DNA database solves one crime for every 800 new entries
DNA database solves one crime for every 800 new entries
Author
Discussion

streaky

Original Poster:

19,311 posts

280 months

Tuesday 6th May 2008
quotequote all
Dail telegraph said:
Only one crime is solved for every 800 new profiles added to the Government's DNA database, it emerged yesterday.

The database, now the biggest of its kind in the world, holds the profiles of a million innocent people who have never been convicted or charged.

But despite a huge expansion last year, it has helped to solve fewer than 1,000 extra crimes.

The Home Office claims the vast bank of information is a "key intelligence tool" in fighting crime. But critics say the figures prove the intrusion into privacy is unjustified.

Michael Parker, of NO2ID, a civil liberties campaign group, said: "It ties up police officers with fingerprinting innocent people when they should be targeting known criminals."

In 2006/7 an extra 661,433 profiles were added – the equivalent of 76 per hour. However, the number of crimes detected only rose by 839 to 41,148.

The cost of holding all the extra information was about £3 million, which could have paid for the training, equipment and salaries of 60 extra police officers.

The database now holds 4.5 million samples, including 150,000 children under 16 and 334,000 aged from 16 to 18.
So, extrapolating, adding the entire UK population (approximately 65.7 m - CIA World Fact Book July 2007 - from age 0 to 65+)) would increase the number of crimes solved by some 8.2m. For 2006/7 the British Crime Survey reported 11.3 m crimes (stable), whereas the 'police recorded' crime figures were 5.4m (down 2%).

No doubt the Home Office would claim that, on the basis of 'police recorded' crime, DNA-printing the entire UK population would eliminate undetected crime. Of course that's not true, as, despite what Brumsturmfurher thinks, not all motorists are criminals, and neither are all citizens. Further, while the figure is 1/800 now, the Law of Diminishing Returns will take greater and greater effect as more and more data are added to the Register, reducing the number of crimes solved by the number of new entries.

Streaky

Edited by streaky on Tuesday 6th May 18:22

Chrispy Porker

17,763 posts

259 months

Tuesday 6th May 2008
quotequote all
I think the word 'yet' is missing somewhere.
Who is to say how many crimes will be detected in the future using the current database.?

Plotloss

67,280 posts

301 months

Tuesday 6th May 2008
quotequote all
So a million completely innocent people having had their details lodged have led to 1000 crimes (of indeterminate seriousness) being solved.

Brilliant.

More than justification for such Orwellian control freak nonsense.

This fking country.

Chrispy Porker

17,763 posts

259 months

Tuesday 6th May 2008
quotequote all
Mr Parker seems to be muddled.
He is talking about fingerprints.
Which are taken, in custody, by a civilian. I fail to see how that is wasting officers time quite honestly.