Staying Silent if arrested?
Discussion
It's a slow day today...
Reading the thread in P&P about have you ever been convicted of something you didn't do, got me thinking.
A numer of years ago when i was a green behind the ears 18 year old working in a ski chalet, we hosted a large number of the met's finest. In one of the (few) sober moments during the week, when we (the staff) generally enquired 'What should we do if we're ever arrested?' they replied almost unanimously with 'don't say anything' qualifying it by saying if they've got enough evidence they'll charge you anyway and by talking, you may likely incriminate yourself further.
Now, would the BIB here agree?
This is purely hypothetical and based on no scenario (i.e. you eiher did or didn't do it). Just interested if you share the view, or whether if you hadn't commited the offence, you should speak up?!
Reading the thread in P&P about have you ever been convicted of something you didn't do, got me thinking.
A numer of years ago when i was a green behind the ears 18 year old working in a ski chalet, we hosted a large number of the met's finest. In one of the (few) sober moments during the week, when we (the staff) generally enquired 'What should we do if we're ever arrested?' they replied almost unanimously with 'don't say anything' qualifying it by saying if they've got enough evidence they'll charge you anyway and by talking, you may likely incriminate yourself further.
Now, would the BIB here agree?
This is purely hypothetical and based on no scenario (i.e. you eiher did or didn't do it). Just interested if you share the view, or whether if you hadn't commited the offence, you should speak up?!
Chrispy Porker said:
You cannot get a caution unless you admit the offence.
If you are otherwise eligible to be cautioned, it would be daft to stay silent and get a charge, and court appearance instead.
Do you know before you have the opportunity to admit to the offence that, if you do so, you'll only get a caution?If you are otherwise eligible to be cautioned, it would be daft to stay silent and get a charge, and court appearance instead.
HRG said:
How about "I do not understand the full legal ramifications of the caution. I would like to seek legal advice before I make any comment".
Repeat to fade....
You can do that yes, however then you will have to prove to the court that you are too thick to understand it. Usually, if the officer suspects you are too stupid to understand it, he will break it down into very simplistic statements etc. If you don't speak English well (or claim not to) then you can be arrested instead I think and an interpreter gets involved instead.Repeat to fade....
You are not entitled to seek legal advice before making the comment, that's the whole point. If you NEED to ask a lawyer what to say, what do you think is a logical inference to be drawn?
Jasandjules said:
HRG said:
How about "I do not understand the full legal ramifications of the caution. I would like to seek legal advice before I make any comment".
Repeat to fade....
You can do that yes, however then you will have to prove to the court that you are too thick to understand it. Usually, if the officer suspects you are too stupid to understand it, he will break it down into very simplistic statements etc. If you don't speak English well (or claim not to) then you can be arrested instead I think and an interpreter gets involved instead.Repeat to fade....
You are not entitled to seek legal advice before making the comment, that's the whole point. If you NEED to ask a lawyer what to say, what do you think is a logical inference to be drawn?
HRG said:
The law is complex, not the caution. I would need to have a full understanding of my rights and obligations before I answer. If I do not have a right to legal counsel I would like someone impartial to confirm that.
However, you are not asked if you wish to plead guilty to an offence contrary to S1 of the Theft Act etc.. and given a copy of Archbold to read and make sure. You are told you are being cautioned for being suspected of an offence, let's say theft of a car at 9am last Thursday, and you don't say anything.Then, once you've spoken to your lawyer, you "suddenly remember" that you were in fact at home alone that night etc etc.. or out with a mate....
That's the point of adverse inferences drawn from a failure to make any statements which you later rely upon in evidence. You do have a right to counsel, the point is IF asked where were you last Thursday you don't answer, then after speaking to lawyer do "recall" where you were and who you were with etc.. then the question is why didn't you already mention that to plod to ensure you weren't arrested and a quick chat to your mate could eliminate you from their enquiries....
Jasandjules said:
HRG said:
The law is complex, not the caution. I would need to have a full understanding of my rights and obligations before I answer. If I do not have a right to legal counsel I would like someone impartial to confirm that.
However, you are not asked if you wish to plead guilty to an offence contrary to S1 of the Theft Act etc.. and given a copy of Archbold to read and make sure. You are told you are being cautioned for being suspected of an offence, let's say theft of a car at 9am last Thursday, and you don't say anything.Then, once you've spoken to your lawyer, you "suddenly remember" that you were in fact at home alone that night etc etc.. or out with a mate....
That's the point of adverse inferences drawn from a failure to make any statements which you later rely upon in evidence. You do have a right to counsel, the point is IF asked where were you last Thursday you don't answer, then after speaking to lawyer do "recall" where you were and who you were with etc.. then the question is why didn't you already mention that to plod to ensure you weren't arrested and a quick chat to your mate could eliminate you from their enquiries....
HRG said:
Oh don't get me wrong, I'm not refusing to talk, I would just like to clarify the ramifications of what you just said.
The ramifications are that it may harm your defence (i.e. they are not as likely to believe it) if you later attempt to rely upon something that you didn't mention when questioned.Jasandjules said:
HRG said:
Oh don't get me wrong, I'm not refusing to talk, I would just like to clarify the ramifications of what you just said.
The ramifications are that it may harm your defence (i.e. they are not as likely to believe it) if you later attempt to rely upon something that you didn't mention when questioned.As I said, if I was in the same situation again, I would say the absolute bare minimum necessary and, once the direction of the questioning becomes apparant, take proper legal advice from the solicitor present.
Jasandjules said:
HRG said:
Oh don't get me wrong, I'm not refusing to talk, I would just like to clarify the ramifications of what you just said.
The ramifications are that it may harm your defence (i.e. they are not as likely to believe it) if you later attempt to rely upon something that you didn't mention when questioned.Jasandjules said:
... If you don't speak English well (or claim not to) then you can be arrested instead I think and an interpreter gets involved instead.
One thing I've wondered about (although not for long on any occasion) is, what if the BiB can't find an interpreter (in time)? - StreakyPS - my native tongue is one of the 800 or so languages and dialects of Papua New Guinea. It does not have a name.
- Sstreaky said:
One thing I've wondered about (although not for long on any occasion) is, what if the BiB can't find an interpreter (in time)? - Streaky
PS - my native tongue is one of the 800 or so languages and dialects of Papua New Guinea. It does not have a name.
- S
For "roadside" enquiries I just call "Language Line" on my mobile - I have a copy of the "Point to your language" poster in my folder.PS - my native tongue is one of the 800 or so languages and dialects of Papua New Guinea. It does not have a name.
- SThis also works in custody, but obviously not for interviews. The firm that provides the interpreters has it in the contract that they have to be able to provide within a timescale (but I'm not sure what this is).
PNG might cause us a few problmes though...
Well the first line of the caution you should be given upon arrest is "You do not have to say anything".
This means your right to silence has not been abolished so you can choose to say nothing.
However, the next line of the caution states
"But it mat harm your defence if you do not mention when questioned/now something that you may later rely on in court"
This means that the court will ask you why you have not accounted for yourself before going to court. They could choose to discount what you say in court as you may have had time to get a rather elaborate version of events into your mind to try and get off the charge etc.
The last part of the caution is "Anything you do say may be given in evidence".
Which means any reply to caution can be used in court. You are also given the caution when you go into interview, there are 3 copies of the tape, a working copy, a copy for you or your legal rep and a copy for the courts to play back if required. The court copy is sealed so can only be opened in court.
Id suggest not staying silent, its best to get your version of events over.
This means your right to silence has not been abolished so you can choose to say nothing.
However, the next line of the caution states
"But it mat harm your defence if you do not mention when questioned/now something that you may later rely on in court"
This means that the court will ask you why you have not accounted for yourself before going to court. They could choose to discount what you say in court as you may have had time to get a rather elaborate version of events into your mind to try and get off the charge etc.
The last part of the caution is "Anything you do say may be given in evidence".
Which means any reply to caution can be used in court. You are also given the caution when you go into interview, there are 3 copies of the tape, a working copy, a copy for you or your legal rep and a copy for the courts to play back if required. The court copy is sealed so can only be opened in court.
Id suggest not staying silent, its best to get your version of events over.
Edited by Greendubber on Tuesday 6th May 15:46
Gassing Station | Speed, Plod & the Law | Top of Page | What's New | My Stuff


