shared passageways and the law..
shared passageways and the law..
Author
Discussion

maddog-uk

Original Poster:

2,392 posts

277 months

Wednesday 16th April 2008
quotequote all
Dont suppose anyone is a lawyer and can offer some advice. We have a shared passageway that lies between our boundary and the neighbours house. The passageway runs along all the neighbours gardens and its an old one. The house changed hands last year and a developer has been converting it to two flats recently without planning permission as he has been turned down twice. He has submitted again. My issue is he is filled the shared passageway with building materials. He dug up the path and put sharp sand mix down minus the concrete which is now blowing everywhere and he has now gone and installed all the houses utility meters in the shared passageway reducing its width. I asked the council who said because its private land which we all own (but its not on our deeds or land ownership forms) we have to maintain it and its a private matter. I just want the developer to put it back as it was and remove his obstructions of building rubble and gas and electricity meters. Can I challenge him legally in someway?

At the same time with the services the clectricity meters and the gas meters have exposed pipework running up to them, not sure of the legalities of that either.

Here is a photo if it helps.



We own the garage on the right. Our boundary is square with our other neighbours fence (we are on a corner). We built 2 feet inside our boundary.

Edited by maddog-uk on Wednesday 16th April 19:00

bimsb6

8,809 posts

252 months

Wednesday 16th April 2008
quotequote all
put a fence down your boundary .

maddog-uk

Original Poster:

2,392 posts

277 months

Wednesday 16th April 2008
quotequote all
I figured that, but to be honest I dont want to. Happy to build a mini wall to stop them using my vehicle crossing, but I just want the rubbish removed and the path put back and being a new dad I am not to keen on gas pipes and electricity cables being so easily exposed.

rs1952

5,247 posts

290 months

Wednesday 16th April 2008
quotequote all
You say the land doesn’t appear on your deeds, so I assume it’s not yours.

However, you should have a right of access over the land, and this should appear as a clause in your conveyance. The clause might include you being required to make a contribution towards repair, or it may not. If you have a right of way on foot then, from the photograph, it appears that you still have one – the passageway has not been blocked.

If there is no clause in your conveyance giving you a right of access, then legally you don’t have one, but you may be able to claim a right of way through established use. This will be time consuming and expensive, and might lead to friction with your neighbour, which would have to be declared in a future sale.

Your best options are a) have a friendly word with the bloke asking him to move his stuff or b) put up with it

randlemarcus

13,646 posts

262 months

Wednesday 16th April 2008
quotequote all
From the looks of the photo, you're well within the bounds of common sense to ask for the path to be made good, to its previous state. I'd suggest you're a bit bu99ered about the gas and electricity meters though - the path isnt wide enough for a vehicle, they are weather sealed units, and its within the bounds of reason that you teach your children not to poke their fingers into plugs, and not to rip other peoples property apart just to see what happens when you lick the wires.

maddog-uk

Original Poster:

2,392 posts

277 months

Wednesday 16th April 2008
quotequote all
thanks for the advice. I will check the deeds.

Chrisgr31

14,298 posts

286 months

Wednesday 16th April 2008
quotequote all
I'd suggest that life is too short to worry about his bag of sand, assuming it goes when the work is completed, however you can ask for the path to be reinstated when the works are complete. Lifes too short to worry about the meter boxes.

However if he has not got planning consent then surely you should be speaking to the enforcement department at your local aithority?

maddog-uk

Original Poster:

2,392 posts

277 months

Wednesday 16th April 2008
quotequote all
ok the text of the deeds is as follows:

"the land has the benefit of a right of way on foot over the passage leading from the back into the road."

it also goes onto to list the resitrictive covenants. one of which says the following "No building material shall be deposited or mixed on any path or roadway and no obstruction shall be placed thereon and int he event of any such obstruction being so placed the vendor his heirs or assigns and his or there agents or any owner of any plot on the estate may remove same without notice and without being responsible for the safe keeping thereof or for any damage occassioned thereto"

There is also another clause which states "no building planned arranged or adapted as flats shall at any time hereafter be erected on any plot and no building thereon shall be used as flats."


So my questions to any one who understands the law is how enforceable ar these schedule of restrictive covenants. Can we as owners of propertys turn around and force no new flat converions because of this? And can i remove his building materials?

The photo is the clearest the passageway has been for 6 months (see below)


To give you all the details. The house was sold last september. Planning permission was applied for to convert it to two flats. It was turned down on the grounds that there is insufficient parking in the area and that the plans showed a substandard thought for the living space. The developer had started converting the flats but blamed the builder, even though thats himself. He reapplied for planning permission and was turned down again. He has continued to build. He was served with an enforcement notice and so he has reapplied. In the meantime he has worked outside of the normal hours, burnt toxic waste in the garden, blocked my garage and drive most of the time lifted the pavement himself and started to lay an illegal vehicle crossing. He built an extension that blocked our light from our garden and to be honest is being a general pain.




Edited by maddog-uk on Wednesday 16th April 23:34

rs1952

5,247 posts

290 months

Thursday 17th April 2008
quotequote all
There is a very big difference between what is possible in law and the practicalities of individual situations. To look at your case in more detail, and in Devils Advocate mode:-

maddog-uk said:
ok the text of the deeds is as follows:

"the land has the benefit of a right of way on foot over the passage leading from the back into the road."
You have still got a right of access on foot – see my previous post

maddog-uk said:
it also goes onto to list the restrictive covenants. one of which says the following "No building material shall be deposited or mixed on any path or roadway and no obstruction shall be placed thereon and in the event of any such obstruction being so placed the vendor his heirs or assigns and his or there agents or any owner of any plot on the estate may remove same without notice and without being responsible for the safe keeping thereof or for any damage occasioned thereto"
From what you say, he is clearly in breach of this covenant. However, to enforce the terms of it, you would have to take a civil action against him, and you would need (I imagine, unless you could put the case together yourself) to employ a solicitor – if you get one for less than £150 an hour, please let me know his name and address!

Even if you did employ one, and even if the matter got to court, his counter-claim would probably be on the lines of “Its only a temporary arrangement, your Honour, and I have every intention of removing it when the work is finished – after all, Sir, you will notice from the photos supplied by the plaintiff that the access is not blocked …”

Under the terms of your conveyance, you could of course move it yourself - however, if he then claims you've nicked it, Plod would be likely to do you for theft - they would be unlikely to be interested in the terms in your conveyance....


maddog-uk said:
There is also another clause which states "no building planned arranged or adapted as flats shall at any time hereafter be erected on any plot and no building thereon shall be used as flats."
This is another matter entirely, and one for your local council to decide upon. This clause, presumably, is in your deeds – it may not appear in his. If it does, that is really probably why he has been refused planning permission (and, as an aside, he would never be able to sell the flats if such a clause appeared in his deeds, because any potential purchaser’s solicitors should spot it immediately)


maddog-uk said:
So my questions to any one who understands the law is how enforceable are these schedule of restrictive covenants.
As you will see from the above – all possible in theory, but expensive in practice



maddog-uk said:
Can we as owners of propertys turn around and force no new flat converions because of this? And can i remove his building materials?
If you want to start a neighbour dispute, that will have to be declared when you sell the house, then yes. However, I would suggest you don’t bother!

maddog-uk

Original Poster:

2,392 posts

277 months

Thursday 17th April 2008
quotequote all
All the houses were built between 1904 and 1909 and have the same clauses in there deeds. But others have been convereted so i guess precedence has been set.

Not interested in starting a neighbour war, but he is a developer he doesnt live here he lives 3 miles away and its been going on since september 2007 which I think is an unreasonable time for it to be carrying on.

But thanks, thats why forums exist to canvass opinions.

Kevin 996C4

13,894 posts

311 months

Thursday 17th April 2008
quotequote all
My first question is which of you has right of access, and which of you owns the land? From your photo it appears the fence line (edge of property) runs from the end of his property in line with the edge of his house? You need to look at the map attached to the deeds to see who owns the land.

maddog-uk

Original Poster:

2,392 posts

277 months

Thursday 17th April 2008
quotequote all
I checked the deeds i own about 2ft of the passageway from my garage out to the fenceline. But to be honest my main issue is the fact he dug them thing up and has left it in a state and mucked the road and broken the pavement up by repeatedly driving over my vehicle crossing.