Handbrake Failure (In my Opinion)
Handbrake Failure (In my Opinion)
Author
Discussion

keredewor

Original Poster:

17 posts

244 months

Saturday 26th April 2008
quotequote all
Scenario

VW T5 California, brand new, 20 dealer testing miles on clock.

Pick up from dealer no mechanical guidance handover and no specific warnings or care bulletins.

Drive 20 mile to office, park up, apply handbrake, handbrake light illuminates, leave vehicle, all is well, T5 is safely parked.

20 minutes later, knock at door, T5 has run backwards down a slight incline for 40yds, smacked into a tree, nearly wiped out a council gardener, comes to rest at a tree, bumper and rear spoiler damaged.

Gardener(s), 4 of them witness handbrake is on, open T5, witness light is on when ignition started, and handbrake is applied.

Contact dealer, T5 will be recovered for investigation but immediate dealer reaction is "Not our Fault mate" you must have forgotten to apply the handbrake correctly and obviously you have not read the 3inch thick handbook in the 1.5hrs since you took the vehicle, including 1 hr drive from us, before the incident.

So I say.........err sort this out, its b a brand new vehicle, this was safely parked and it MUST be a fault in the handbraking system or something else.

I can feel a fight coming on, by the way the T5 also came without a grille that had been ordered, a ripped sun canopy, a dent in the chrome bull bars, a rear cover mat for a different VW.....

I do believe that if the dealer begins to be difficult that I may have a case of "Non conformance to the Sale of Goods Act".....anyone


Edited by keredewor on Saturday 26th April 19:25

Jon Ison

1,304 posts

264 months

Saturday 26th April 2008
quotequote all
May be useful information, may not apply ? My T5 transporter went in for a recall to have a new handbrake lever fitted back end of last year, has yours had the work done or was it built after the recall ? Worth checking.

keredewor

Original Poster:

17 posts

244 months

Saturday 26th April 2008
quotequote all
Thanks....that may in the end be relevant, my T5 was built in February/March 2008 and delivered 25/4/08

tigger1

8,485 posts

252 months

Saturday 26th April 2008
quotequote all
keredewor said:
I do believe that if the dealer begins to be difficult that I may have a case of "Non conformance to the Sale of Goods Act".....anyone
IANAL but - now is probably too late to consider that angle in terms of the other defects, as you're presumably going to struggle to take it back in its original condition. The time to worry about the defects was before you accepted the car IMHO.

Whilst I can understand your annoyance (and this is going to sound horrible!) - do you normally leave your car with only the handbrake on when on an incline? Perhaps I've driven cars where I've not trusted the handbrake as much, but I would always leave it in gear - and I believe the highway code suggests turning the wheels into the kerb too...to prevent a situation.

On the plus side, at least there were no deaths / injuries - could have been very messy. Good luck getting sorted

Daschund

374 posts

223 months

Saturday 26th April 2008
quotequote all
You didn't park it in gear?

tigger1

8,485 posts

252 months

Saturday 26th April 2008
quotequote all
Link to the highway code info on parking on hills - point 252.

It's also an offence to park and leave the car without applying the handbrake wink

What have your insurance company said? Have you legal help with that?

Edited for bad tag

Edited by tigger1 on Saturday 26th April 22:43

Parrot of Doom

23,075 posts

265 months

Saturday 26th April 2008
quotequote all
Discs cool down = contraction = no more handbrake.

Mattt

16,664 posts

249 months

Saturday 26th April 2008
quotequote all
Parrot of Doom said:
Discs cool down = contraction = no more handbrake.
I never leave my cars in gear, and I've never had that happen. Not saying it doesn't, but must be rare.

mph999

2,780 posts

251 months

Saturday 26th April 2008
quotequote all
Mattt said:
Parrot of Doom said:
Discs cool down = contraction = no more handbrake.
I never leave my cars in gear, and I've never had that happen. Not saying it doesn't, but must be rare.
Depends how hot (+ therefore 'expanded') the discs are ... Quite common on Minis, I've heard or quite a few cases.

Martin

Edited by mph999 on Sunday 27th April 04:00

keredewor

Original Poster:

17 posts

244 months

Saturday 26th April 2008
quotequote all
Mattt said:
Parrot of Doom said:
Discs cool down = contraction = no more handbrake.
I never leave my cars in gear, and I've never had that happen. Not saying it doesn't, but must be rare.
This, in my mind is what actually happened combined with what I believe were valetting chemicals on the discs/pads.....this vehicle had travelled "20" miles....the handbrake was "Firmly engaged"


keredewor

Original Poster:

17 posts

244 months

Saturday 26th April 2008
quotequote all
keredewor said:
Mattt said:
Parrot of Doom said:
Discs cool down = contraction = no more handbrake.
I never leave my cars in gear, and I've never had that happen. Not saying it doesn't, but must be rare.
This, in my mind is what actually happened combined with what I believe were valetting chemicals on the discs/pads.....this vehicle was "Brand New" had only travelled "20" miles....the handbrake was "Firmly engaged"

AndrewTait

1,849 posts

225 months

Sunday 27th April 2008
quotequote all
It happens on my Skoda Octavia (VW in clowns clothing!), but not quite to this extent.

Park my car after a run on the motorway, and apply the hand brake. Let the brakes cool, and you can push the car without even unlocking it, let alone taking the hand brake off. Ok there is some resistance, but I can move it on my own when this happens.

I suspect that if I parked it on a suitable incline, then the same would happen, being a quite heavy car, and hence I always leave it in gear.

eldar

25,363 posts

227 months

Sunday 27th April 2008
quotequote all

Richard C

1,685 posts

288 months

Sunday 27th April 2008
quotequote all
Parrot of Doom said:
Discs cool down = contraction = no more handbrake.
common on Ford Cosworth/ Sierra XR4x4 - had this happen to me twice with car 20 feet down the garden in the morning. House is on a steep slope. Left in gear and with wheel chocks after that

5lab

1,949 posts

227 months

Monday 28th April 2008
quotequote all
could it be that the pads weren't fully 'aligned' (can't think of the right word) to the disks? the first time i put the handbrake on in my car after having the pads and discs changed, it had resistance but went up to the top of its travel, as the pad wear system re-adjusted itself.

for what its worth, the light being on can't be trusted to show the handbrake will hold a car. mine comes on with one click of the lever, which does exactly nowt to slow the car.

skymaster

731 posts

238 months

Monday 28th April 2008
quotequote all
As far as I am aware it's the drivers responsibility to ensure the parked vehicle remains parked and doesn't go for it's own little jolly. This is irrespective of how good the handbrake is. Had the vehicle killed or injured someone (OK, a council employee, no great loss) you would have likley been held liable.

There are loads of cases where the handbrake might become very innefective, on new cars as well as old ones. A brand new set of pads and discs that are yet to fully bed in for example. Or a cable might just snapp!

keredewor

Original Poster:

17 posts

244 months

Monday 28th April 2008
quotequote all
skymaster said:
As far as I am aware it's the drivers responsibility to ensure the parked vehicle remains parked and doesn't go for it's own little jolly. This is irrespective of how good the handbrake is. Had the vehicle killed or injured someone (OK, a council employee, no great loss) you would have likley been held liable.

There are loads of cases where the handbrake might become very innefective, on new cars as well as old ones. A brand new set of pads and discs that are yet to fully bed in for example. Or a cable might just snapp!
Ok then.....

1. I am a totally responsible person, I am a responsible person because I left the vehicle in a safe condition with the handbrake applied, if I was not a responsible person I would not have "FULLY" applied the handbrake after getting out of the vehicle and it would have rolled instantly.

2. At handover no details of the vehicle, safety or otherwise, were explained to me, none and no time had elapsed for any reasonable person to accept that a handbook containing 500 plus pages could have been read, digested and acted upon.

3. The vehicle had travelled 20 miles, yes 20 miles, it is inconcievable that anyone would think of failure of any car of that age.

Hindsight is all very well, if the handbrake on a vehicle is such a dangerous peice of apparatus and so prone to failure I do believe that prior to anyone taking delivery of a car should be told by the dealer that the handbrake is prone to failure...........if they have the knowledge that this single point of failure can be catastrophic they should take all reasonable steps to inform the buyers then I would accept it is my liability because I would have then chosen to ignore the advice.





Edited by keredewor on Monday 28th April 14:46

skymaster

731 posts

238 months

Monday 28th April 2008
quotequote all
Sorry, I didn't mean to wind you up about it. If I were you I would be severely annoyed at this as well. I wanted to point out that applying the handbrake alone is not enough. Having worked with cars in the past I have learned never to 100% trust any mechanical part of them. Cos I am the paranoid sort I always go under the assumption that my handbrake will fail and secure the car accordingly by turning the wheels and leaving it in gear.

The supplying dealer are going to try their hardest the wriggle out of it. I think for you to get anything from them you will have to get someone else to inspect the vehicle and declare that there is indeed something wrong with the handbrake. The garage do have a duty of care when they do the pre delivery inspection of the vehicle and if they have neglected then you may may well have a claim against them.

dugt

1,657 posts

238 months

Monday 28th April 2008
quotequote all
what i do is:

switch off engine
put car in gear(usually second)
take feet off pedals and allow gearbox to "lock up"
apply handbrake


what does everyone else do?
ive never trusted handbrakes

doug

Engineer1

10,486 posts

240 months

Monday 28th April 2008
quotequote all
bad luck, was the handbrake fully on? or was it just caught? either way i suspect you are stuffed getting them to admit anything was wrong with the vehicle, i suspect it's one pf those things you've learnt the hard way. all my older cars where parked in gear with the handbrake on but my parents drive is steep, and my current car only starts if the clutch is depressed so i can leave it in gear too.