Insurance Claim Question
Author
Discussion

dougc

8,241 posts

296 months

Friday 11th April 2008
quotequote all
Wasn't driving an MG estate was he? biggrin

JustinP1

13,364 posts

261 months

Friday 11th April 2008
quotequote all
With regard to the 'legal obligation', the only lawful obligation you have is to recompense him for the damage caused by your negligence.

He has no right to choose whether you pay this, or your insurance company pays this.

The way I would word it to him is that you are happy to admit full liability as long as it can be dealt with without involving the insurance companies. Ask him to get a couple of quotes for the work and offer that you will pay for the best quote.

Explain that this will be a better option than having an accident added to the record to both of your insurance companies.

Ean218

2,046 posts

281 months

Friday 11th April 2008
quotequote all
You will have to tell your insurance co. about the incident whether you claim or not. They will then load your premium anyway. You might as well claim properly.

herewego

8,814 posts

244 months

Friday 11th April 2008
quotequote all
You could offer to pay for his repair at a garage of his choosing, or offer a cash lump sum, but don't be surprised if he turns you down, as he may not wish to trust you. If you have a crash you are supposed to inform your insurance company although you don't have to make a claim.

JustinP1

13,364 posts

261 months

Friday 11th April 2008
quotequote all
peterbean said:
Thank you Justin. I thank you for your quick reply. Should I worry about him speaking to his insurance company first? Just for information there was damage to the rear door and he rear three quarter panel. I'm not a mechanic or a body specialist but I think that it will be just under £1000. A pain to pay now but possibly the best idea in the long run? What is your opinion. For the record I am 21 with 2 years NCB and currently pay about £1500 which I estimate would jump to £2500 with the claim.
What you need to work out are the exact figures.

For example, if the claim starts becoming a few grand then this is not economical. What you have to work out is what your NCB is worth to you over the next few years. If it is put back effectively three years, you may be losing out on a saving of £1000 in the first year, £700 in the second year, £500 in the third year, £300 in the forth year and so on. Of course those arnt exact figures but you get my drift.

If it were me, I would be looking to sort with him first. I would also tell my insurance company that I had been in a minor accident for which was small enough to settle yourself, after you have sorted it with him.

You should not lose your NCB as you have not made a claim and secondly your insurance would not be loaded anywhere near as much as if they had to pay out.

You can't really make a final decision until you know the cost of the damage, as to whether it is worth letting the insurance company deal with it. On the face of it though, if your excess is say £500, then the prang in total is going to cost you maybe £2500 in that and premiums. So, if it costs less than that, then it may be worth pushing to pay to fix it yourself.

mechsympathy

58,921 posts

286 months

Friday 11th April 2008
quotequote all
dougc said:
Wasn't driving an MG estate was he? biggrin
biggrinnonotongue out

Fair play to the OP for holding your hands up and doing the right thing.

streaky

19,311 posts

280 months

Friday 11th April 2008
quotequote all
peterbean said:
This morning I was waiting to pull out from a T-Junction. Traffic was flowing in both directions of the 30 limit road. A car turned into the junction and as he entered (and I thought it was clear) I left the junction. He braked suddenly and we made contact. Although I didn't admit any blame at the scene I think I was in the wrong.
I presume the car that turned into the junction was coming from your left and that you were turning right. Is that the case? If so, you are probably correct that you were in the wrong. Otherwise, what was the situation? If he was coming from your right, how did he hit you by braking suddenly? Did he skid? What side of the road was he on? What side were you on? Streaky

JustinP1

13,364 posts

261 months

Friday 11th April 2008
quotequote all
peterbean said:
I have just spoken to the guy and he has already spoken to his insurance company who will phone me this afternoon. I understand I need to speak to my insurance company. Do I tell them I am to blame or just explain the situation and leave it at that? Thanks.
The thing is he has every right to opt to ask his insurance company to sort it out on his behalf. On the other hand, you have every right to pay the claim out of your own money. I have even heard people no this even if the claim does goes through your insurance company to save their no claims bonus as effectively your insurance company have not paid out.

The second thing is that it may be difficult to field the call from their insurance company. I suppose you could just say that 'without prejudice' - that means without admitting your guilt, then you are offering to cover the claim out of your own pocket. His insurers may like this or they may not.

Deva Link

26,934 posts

276 months

Friday 11th April 2008
quotequote all
Someone ran into the back of Mrs DL's car and then called me and wanted to settle outside the insurance, but why should I deal with someone I don't know - how do I know they'll actually pay me or not quibble about the cost?

I just reported the accident to my insurance and let them sort it out. They took care of the whole thing with the minimum of hassle and inconvenience to me. That's what I pay my insurance premiums for. Why would any 3rd party want to do anything else?

Perhaps the facility exists to repay the insurance company and protect your NCB, but, as other have said, you have to report it anyway, so your premium would likely increase. The bummer for the other guy is his insurance might go up as he'll have a non-fault accident recorded on his record.

Edited by Deva Link on Friday 11th April 14:15

Noger

7,117 posts

280 months

Friday 11th April 2008
quotequote all
peterbean said:
I have just spoken to the guy and he has already spoken to his insurance company who will phone me this afternoon. I understand I need to speak to my insurance company. Do I tell them I am to blame or just explain the situation and leave it at that? Thanks.
Just tell them you are dealing with the damage on your own, it isn't that uncommon. You need to be careful that no PI element comes back to haunt you.

However I would suggest that most situations like this end up coming back to the insurer. The cost may well be higher than you imagine.

The alternative is to pay back your Insurer at the end. Again, unusual but not that uncommon.

Edited by Noger on Friday 11th April 15:01