No MOT even if you have an MOT?
Discussion
Anybody see the letter in this morning's Sunday Times?
Seems that if you take your car in for MOT and it fails, then you are driving illegally, even if your existing MOT has a few weeks to run! The database is undated and you are not supposed to drive it.
Seems nonesense to me, as there are things on an MOT not covered entirely by the Con and Use regs ( I think) which unless they rendered it as an a 'dangerous condition' would not result in prosecution.
Surely the law requires you have a valid MOT and that last 12 months, even if you decide to have it retested?
When MOTs were cheaper I used to MOT my old car every 6 months to have a way of knowing what was wearing out as I am not a mechanic and doinmg his was a way of keeping on top if things and allowing me to source parts at the right price by having a bit of time (things like gaiters, suspension units, headlamps etc).
Seems that if you take your car in for MOT and it fails, then you are driving illegally, even if your existing MOT has a few weeks to run! The database is undated and you are not supposed to drive it.
Seems nonesense to me, as there are things on an MOT not covered entirely by the Con and Use regs ( I think) which unless they rendered it as an a 'dangerous condition' would not result in prosecution.
Surely the law requires you have a valid MOT and that last 12 months, even if you decide to have it retested?
When MOTs were cheaper I used to MOT my old car every 6 months to have a way of knowing what was wearing out as I am not a mechanic and doinmg his was a way of keeping on top if things and allowing me to source parts at the right price by having a bit of time (things like gaiters, suspension units, headlamps etc).
I would argue that ST have it wrong.
If a vehicle is tested within the currency of a MOT already issued and fault found then the original MOT is still valid until date of expiry.
Any offence committed on drive away providing evidence is there, will be that contrary to Con and Use, Lighting etc and not using without a Test certificate.
There are some exemptions in this i.e. Lighting fault present during the hours of daylight and occurred during current journey, steps taken to rectify speedo.
dvd
If a vehicle is tested within the currency of a MOT already issued and fault found then the original MOT is still valid until date of expiry.
Any offence committed on drive away providing evidence is there, will be that contrary to Con and Use, Lighting etc and not using without a Test certificate.
There are some exemptions in this i.e. Lighting fault present during the hours of daylight and occurred during current journey, steps taken to rectify speedo.
dvd
Not seen the article but would argue that if a vehicle fails an MOT even during the validity period of an existing one then that vehicle becomes unroadworthy. Why should it remain legal if it is carrying a fault?
Let's imagine my car passes the MOT but as I drive away I suffer damage to the tyres, brakes or suspension. Something that renders the vehicle unsafe although not obviously so under cursory inspection. Am I right if I continue to drive on a public road knowing that my vehicle is unsafe? I think not.
Let's imagine my car passes the MOT but as I drive away I suffer damage to the tyres, brakes or suspension. Something that renders the vehicle unsafe although not obviously so under cursory inspection. Am I right if I continue to drive on a public road knowing that my vehicle is unsafe? I think not.
Edited by Flintstone on Sunday 27th April 18:29
Flintstone said:
Not seen the article but would argue that if a vehicle fails an MOT even during the validity period of an existing one then that vehicle becomes unroadworthy. Why should it remain legal if it is carrying a fault?
Let's imagine my car passes the MOT but as I drive away I suffer damage to the tyres, brakes or suspension. Something that renders the vehicle unsafe although not obviously so under cursory inspection. Am I right if I continue to drive on a public road knowing that my vehicle is unsafe? I think not.
No it wouldn't be legal, but it doesn't render the MOT invalid either.Let's imagine my car passes the MOT but as I drive away I suffer damage to the tyres, brakes or suspension. Something that renders the vehicle unsafe although not obviously so under cursory inspection. Am I right if I continue to drive on a public road knowing that my vehicle is unsafe? I think not.
Say the tyres are worn/bulging or something and it fails the MOT. You have them replaced at the same garage but the testing person is too busy to re-issue the certificate so you drive home and get it reissued the following week. Illegal? Of course not.
Flintstone said:
Not seen the article but would argue that if a vehicle fails an MOT even during the validity period of an existing one then that vehicle becomes unroadworthy. Why should it remain legal if it is carrying a fault?
Let's imagine my car passes the MOT but as I drive away I suffer damage to the tyres, brakes or suspension. Something that renders the vehicle unsafe although not obviously so under cursory inspection. Am I right if I continue to drive on a public road knowing that my vehicle is unsafe? I think not.
There are many things, emissions, lights in daylight, wipers when its dry, empty washer bottle etc which would result in an MoT failure but do not render the vehicle unsafe. Let's imagine my car passes the MOT but as I drive away I suffer damage to the tyres, brakes or suspension. Something that renders the vehicle unsafe although not obviously so under cursory inspection. Am I right if I continue to drive on a public road knowing that my vehicle is unsafe? I think not.
Edited by Flintstone on Sunday 27th April 18:29
Richard C said:
There are many things, emissions, lights in daylight, wipers when its dry, empty washer bottle etc which would result in an MoT failure but do not render the vehicle unsafe.
Whether it's safe or not, there's still a legal requirement that it complies with the requirements of the MOT test at all times (not just once a year). The annual test just shows that it's been inspected recently, it doesn't give you a get out of jail card for the rest of the year.Whoever wrote the letter has it wrong. An MOT is valid until it expires. Any new tests taken are recorded on the database but the pass is still recorded and is not invalidated by any subsequent failures.
The actual MOT proves nothing as far as roadworthiness is concerned, see below:
The actual MOT proves nothing as far as roadworthiness is concerned, see below:
MOT website said:
A test certificate relates only to the condition of testable items at the time of the test and should not be regarded as:
* evidence of their condition at any other time
* evidence of the general mechanical condition of the vehicle
* evidence that the vehicle fully complies with all aspects of the law on vehicle construction and use.
* evidence of their condition at any other time
* evidence of the general mechanical condition of the vehicle
* evidence that the vehicle fully complies with all aspects of the law on vehicle construction and use.
Gassing Station | Speed, Plod & the Law | Top of Page | What's New | My Stuff


