Final notice NIP after 5 1/2 months?
Final notice NIP after 5 1/2 months?
Author
Discussion

elenitro

Original Poster:

245 posts

225 months

Tuesday 22nd April 2008
quotequote all
I've just received a final notice NIP for an 'incident' that happened just over 5 1/2 months ago for driving the mrs' car.
How on earth are you supposed to know if you were driving a car that long ago?

vonhosen

40,597 posts

248 months

Tuesday 22nd April 2008
quotequote all
elenitro said:
I've just received a final notice NIP for an 'incident' that happened just over 5 1/2 months ago for driving the mrs' car.
How on earth are you supposed to know if you were driving a car that long ago?
Surely there was an earlier NIP issued.

SS2.

14,712 posts

269 months

Tuesday 22nd April 2008
quotequote all
Does the time period within which you must respond take you beyond 6 calendar months of the date of the alleged offence ?

jondude

2,441 posts

248 months

Wednesday 23rd April 2008
quotequote all
SS2. said:
Does the time period within which you must respond take you beyond 6 calendar months of the date of the alleged offence ?
Was thinking the same. You could request further information and set out of your case by recorded delivery on day 27...meaning ( perhaps ) your response, while perfectly correct, has left the police with a time out problem. ( They must lay the papers before a court no more than 6 months from the date of the alleged offence, and you cannot be held responsible for their negligence )

It may be an hopeful attempt at getting you to pay before it is too late.

No guarantees, though!

streaky

19,311 posts

280 months

Wednesday 23rd April 2008
quotequote all
jondude said:
SS2. said:
Does the time period within which you must respond take you beyond 6 calendar months of the date of the alleged offence ?
Was thinking the same. You could request further information and set out of your case by recorded delivery on day 27...meaning ( perhaps ) your response, while perfectly correct, has left the police with a time out problem. ( They must lay the papers before a court no more than 6 months from the date of the alleged offence, and you cannot be held responsible for their negligence )

It may be an hopeful attempt at getting you to pay before it is too late.

No guarantees, though!
According to the OP, this is a NOIP, not a summons. If the original NOIP was sent to the RK within the 15 day period, there's no requirement on when a further NOIP (e.g. to the nominated driver) can be sent. A summons must be laid before the court within six months of the offence, but if the offence is under S172 ('failiure to name'), that's not tied to the original offence (e.g. speeding). Laying before the court is not tied in time to notifying the offender. If I am wrong, someone more knowledgeable will be along shortly to correct me - Streaky

SS2.

14,712 posts

269 months

Wednesday 23rd April 2008
quotequote all
streaky said:
A summons must be laid before the court within six months of the offence, but if the offence is under S172 ('failiure to name'), that's not tied to the original offence (e.g. speeding). Laying before the court is not tied in time to notifying the offender.
An offence of failing to provide driver details would occur 28 days after a lawful s.172 request had been served on the accused. 'Timeout' for this offence would thus occur 6 months after the end of this 28 day period.

If the first lawful s.172 request was served on the accused some 5.5 months after the alleged substantive offence, then as long as the OP replies in good time (and provides all of the information requested), then they have satisfied their obligations under s.172 RTA 1988.

I would suggest that if the OP were to comply with this s.172 request but was subsequently prosecuted for an earlier s.172 offence which related to the same substantive offence (where a notice 'went missing', for instance), then this could amount to an abuse of process..


streaky

19,311 posts

280 months

Wednesday 23rd April 2008
quotequote all
SS2. said:
streaky said:
A summons must be laid before the court within six months of the offence, but if the offence is under S172 ('failiure to name'), that's not tied to the original offence (e.g. speeding). Laying before the court is not tied in time to notifying the offender.
An offence of failing to provide driver details would occur 28 days after a lawful s.172 request had been served on the accused. 'Timeout' for this offence would thus occur 6 months after the end of this 28 day period.
Indeed you are correct. What I intended to say was that if the S172 is complied with (by the RK), there can then be a to-ing and fro-ing of indeterminate length with the 'nominated' driver(s) [but apparently not applicable in this instance] - Streaky

elenitro

Original Poster:

245 posts

225 months

Wednesday 23rd April 2008
quotequote all
Hi,

The car is in the mrs name so the original NIP would have been sent to her. If she's delayed by asking for infomation like suggested (photograph etc) and then said it was me driving and thus I've now got the NIP.
If I reply asking for the same information, which assuming they get it to my before the 6 months but I am then given until after the 6 months to reply, where does that leave me?

Leon

SS2.

14,712 posts

269 months

Wednesday 23rd April 2008
quotequote all
I assume that the 'incident' in question was either an alleged speeding, or traffic sign / signal offence ?

So, to be clear, you have received a notice some 5.5 months after the alleged offence ?

And does this notice give you the statutory 28 days to respond ?

If yes, would the end of this 28 day period be beyond 6 calendar months from the date of the alleged offence ?

If yes, (and assuming that you know you were driving), then there is nothing to be gained by employing delaying tactics. Simply complete and sign the s.172 form and ensure that it is returned to the police within 28 days of the day you received it (but more than 6 months from the alleged offence date)..

That way, you would have complied with your statutory obligations under s.172 AND prosecution of the substantive offence would be time barred and could not be proceeded.

elenitro

Original Poster:

245 posts

225 months

Wednesday 23rd April 2008
quotequote all
SS2. said:
I assume that the 'incident' in question was either an alleged speeding, or traffic sign / signal offence ?

So, to be clear, you have received a notice some 5.5 months after the alleged offence ?

And does this notice give you the statutory 28 days to respond ?

If yes, would the end of this 28 day period be beyond 6 calendar months from the date of the alleged offence ?

If yes, (and assuming that you know you were driving), then there is nothing to be gained by employing delaying tactics. Simply complete and sign the s.172 form and ensure that it is returned to the police within 28 days of the day you received it (but more than 6 months from the alleged offence date)..

That way, you would have complied with your statutory obligations under s.172 AND prosecution of the substantive offence would be time barred and could not be proceeded.
It was for speeding (73 in a 60).

Yes, this is the first I have heard of it.

This is a final notice (surely a first notice should have been sent/received?) and it gives me 10 days to reply.

This 10 days does not take it over 6 months.

I have no idea if I was actually driving at the time (I have my own car and bike). I don't even know if I was in the car at the time!

moosepig

1,306 posts

272 months

Wednesday 23rd April 2008
quotequote all
Might I respectfully suggest that you ask your wife?

Dwight VanDriver

6,583 posts

275 months

Wednesday 23rd April 2008
quotequote all
Be careful as the S172 demand is not tied in the wthe date of the original speeding offence.

If the offence committed on 1.1.08 and they have sent forms to Reg Keeper and they are still after a driver, irrespective of the fact that they can summons Reg Keeper for not responding in 28 days and now have information of a new driver, whilst the speeding offence is going to be outside the limitations on proceedngs they can still make a demand under 172 of

any other person shall if required as stated above give any information which it is in his power to give and may lead to identification of the driver.

In relation to him the defence open to Reg Keeper does not apply.

Limitation on proceedings in this case will apply 6 months from the time 28 days after the latest demand took place.

dvd

elenitro

Original Poster:

245 posts

225 months

Wednesday 23rd April 2008
quotequote all
OK thanks for the info.

Basically if the original NIP was eventually complied with in that I was put down as the driver and so now I have a NIP does the 6 months time limit still apply?

If I reply requesting information (i.e photograph) and look into what I was doing on the day and then after the 6 months has expired, comply with the s172 and say either I was driving or wasn't what happens then?

Leon

Dwight VanDriver

6,583 posts

275 months

Wednesday 23rd April 2008
quotequote all
If this is a 'new' request on behalf of Chief of police then if you fail to respond (they generally allow 28 days to do so)then the offence will be on the date they made the request.

From the date of the offence they have 6 months to lay an Information about the offence (basically an Information is charge made before a Justice to the effect that some person has or is suspected of having committed an offence. It is the preliminary step towards obtaining a summons). Outside this time limit, if Information not laid, limitation on proceedings kick in - they cannot go ahead with the offence and issue summons. They can still continue if they have laid the information within the 6 months and serve a summons outside this time.

So what was the date of their letter and when did you receive it?

dvd

SS2.

14,712 posts

269 months

Wednesday 23rd April 2008
quotequote all
Dwight VanDriver said:
If this is a 'new' request on behalf of Chief of police then if you fail to respond (they generally allow 28 days to do so) then the offence will be on the date they made the request.
Are you sure about that, DVD ?

The offence of failing to provide driver details occurs 28 days after a lawful request has been served upon the accused (assuming that the accused fails to comply with the requirements of the request).

SS2.

14,712 posts

269 months

Wednesday 23rd April 2008
quotequote all
elenitro said:
Basically if the original NIP was eventually complied with in that I was put down as the driver and so now I have a NIP does the 6 months time limit still apply?
Yes. The 6 month limitation for proceedings to be commenced is strict.

elenitro said:
If I reply requesting information (i.e photograph) and look into what I was doing on the day and then after the 6 months has expired, comply with the s172 and say either I was driving or wasn't what happens then?
If you fail to confirm who was driving then you will not have complied with s.172 and could be summoned for failing to provide driver details.

If you confirm the identity of the driver outside of the permitted timescales, and unless you could demonstrate that it was not practicably possible to provide the information any sooner, then you would be liable to be prosecuted for failing to provide driver details.

Dwight VanDriver

6,583 posts

275 months

Thursday 24th April 2008
quotequote all
>>>>>The offence of failing to provide driver details occurs 28 days after a lawful request has been served upon the accused (assuming that the accused fails to comply with the requirements of the request).<<<<<

As there is no time mentioned in Section 172 (2)(a) and (b)RTA 88 I have always understood that once the request has been made and not complied with the offence has been committed once the paper has been 'served'. The 28 days are purely admin to allow details to be given this showing to the Court ample oportunity to provide.

Further, there is nothing to state that it has to be in writing and providing the Officer is authorised by Chief of Police he can, it seems, make a verbal request.

dvd

SS2.

14,712 posts

269 months

Thursday 24th April 2008
quotequote all
Dwight VanDriver said:
As there is no time mentioned in Section 172 (2)(a) and (b)RTA 88 I have always understood that once the request has been made and not complied with the offence has been committed once the paper has been 'served'.
That's not how I understand it or indeed how the courts view it..

I acknowledge that where statute requires something to be done within a fixed timescale, the offence generally continues until it is done, but the offence of failing to furnish is (AIUI) alleged to have occurred on the first date after the expiry of the fixed response period.

For instance, when the higher points tariff for failing to furnish information took effect on 24.09.2007, this was applicable to all such offences where the 28 days expired AFTER 24.09.2007 ie any s.172 request which had been served after 27.08.2007 (and not complied with) attracted 6 points upon conviction.

Dwight VanDriver said:
Further, there is nothing to state that it has to be in writing and providing the Officer is authorised by Chief of Police he can, it seems, make a verbal request.
Of course a verbal request can be made. But the 28 day response time applies only to requests made by post - s.172 (7).


Edited by SS2. on Thursday 24th April 11:34

elenitro

Original Poster:

245 posts

225 months

Thursday 24th April 2008
quotequote all
Dwight VanDriver said:
If this is a 'new' request on behalf of Chief of police then if you fail to respond (they generally allow 28 days to do so)then the offence will be on the date they made the request.

From the date of the offence they have 6 months to lay an Information about the offence (basically an Information is charge made before a Justice to the effect that some person has or is suspected of having committed an offence. It is the preliminary step towards obtaining a summons). Outside this time limit, if Information not laid, limitation on proceedings kick in - they cannot go ahead with the offence and issue summons. They can still continue if they have laid the information within the 6 months and serve a summons outside this time.

So what was the date of their letter and when did you receive it?

dvd
The letter is dated 17/04/2008 with a postmark of the same date and I received it on the 18/04/2008. It is a final notice which gives me 10 days to respond.

I have every intention of complying with it but this 10 days (27/04/08) is not 6 months from the date of the incident (04/11/07).
I am within my rights to ask for the photograph/video of the incident as the NIP states this is what they have. Obviously by the time they send this to me and give me the 10 days to respond to this, the 4th May will have passed and so the 6 months has passed.
I will then state if it was me or not (as I mentioned how you're supposed to know after this amount of time is beyond me).
If I say it was me then will I still get points/fine?
If I say it wasn't me and name the mrs what happens then considering that she has already said it was me on the original NIP?

Cheers,

Leon

Dwight VanDriver

6,583 posts

275 months

Thursday 24th April 2008
quotequote all
Obliged SS.

Now found the amendment to Section 172 RTA 88 by Sect 21 RTA 1991 and the important added Sub sect 7 - 28 days cast in stone.
(http://www.tinyurl.com/2360 - for inf of poster)

So if the poster was served on 18th April 2008 then he has to 16th June 08 to respond and it would therefore appear he can ignore the 10 day deadline they are imposing?.

So this is becoming a game of chess.

Offence of speeding committed on 4.11.07.
L on P on 3.May 2008.

172 to name served on 18th April, 2008
Response time ends 16th May 2008 under 28 day rule.
This is outside the L of P for the proceedings for speeding offence so if he replies after 3rd May and names himself no action can be taken for speeding or fail to name 172.
If he does not give the information then L on P for this expires 17th October 2008.

It is interesting that they have placed a 10 day deadline for reply i.e. 28th April 2008. This as far as I can see is against the 28 days allowed under 172(7).

Obviously they appear to be aware of the fast approaching 3rd May so what can they do to bring closure?

This scenario may be possible - whether they would do it is another matter.

They are not bound by law to enter into any dialogue in relation to a photo at this stage. Some do but not obliged to do so.

Having a name and address of the poster they can lay an information before 2.5.08 for the speed offence to cover any
admission he may make and if so made progress to summons. L of P this defeated.

If poster does not provide information then they are still in within the limits on proceedings for this offence.

As a layman it seems poster could be on a winner here and suggest he runs it past a Solicitor before hand.

Poster please advise developments....

dvd