Red light cameras (NO not that kind!)
Red light cameras (NO not that kind!)
Author
Discussion

LoudPedal

Original Poster:

72 posts

231 months

Saturday 19th April 2008
quotequote all
I've seen plenty of complaining about speed cameras in the UK on this forum, just thought I'd share the similar plague over here (in the US), the red light camera, mounted at intersections to catch offenders. They're highlighted in this article which shows the striking similarities in both policies and especially what they seem to be REALLY used for...

http://arstechnica.com/news.ars/post/20080413-red-...

Edited by LoudPedal on Saturday 19th April 07:16

rewc

2,187 posts

264 months

Saturday 19th April 2008
quotequote all
I am trying to get my head around " camera-enforced intersections were timed for just 3.15 seconds, or 0.35 seconds less than the Texas Department of Transportation minimum. In this case, a third of a second may make a substantial difference in revenue—theNewspaper reports that most (80 percent) red-light tickets are issued less than one second after the light has turned to red".

Obviously a change so that enforecement doesn't start to 1 second after the red would be a significant drop in revenue.

Has there ever been any tests at "troublesome" sites in the UK where increasing the amber phase timing has reduced the offending rate?

tvrgit

8,490 posts

283 months

Saturday 19th April 2008
quotequote all
rewc - There was another thread on this earlier in the week.

The 3 second amber and 2 second red/amber are fixed in the UK - local authorities can't change them. Those times were set out years ago (so long ago I can't find it now!) in a Statutoory Instrument by Parliament. The controllers must have those timings fixed, to be type-approved for use on UK roads.

The change times between one traffic stream stopping and another one going (the intergreen), are varied by introducing an all-red period if required, not by changing the duration of the ambers. The intergreen can vary from 4 seconds (where the red/amber and amber for the other traffic overlap by 1 second) up to whatever you need depending on the size of the junction and the speed of traffic on the approaches.

flemke

23,515 posts

268 months

Saturday 19th April 2008
quotequote all
The article is incomplete.
Several years ago this racket was exposed. The main supplier of this equipment (Rockwell, IIRC) would approach a municipality with a proposal: "We'd like to install red-light cameras for you FOC, and then we'll split with your municipality any revenue, 50/50."
After the LA would agree to that, the contractor would go on, "And perhaps you'd like to take another look at your light phases. There's nothing sacred about the current length of the yellow phase, is there?"
This abuse became so rampant that one US state banned all red-light cameras.

tvrgit

8,490 posts

283 months

Saturday 19th April 2008
quotequote all
Flemke you're quite right. The main difference here in the UK is that the answer to the question "There's nothing sacred about the current length of the yellow phase, is there?" is "Well as a matter of fact, there is..."