Cops Cause Crashes!
Author
Discussion

DonnyMac

Original Poster:

3,634 posts

234 months

Monday 21st April 2008
quotequote all
It hadn't really crossed my mind before, but just watched BBC Breakfast News and saw a piece about a crackdown on speeding across Europe, including the UK.

They were presenting how effective those sneaky camera vans are and how speed is the evil that causes death and destruction on our roads; they did this by showing loads of high speed accidents around the mobile van sites.

Car speeding, 100+, spots van, slams on anchors, spins, crashes.

They showed about five of them crashing in exactly the same way.

Hold on a sec... all the drivers attempted an emergency stop on a straight and clear road because of the police! Then crashed; whereas they wouldn't have done if said 'saftey' enforcer wasn't there.

How many serious injuries or, god forbid, deaths have been caused because of these 'saftey' vans?

Thoughts/experiences.

Jasandjules

72,690 posts

260 months

Monday 21st April 2008
quotequote all
There have certainly been a couple of bikers killed as a result of heavy braking when a tax collection system is spotted.

But no doubt the "cause" of the accident is cited as speeding though...

p1esk

4,914 posts

227 months

Monday 21st April 2008
quotequote all
If people were not speeding, and they knew they weren't speeding this type of accident wouldn't happen, but don't shout at me too much for saying that. smile

Looking at it more realistically, people do exceed speed limits, in which case the speed trap causes behaviour that wouldn't otherwise occur, sometimes leading to a crash. I therefore think that any such crashes should be set against whatever safety benefits are generated by speed enforcement of this type.

It's all very well saying what people should do, but we also have to take fair account of what they actually do do, and look at the overall result.

Best wishes all,
Dave.

herewego

8,814 posts

244 months

Monday 21st April 2008
quotequote all
Jasandjules said:
There have certainly been a couple of bikers killed as a result of heavy braking when a tax collection system is spotted.

But no doubt the "cause" of the accident is cited as speeding though...
You don't say wether they were actually speeding, but we're supposed to drive within a speed from which we can safely stop if need be aren't we, so I'd say they were driving too fast for the conditions. The reason for needing to stop could have been a child or another biker lying in the road.

Derek Smith

50,032 posts

279 months

Monday 21st April 2008
quotequote all
Bishopsgate in the City of London in the early '80s. A sergeant (not me) was out instructing a PC on how to go about performaing 'stops' of people and vehicles.

Sergeant sees a Cortina that he feels is worth further investigation. Sergeant gives the number 1 signal, driver slams on his brakes. 2-year-old on mother's lap is thrown into dashboard, hitting his head on the choke knob.

PC under instruction calls for urgent assistance. I (acting inspector) found a baby with what appeared to be a depressed fracture of the skull as there was a dent in the kid's head of about half an inch. It turned out that the impact had caused a lot of fluid to go to the kid's face so whilst there was a certain depression, is was miniscule. But you can guess how everyone at the scene felt.

The decision of the discipline board was that the accident was the fault of the police officer as he must expect drivers to react suddenly and without reason when seeing police officers leaping out at them.

I was given official 'advice' which was not to let the sergeant out of the nick.

It's no good saying that 'It's not the fault of the speed camera'. The way people react in such situations must be taken into consideration.

jwo

989 posts

280 months

Monday 21st April 2008
quotequote all
Donnymac - your post beat me to it!

I saw this article too - basically it showed that speed cameras cause accidents. The chap in the vectra estate making good progress - good weather, roads relatively clear - eyeballs van and drops the anchors spinning the car into the central reservation and across to the verge. Now, if the van wasn't there would he have done this??

Potentially would the £60 fine outweigh the thousands of pounds a road accident would cost (caused by camera van).

The BBC article also had the usual guff the 'speed kills' - of the 40k accidents annually in europe one third are cause by speeding etc etc.

What the footage clearly showed was vans causing accidents - however did Norfolk Constabulary allow this to be shown i have no idea.

To be honest I spied a van the other day on a dual carriageway, I was making good progress (knew nothing was behind me), as soon as i saw the van (about 800m away) i dropped anchors very rapidly too.


herewego

8,814 posts

244 months

Monday 21st April 2008
quotequote all
jwo said:
Donnymac - your post beat me to it!

I saw this article too - basically it showed that speed cameras cause accidents. The chap in the vectra estate making good progress - good weather, roads relatively clear - eyeballs van and drops the anchors spinning the car into the central reservation and across to the verge. Now, if the van wasn't there would he have done this??

Potentially would the £60 fine outweigh the thousands of pounds a road accident would cost (caused by camera van).

The BBC article also had the usual guff the 'speed kills' - of the 40k accidents annually in europe one third are cause by speeding etc etc.

What the footage clearly showed was vans causing accidents - however did Norfolk Constabulary allow this to be shown i have no idea.

To be honest I spied a van the other day on a dual carriageway, I was making good progress (knew nothing was behind me), as soon as i saw the van (about 800m away) i dropped anchors very rapidly too.
Was this footage taken from the camera van or was someone else filming and there just happened to be a camera van there?

Jasandjules

72,690 posts

260 months

Monday 21st April 2008
quotequote all
herewego said:
You don't say wether they were actually speeding, but we're supposed to drive within a speed from which we can safely stop if need be aren't we, so I'd say they were driving too fast for the conditions. The reason for needing to stop could have been a child or another biker lying in the road.
My recollection of the bikers in question is that they were both actually speeding, but put on the brakes hard, and got creamed by following vehicles who couldn't stop as quickly. So it was the car behind who was at fault, not the biker. But it was the biker who was killed. And if there is a child or biker laying in the road, a biker can swerve round.

jwo

989 posts

280 months

Monday 21st April 2008
quotequote all
The footage they showed was clearly taken from a camera van (the cross hairs and time date etc were on the video too). They also showed a motorcylcist speeding and said he was doing 130mph etc. but the error3 code wash flashing up (being a layman i would assume an error code = not working properly?)

herewego

8,814 posts

244 months

Monday 21st April 2008
quotequote all
Jasandjules said:
herewego said:
You don't say wether they were actually speeding, but we're supposed to drive within a speed from which we can safely stop if need be aren't we, so I'd say they were driving too fast for the conditions. The reason for needing to stop could have been a child or another biker lying in the road.
My recollection of the bikers in question is that they were both actually speeding, but put on the brakes hard, and got creamed by following vehicles who couldn't stop as quickly. So it was the car behind who was at fault, not the biker. But it was the biker who was killed. And if there is a child or biker laying in the road, a biker can swerve round.
Maybe you don't ride a bike. I'd say the chances of a biker at speed swerving around somehing lying the road is minimal. You're right though it was the fault of the following drivers too close or paying insufficient attention for the speed.

g_stacey

644 posts

264 months

Monday 21st April 2008
quotequote all
Just caught this this morning. What was the comment from the Officer of a camera aimed from the front of the police van, to follow a vechile that would have just passed the van. Do they all have them? Just wondered as most of the time I'm on a motorbike, and thats the only time they'll see my No' plate.

G

herewego

8,814 posts

244 months

Monday 21st April 2008
quotequote all
jwo said:
The footage they showed was clearly taken from a camera van (the cross hairs and time date etc were on the video too). They also showed a motorcylcist speeding and said he was doing 130mph etc. but the error3 code wash flashing up (being a layman i would assume an error code = not working properly?)
So any other reason for the driver having to slow unexpectedly could achieve the same result. If a bike with a camera on it were to pull out say 1000 times from a side road in the same location eventually the camera would record someone who was driving too fast slamming on their brakes and losing it. Obviously this would be a daft thing to do, but I’m trying to make the point that the only reason they have the footage is because they have filmed thousands of speeding drivers. Also there could have been a real reason for him having to stop safely at that location and he couldn’t do it.

mark69sheer

3,906 posts

233 months

Monday 21st April 2008
quotequote all
I can't really stand up for anyone going through a camera at silly speeds.

What I can say with confidence is that cameras cause erratic driving.

More often than not I will follow behind someone on a 60mph road who will slow to 40mph upon seeing a camera.

They shouldn't do this of course but the doubt in their minds since 60mph roads don't have the limit posted make them err on caution and brake.

It doesn't bother me since I actually expect people to do this. the simple solution of putting the speed of the camera on the box has not been taken up presumably because they don't want people to know the speed of any boxes and hope they are therefore passed too quickly.

So yes the boxes do have some safety issues in direct conflict with their stated safety role.

Jasandjules

72,690 posts

260 months

Monday 21st April 2008
quotequote all
herewego said:
Maybe you don't ride a bike.
Only one with pedals on... biggrin

Though to save the planet I think I'm going to have to use the TVR in future...biggrin

Davi

17,153 posts

251 months

Monday 21st April 2008
quotequote all
herewego said:
So any other reason for the driver having to slow unexpectedly could achieve the same result. If a bike with a camera on it were to pull out say 1000 times from a side road in the same location eventually the camera would record someone who was driving too fast slamming on their brakes and losing it. Obviously this would be a daft thing to do, but I’m trying to make the point that the only reason they have the footage is because they have filmed thousands of speeding drivers. Also there could have been a real reason for him having to stop safely at that location and he couldn’t do it.
Are you saying it's OK to put lives in actual danger because a hypothetic situation could see a similar result? An obstruction in the road can often be avoided whereas these camera's effectively put up a brick wall - a point covering the entire carriage way where you MUST have achieved the braking maneuver by without fail. Very few incidences do the same - cameras do not allow for alternative actions to avoid therefor are IMO considerably more likely to cause an avoidable accident.

jwo

989 posts

280 months

Monday 21st April 2008
quotequote all
Generally whilst driving a 'good' driver can read the conditions and drive accordingly.

When a 'good' driver sees a camera van (and knows they are over the limit (but not killing anyone)) the only course of action is to brake suddenly to below the limit. Less observant drivers (one not tuned in to camera hazards etc.) will be caught out by this seemingly erronous braking and may have further repercussions.

A police car however, with real people in, will be able to differentiate between safe driving above th espeed limit and dangerous driver and deal with the culprit accordingly.


Brett928S2

1,504 posts

246 months

Monday 21st April 2008
quotequote all
Hi smile

I saw this as well....and once the van/camera had caused that crash.....why did not the canera operator say....oh ,I just caused a major crash so I had better move my unit to somewhere where I DONT CAUSE CRASHES !!!

Unbelieveable...and I somehow doubt any BIB here can defend his actions AFTER causing that crash????

All the best Brett smile

herewego

8,814 posts

244 months

Monday 21st April 2008
quotequote all
Davi said:
herewego said:
So any other reason for the driver having to slow unexpectedly could achieve the same result. If a bike with a camera on it were to pull out say 1000 times from a side road in the same location eventually the camera would record someone who was driving too fast slamming on their brakes and losing it. Obviously this would be a daft thing to do, but I’m trying to make the point that the only reason they have the footage is because they have filmed thousands of speeding drivers. Also there could have been a real reason for him having to stop safely at that location and he couldn’t do it.
Are you saying it's OK to put lives in actual danger because a hypothetic situation could see a similar result? An obstruction in the road can often be avoided whereas these camera's effectively put up a brick wall - a point covering the entire carriage way where you MUST have achieved the braking maneuver by without fail. Very few incidences do the same - cameras do not allow for alternative actions to avoid therefor are IMO considerably more likely to cause an avoidable accident.
I take your point, but we can't do nothing. I doubt the risk is higher than any other kind of speed enforcement other than hidden cameras and NIPs in the post, but people don't seem to like that idea. If open enforcement turns out to have increased risk maybe that's the way it will go. After all you don't want a guy on the road that drives so fast that he crashes when he touches the brakes.

Davi

17,153 posts

251 months

Monday 21st April 2008
quotequote all
herewego said:
Davi said:
herewego said:
So any other reason for the driver having to slow unexpectedly could achieve the same result. If a bike with a camera on it were to pull out say 1000 times from a side road in the same location eventually the camera would record someone who was driving too fast slamming on their brakes and losing it. Obviously this would be a daft thing to do, but I’m trying to make the point that the only reason they have the footage is because they have filmed thousands of speeding drivers. Also there could have been a real reason for him having to stop safely at that location and he couldn’t do it.
Are you saying it's OK to put lives in actual danger because a hypothetic situation could see a similar result? An obstruction in the road can often be avoided whereas these camera's effectively put up a brick wall - a point covering the entire carriage way where you MUST have achieved the braking maneuver by without fail. Very few incidences do the same - cameras do not allow for alternative actions to avoid therefor are IMO considerably more likely to cause an avoidable accident.
I take your point, but we can't do nothing. I doubt the risk is higher than any other kind of speed enforcement other than hidden cameras and NIPs in the post, but people don't seem to like that idea. If open enforcement turns out to have increased risk maybe that's the way it will go. After all you don't want a guy on the road that drives so fast that he crashes when he touches the brakes.
I'd put a fairly substantial wadge of cash on that patrol cars have a substantially lower risk. They also catch real criminals and dangerous people while at it. Plus they have the added advantage of using intelligent thought on deciding how to proceed with a driver who may have strayed.

Dwight VanDriver

6,583 posts

275 months

Monday 21st April 2008
quotequote all
Muse mode on.......

If the object of the camera is catch those that are exceeding the speed limit then why make them visible? Hide them and there will be no sudden braking etc. Not knowing when one is going to get pinged surely would concentrate the mind better ?

If the object is to reduce speed then use the Speed Matrix boards

(Pssst one going cheap Cumbria way

http://news.bbc.co.uk/1/hi/england/cumbria/7357190...

Lastly if HMG want to reduce speed at which we travel why do they allow cars that can do 100 plus on the road. De tune em, bring back the 998cc moggie minor etc. Lower speeds less motion lotion used and more for the Chinese/Indians? .

Muse mode off....

dvd

Edited by Dwight VanDriver on Monday 21st April 14:39