Accident, small claims ct advice, Not his fault?
Discussion
A friend of mine had an accident when he was driving along a duel carriageway and a woman in an old Datsun came from nowhere and hit him in the side of his car. When he pulled over his car was damaged from the front door panel right down the car to the back due to the drag on impact but the woman’s car had minor damage to the front bumper. Her car was missing a front bumper light or indicator and some of the damage looked old? When questioned, the woman admitted “that was already missing” which proved her car was damaged before the accident and it may not have even been legal.
My mate had to go to his insurer to get his car rebuilt which was done without problem as right from the accident he claimed the accident was not his fault as he was just driving straight when he was hit from the side.
Sadly he has no Photos of the damage to either car but his insure should have details of his repairs.
This happened quite a while back in 2007 but out of the blue it now appears the nice woman is taking him to the small claims court for a Bill of £1800? She is claiming £600 for repairing her car and around the same for a hire car plus her XS charges and time needed off work?
I suspect the woman’s car was not insured fully comp due to its age and it would be interesting to see what repairs were done to her car for £600?
The police were not involved as no one was injured but the woman now appears to be making out it was my mates fault that she hit him? NO WIN NO FEE I SUSPECT TOO?
It now seems its just his word against hers?
He now has 14 days to dispute the claim but the sad thing is he has no witnesses so can anyone help advise him on where to go next?
Can anyone recommend someone in the Leeds area to help him defend his corner?
Will it go against him due to the lack of witnesses and will he have to pay the costs?
Cheers
H
My mate had to go to his insurer to get his car rebuilt which was done without problem as right from the accident he claimed the accident was not his fault as he was just driving straight when he was hit from the side.
Sadly he has no Photos of the damage to either car but his insure should have details of his repairs.
This happened quite a while back in 2007 but out of the blue it now appears the nice woman is taking him to the small claims court for a Bill of £1800? She is claiming £600 for repairing her car and around the same for a hire car plus her XS charges and time needed off work?
I suspect the woman’s car was not insured fully comp due to its age and it would be interesting to see what repairs were done to her car for £600?
The police were not involved as no one was injured but the woman now appears to be making out it was my mates fault that she hit him? NO WIN NO FEE I SUSPECT TOO?
It now seems its just his word against hers?
He now has 14 days to dispute the claim but the sad thing is he has no witnesses so can anyone help advise him on where to go next?
Can anyone recommend someone in the Leeds area to help him defend his corner?
Will it go against him due to the lack of witnesses and will he have to pay the costs?
Cheers
H
Erijaso said:
Just tell your mate to pass the proceedings to his motor insurers. They will instruct solicitors to act on his behalf.
HTH
Indeed, in my case. My Insurance company put in a counter claim and WON. LOL. HTH
Edited by Erijaso on Thursday 1st May 13:48
Tell him to do a drawing of the scene, and to write an account of what happened. Make him take photo's of the road layout and take them to court.
She'll have to pay the counter claim on to her insurance and the SH!T will hit fan for her. LOL silly bint.
Erijaso said:
Just tell your mate to pass the proceedings to his motor insurers. They will instruct solicitors to act on his behalf.
HTH
To be frank she is probably trying it on and would fold before court. If not, a modicum of defence would mean her claim would fail.HTH
Edited by Erijaso on Thursday 1st May 13:48
However rather than arsing around, I agree, there is no need. This is why you have insurance, let them deal with her silly claim.
My father had exactly the same when someone pulled out of a side street into him.
They claimed through the small claims court and supplied a neighbour as a witness who hadn't been at the scene at the time .Noone was there at the time as my father had looked around for a witness himself.
He had to stump up because he had no counter witness.
Small claims courts should not be allowed to adjudicate motor claims its b
ks the lack of evidence they will allow.
Are you sure you didn't have a witness.?
They claimed through the small claims court and supplied a neighbour as a witness who hadn't been at the scene at the time .Noone was there at the time as my father had looked around for a witness himself.
He had to stump up because he had no counter witness.
Small claims courts should not be allowed to adjudicate motor claims its b
ks the lack of evidence they will allow.Are you sure you didn't have a witness.?

Gassing Station | Speed, Plod & the Law | Top of Page | What's New | My Stuff


