Another right to silence to vanish its rubbish
Discussion
http://news.bbc.co.uk/1/hi/uk/7343937.stm
nasty folk said:
Local authorities in England and Wales often find it difficult to prove that a particular individual was to blame.
The Local Government Association wants a new system where the vehicle owner would face a penalty of up to £80 if the culprit cannot be identified.
Yet another right to silence looks like it will be vanishing for those nasty nasty car driversThe Local Government Association wants a new system where the vehicle owner would face a penalty of up to £80 if the culprit cannot be identified.
And what if a back seat passenger throws out rubbish without the driver's knowledge? This 'offence' could be committed by anyone in a vehicle. Bus passenger? - driver fined?
Defence? "I had three passengers in the car and I don't know which one threw out the rubbish. I was concentrating on my driving (or 'speed' or 'CO2 emmissions'!) at the time and not observing the passengers."
Defence? "I had three passengers in the car and I don't know which one threw out the rubbish. I was concentrating on my driving (or 'speed' or 'CO2 emmissions'!) at the time and not observing the passengers."
Edited by Glosphil on Saturday 12th April 10:54
thinfourth2 said:
http://news.bbc.co.uk/1/hi/uk/7343937.stm
Looks like I'll be refusing to carry passengers then, and fck 'em.nasty folk said:
Local authorities in England and Wales often find it difficult to prove that a particular individual was to blame.
The Local Government Association wants a new system where the vehicle owner would face a penalty of up to £80 if the culprit cannot be identified.
Yet another right to silence looks like it will be vanishing for those nasty nasty car driversThe Local Government Association wants a new system where the vehicle owner would face a penalty of up to £80 if the culprit cannot be identified.
It's amazing. One minute you absolutely cannot use a mobile phone in any shape or form whatsoever and you cannot talk and you must never ever multitask in any way when behind the wheel otherwise you're a child murderer, and the next minute those people from sink estates for whom throwing rubbish out of cars is an issue are expected to watch, monitor and indeed remonstrate, if necessary, with passengers whilst driving.
I wish they'd make their minds up.
I wish they'd make their minds up.
RK who can be traced in "getting fined for not committing an offence" shock...
They may as well just ask everyone who owns a car to pay a "we want it, and we'll get it anyway we can" tax and be done with it.
Strange how these self same CCTV cameras are not used to catch MoP who are walking along dropping litter, isn't it!?!?
They may as well just ask everyone who owns a car to pay a "we want it, and we'll get it anyway we can" tax and be done with it.
Strange how these self same CCTV cameras are not used to catch MoP who are walking along dropping litter, isn't it!?!?
Funny how it all comes down to "fines" with this pack-0-s
tes isnt it?
Fines and cameras, cameras and fines.
Cant see how fining a driver who didnt throw anything out the window will address the problem of the person who actually chucked it, let alone who will pick it up...
Critical mass is on final approach.
tes isnt it?Fines and cameras, cameras and fines.
Cant see how fining a driver who didnt throw anything out the window will address the problem of the person who actually chucked it, let alone who will pick it up...
Critical mass is on final approach.
thinfourth2 said:
Yet another right to silence looks like it will be vanishing for those nasty nasty car drivers
Not a right to silence disappearing though is it ?The registered keeper is responsible for those using the car in respect of this matter, they don't have to say anything.
It's the same as parking, bus lanes, box junctions, no left turn etc.
Jasandjules said:
How is it just to fine someone who has committed no offence?!?!?!
Well the Nazi's informant state worked for a while, it's downfall being Hitler's want to expand, perhaps this is the route we'll be taken down by the people who have our best interests at heart. Perhaps they could get children to inform the police...What happens if you were not even in the car at the time?
What happens if you have lent the car to other members of your family and it is something more serious such as not stopping after an accident or hit and run. Are you as the registered keeeper going to be responsible if the driver does not own up? There could be more than one family member in the car.
What happens if you have lent the car to other members of your family and it is something more serious such as not stopping after an accident or hit and run. Are you as the registered keeeper going to be responsible if the driver does not own up? There could be more than one family member in the car.
nats1rt said:
Jasandjules said:
How is it just to fine someone who has committed no offence?!?!?!
Well the Nazi's informant state worked for a while, it's downfall being Hitler's want to expand, perhaps this is the route we'll be taken down by the people who have our best interests at heart. Perhaps they could get children to inform the police...IT's already begun, a bit like removing WWII from the History books the EU issues to schools..
rewc said:
What happens if you were not even in the car at the time?
What happens if you have lent the car to other members of your family and it is something more serious such as not stopping after an accident or hit and run. Are you as the registered keeeper going to be responsible if the driver does not own up? There could be more than one family member in the car.
You are responsible for your car, so don't lend it to people you don't trust. You can always make them pay you for any penalties you incur as a result of their misuse.What happens if you have lent the car to other members of your family and it is something more serious such as not stopping after an accident or hit and run. Are you as the registered keeeper going to be responsible if the driver does not own up? There could be more than one family member in the car.
It's not much different to allowing them to drive your car on your insurance, you are effectively indemnifying them. You wouldn't allow that for people you didn't trust.
This is not the same as criminal offences such as failing to stop following a collision would be. There are different rules for criminal offences in place.
Edited by vonhosen on Saturday 12th April 12:49
vonhosen said:
thinfourth2 said:
Yet another right to silence looks like it will be vanishing for those nasty nasty car drivers
Not a right to silence disappearing though is it ?The registered keeper is responsible for those using the car in respect of this matter, they don't have to say anything.
It's the same as parking, bus lanes, box junctions, no left turn etc.
It stinks and you know it stinks
Drivers are treated as enemy number 1 and examples like this show it more and more
article said:
Local authorities in England and Wales often find it difficult to prove that a particular individual was to blame.
It is basically lazy policing If they want to pursue us evil drivers then why don't we have registration plates instead of the car?
Would certainly solve alot of problems with blame. When you change drivers you change the plates nice and easy. it wouldn't be hard just a magnetic plate (added advantage it annoys TVR owners) Also to get the plate you pay for third party insurance for any car which removes the uninsured driver problem as well. Apart from those that are above the law by running cloned plates.
With the added benefit that the plates can be fixed to our foreheads when we are around town for easy distribution of fines
thinfourth2 said:
vonhosen said:
thinfourth2 said:
Yet another right to silence looks like it will be vanishing for those nasty nasty car drivers
Not a right to silence disappearing though is it ?The registered keeper is responsible for those using the car in respect of this matter, they don't have to say anything.
It's the same as parking, bus lanes, box junctions, no left turn etc.
It stinks and you know it stinks
Drivers are treated as enemy number 1 and examples like this show it more and more
article said:
Local authorities in England and Wales often find it difficult to prove that a particular individual was to blame.
It is basically lazy policing If they want to pursue us evil drivers then why don't we have registration plates instead of the car?
Would certainly solve alot of problems with blame. When you change drivers you change the plates nice and easy. it wouldn't be hard just a magnetic plate (added advantage it annoys TVR owners) Also to get the plate you pay for third party insurance for any car which removes the uninsured driver problem as well. Apart from those that are above the law by running cloned plates.
With the added benefit that the plates can be fixed to our foreheads when we are around town for easy distribution of fines
You are not prosecuted, as in a crime, because a crime is not alleged by you.
You are not being dealt with as a criminal, you are not being convicted of a crime.
Littering is disgusting, something needs to be done about.
You as a keeper of a vehicle are going to be required to make sure that your vehicle is not used for littering, that isn't a great deal to ask & you doing your bit to make sure littering doesn't take place is a good thing rather than just an abolition of responsibility.
If you wish to commit crime in order to avoid that rather simple obligation then you run the risk of being dealt with as a criminal (which is not what it is happening with the littering scenario).
Edited by vonhosen on Saturday 12th April 13:18
vonhosen said:
rewc said:
What happens if you were not even in the car at the time?
What happens if you have lent the car to other members of your family and it is something more serious such as not stopping after an accident or hit and run. Are you as the registered keeeper going to be responsible if the driver does not own up? There could be more than one family member in the car.
You are responsible for your car, so don't lend it to people you don't trust. You can always make them pay you for any penalties you incur as a result of their misuse.What happens if you have lent the car to other members of your family and it is something more serious such as not stopping after an accident or hit and run. Are you as the registered keeeper going to be responsible if the driver does not own up? There could be more than one family member in the car.
This is not the same as criminal offences such as failing to stop following a collision would be. There are different rules for criminal offences in place.
As Guam noted the use of RIPA by councils (over 12,000 last year); Nu Labia MP Keith Vaz reportedly condemned its use ... excuse me? Mr Vaz was a member of the government that brought RIPA in and didn't restrict its use more tightly (albeit, he appears to have absented himself from voting several times in connection with the Bill, and I can't discover how he voted in the final debate).
Streaky "As Guam noted the use of RIPA by councils (over 12,000 last year); Nu Labia MP Keith Vaz reportedly condemned its use ... excuse me? Mr Vaz was a member of the government that brought RIPA in and didn't restrict its use more tightly etc."
Funny how MP's objected when the member for Tooting was allegedly bugged whilst visiting a constituent in Prison. One rule for them etc.....
Funny how MP's objected when the member for Tooting was allegedly bugged whilst visiting a constituent in Prison. One rule for them etc.....
vonhosen said:
thinfourth2 said:
Yet another right to silence looks like it will be vanishing for those nasty nasty car drivers
Not a right to silence disappearing though is it ?The registered keeper is responsible for those using the car in respect of this matter, they don't have to say anything.
It's the same as parking, bus lanes, box junctions, no left turn etc.
Tell me VonStrumpferHosen, why should the RK be fined????
Let me guess, cos its his vehicle that it came out of?
Hasnt law and order dropped to an all time low in terms of public respect for it.....and its getting lower by the day the more of these stasi tactics are introduced.
vonhosen said:
rewc said:
What happens if you were not even in the car at the time?
What happens if you have lent the car to other members of your family and it is something more serious such as not stopping after an accident or hit and run. Are you as the registered keeeper going to be responsible if the driver does not own up? There could be more than one family member in the car.
You are responsible for your car, so don't lend it to people you don't trust. You can always make them pay you for any penalties you incur as a result of their misuse.What happens if you have lent the car to other members of your family and it is something more serious such as not stopping after an accident or hit and run. Are you as the registered keeeper going to be responsible if the driver does not own up? There could be more than one family member in the car.
It's not much different to allowing them to drive your car on your insurance, you are effectively indemnifying them. You wouldn't allow that for people you didn't trust.
This is not the same as criminal offences such as failing to stop following a collision would be. There are different rules for criminal offences in place.
Edited by vonhosen on Saturday 12th April 12:49
Deltaf01 said:
vonhosen said:
thinfourth2 said:
Yet another right to silence looks like it will be vanishing for those nasty nasty car drivers
Not a right to silence disappearing though is it ?The registered keeper is responsible for those using the car in respect of this matter, they don't have to say anything.
It's the same as parking, bus lanes, box junctions, no left turn etc.
Tell me VonStrumpferHosen, why should the RK be fined????
Let me guess, cos its his vehicle that it came out of?
Hasnt law and order dropped to an all time low in terms of public respect for it.....and its getting lower by the day the more of these stasi tactics are introduced.
Gassing Station | Speed, Plod & the Law | Top of Page | What's New | My Stuff


