Insurance question... Am I in the sh1t?
Discussion
Right,, Saturday night - pulled over in my mum's A-Class for going too fast over a roundabout (stop sniggering).
Was very apologetic etc, and they ran their checks on the car etc.
Anyway, it came up as having no insurance - which I know it does becuase I'm a named driver. The database centre was closed to follow it up, so I got a producer.
Went out yesterday and went back to the folks' to find out the reason why the car came up as no insurance was because it was still on it's original number plate, and not the private one. Don't know at this point whether the insurance company or the folks are at fault yet.
I have my own third party coverage, but if the policy on the Mercedes isn't valid, does this invalidate my right to drive any car with the owners permission?
Any input would be great...
Was very apologetic etc, and they ran their checks on the car etc.
Anyway, it came up as having no insurance - which I know it does becuase I'm a named driver. The database centre was closed to follow it up, so I got a producer.
Went out yesterday and went back to the folks' to find out the reason why the car came up as no insurance was because it was still on it's original number plate, and not the private one. Don't know at this point whether the insurance company or the folks are at fault yet.
I have my own third party coverage, but if the policy on the Mercedes isn't valid, does this invalidate my right to drive any car with the owners permission?
Any input would be great...
On the first bit, I think there was been discussion before about a similar thing. I would suggest you would be OK, afterall registration no is hardly a mterial fact as long as the vehicle details are correct.
On the second bit, no, your DOC cover won't be invalidated by any potential lack of cover on the vehicle elsewhere.
On the second bit, no, your DOC cover won't be invalidated by any potential lack of cover on the vehicle elsewhere.
I think the bottom line the car is covered ... I have changed the wife's car to have a new plate .. but the car is fundamentally covered and it is an admin error.
You would be in the s
t, if the car had no 3rd party cover as this is an offense to drive a car with no insurance, DESPITE you having cover from your own policy ... That is how I understand it to work
You would be in the s
t, if the car had no 3rd party cover as this is an offense to drive a car with no insurance, DESPITE you having cover from your own policy ... That is how I understand it to work andyuk911 said:
You would be in the s
t, if the car had no 3rd party cover as this is an offense to drive a car with no insurance, DESPITE you having cover from your own policy ... That is how I understand it to work
No, that is fine. All comes down to the RTA talking about "use" and "permit to use" etc
t, if the car had no 3rd party cover as this is an offense to drive a car with no insurance, DESPITE you having cover from your own policy ... That is how I understand it to work As long as you have cover for the USE, it doesn't matter what is happening elsewhere. Until you park it on a road and leave it for the owner. Then they are "using" it and don't have cover, depsite not actually "using" it at the time. Clear
Noger said:
andyuk911 said:
You would be in the s
t, if the car had no 3rd party cover as this is an offense to drive a car with no insurance, DESPITE you having cover from your own policy ... That is how I understand it to work
No, that is fine. All comes down to the RTA talking about "use" and "permit to use" etc
t, if the car had no 3rd party cover as this is an offense to drive a car with no insurance, DESPITE you having cover from your own policy ... That is how I understand it to work As long as you have cover for the USE, it doesn't matter what is happening elsewhere. Until you park it on a road and leave it for the owner. Then they are "using" it and don't have cover, depsite not actually "using" it at the time. Clear
skwdenyer said:
Really? I was under the impression that this was precisely the sort of thing that various BiB were trying to crack down on - cars kept off road by their owners, but used by others on 3rd party OC.
Ah, but what about lease cars ? I don't "own" my car but I am perfectly entitled to drive it on the road using my insurance.Anyway, the Road Traffic Act is what counts.
"a person must not use a motor vehicle on a road unless there is in force in relation to the use of the vehicle by that person such a policy of insurance or such a security in respect of third party risks as complies with the requirements of this Part of this Act, and"
So under your DOC (if you have it) you are pefectly entitled to drive whatever car you like, as long as it is not owned by, or hired or loaned to, you. i.e. I can't drive my lease car under DOC cover.
I think what you are refering to is young drivers using their DOC cover to drive a higer group car owned by someone else ? This has largely been stopped by restricting DOC to older drivers. And IIRC Norwich Onion removed DOC for everyone (although they may have put it back, as nobody was that keen to follow).
Insurers do huff and puff about it being for emergency purposes only, but huff&puff is not legally binding.
Noger said:
skwdenyer said:
Really? I was under the impression that this was precisely the sort of thing that various BiB were trying to crack down on - cars kept off road by their owners, but used by others on 3rd party OC.
Ah, but what about lease cars ? I don't "own" my car but I am perfectly entitled to drive it on the road using my insurance.Anyway, the Road Traffic Act is what counts.
"a person must not use a motor vehicle on a road unless there is in force in relation to the use of the vehicle by that person such a policy of insurance or such a security in respect of third party risks as complies with the requirements of this Part of this Act, and"
So under your DOC (if you have it) you are pefectly entitled to drive whatever car you like, as long as it is not owned by, or hired or loaned to, you. i.e. I can't drive my lease car under DOC cover.
I think what you are refering to is young drivers using their DOC cover to drive a higer group car owned by someone else ? This has largely been stopped by restricting DOC to older drivers. And IIRC Norwich Onion removed DOC for everyone (although they may have put it back, as nobody was that keen to follow).
Insurers do huff and puff about it being for emergency purposes only, but huff&puff is not legally binding.
Thanks for your thoughts guys.
My own insurance is with Direct Line - and the certificate refers to 'owners permission' rather than 'policy holders permission' (which I thought was the scenario).
The A-Class insurance has now been changed, but I'm going to take my own insurance to produce - don't really want to bring trouble to situation if it isn't needed. Worst case scenario, I'll have to take both A-Class certificates with the different reg plates as well as my own.
Accept it's a bit a of a f
k up and move on.
My own insurance is with Direct Line - and the certificate refers to 'owners permission' rather than 'policy holders permission' (which I thought was the scenario).
The A-Class insurance has now been changed, but I'm going to take my own insurance to produce - don't really want to bring trouble to situation if it isn't needed. Worst case scenario, I'll have to take both A-Class certificates with the different reg plates as well as my own.
Accept it's a bit a of a f
k up and move on. It would be best to take both, because it may be that if your WERE covered as a named driver, then your DOC cover would not be valid.
Whilst I think the "must be insured" clause is rare, it is quite common to have "there is no other insurance in force which covers the same claim". That is a direct quite from the DL policy booklet.
Although to be honest I doubt the busy person at the desk is going to be that rigourous.
Whilst I think the "must be insured" clause is rare, it is quite common to have "there is no other insurance in force which covers the same claim". That is a direct quite from the DL policy booklet.
Although to be honest I doubt the busy person at the desk is going to be that rigourous.
couple of years ago (fortunatly before ANPR was in force in a big way) i swapped my policy from a temporary car to my new one about 6 months into my policy - remember it vividly because despite moving to a smaller car, lower ins group etc, the admin fee meant i didnt get anything back. Anyway, come renewal time it transpired that tesco had failed to change the details over so i'd essentially been driving round without insurance for 6 months! eep..
i dealt with ver same situation at work, a woman put a cherished plate on and forgot to tell insurance company the new reg. A quick call to them confirmed they would have covered the vehicle with the wron plate on. After all it doesnt increase risk. The woman was given words of advice and sent on her way.
sensible resolution i think.
sensible resolution i think.
Noger said:
skwdenyer said:
Really? I was under the impression that this was precisely the sort of thing that various BiB were trying to crack down on - cars kept off road by their owners, but used by others on 3rd party OC.
Ah, but what about lease cars ? I don't "own" my car but I am perfectly entitled to drive it on the road using my insurance.Anyway, the Road Traffic Act is what counts.
"a person must not use a motor vehicle on a road unless there is in force in relation to the use of the vehicle by that person such a policy of insurance or such a security in respect of third party risks as complies with the requirements of this Part of this Act, and"
So under your DOC (if you have it) you are pefectly entitled to drive whatever car you like, as long as it is not owned by, or hired or loaned to, you. i.e. I can't drive my lease car under DOC cover.
I think what you are refering to is young drivers using their DOC cover to drive a higer group car owned by someone else ? This has largely been stopped by restricting DOC to older drivers. And IIRC Norwich Onion removed DOC for everyone (although they may have put it back, as nobody was that keen to follow).
Insurers do huff and puff about it being for emergency purposes only, but huff&puff is not legally binding.
How much it did, is arguable. The Porsche would still only be covered TPO - not damages, not theft.
I think it ended with a proposed blanket ban on the DOV extension to under 25s, but even here, as insurers are cold businesses, many started to offer it again to get business.
I certainly do not know of any company which demands the other car must be insured, but would not be surprised if this is written in many under 25 contracts.
jondude said:
Noger said:
skwdenyer said:
Really? I was under the impression that this was precisely the sort of thing that various BiB were trying to crack down on - cars kept off road by their owners, but used by others on 3rd party OC.
Ah, but what about lease cars ? I don't "own" my car but I am perfectly entitled to drive it on the road using my insurance.Anyway, the Road Traffic Act is what counts.
"a person must not use a motor vehicle on a road unless there is in force in relation to the use of the vehicle by that person such a policy of insurance or such a security in respect of third party risks as complies with the requirements of this Part of this Act, and"
So under your DOC (if you have it) you are pefectly entitled to drive whatever car you like, as long as it is not owned by, or hired or loaned to, you. i.e. I can't drive my lease car under DOC cover.
I think what you are refering to is young drivers using their DOC cover to drive a higer group car owned by someone else ? This has largely been stopped by restricting DOC to older drivers. And IIRC Norwich Onion removed DOC for everyone (although they may have put it back, as nobody was that keen to follow).
Insurers do huff and puff about it being for emergency purposes only, but huff&puff is not legally binding.
How much it did, is arguable. The Porsche would still only be covered TPO - not damages, not theft.
I think it ended with a proposed blanket ban on the DOV extension to under 25s, but even here, as insurers are cold businesses, many started to offer it again to get business.
I certainly do not know of any company which demands the other car must be insured, but would not be surprised if this is written in many under 25 contracts.
When it does you'll be covered driving the vehicle under DOC cover, but the registered keeper will be still be committing an offence if the vehicle itself is not on a policy.
Gassing Station | Speed, Plod & the Law | Top of Page | What's New | My Stuff


