4 year old Peugeot engine blown up
4 year old Peugeot engine blown up
Author
Discussion

supermono

Original Poster:

7,464 posts

279 months

Tuesday 15th April 2008
quotequote all
From a friend (honest!)
"I have a peugeot 307. Had it from new, Bought 4 years ago. 34000 miles on the clock.

Went out in on Friday and the engine blew up. Just out of warantee. Big hole in the engine, and main dealer are quoting 4k to fix.

I have raised a complaint with Peugeot customer services. I've always had it serviced at the main dealer and the last service was the 30k service in December."

Surely he's got a case: 1 owner, FPSH, 34k, 4 years old. We must assume he didn't select 2nd at 100mph.

What's the best approach?

SM

Martin_Hx

4,029 posts

229 months

Tuesday 15th April 2008
quotequote all
supermono said:
What's the best approach?

SM
Dont buy French ?

Sorry !

Not sure to be honest, if its out of warranty frown

streaky

19,311 posts

280 months

Tuesday 15th April 2008
quotequote all
Push for a generous "good will" settlement - Streaky

hondafanatic

4,969 posts

232 months

Tuesday 15th April 2008
quotequote all
streaky said:
Push for a generous "good will" settlement - Streaky
I agree, You might be able to get the labour free, have to pay for parts, or the other way round.

Might be worth mentioning that the question was asked on a popular website and we're all waiting with baited breath on the outcome?!??

p1esk

4,914 posts

227 months

Tuesday 15th April 2008
quotequote all
streaky said:
Push for a generous "good will" settlement - Streaky
I don't see what else can be done, as it's well out of warranty. It's extremely bad luck unless it was being seriously ill-treated.

The old 406 HDi has now done about 110,000 miles and it's going better than ever. Mind you, they do say they always go well just before a major blow-up. yikes

Best wishes all,
Dave.

supermono

Original Poster:

7,464 posts

279 months

Tuesday 15th April 2008
quotequote all
Martin_Hx said:
Dont buy French ?
Well I bought a new 207 1.6HDI 25k miles ago and I absolutely drive the total living hell out of the poor thing wherever I go and it's good as gold.

(By the way if you're reading this in my history having seen an advert for the car in classifieds, as a matter of fact I drive it like miss daisy everywhere and wash it twice daily.)

SM

Hooli

32,278 posts

231 months

Tuesday 15th April 2008
quotequote all
when i used to work at a volvo dealer if the customer complained enough volvo uk would settle as a percentage of under 100k. so you'd pay 34% of a new engine at 34k as it was expected to last 100k. id be surprised if other companies didnt use a similar scheme.

mph999

2,780 posts

251 months

Tuesday 15th April 2008
quotequote all
sales of goods act ....


paoloh

8,617 posts

235 months

Tuesday 15th April 2008
quotequote all
mph999 said:
sales of goods act ....
What planet are you living on??

andye30m3

3,501 posts

285 months

Tuesday 15th April 2008
quotequote all
was there not a guy who was trying to raise cash to crash his 307 into a cube and so he could leave it outside the main dealers.

I Would try for goodwill i think bmw have been know to do this. Or is there a case for the car not being fit for purpose which could be looked at through trading standards? a 34,000 mile car with full main dealer history shouldn't just blow up

Deva Link

26,934 posts

276 months

Tuesday 15th April 2008
quotequote all
paoloh said:
mph999 said:
sales of goods act ....
What planet are you living on??
Which one are you on? I think there would be every chance of success of a sub-5yr old car. Remember that warranties and guarantees are "in addition to your statutory rights".

An item should be "durable" - that means it should last a reasonable length of time. Who would say 4yrs/34K miles is reasonable?

The complication with cars (which generally doesn't arise with other consumer goods) is that if you're going to sue you have to go after whoever sold you the car, which is messy if you're not the original owner or the dealer has changed hands.

paoloh

8,617 posts

235 months

Tuesday 15th April 2008
quotequote all
Deva Link said:
paoloh said:
mph999 said:
sales of goods act ....
What planet are you living on??
Which one are you on? I think there would be every chance of success of a sub-5yr old car. Remember that warranties and guarantees are "in addition to your statutory rights".

An item should be "durable" - that means it should last a reasonable length of time. Who would say 4yrs/34K miles is reasonable?

The complication with cars (which generally doesn't arise with other consumer goods) is that if you're going to sue you have to go after whoever sold you the car, which is messy if you're not the original owner or the dealer has changed hands.
Have you not just argued my point?

Deva Link

26,934 posts

276 months

Tuesday 15th April 2008
quotequote all
paoloh said:
Deva Link said:
paoloh said:
mph999 said:
sales of goods act ....
What planet are you living on??
Which one are you on? I think there would be every chance of success of a sub-5yr old car. Remember that warranties and guarantees are "in addition to your statutory rights".

An item should be "durable" - that means it should last a reasonable length of time. Who would say 4yrs/34K miles is reasonable?

The complication with cars (which generally doesn't arise with other consumer goods) is that if you're going to sue you have to go after whoever sold you the car, which is messy if you're not the original owner or the dealer has changed hands.
Have you not just argued my point?
I don't think so, the OP says "his friend" has owned the car from new.

Chances are Peugeot will pay for this. Any significant shortfall then I would ask the supplying dealer to do the work and then ask them to repay. If they won't then I would issue a claim using moneyclaimonline.

There was a recent story on HonestJohn about Honda replacing a 5yr old engine on a CRV and it didn't even have a full Honda service history.

Edited by Deva Link on Tuesday 15th April 17:47

mph999

2,780 posts

251 months

Tuesday 15th April 2008
quotequote all
paoloh said:
mph999 said:
sales of goods act ....
What planet are you living on??
I rejected a "new" peugeot 206 due to an engine noise that you could hardly hear (bearing type sound" after nearly 9 months ...)

So I guess I must be on planet "SOGA is your friend" ... tongue out

(It was hard though and I had a few sleepless nights ...) All you need to do is show that it is unreasonable for a car of that make to have such a failure. Now in this case, age is less relevant I would say than the mileage which is low, so yep, I think you could get somewhere.

Martin

Edited by mph999 on Tuesday 15th April 20:43

Parrot of Doom

23,075 posts

265 months

Tuesday 15th April 2008
quotequote all
£4000 for a Pug engine? Who are they kidding?

Deva Link

26,934 posts

276 months

Wednesday 16th April 2008
quotequote all
Parrot of Doom said:
£4000 for a Pug engine? Who are they kidding?
I'm surprised it's not more than that - manufacturers often ship complete new engines. A significant part of that cost will be labour, and the less complete the engine is, the more labour charges there will be.

Munter

31,331 posts

272 months

Wednesday 16th April 2008
quotequote all
mph999 said:
paoloh said:
mph999 said:
sales of goods act ....
What planet are you living on??
I rejected a "new" peugeot 206 due to an engine noise that you could hardly hear (bearing type sound" after nearly 9 months ...)

So I guess I must be on planet "SOGA is your friend" ... tongue out

(It was hard though and I had a few sleepless nights ...) All you need to do is show that it is unreasonable for a car of that make to have such a failure. Now in this case, age is less relevant I would say than the mileage which is low, so yep, I think you could get somewhere.

Martin

Edited by mph999 on Tuesday 15th April 20:43
I'm with mph999. If it's got a service history showing it's been serviced. And the blowup is not due to no oil or the like. Then he should be able to get a % of the work free.

Probably on similar grounds as suggested above that Volvo used to do. E.g. he's had 34,000 miles out of an engine you would expect to do 100,000 miles. Therefore he might pay 34% of the costs to pay for a new engine with 0 miles .

Deva Link

26,934 posts

276 months

Wednesday 16th April 2008
quotequote all
Munter said:
Probably on similar grounds as suggested above that Volvo used to do. E.g. he's had 34,000 miles out of an engine you would expect to do 100,000 miles. Therefore he might pay 34% of the costs to pay for a new engine with 0 miles .
I certainly wouldn't be happy with that. I bet thew £4000 is ex-VAT so 34% still lands the owner with a bill that he would should never expect to get for £1600.

MentalSarcasm

6,083 posts

242 months

Wednesday 16th April 2008
quotequote all
We've got a 205 with 125k on the clock and other than the occasional dead battery it's been fine.

supermono

Original Poster:

7,464 posts

279 months

Wednesday 16th April 2008
quotequote all
MentalSarcasm said:
We've got a 205 with 125k on the clock and other than the occasional dead battery it's been fine.
Ahh -- I'll be sure and pass that information on to him. He'll be hugely relieved.

smile

SM