Discussion
Is it a legal requirement to have a spare wheel in a car? I thought it was not, but if you did have one then it had to have legal tread.
reason i ask is because i helped a woman with a new honda civic that happened to have a puncture at the weekend and no spare wheel was present, only a portable pump.
reason i ask is because i helped a woman with a new honda civic that happened to have a puncture at the weekend and no spare wheel was present, only a portable pump.
Parrot of Doom said:
I sometimes wonder if spare wheels are necessary, even if not required by law. Have you ever seen anyone but professional drivers change one at the roadside?
I've seen plenty of cars pulled over with all the bits out, and the driver stood by looking completely perplexed.
Just wait to you have a puncture in rural France at 2am when 250 miles from the ferry back to the UK. Then you will be glad of a full-size spare wheel and the ability to fit it.I've seen plenty of cars pulled over with all the bits out, and the driver stood by looking completely perplexed.
ganglandboss said:
You do not have to carry a spare but if you do it must be legal. As DVD has said, it is not a testable item. Remember though that having a valid MOT does not mean the vehicle is roadworthy and says so on the certificate.
I think DvD said that only the wheels fitted onto the car had to have legal tyres. The spare can be bald or illegal. For example, if you split a tyre and fitted the fully legal spare, then the tyre on the 'spare', which you have just removed, would be completely illegal for use on the road - it would also be completely flat. However, it would be legal to carry it in the car as you would need to take it to get a replacement fitted.ganglandboss said:
You do not have to carry a spare but if you do it must be legal. As DVD has said, it is not a testable item.
You have contradicted yourself. As the spare is not a testable item, it can quite legally be completely bald with wires poking out of it. It would only become illegal when such a tyre was actually used as a road wheel.Cooperman said:
ganglandboss said:
You do not have to carry a spare but if you do it must be legal. As DVD has said, it is not a testable item. Remember though that having a valid MOT does not mean the vehicle is roadworthy and says so on the certificate.
I think DvD said that only the wheels fitted onto the car had to have legal tyres. The spare can be bald or illegal. For example, if you split a tyre and fitted the fully legal spare, then the tyre on the 'spare', which you have just removed, would be completely illegal for use on the road - it would also be completely flat. However, it would be legal to carry it in the car as you would need to take it to get a replacement fitted.ganglandboss said:
I'm not doubting what he says, I'm merely pointing out that having an MOT and being road legal aren't the same thing. I'm sure that you can legally carry it for the purpose of having it repaired - that I have not looked into.
Anyone is perfectly entitled to carry non-functional car parts within their vehicle. For instance, if a lorry is loaded hundreds of scrap tyres to take to be remoulded or for a farmer to use on his silage cover, do you think that would be illegal? Would carrying a cracked windscreen or a blown bulb in your boot be illegal?FACTS:
You are not legally required to carry a spare tyre in the UK.
You may legally carry a worn out tyre within your car and that tyre would not be testable in an MOT.
This is one of those urban myths that just keeps getting recycled.
Mr2Mike said:
ganglandboss said:
I'm not doubting what he says, I'm merely pointing out that having an MOT and being road legal aren't the same thing. I'm sure that you can legally carry it for the purpose of having it repaired - that I have not looked into.
Anyone is perfectly entitled to carry non-functional car parts within their vehicle. For instance, if a lorry is loaded hundreds of scrap tyres to take to be remoulded or for a farmer to use on his silage cover, do you think that would be illegal? Would carrying a cracked windscreen or a blown bulb in your boot be illegal?FACTS:
You are not legally required to carry a spare tyre in the UK.
You may legally carry a worn out tyre within your car and that tyre would not be testable in an MOT.
This is one of those urban myths that just keeps getting recycled.
Edited by moanthebairns on Tuesday 22 April 09:08
Gassing Station | Speed, Plod & the Law | Top of Page | What's New | My Stuff


