Burglary statistics . . what do they say?
Burglary statistics . . what do they say?
Author
Discussion

mark69sheer

Original Poster:

3,906 posts

233 months

Saturday 19th April 2008
quotequote all
We have Home office Statistics telling us that Burglaries have halfed since 1997.

However what do these statistics really tell us. I hear tales of burglaries on a dialy basis. I read of cars stolen when the keys are removed from homes. I know people personally who have been burgled recently.
What has caused the apparent halving in burglary statistics since 1997.

Is it because we have had a period of economic growth?
Will burglaries increase again now we are in a period of economic slowing?
Do people not bother reporting burglaries?
Have UPVC windows made burglary harder?
Has DNA profiling discouraged burglars?
Is burglary not a good way to earn money crimewise?
Certainly there are areas I work in where all houses are alarmed and Ironically in those areas some people can't afford an alarm.
What is the rate of burglaries today?
Are they on the increase again due to immigrants?
Are they on the increase again and will show up in the next statistics at the end of the year?

Do you know anyone who has been burgled.

My parents were five times. I had my office burgled five times and property stolen from the garden...

Are we realy as safe as they suggest?

vonhosen

40,597 posts

248 months

Saturday 19th April 2008
quotequote all
I've never been burgled & neither have any of my extended family.

mark69sheer

Original Poster:

3,906 posts

233 months

Saturday 19th April 2008
quotequote all
vonhosen said:
I've never been burgled & neither have any of my extended family.
Is that because you are alarmed or live in good areas?





Derek Smith

50,032 posts

279 months

Saturday 19th April 2008
quotequote all
mark69sheer said:
We have Home office Statistics telling us that Burglaries have halfed since 1997.

However what do these statistics really tell us. I hear tales of burglaries on a dialy basis. I read of cars stolen when the keys are removed from homes. I know people personally who have been burgled recently.
What has caused the apparent halving in burglary statistics since 1997.

Is it because we have had a period of economic growth?
The general rule is that it is greed, not need, that fuels crime.

mark69sheer said:
Will burglaries increase again now we are in a period of economic slowing?
Crime increase with the GDP. More property, more temptation, more jealousy, more greed.

mark69sheer said:
Do people not bother reporting burglaries?
No dependable stats but if a householder is insured then most insurance companies demand a crime number.

mark69sheer said:
Have UPVC windows made burglary harder?
Double glazing units once removed make it much less dangerous for entry. And unless you go upmarket, they are easy, so easy, to remove.

mark69sheer said:
Has DNA profiling discouraged burglars?
I have no idea but one of the fundamentals in policing is that the risk of getting caught is the only dependable deterrant.

mark69sheer said:
Is burglary not a good way to earn money crimewise?
As compared to what?

mark69sheer said:
What is the rate of burglaries today?
No one knows. One cannot depend on any stats that are produced by those whose efficiency is judged by them.

mark69sheer said:
Are they on the increase again due to immigrants?
You'll have to ask the Daily Mail as they seem to have a monopoly on such stats. Mind you, they are to an extent judged by them as well. If it does not come up with its weekly diet of horror from foreigners then their sales would drop. Remember that stats produced by police, whilst being pure fantasy, are still more reliable than the Daily Mail.

mark69sheer said:
Are we realy as safe as they suggest?
The risk from crime is disproportionate to fear.

What is true is that those who are not insured often do not bother to report burglaries. Some premiums are way out of the reach of council estate residents but New Labour is not that particularly bothered by them. From their point of view, a crime not reported is a crime solved.

I was brought up in the east end of London in an annonymous terraced street with a bomb crater that remained in situ until 1974. No family ever bothered to report crime. It was just not done. If you knew who it was, you got it back. If you didn't you made your place more secure. There was little crime but then there was little property. One chap, a burly lighterman, had items stolen from his car by, he assumed, one of a group of slobs from a nearby street. The chap took out the widows of a car belonging to one of the group and was never bothered again. It didn't matter to him if he had got the right person or even group. He just sent out a signal so making his car much more secure.

mark69sheer

Original Poster:

3,906 posts

233 months

Saturday 19th April 2008
quotequote all
Thanks Derek.

I think the only certainty is that some areas are burgled more than others.
I went to see some poor chap the other day who wanted an alarm fitting but couldn't afford it.
The area was certainly policed. I saw more police there than I have seen for a while.
I think I shall approach the local authorities to see if a deal can be struck to provide them for elderly or disabled residents.

vonhosen

40,597 posts

248 months

Saturday 19th April 2008
quotequote all
mark69sheer said:
vonhosen said:
I've never been burgled & neither have any of my extended family.
Is that because you are alarmed or live in good areas?
I'm the only one alarmed.
Good area laugh

JustinP1

13,364 posts

261 months

Saturday 19th April 2008
quotequote all
vonhosen said:
I've never been burgled & neither have any of my extended family.
Is that because you live in the police station?

...and I can guess who your 'extended family' are...!



(Only joking Von, incidentally I almost bought a house 30 feet from a police station. They said it made no difference to their insurance quote!)

Mg6b

6,649 posts

294 months

Saturday 19th April 2008
quotequote all
Most burglaries are committed by opportunists. If householders think about reducing the opportunity for opportunists, they will reduce the probablility of being burgled.

Simple things like making sure gates are properly locked to prevent access to the rear, cutting away hedges that mask the front areas to houses whereby burglars can work uninterrupted by anyone wlaking past or living close by who might see them, Reducing access opportunity to the rear of premises, locking windows when going out for an hour or two etc etc,

If you are subject of a planned burglary which are not common, then whatever security you employ will probably be looked at by the perpetrators and they will inevitably find a way to get around it if they are really intent on stealing whatever is attractive to them in your property. The harder it is for them, the more likely they are going to go somewhere else. Most burglars are lazy and don't like having to make things difficult for themselves to achieve their aim.


Edited by Mg6b on Saturday 19th April 13:20

Jasandjules

72,689 posts

260 months

Saturday 19th April 2008
quotequote all
JustinP1 said:
Is that because you live in the police station?
I doubt it, there was a thing in the paper the other day about thefts from police stations.... No idea how accurate it was, but it would have boosted the burglary stats!!

I know a couple of people who have burgled, I've not had my house done, but we did have a garage done. I know a couple of other people who have had their garages done, none of them reported it, and in future I won't bother either. I've also had a few cars broken into, as have my parents, my sister, and a few friends.. Can you guess how many times we bothered to report it?

Chrispy Porker

17,763 posts

259 months

Saturday 19th April 2008
quotequote all
I had a tax disc stolen from a Land Rover.
I went to my local station to report it, and watched the station clerk record it in the lost property book.

eldar

25,362 posts

227 months

Saturday 19th April 2008
quotequote all
Depends where you live, I guess. I know of one break (house, car, garden, etc.) in in the last 6 years locally (and that was a pissed local, solved without the involvement of plod)

Coincidentally we don't have either a drug problem, or easy main road access. Nice and peaceful.

ypauly

15,137 posts

231 months

Saturday 19th April 2008
quotequote all
i would suggest that the price of electrical items
like dvd players being so cheap has had the biggest effect on the figures
so it just aint worth the hassle

I too am not a burglar nor have i ever burgled

streaky

19,311 posts

280 months

Saturday 19th April 2008
quotequote all
Chrispy Porker said:
I had a tax disc stolen from a Land Rover.
I went to my local station to report it, and watched the station clerk record it in the lost property book.
Apparently, some (many?) burglaries are being recorded as "criminal damage" ... it makes the stats look better - Streaky

vonhosen

40,597 posts

248 months

Saturday 19th April 2008
quotequote all
streaky said:
Chrispy Porker said:
I had a tax disc stolen from a Land Rover.
I went to my local station to report it, and watched the station clerk record it in the lost property book.
Apparently, some (many?) burglaries are being recorded as "criminal damage" ... it makes the stats look better - Streaky
Then you'd expect criminal damage to go up.

Since 1995 domestic burglary is down 59% & vandalism down 11%

vonhosen

40,597 posts

248 months

Saturday 19th April 2008
quotequote all
Quinny said:
vonhosen said:
Since 1995 domestic burglary is down 59% & vandalism down 11%
And talking bks is up 100%roflrofl




Come on Von, do you really believe those statistics??

I certainly don't
Well can we disprove them ?

I know I certainly report far far less burglary & vandalism, but I know that's not a reliable indicator at all smile

streaky

19,311 posts

280 months

Sunday 20th April 2008
quotequote all
Can we please refer to reported offences. Some (many?) people are so disenchanted with the lack of apparent response from the police that the only reason for reporting an offence of burglary or 'criminal damage' is to get a CRN for submission to their insurers. If the value lost is less that the uninsured loss portion of the policy or if a claim will hike their premium, it's cheaper not to report and claim. Many thefts (of personal items) from workplaces are not reported as the lose is not covered by insurance and the company doesn't want the police tramping around (bad for business!). "Shrinkage" in the retail trade is now largely a 'cost of doing business' and not reported ... shop-lifting is largely ignored by the police anyway, so shop-keepers don't report. I'm sure there are many other instances of crimes unreported "because no-one wants to know; no-one cares; and no-one does anything".

Sorry, von et al, 'you' - that is the police and the government - have brought about this state of affairs by focusing on target-setting and meeting, exacerbated by a concommitant overload of paperwork leading to a 'tick-box' approach to much crime ... especially that which is likely to affect J Public most often.

Streaky

mark69sheer

Original Poster:

3,906 posts

233 months

Sunday 20th April 2008
quotequote all
There certainly is an element of why bother reporting although we always reported the contimual crime we suffered at our factory based between Leeds and Bradford to the local nick because to fail to do so would have given them the impression that crime didn't exist and they may have lost local resources and budgeting.

AndyRw

740 posts

240 months

Sunday 20th April 2008
quotequote all
streaky said:
Some (many?) people are so disenchanted with the lack of apparent response from the police that the only reason for reporting an offence of burglary or 'criminal damage' is to get a CRN for submission to their insurers.
I could understand people not bothering reporting if the response to a burglary really is only a crime number. I can only speak for where I work, but burglary of both sorts (dwelling and other) gets a 'response within 1 hour' grading for a response officer to attend. If the 'target' (yes, another) is missed, a dwelling burglary is upgraded to emergency response - though no-one will go on blue lights as it isn't proportionate. Burglary in progress (either sort) automatically gets dog units and the force helicopter (if not already tasked) as well as virtually everybody else going.

In any case, a PC will attend and take a statement. A Scenes Of Crime Officer will attend (for dwelling tasked immediately - often even before the PC is asked to go). And if there is one available a DC or DS will attend (nights its unlikely as there's only one for the region). A dwelling burglary is investigated by CID after the initial report from uniform.

That our response is as is - which I think is pretty good and what I would hope for as a homeowner - makes me wonder at other forces where people report no interest. In response to the recording of crime it is worth considering the British Crime Survey on top of Police statistics.

British Crime Survey 2006/7 said:
Since 1995 the number of domestic burglaries estimated by the BCS has fallen by 59 per cent from 1,770,000 to 726,000 in the 2006/07 BCS
...
The 2006/07 BCS estimated that 66 per cent of domestic burglaries were reported to the police, and that burglaries with loss were the type of burglary most likely to be reported (81%)
While this shows people don't report them all it also supports the Police statistics that burglary has fallen, using a new dataset (not just a rehash of the Police stats). I'm not defending the Police statistics as reliable - I entirely agree that statistics can be manipulated by everybody to show exactly what you want them to show - just that there are other sources supporting the suggestion it has fallen.

I also understand shops not reporting all shoplifting. We hardly ignore it though - there is a realistic approach from both shopkeepers and the Police whereby the initial report is assessed for any lines of enquiry to follow by phone. If there are any (witnesses with a description, CCTV, etc...) then it is passed to a PC. I'm afraid I can't do alot if the only description is 'male wearing blue jeans'. People are often arrested for shoplifting - certainly more than we give £80 tickets to. And the tickets are only issued where the shopkeeper supports and the property is recovered and is fit for resale (or the offender 'volunteers' some compensation). The only time I may not record a crime is with a juvenille where they have no record and the value is a couple of quid - I'd rather use the old approach of taking them home for a telling off in front of mum & dad. I then have to justify why I haven't 'detected' a crime from it.

I am not one for the target culture, which is why my list of 'detected crimes' consists mainly of what I would consider proper crime (assaults, damage, theft) and is not just a list of Section 5 public order offences (though they have their place - e.g. gobby oik swearing their mouth off in front of young kids). I am sadly measured on this list though our station inspector is generally happy so long as everybody keeps their victims happy (where possible). I am happiest when I get letters of thanks from the people I deal with (and the odd box of chocolates goes down quite well among the section - though obviously we have to declare them before we eat them) and when I'm out of the station on patrol. For those who believe the Police are picking on motorists, I have no targets relating to the issuing of tickets or submitting summons files for traffic offences. They do not constitute 'detected crimes' nor do Drunk & Disorderly tickets/charges.

esselte

14,626 posts

298 months

Sunday 20th April 2008
quotequote all
AndyRw said:
streaky said:
Some (many?) people are so disenchanted with the lack of apparent response from the police that the only reason for reporting an offence of burglary or 'criminal damage' is to get a CRN for submission to their insurers.
I could understand people not bothering reporting if the response to a burglary really is only a crime number. I can only speak for where I work, but burglary of both sorts (dwelling and other) gets a 'response within 1 hour' grading for a response officer to attend. If the 'target' (yes, another) is missed, a dwelling burglary is upgraded to emergency response - though no-one will go on blue lights as it isn't proportionate. Burglary in progress (either sort) automatically gets dog units and the force helicopter (if not already tasked) as well as virtually everybody else going.

In any case, a PC will attend and take a statement. A Scenes Of Crime Officer will attend (for dwelling tasked immediately - often even before the PC is asked to go). And if there is one available a DC or DS will attend (nights its unlikely as there's only one for the region). A dwelling burglary is investigated by CID after the initial report from uniform.

That our response is as is - which I think is pretty good and what I would hope for as a homeowner - makes me wonder at other forces where people report no interest. In response to the recording of crime it is worth considering the British Crime Survey on top of Police statistics.

British Crime Survey 2006/7 said:
Since 1995 the number of domestic burglaries estimated by the BCS has fallen by 59 per cent from 1,770,000 to 726,000 in the 2006/07 BCS
...
The 2006/07 BCS estimated that 66 per cent of domestic burglaries were reported to the police, and that burglaries with loss were the type of burglary most likely to be reported (81%)
While this shows people don't report them all it also supports the Police statistics that burglary has fallen, using a new dataset (not just a rehash of the Police stats). I'm not defending the Police statistics as reliable - I entirely agree that statistics can be manipulated by everybody to show exactly what you want them to show - just that there are other sources supporting the suggestion it has fallen.

I also understand shops not reporting all shoplifting. We hardly ignore it though - there is a realistic approach from both shopkeepers and the Police whereby the initial report is assessed for any lines of enquiry to follow by phone. If there are any (witnesses with a description, CCTV, etc...) then it is passed to a PC. I'm afraid I can't do alot if the only description is 'male wearing blue jeans'. People are often arrested for shoplifting - certainly more than we give £80 tickets to. And the tickets are only issued where the shopkeeper supports and the property is recovered and is fit for resale (or the offender 'volunteers' some compensation). The only time I may not record a crime is with a juvenille where they have no record and the value is a couple of quid - I'd rather use the old approach of taking them home for a telling off in front of mum & dad. I then have to justify why I haven't 'detected' a crime from it.

I am not one for the target culture, which is why my list of 'detected crimes' consists mainly of what I would consider proper crime (assaults, damage, theft) and is not just a list of Section 5 public order offences (though they have their place - e.g. gobby oik swearing their mouth off in front of young kids). I am sadly measured on this list though our station inspector is generally happy so long as everybody keeps their victims happy (where possible). I am happiest when I get letters of thanks from the people I deal with (and the odd box of chocolates goes down quite well among the section - though obviously we have to declare them before we eat them) and when I'm out of the station on patrol. For those who believe the Police are picking on motorists, I have no targets relating to the issuing of tickets or submitting summons files for traffic offences. They do not constitute 'detected crimes' nor do Drunk & Disorderly tickets/charges.
If Von's earlier figure of only 14% of burglaries being solved then it would appear that a crime number is the best a homeowner could hope for...