Advice Please - maybe Case Law?
Advice Please - maybe Case Law?
Author
Discussion

peterguk V6 KWK

Original Poster:

2,622 posts

248 months

Saturday 12th April 2008
quotequote all
OK, i was allegdly caught speeding last Autumn. 84 on motorway. Shortly after postal strike. Backlogs in postal deliveries still common.

Received NIP on day 17.

My postman (who i do not know, except that he is my postman), handed my the NIP on the driveway, saw me open it, and saw the contents.

He is willing to act as a witness.

Sent usual letters to scamera partnership quoting relevant parts of RTOA etc.

Received summons to appear. Scamera partnership claim NIP sent a few days after date of offence.

Pleaded not guilty last Thursday.

Waiting for pre-trial date.

I suspect i might get steam-rollered as in mags not interested in NIP served date, but AFAIK my independant witness of good character should carry some weight.

Any advice to help me win my case is appreciated.

Clean licence so no vested interest in not taking the points except for matters of principal.


Edited by peterguk V6 KWK on Saturday 12th April 09:20

rsv gone!

11,288 posts

272 months

Saturday 12th April 2008
quotequote all

peterguk V6 KWK

Original Poster:

2,622 posts

248 months

Saturday 12th April 2008
quotequote all
rsv gone! said:
Thanks. Was posting here as there are some well-informed guys here...

James Heath

18 posts

225 months

Saturday 12th April 2008
quotequote all
Keep us updated, and good luck

Kevin 996C4

13,894 posts

311 months

Saturday 12th April 2008
quotequote all
Date of delivery not actually relevant provided the scamera team can show they posted it with enough time for the expectation of delivery by the 14th day (+1). Sorry.

Edited by Kevin 996C4 on Saturday 12th April 15:59

peterguk V6 KWK

Original Poster:

2,622 posts

248 months

Saturday 12th April 2008
quotequote all
Kevin 996C4 said:
Date of delivery not actually relevant provided the scamera team can show they posted it with enough time for the expectation of delivery by the 14th day (+1). Sorry.

Edited by Kevin 996C4 on Saturday 12th April 15:59
So... RTOA 1988 is just ignored then?????


(1)
(c) within fourteen days of the commission of the offence a notice of the intended prosecution specifying the nature of the alleged offence and the time and place where it is alleged to have been committed, was—
(i) in the case of an offence under section 28 or 29 of the [1988 c. 52.] Road Traffic Act 1988 (cycling offences), served on him,
(ii) in the case of any other offence, served on him or on the person, if any, registered as the keeper of the vehicle at the time of the commission of the offence.

It was not served on me within 14 days.

(2) A notice shall be deemed for the purposes of subsection (1)(c) above to have been served on a person if it was sent by registered post or recorded delivery service addressed to him at his last known address, notwithstanding that the notice was returned as undelivered or was for any other reason not received by him.

It was sent standard post during/shortly after a national postal strike.

(3) The requirement of subsection (1) above shall in every case be deemed to have been complied with unless and until the contrary is proved.

My witness will prove otherwise.


Edited by peterguk V6 KWK on Saturday 12th April 16:27

vonhosen

40,597 posts

248 months

Saturday 12th April 2008
quotequote all
When a document has to be or may be served by post, section 7 of the Interpretation Act 1978 is relevant. This provides that service is deemed to be effected by properly addressing, pre-paying and posting the document and that, unless the contrary is proved, service is deemed to have been effected when the document would be delivered in the ordinary course of post.

SS2.

14,712 posts

269 months

Saturday 12th April 2008
quotequote all
vonhosen said:
s.7 Interpretation Act 1978....provides that service is deemed to be effected by properly addressing, pre-paying and posting the document and that, unless the contrary is proved, service is deemed to have been effected when the document would be delivered in the ordinary course of post.
I have highlighted what is, IMO, the key bit..

If the contrary can be proven, then service is not deemed to have been effected at the time when the document would have ordinarily been delivered.

Normally, proving a negative such as this would require a defendant to give evidence under oath that the notice was received out of time. If it was not possible to produce any other evidence to support this claim, a successful defence would thus be reliant solely on the defendant's credibility as a witness.

In the present case, however, proving the contrary appears somewhat more straightforward because the postman is willing to independently confirm the exact date the notice was delivered (which was outside of the 14 days required by statute)..

peterguk V6 KWK

Original Poster:

2,622 posts

248 months

Saturday 12th April 2008
quotequote all
vonhosen said:
When a document has to be or may be served by post, section 7 of the Interpretation Act 1978 is relevant. This provides that service is deemed to be effected by properly addressing, pre-paying and posting the document and that, unless the contrary is proved, service is deemed to have been effected when the document would be delivered in the ordinary course of post.
Thanks VH.

So, if the "ordinary course of post" is affected by a national postal strike, and the sender had prior knowledge of said strike and the publicised effects of said strike, is it not the case that the sender should have taken more care in ensuring delivery within regulations defined by RTOA?

If not, then i see no point in RTOA....

vonhosen

40,597 posts

248 months

Johnbmw6

331 posts

240 months

Saturday 12th April 2008
quotequote all
rsv gone! said:
NO don't: go too www.motoringlawyers.com get them to defend you and you will walk.

SS2.

14,712 posts

269 months

Saturday 12th April 2008
quotequote all
vonhosen said:
I know the case. Correct result (because it refers to recorded delivery) but completely the wrong reasoning and might prove to be very damaging..mad

The judgment will be binding for those north of the border, but merely persuasive in England & Wales.

peterguk V6 KWK

Original Poster:

2,622 posts

248 months

Saturday 12th April 2008
quotequote all
VH

I am a little confused....

It appaears my postman could be the key to my defence, and luckily he will attend Court.

BUT

the case link if i understand it correctly, suggests the defendant won in Court, but lost on Appeal by the CPS?

Edited by peterguk V6 KWK on Saturday 12th April 17:56

vonhosen

40,597 posts

248 months

Saturday 12th April 2008
quotequote all
peterguk V6 KWK said:
VH

I am a little confused....

It appaears my postman could be the key to my defence, and luckily he will attend Court.

BUT

the case link if i understand it correctly, suggests the defendant won in Court, but lost on Appeal by the CPS?
It was Scotland (so PF as opposed to CPS) & yes defendant was originally acquitted but that was overturned.
See SS2's post above.

I make no judgement about the case, I only posted it as an example of a recent ruling that illustrates these points are still being argued & ruled upon.
If there is argument of whether the NIP has been served (& what that means) then the court will be the arbiter.

peterguk V6 KWK

Original Poster:

2,622 posts

248 months

Saturday 12th April 2008
quotequote all
vonhosen said:
peterguk V6 KWK said:
VH

I am a little confused....

It appaears my postman could be the key to my defence, and luckily he will attend Court.

BUT

the case link if i understand it correctly, suggests the defendant won in Court, but lost on Appeal by the CPS?
It was Scotland (so PF as opposed to CPS) & yes defendant was originally acquitted but that was overturned.
See SS2's post above.

I make no judgement about the case, I only posted it as an example of a recent ruling that illustrates these points are still being argued & ruled upon.
If there is argument of whether the NIP has been served (& what that means) then the court will be the arbiter.
Thanks for making that clear.

So no harm in putting on my best suit and trying then.

Assuming i am capable of presenting myself, putting a point in front of an audience, is there any advantage in having a solictor represent me?

Mr_annie_vxr

9,270 posts

242 months

Saturday 12th April 2008
quotequote all
peterguk V6 KWK said:
vonhosen said:
peterguk V6 KWK said:
VH

I am a little confused....

It appaears my postman could be the key to my defence, and luckily he will attend Court.

BUT

the case link if i understand it correctly, suggests the defendant won in Court, but lost on Appeal by the CPS?
It was Scotland (so PF as opposed to CPS) & yes defendant was originally acquitted but that was overturned.
See SS2's post above.

I make no judgement about the case, I only posted it as an example of a recent ruling that illustrates these points are still being argued & ruled upon.
If there is argument of whether the NIP has been served (& what that means) then the court will be the arbiter.
Thanks for making that clear.

So no harm in putting on my best suit and trying then.

Assuming i am capable of presenting myself, putting a point in front of an audience, is there any advantage in having a solictor represent me?
It will save you their fees. HTH

Not sure but if you do represent yourself make sure you read up, don't get emotive or embroiled in an argument about other matters.

JustinP1 often gives some good advice apparently.