Need help regarding jumping traffic lights to let police by
Need help regarding jumping traffic lights to let police by
Author
Discussion

craigeastlondon

Original Poster:

3 posts

223 months

Tuesday 15th April 2008
quotequote all
hi peeps new user but looks a good forum from what ive been reading,

right tonight on the way home on the a4 i was in the 3rd lane but saw the police comming so moved over into 2nd lane but the other driver in the 3rd lane stayed where there in the 3rd lane and the traffic lights turned red so now theres no through gap for the police van, so i had to jump the lights to allow a gap for the van to get through i made a gap but the guy behind me made it tight so had to pull forward more, now the copper flapped his hands because i didnt move out of the way quick enough for him and the reason for that is
i was under the impression that jumping traffic lights is still a points offence even if there is an emergancy vehicle trying to get through as there was a traffic light jumping camera at the lights, now all i want to know is am i in the wrong and should of just moved out of the way as i wouldnt of been fined nor got any points or was the copper in the wrong, would rather know so i dont do it again
many thanks craig

flemke

23,515 posts

268 months

Tuesday 15th April 2008
quotequote all
craigeastlondon said:
hi peeps new user but looks a good forum from what ive been reading,

right tonight on the way home on the a4 i was in the 3rd lane but saw the police comming so moved over into 2nd lane but the other driver in the 3rd lane stayed where there in the 3rd lane and the traffic lights turned red so now theres no through gap for the police van, so i had to jump the lights to allow a gap for the van to get through i made a gap but the guy behind me made it tight so had to pull forward more, now the copper flapped his hands because i didnt move out of the way quick enough for him and the reason for that is
i was under the impression that jumping traffic lights is still a points offence even if there is an emergancy vehicle trying to get through as there was a traffic light jumping camera at the lights, now all i want to know is am i in the wrong and should of just moved out of the way as i wouldnt of been fined nor got any points or was the copper in the wrong, would rather know so i dont do it again
many thanks craig
More knowledgable persons than I will probably be along soon, but I believe that you are not only allowed but required to go through a red light when instructed to do so by a police officer. It seems that in this case you were so instructed: "the copper flapped his hands".
Had there been no indication from the officer, or if the vehicle had been an ambulance or fire vehicle, you would have been expected to hold station.

T_Pot

2,542 posts

228 months

Tuesday 15th April 2008
quotequote all
I have just been told the ONLY vehicle you HAVE to give way too, is ambulance?

of course, i give way where i can to all emergency, but my point being, if this is true, then would you have no argument against the points and fine ?

craigeastlondon

Original Poster:

3 posts

223 months

Tuesday 15th April 2008
quotequote all
thanks for the comments peeps, now dont get me wrong il move out of the way where possble but if its going to cost me / hit me with points then im sorry i will not move unless theres no camera as my licence is my job at the end of the day

Finlandia

7,818 posts

262 months

Tuesday 15th April 2008
quotequote all
This has been argued on before, and I believe that you should be able to (with the help of the emergency vehicle operators testimony) get away with it. Hopefully.

Mg6b

6,649 posts

294 months

Tuesday 15th April 2008
quotequote all
T_Pot said:
I have just been told the ONLY vehicle you HAVE to give way too, is ambulance?
By a man down the pub know doubt!

Fail to give way to 30 tons of Red DENNIS in a hurry is likely to see you with a considerable repair bill and probably at your own expense biggrin


sublimatica

3,211 posts

285 months

Tuesday 15th April 2008
quotequote all
Finlandia said:
This has been argued on before, and I believe that you should be able to (with the help of the emergency vehicle operators testimony) get away with it. Hopefully.
You'd better hope you get the registration number of the emergency vehicle as it speeds off. And hope you then find a pen & paper to write it down before you forget it. And hope that the emergency service 'customer care' department is willing to provide the name of the driver. And hope that the driver is willing to appear in court to testify for you that you moved through the red light on their clear instructions. And hope that the magistrates don't consider it an absolute offence.

Hmm. Or you could sit tight and wait for the lights to change.

Finlandia

7,818 posts

262 months

Tuesday 15th April 2008
quotequote all
sublimatica said:
Finlandia said:
This has been argued on before, and I believe that you should be able to (with the help of the emergency vehicle operators testimony) get away with it. Hopefully.
You'd better hope you get the registration number of the emergency vehicle as it speeds off. And hope you then find a pen & paper to write it down before you forget it. And hope that the emergency service 'customer care' department is willing to provide the name of the driver. And hope that the driver is willing to appear in court to testify for you that you moved through the red light on their clear instructions. And hope that the magistrates don't consider it an absolute offence.

Hmm. Or you could sit tight and wait for the lights to change.
Unfortunately that could be the scenario too, in the age of automated traffic surveillance and revenue hungry camera operators.

But, if you get the emergency vehicle number, or at least the time and place correct, then you should be ok'ish.

Holst

2,468 posts

252 months

Tuesday 15th April 2008
quotequote all
Funny this should come up again as I had this exact thing happen to me this week.

Approaching a roundabout from a single carrageway road on a red light.
An ambulance appears behind me with lights and sirens, obviously going at a decent pace (I guess they were on there way to a call as they were both in the front)
It wasnt possible for me to move out of the way before I reached the lights.

I stopped at the light and the ambulance was getting close, so I checked to see if the roundabout was clear but a mondeo was coming round.

The mondeo driver was paying attention and stopped on the roundabout, leaving it safe for me to pull out and leave space for the ambulance to pass me on the left. Excelent driving from mondeo man biggrin

If there was a red light camera I would have been left with an awquard choice.
I think I would have waited at the light and watched to see what the ambulance driver signaled. If he had waved me forward then I would have run the light, otherwise i would have waited and got out of the way as soon as it went green.

Edited by Holst on Tuesday 15th April 19:27

thinfourth2

32,414 posts

235 months

Tuesday 15th April 2008
quotequote all
to be legal you stay until given instructions to move

Real world ambulance or fire engine i will move out of the way if i get a fine so be it

Police car fk it i'm staying still if the law enforcement system wants us to obey every single law without question then i shall.

Jasandjules

72,690 posts

260 months

Tuesday 15th April 2008
quotequote all
I believe the law is "clear" - you do not move through a red light, unless directly ordered by a police officer. That means that an ambulance, fire engine etc.. cannot so order you - if you travel through, you can expect to be hit with points and a fine - write to your MP about this ridiculous state of affairs, I wrote to mine.

steelej

1,761 posts

238 months

Tuesday 15th April 2008
quotequote all
I'll take 3 points and a fine to potentially help someone to stay alive, it's rather selfish to do otherwise. If someone close to you died because someone didn't move out of the way at a red light how would you feel about it......

John.

Jasandjules

72,690 posts

260 months

Tuesday 15th April 2008
quotequote all
steelej said:
I'll take 3 points and a fine to potentially help someone to stay alive, it's rather selfish to do otherwise. If someone close to you died because someone didn't move out of the way at a red light how would you feel about it......

John.
So would I, and I'd be in the press moaning about it too... biggrin

bigdods

7,175 posts

258 months

Tuesday 15th April 2008
quotequote all
Jasandjules said:
I believe the law is "clear" - you do not move through a red light, unless directly ordered by a police officer. That means that an ambulance, fire engine etc.. cannot so order you - if you travel through, you can expect to be hit with points and a fine - write to your MP about this ridiculous state of affairs, I wrote to mine.
Sums it up for me. Happened to me a few times. Now if its a junction I know well, so Im sure there are no cameras and its safe to do so I will make some space. Otherwise its stay put Im afraid. My licence is too important to me for my work. Very sad state of affairs. And to be honest it would take more then a police officer waving his hands at me as a direct order. I'd expect to seem him point at me, the light then motion me forwards or to the side.

Unfortunately the judgement call isnt yours to make any more.

Same applies if you were (for example) in a single lane roadworks with blues and twos behind you. You cannot ignore the law even though you might want to speed up to help the emergency services along.

ETA: I just had a thought. If you dont jump the light maybe they can do you for obstruction of an officer (I think thats the offence). So damned if you do and damned if you dont.

Edited by bigdods on Tuesday 15th April 21:31

HRG

72,863 posts

270 months

Tuesday 15th April 2008
quotequote all
Nice to see all the cameras have influenced peoples behavior.....

Medic-one

3,143 posts

234 months

Tuesday 15th April 2008
quotequote all

Try reading these discussions, this item is widely discused in there :

http://www.pistonheads.com/gassing/topic.asp?h=0&a...

http://www.pistonheads.com/gassing/topic.asp?h=0&a...

sublimatica said:
You'd better hope you get the registration number of the emergency vehicle as it speeds off. And hope you then find a pen & paper to write it down before you forget it. And hope that the emergency service 'customer care' department is willing to provide the name of the driver.
Instead of trying to remember the reg number, write down the vehicle ID number, almost every emergency vehicle has a callsign on the sides, back and roof so just write that down.

In our cases it's a 3 digit number (048, 049, 363 etc).

And you won't need name of the driver, and he won't need to testify in court, just tell them you moved over for ambulance 048, they will look at their system/paperwork (all vehicle's are tracked, and all times/routes/dates of any job we run on are logged) and will be able to confirm that particular vehicle drove there at that time.

"Or you could sit tight and wait for the lights to change"

Or you could get home 15 minutes later to found that that ambulance you won't let through is now at your house and you find they didn't make it in time to save your wife/husbend/kid...

Jasandjules said:
I believe the law is "clear" - you do not move through a red light, unless directly ordered by a police officer. That means that an ambulance, fire engine etc.. cannot so order you - if you travel through, you can expect to be hit with points and a fine - write to your MP about this ridiculous state of affairs, I wrote to mine.
You are right we cannot order anyone to move through a red light, but we don't have those lights and sirens flashing for nothing, and it might just be someone in your family we're trying to get to.

And if you do flashed it's just a case of writing a letter and explaining, and you won't have to worry about points/fine.

MKH9130

4,121 posts

239 months

Tuesday 15th April 2008
quotequote all
Although not applicable in this case maybe, if I am waiting at a set of lights and am at the front of the queue, I will always leave a car length in front of me before the white line - this allows room to manoeuvre to let an emergency vehicle past without setting off the red-light scameras.

streaky

19,311 posts

280 months

Tuesday 15th April 2008
quotequote all
The drivers of emergency vehicles will manoeuver around stationary vehicles, it's part of their training. It is easier to plot a route when other vehicles are stationary. When they move unpredictably, problems can arise.

There will always be the emotive: "What if it's your house that's burning?" question. That's just another "Think of the children" cri de coeur. I would not risk triggering a RLC to let an emergency vehicle pass ... but I would try to assist its passage otherwise.

It's bad behaviour for the driver of an emergency vehicle to 'lean on the horn' to try to force a passage. When it is evident they're stuck, they'll turn off the 'twos'. Last week I saw a Met car become bogged down in traffic on a shout. The driver turned off the 'twos', but left the 'blues' spinning and waited patiently until he could proceed. Then he turned them on again and went through the traffic signals ahead on red, on the wrong side, but with restraint.

Streaky

Beyond Rational

3,544 posts

246 months

Tuesday 15th April 2008
quotequote all
I'm confused, was the second lane clear until you moved into it?

WeirdNeville

6,053 posts

246 months

Tuesday 15th April 2008
quotequote all
I would not expect people to drive through red lights for me. That's my job, not theirs. I try and plan my approach to a junction so that no-one has to move through a red to let me through, although this is not always possible.

I'd break it down like this:
Heavy stationary traffic held at a busy jusntion: I'll turn my sirens and possibly even lights off so as not to encourage people to jump the lights. I'll move as the lights change and there is space to do so.

Light traffic held at lights: More often than not space to proceed on the offside without anyone at the lights being inconvenienced

Basically I make my plans on the vehicles remaining where they are. If they choose to move due to my presence then so be it, and I will take advantage of any space they offer me, but if they don't move then that is their perogative, and unless another bomb has gone off I won't be getting in a flap about it.