PNC'ing the Victim
Discussion
Is this standard procedure?
Cut a long tedious story short.
Mate splits up with GF, whilst he's out, she empties flat and takes his car.
He reports car stolen, Police arrive. GF tells them, he owes her money, Police say, it's a civil matter, you'll have to take her to court to get your car back ( that also makes no sense to me )
Then start reeling off his past after PNC'ing him.
Cut a long tedious story short.
Mate splits up with GF, whilst he's out, she empties flat and takes his car.
He reports car stolen, Police arrive. GF tells them, he owes her money, Police say, it's a civil matter, you'll have to take her to court to get your car back ( that also makes no sense to me )
Then start reeling off his past after PNC'ing him.
paoloh said:
Is this standard procedure?
I PNC almost anyone I encounter at a job who is in some way involved for the simple reasons that it helps confirm identity, warn me about certain individuals and you never know, they may be wanted. Only a few weeks ago stopped a shed of a vehicle for various reasons. Passenger turned out to be wanted for TWOC and failing to appear in court for an assault and had been wanted for 3 years. He knew he was wanted and had evaded capture for that long.If a matter goes to court everybody will be checked on PNC (and probably local intelligence systems). Better that the crown know about anything the defence may try and use to discredit the victims and witnesses.
AndyRw said:
paoloh said:
Is this standard procedure?
I PNC almost anyone I encounter at a job who is in some way involved for the simple reasons that it helps confirm identity, warn me about certain individuals and you never know, they may be wanted. Only a few weeks ago stopped a shed of a vehicle for various reasons. Passenger turned out to be wanted for TWOC and failing to appear in court for an assault and had been wanted for 3 years. He knew he was wanted and had evaded capture for that long.If a matter goes to court everybody will be checked on PNC (and probably local intelligence systems). Better that the crown know about anything the defence may try and use to discredit the victims and witnesses.
What is your take on the civil matter?
For court cases the aggrieved and all witnesses are PNC'd as a matter of course. All gets noted on the witness list (MG9 form) so that if people have a shady past that might undermine their evidence CPS are aware.
I don't PNC aggrieved parties as a matter of course, but will generally PNC anyone I have cause to stop or search - it's standard practice round my way (and presumably elsewhere)
I don't PNC aggrieved parties as a matter of course, but will generally PNC anyone I have cause to stop or search - it's standard practice round my way (and presumably elsewhere)
Yep, when seeking advice from the CPS (with regards to charging an offender) they will often ask us for the victims pre-cons.
for example, an assault, I PNC the I/P and there's no other witnesses, CPS NFA the offender on the fact that the I/P's previous convictions will have an effect on getting the offender found guilty.
Load of cr&p as far as I'm concerned, but thats the wonderfull CPS for you.
for example, an assault, I PNC the I/P and there's no other witnesses, CPS NFA the offender on the fact that the I/P's previous convictions will have an effect on getting the offender found guilty.
Load of cr&p as far as I'm concerned, but thats the wonderfull CPS for you.
paoloh said:
Thanks Andy, info much appreciated.
What is your take on the civil matter?
There'd be lots of questions to be asked to make a decision but I'll be honest that my approach to property disputes following breakups is often that we're starting at a civil dispute. If there's anything obviously criminal we'll take it from there but that can be a minefield. The problem is that for a long relationship it is common that agreements are made that one person buys one thing, the other something else and they both use it as if it is their own. Sorting out 'ownership' is then a messy business - that's why divorce lawyers earn so much (allegedly). Is she claiming the money owed relates to the car? - if so then I would probably say it was a civil dispute. If it relates to something else, but all of the property is a tangled web of ownership, that would probably still be a civil dispute. I may be inclined to have a quiet word with her telling her to give the car back and take legal advice about recovering the money.What is your take on the civil matter?
The criminal offence (if any) would probably be Taking Without Owner's Consent (TWOC) - S12 Theft Act 1968. She's not depriving him of it permanently as she's saying she'll give it back at some point. The questions would be can she claim ownership (different to being registered keeper), can she claim a lawful authority to take it - possible, would she have authority to keep it as a surety against being paid the money owed? - or can she claim that she believed the owner would have consented in the circumstances - a brief's first questions to her may well have been 'Did he let you use it without asking while you were in a relationship and did you believe he would have let you borrow it to move all your things out?'. Going down the criminal lines the Police would seize the vehicle. If she turned it into a court case claiming a statutory defence the car might be kept by the Police pending the result - meaning your mate is deprived of his car for quite a while - though they may give it to him in exchange for him signing a form promising to bring it to court if required. If I thought it was sufficient to arrest on suspicion of TWOC I'd probably start with the quiet word telling her she's liable to be arrested if the car isn't returned now, in the hope that things can be resolved a little more amicably without criminalising anyone. I'd imagine your mate simply wanted his car back too.
With regards to the PNC check:
This can be fraught if there is no reason for it other than idle curiosity. If the officers had resulted it as no cause for police action then I would suggest that there is no right for them to check afterwards. It is, though, common practice.
The police do not have carte blanche access to the PNC records. They must have a valid reason for a check. There are non exclusive codes that give guidelines. When I was in charge of a control room I did a dip check of PNC checks completed by my staff at the request of officers and police staff and found that >10% broke the rules (and, unbelievably, that >25% were requested by people who not only had access to the PNC computer, but had had the course as well. They were just idle.) Being the OIC I would have been liable on discipline for the >10% lot. I was taken to task by one of the divisional superintendents and I said that if he gave me chapter and verse so that responsibility went to him, I'd be happy to oblige. I am, of course, still waiting on the post. Mind you, even so, I'd still be to blame.
In this specific circumstance I would have been happy for the officer to complete a check at the scene although I'd expect a 'local' check (forces have their own criminal information system, a sort of collator's file) to have been completed first. If the chap has considerable form, I'd expect the lads to know of it if they were local units.
Correction: I've just reread the post checking for speling mitsakes and I must admit that >25% of checks are due to idleness is not unbelievable but par for the course.
This can be fraught if there is no reason for it other than idle curiosity. If the officers had resulted it as no cause for police action then I would suggest that there is no right for them to check afterwards. It is, though, common practice.
The police do not have carte blanche access to the PNC records. They must have a valid reason for a check. There are non exclusive codes that give guidelines. When I was in charge of a control room I did a dip check of PNC checks completed by my staff at the request of officers and police staff and found that >10% broke the rules (and, unbelievably, that >25% were requested by people who not only had access to the PNC computer, but had had the course as well. They were just idle.) Being the OIC I would have been liable on discipline for the >10% lot. I was taken to task by one of the divisional superintendents and I said that if he gave me chapter and verse so that responsibility went to him, I'd be happy to oblige. I am, of course, still waiting on the post. Mind you, even so, I'd still be to blame.
In this specific circumstance I would have been happy for the officer to complete a check at the scene although I'd expect a 'local' check (forces have their own criminal information system, a sort of collator's file) to have been completed first. If the chap has considerable form, I'd expect the lads to know of it if they were local units.
Correction: I've just reread the post checking for speling mitsakes and I must admit that >25% of checks are due to idleness is not unbelievable but par for the course.
Bibs_LEF said:
Greendubber said:
for example, an assault, I PNC the I/P and there's no other witnesses, CPS NFA the offender on the fact that the I/P's previous convictions will have an effect on getting the offender found guilty.
:-/Once more?
CPS for you, Criminal Protection Service!.
Gassing Station | Speed, Plod & the Law | Top of Page | What's New | My Stuff


