting a solicitor, and a year later I forced them to return our excess and chase the third party for costs.




Edited by JustinP1 on Friday 11th April 15:35