Advice on FPN for Willfull Obstruction
Advice on FPN for Willfull Obstruction
Author
Discussion

lifesabeach

Original Poster:

185 posts

238 months

Thursday 1st May 2008
quotequote all
Some advice please!!!
Yesterday evening I was due to collect my wife from Luton airport. The flight turned out to be running 2 hours late with an estimated arrival at 11.55PM!! I arrived around 11.40 and quickly found that there was no place to actually park for a few mins, so after driving around saw that a lot of cars had stopped in front on the Ibis hotel, which was a side road off the main in route.
I stopped in line with the other cars and with the engine running, took the time to check a map for a route out, as the slip road had been closed back onto the M1.
Within a few mins, a local police car arrived and started to move people on, as to be fair the road had double yellow lines on it. When the police car came along side me, I asked the driver, where I could stop for a few mins.............to which he replied "the car park of course, what do you they are they for". I agreed, but as I only expected to be in the area for a matter of mins, rather than keep driving around, I had stopped in a safe place to check map etc.
At this point the officer seemed to explode and went on to verbally abuse me on the rules of the road and double yellow lines, meaning you cant stop anywhere in the world on?? ending with, you have 1 min to put down your map and drive on.
The manner to which he was speaking, made me ask for his shoulder number, from which he jumped out of his car and shouted for me to turn my engine off as he was dealing with me with a fixed penalty, which would show his shoulder number...........
I replied that it was less than the min he had given me to move, which was replied with, I have changed my mind and your getting a ticket.
His collegue had now got out of the vehicle, (which was still running and in the middle of the road) and proceeded to fill in a "encounter stop and search record".
People were tying to arrive and leave the hotel, but the road was blocked with the police car, asking the officer if it was allowed to block the road and leave the car running, I was again told he was at liberty to do what he wanted................
The FPN was issued for wilfull obstruction??

I have noticed this morning, that the FPN issued is missing the last digit of the cars numberplate, however it is complete on the stop and search form.

My question of advice is..............should I just accept the FPN and put it down to experience, or take the matter up with a complaint and ask to go to court on the FPN form, or as its incomplete, ignore it and see what happens.....(perhaps not the best way)..

I dont have a problem for getting a ticket for wrong doing, but one min I asked being told to leave, (fair enough) but then because I asked for his ID, he decided to issue a ticket?? To me it seemed a power trip???

(I did notice however, that the whole airport is covered with double yellow lines, including the 10 min drop of zone, where I collected the wife from when she walked out...................).

biglepton

5,042 posts

232 months

Thursday 1st May 2008
quotequote all
Did it not cross your mind that the police are a trifle edgy in airports these days? You weren't driving a Jeep Cherokee with gas bottles in the back and a tea-towel on your head were you?

Double yellows mean 'no waiting', not no parking so engine on/off or map reading is not relevant. He gave you chance to move and you didn't take it. You would probably have got a second chance anywhere but an airport, so I would personally pay up and put it down to experience or blame Labour for using the threat of terrorism they have exacerbated to curtail civil liberties by exploiting fear amongst the population.

streaky

19,311 posts

280 months

Thursday 1st May 2008
quotequote all
biglepton said:
Double yellows mean 'no waiting', not no parking so engine on/off or map reading is not relevant.
True, but you may only stop to load and unload (if there are no loading restrictions) or to drop off or pick up passengers. Reading a map does not fulfil one of those criteria - Streaky

JustinP1

13,364 posts

261 months

Thursday 1st May 2008
quotequote all
lifesabeach said:
...I dont have a problem for getting a ticket for wrong doing, but one min I asked being told to leave, (fair enough) but then because I asked for his ID, he decided to issue a ticket?? To me it seemed a power trip???
OK, devil's advocate here:

You knew you were on double yellows, and the officer gave you a minute to check your map. To this you thought was 'fair enough'.

After that you then started asking for his ID, escalating the situation.

Who was on the power trip, you or him? Who was doing their job, and who provoked the reaction?

There was a willy waving contest, and you lost this one. My advice would be to move on.


esselte

14,626 posts

298 months

Thursday 1st May 2008
quotequote all
JustinP1 said:
lifesabeach said:
...I dont have a problem for getting a ticket for wrong doing, but one min I asked being told to leave, (fair enough) but then because I asked for his ID, he decided to issue a ticket?? To me it seemed a power trip???
OK, devil's advocate here:

You knew you were on double yellows, and the officer gave you a minute to check your map. To this you thought was 'fair enough'.

After that you then started asking for his ID, escalating the situation.

Who was on the power trip, you or him? Who was doing their job, and who provoked the reaction?

There was a willy waving contest, and you lost this one. My advice would be to move on.
The OP said the PC gave him verbal before the OP asked for his shoulder number.....

cptsideways

13,904 posts

283 months

Thursday 1st May 2008
quotequote all
An officer should give his ID number or warrant card without recourse or verbal abuse I do beleive. Not sure what the book says??

EU_Foreigner

2,838 posts

257 months

Thursday 1st May 2008
quotequote all
To be honest, you will always lose an argument, especially if you are weakened by being in the wrong in the first place (i.e. double yellows).

Anything to do with airports is not pleasant, the same reason I don't argue with customs or security even though you often feel inclined to thump them for their rudeness.

Ean218

2,046 posts

281 months

Thursday 1st May 2008
quotequote all
lifesabeach said:
Within a few mins, a local police car arrived and started to move people on, as to be fair the road had double yellow lines on it. When the police car came along side me, I asked the driver, where I could stop for a few mins.............to which he replied "the car park of course, what do you they are they for". I agreed, but as I only expected to be in the area for a matter of mins, rather than keep driving around, I had stopped in a safe place to check map etc.
You failed the "attitude test". The others simply moved on when asked, you started coming up with lame excuses. You were in the wrong but choose to discuss it, your mistake.

Jasandjules

72,691 posts

260 months

Thursday 1st May 2008
quotequote all
I think, though I could be wrong, the bottom line is you were on double yellows and your reason was not a valid one, so he could have issued an FPN there and then. The officer still gave you a moment to sort yourself out and move on, as all the other cars had done. You decided not to obey. Now you have an FPN.


Isoproturon1

3,641 posts

232 months

Thursday 1st May 2008
quotequote all
What's the issue with him leaving the engine running? They're fitted with run-lock.

smartie

2,630 posts

304 months

Thursday 1st May 2008
quotequote all
Isoproturon1 said:
What's the issue with him leaving the engine running? They're fitted with run-lock.
its an offence to leave an unattended car with the engine running

vonhosen

40,597 posts

248 months

Thursday 1st May 2008
quotequote all
smartie said:
Isoproturon1 said:
What's the issue with him leaving the engine running? They're fitted with run-lock.
its an offence to leave an unattended car with the engine running
Not for the emergency services it's not.

Puggit

49,832 posts

279 months

Thursday 1st May 2008
quotequote all
vonhosen said:
smartie said:
Isoproturon1 said:
What's the issue with him leaving the engine running? They're fitted with run-lock.
its an offence to leave an unattended car with the engine running
Not for the emergency services it's not.
VH - can you back up your comment. Purely out of interest, not trying to get one up!

Pooh

3,693 posts

284 months

Thursday 1st May 2008
quotequote all
My reading of this is that the police officer failed the attitude test first, he is supposed to be trained to deal with people not just explode if a member of the public asks a question, issuing a FPN as a response to a request for his badge number is a total abuse of power IMO.

smartie

2,630 posts

304 months

Thursday 1st May 2008
quotequote all
vonhosen said:
smartie said:
Isoproturon1 said:
What's the issue with him leaving the engine running? They're fitted with run-lock.
its an offence to leave an unattended car with the engine running
Not for the emergency services it's not.
Why? And even if there is an exemption, surely he should have a reason for doing it? After all, it takes a second to restart a car..... and think of the baby co2's he's killing by leaving it running!

Mr_annie_vxr

9,270 posts

242 months

Thursday 1st May 2008
quotequote all
Pooh said:
My reading of this is that the police officer failed the attitude test first, he is supposed to be trained to deal with people not just explode if a member of the public asks a question, issuing a FPN as a response to a request for his badge number is a total abuse of power IMO.
Of course we have heard both sides of the story...

You can read the ops record of events and a an experienced officer easily read between the lines and come up with the OP being out of order.

Take the flowering up out and the OP very much in the wrong, add it in and not so much... so who knows, What I do know is that go back a 15 years and you would not argue with an officer telling you to move.

Its my experience that very very few people, let alone officers go from placid to screaming looney in a few seconds and without some form of provocation.

Pooh

3,693 posts

284 months

Thursday 1st May 2008
quotequote all
Mr_annie_vxr said:
Pooh said:
My reading of this is that the police officer failed the attitude test first, he is supposed to be trained to deal with people not just explode if a member of the public asks a question, issuing a FPN as a response to a request for his badge number is a total abuse of power IMO.
Of course we have heard both sides of the story...

You can read the ops record of events and a an experienced officer easily read between the lines and come up with the OP being out of order.

Take the flowering up out and the OP very much in the wrong, add it in and not so much... so who knows, What I do know is that go back a 15 years and you would not argue with an officer telling you to move.

Its my experience that very very few people, let alone officers go from placid to screaming looney in a few seconds and without some form of provocation.
That is a fair point regarding the officers explosive reaction, assuming the OP has stretched the truth slightly and remembering that a Police Officer is probably more likely to take a fellow Police Officers side but does not excuse his reaction to being asked for his badge number.

DPX

1,027 posts

231 months

Thursday 1st May 2008
quotequote all
they do what they like when they like , just stay cool and at least 500 meters away.
If near a airport or ferry porr , channel tunnel then big special rules exist stay even cooler and go with the flow ( of what ever it is ) .

I have thought many times about getting out and letting rip , but in end I just love it after a clean search / check giving a "Be seeing you" ( from the prisoner ) , and then seeing a ciggy factory on wheels drive through.

It is always good to keep some very strange but legal object in the car for example :-
cannibus flavor condoms
new nappy with with a smear of axle grease in a super market carrier bag
blow up doll puncture repair kit ( available from novelty shops run flat repair kit )

AndyRw

740 posts

240 months

Thursday 1st May 2008
quotequote all
smartie said:
Why? And even if there is an exemption, surely he should have a reason for doing it? After all, it takes a second to restart a car..... and think of the baby co2's he's killing by leaving it running!
Obviously not privy to the exact circumstances, but I leave my vehicle on run lock for such stops to stop the onboard computer powering down (if a short stop) and in all cases if I have blue lights or rear red lights on, as they drain the battery very quickly and lead to the embarrassing situation of a flat battery and a stuck job car. Some of our cars have properly working auxiliary batteries so it is ok to turn the engine off without the computer shutting down but others don't and it takes a ridiculous amount of time to boot it up again. If I'm stopping a vehicle I'm likely to want the PNC facilities on the terminal for the stop, so I want it to stay on.

vonhosen

40,597 posts

248 months

Thursday 1st May 2008
quotequote all
smartie said:
vonhosen said:
smartie said:
Isoproturon1 said:
What's the issue with him leaving the engine running? They're fitted with run-lock.
its an offence to leave an unattended car with the engine running
Not for the emergency services it's not.
Why? And even if there is an exemption, surely he should have a reason for doing it? After all, it takes a second to restart a car..... and think of the baby co2's he's killing by leaving it running!
Why ?

Because there is an exemption written into the legislation (Reg 107(2) Road Vehicle (Construction & Use) Regulations 1986)

Edited by vonhosen on Thursday 1st May 20:56