"Full and final settlement"
"Full and final settlement"
Author
Discussion

supermono

Original Poster:

7,464 posts

279 months

Sunday 4th May 2008
quotequote all
My local council keep demanding too much council tax and despite my laying out the correct calculation, I've just had a final demand for the wrong amount.

They're demanding £B but I'm offering £A where A<B (justification irrelevant here). So I sent a cheque for A saying it's an offer of full and final settlement and if they cash it I will not enter into any further correspondence and will consider my 2007/2008 liability discharged.

So I get a reply from this bloke saying someone else cashed the cheque before he'd had a chance to read the letter and that he refuses to accept full and final settlement. And that if I wish to recall the cheque I must speak to my bank about it. The implication is that this cheque is a partial payment.

Now he can't do that can he? I mean basically someone authorised to deal with council tax got my letter, read it, detached the cheque and cashed it but this bloke disagrees with him.

So what do I do? It sounds like a standard scam they've worked out to deal with this sort of thing, where they get whatever money they can but then go after the rest even of the payment was supposed to be full and final...

I'd appreciate some advice thanks.

SM

Boosted LS1

21,200 posts

291 months

Sunday 4th May 2008
quotequote all
I can't offer advice but it's an interesting situation. If I end up in a similar situation I might write full and final settlement on the cheque itself. Good luck.

Mandat

4,656 posts

269 months

Sunday 4th May 2008
quotequote all
I always thought that "full and final settlement" did not have much legal standing and that just simply writting it on a cheque does not prevent the party cashing it as partial payment, chasing for the remainder of a legaly due debt.

DonnyMac

3,634 posts

234 months

Sunday 4th May 2008
quotequote all
Boosted LS1 said:
I can't offer advice but it's an interesting situation. If I end up in a similar situation I might write full and final settlement on the cheque itself. Good luck.
Beat me to it.

Hooks

95 posts

268 months

Sunday 4th May 2008
quotequote all
i do recall case law about this, it was concerning a utility company where the payment and correspondance depatments were separate. basically, letters arrived and were opened by the post boy, payment cheques went to one department and the letter to another. in that case it was held that the company could not be exected to know in advance about stipulations in the letter and therefore the 'full and final settlement' was rejected by the cout. i know its specific to that case, but id imagine there may be a similar set up in the council.

supermono

Original Poster:

7,464 posts

279 months

Sunday 4th May 2008
quotequote all
I just read similar case law. Seems very odd that a judge can uphold a system with this flaw designed into it, but there you are. It seems reasonable to me that if the cheque is stapled to a letter the whole thing needs to go to the department.

Maybe I'll get in touch with the bank then on Tuesday.

So if he was serious about not wanting to accept the payment, wouldn't he have sent me a refund? Rather than make me go to the trouble and expense of stopping a cheque. A further question: if I take time off work, go to the bank, pay to have the cheque cancelled, can I charge him for this? After all he mistakenly cashed it and invited me to cancel it.

Is him not sending a refund important here?

SM

peterguk V6 KWK

2,622 posts

248 months

Sunday 4th May 2008
quotequote all
So let me get this right - the OP doesn't fancy paying his council tax bill like the rest of us, just what he thinks is a fair amount.....

Good luck.

odyssey2200

18,650 posts

240 months

Sunday 4th May 2008
quotequote all
Supermono

I have similar issues with my Local Council.

Quite frankly they could not organise a piss up in a brewery.

It has now cost me £350 in solicitors fees because they lost 2 letters I sent them and while aknowledging a third took 2 months and 3 reminders from me before doing anything.

There now accuse me of fraud and I had to go through an interview under caution!

I would point out to your guys that "the council" cashed your check and is therefore deemed to have accepted your terms.

Vicarious Liability IIRC.

My advise is to get hold of your local councillor and send him a detailed account of your tale of woe and make him earn his keep.



Edited by odyssey2200 on Sunday 4th May 18:04

supermono

Original Poster:

7,464 posts

279 months

Sunday 4th May 2008
quotequote all
peterguk V6 KWK said:
So let me get this right - the OP doesn't fancy paying his council tax bill like the rest of us, just what he thinks is a fair amount.....

Good luck.
Their bill is calculated wrongly.

SM
edited to remove expletive aimed at member.

Edited by supermono on Sunday 4th May 18:07

supermono

Original Poster:

7,464 posts

279 months

Sunday 4th May 2008
quotequote all
odyssey2200 said:
My advise is to get hold of your local councillor and send him a detailed account of your tale of woe and make him earn his keep.
That's a great idea. I might well write to him/her.

SM

Jasandjules

72,694 posts

260 months

Sunday 4th May 2008
quotequote all
Was the cheque stapled to the letter?

supermono

Original Poster:

7,464 posts

279 months

Sunday 4th May 2008
quotequote all
Jasandjules said:
Was the cheque stapled to the letter?
Yes. And his letter talks about it being detached before he got to read the letter.

SM

odyssey2200

18,650 posts

240 months

Sunday 4th May 2008
quotequote all
supermono said:
odyssey2200 said:
My advise is to get hold of your local councillor and send him a detailed account of your tale of woe and make him earn his keep.
That's a great idea. I might well write to him/her.

SM
Sod writing!!

look on your LC website and ours has actual contact details.

I rang the council and tey gave me his mobile number.

The guy has been very helpful and as an added bonus he hate the MMGW PC brigadehehe so we had quite a chat!

onedsla

1,135 posts

287 months

Sunday 4th May 2008
quotequote all
http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Pinnel's_Case

I belive you still owe B - A.

NB - not my area of law

DPX

1,027 posts

231 months

Sunday 4th May 2008
quotequote all
So I get a reply from this bloke saying someone else cashed the cheque before he'd had a chance to read the letter and that he refuses to accept full and final settlement. And that if I wish to recall the cheque I must speak to my bank about it. The implication is that this cheque is a partial payment.

if they mess up u have to live with it , they have final say ,anything you have is bla bla . They have far more resource to fight you than you have to fight them . Next time do it in a way that they cannot wiggle out .

And if you find a way there are 0000's listening

Good luck

Jasandjules

72,694 posts

260 months

Monday 5th May 2008
quotequote all
supermono said:
Jasandjules said:
Was the cheque stapled to the letter?
Yes. And his letter talks about it being detached before he got to read the letter.

SM
Then I think you have a problem, as he didn't accept your terms.

Cancel that cheque, send another one with full and final settlement written on the back........See if they bank it... biggrin

And take a photocopy of your cheque before you post it.


Edited by Jasandjules on Monday 5th May 09:12

supermono

Original Poster:

7,464 posts

279 months

Tuesday 6th May 2008
quotequote all
Reading case law, there's something about the IR who were found to be ok about cashing it and not accepting the terms because they have a post handler who cashes cheques and passes on the letters. It seemed that case turned on the intention of the parties. Because the IR bod telephoned the taxpayer and offered a refund immediately because of the mistake, the intention was found to be not to cash the cheque/accept the terms.

In my case the original bod cashed the cheque, and the subsequent bod has done nothing to reverse that. I'm thinking the intention of the council was obviously to cash the cheque but ignore my terms instead treating it as a partial payment. I don't think that putting the onus on me to cancel it really changes that position -- indeed the letter was too late for me even to be able to do that.

I think I'll write to him suggesting that since the letter arrived too late, he can post me a refund if it was his intention not to cash the cheque, otherwise I'll be happy for a judge to make the decision as to his intention.

Blimey it's only a matter of < 100 quid FFS, AND the only reason they've overbilled me is because of their and another council's incompetence. Talk about a waste of tax payers' money!

SM