You couldn't make it up,,,,, or could you
You couldn't make it up,,,,, or could you
Author
Discussion

whyohwhy

Original Poster:

280 posts

243 months

Wednesday 7th May 2008
quotequote all
Driver 'sped' for epileptic wife
A man is facing a speeding fine after his wife suffered an epileptic fit while he was driving.

Full-time carer Sydney Duffy, 63, was clocked at 35mph in a 30mph zone when his wife Rovina became ill on Beacon Edge, Penrith, on 23 February.

He said his foot hit the accelerator because he turned to check on his wife. Mr Duffy has been ordered to appear in court after failing to pay a fine.

Cumbria Police said the court would listen to mitigating circumstances.

Mr Duffy, of Penrith, said he was shocked at the decision to go ahead with a prosecution.

He said: "I was travelling at 30mph when the attack occurred.

"My priority was to get Rovina in a position where she could not harm herself while thrashing around.

"I was also frightened she would swallow her tongue."

Fixed penalty

Mr Duffy was caught by a mobile speed camera near his home.

He added: "Rovina fits three or four times a day. I know it's coming because she gets an excruciating pain in the back of the head, grabs it, and then starts thrashing about."

A letter sent from the central ticket office of Cumbria Police said: "While we sympathise with the circumstances surrounding your wife's health, and in particular on this journey, your speed was within the parameters where a fixed penalty will be processed and therefore the penalty will stand.

"Our file has already been submitted to the prosecutions department and you will be sent the relevant paperwork.

"At the court hearing you will be given the opportunity to put all your mitigation to the magistrates."



bigdods

7,175 posts

258 months

Wednesday 7th May 2008
quotequote all
Book him danno...

Seriously if she suffers 4 attacks a day then its something he should be expecting and therefore have an action plan. Like oh I dont know, maybe stop the car then sort her out ? Not being in control on what sounds like a regular basis , he'll be lucky if they dont increase the fine.

10 Pence Short

32,880 posts

248 months

Wednesday 7th May 2008
quotequote all
It's a tough one. I only live abut 15 minutes from there, too. The road is about 30 feet wide with residential on one side and fields on the other. Coming into the 30 limit you're coming downhill from a section of NSL. Visibility is a good 400 yards into it.

Very, very few people are doing 30mph when they first enter the 30mph section.

I'm not sure I see too much leeway from the Mags with the mitigation, in that if she fits regularly, you should already be prepared to deal with it in a lawful way, and it's much safer to stop by the roadside than to speed up in a residential road if she does fit.

Edited by 10 Pence Short on Wednesday 7th May 13:23

Plotloss

67,280 posts

301 months

Wednesday 7th May 2008
quotequote all
+10%+2mph

So he's already at the minimum recommended prosecutable speed with a wife having a seizure.

Why exactly is this seeing a court and thus being a burden on the taxpayer?

Utterly absurd, the local constabulary/council should be appalled at their inability to be pragmatic.

10 Pence Short

32,880 posts

248 months

Wednesday 7th May 2008
quotequote all
Plotloss said:
+10%+2mph

So he's already at the minimum recommended prosecutable speed with a wife having a seizure.

Why exactly is this seeing a court and thus being a burden on the taxpayer?

Utterly absurd, the local constabulary/council should be appalled at their inability to be pragmatic.
I agree.

It's going to court because the FP wasn't taken up and the Police won't drop it.

Davi

17,153 posts

251 months

Wednesday 7th May 2008
quotequote all
bigdods said:
Book him danno...

Seriously if she suffers 4 attacks a day then its something he should be expecting and therefore have an action plan. Like oh I dont know, maybe stop the car then sort her out ? Not being in control on what sounds like a regular basis , he'll be lucky if they dont increase the fine.
I think it's quite ironic that he is probably a greater danger to other road users for something he would probably never be pulled up on, than for the charge he has been.

Soton Pug

374 posts

226 months

Wednesday 7th May 2008
quotequote all
Although I agree that pulling over or even hitting the hazards and coming to abrupt holt would be a safer way of dealing with the situation, taking it to court so they can decide that mitigating circumstances renders the charge nul and void is complete waste of time and money IMO.

Surely time could be better spent dealing with more serious issues?

Hooli

32,278 posts

231 months

Wednesday 7th May 2008
quotequote all
bigdods said:
Book him danno...

Seriously if she suffers 4 attacks a day then its something he should be expecting and therefore have an action plan. Like oh I dont know, maybe stop the car then sort her out ? Not being in control on what sounds like a regular basis , he'll be lucky if they dont increase the fine.
got to agree with that.
something so regular & you cant deal with it in a calm collected way?

R5GTTgaz

7,897 posts

251 months

Wednesday 7th May 2008
quotequote all
Sounds like a fitting punishment.

bcnrml

2,107 posts

241 months

Wednesday 7th May 2008
quotequote all
Economists like to talk of the concept of value-add (something akin to profit, based on inputs and outputs).

This case - and many others involving the vindictive pursuit of motorists - makes me even more certain that the UK system is now one that destroys value and undermines productivity.

How can it make sense to prosecute? Surely if he claimed the same mitigation for repeated speeding, he might be seen as taking the mickey.

But I'm no longer amazed. We're the best in Europe, I suspect, at towing cars that are not causing obstructions, clamping cars that have overstayed their time in bays, and doing little or nothing about it!

eldar

25,366 posts

227 months

Wednesday 7th May 2008
quotequote all
bigdods said:
Book him danno...

Seriously if she suffers 4 attacks a day then its something he should be expecting and therefore have an action plan. Like oh I dont know, maybe stop the car then sort her out ? Not being in control on what sounds like a regular basis , he'll be lucky if they dont increase the fine.
Action plan like what? Emergency stop, maybe. Find somewhere safe to stop to get the situation under control, I'd guess. Whatever, I suspect that ensuring you don't let your speed drift up a couple of miles an hour would come secondary to ( I think 35 mph is the lower limit for speeding in a 30) avoiding injury.

stuttgartmetal

8,167 posts

247 months

Wednesday 7th May 2008
quotequote all
black or white law
commie pinko shysters

Stefluc

274 posts

240 months

Wednesday 7th May 2008
quotequote all
What is more dangerous the 5mph over the limit or the constant turning around taking one or both hands off the wheel to see to his loved one,his luck is bound to run out and no doubt it will be for the wrong one.
He will probably take someone else or more out and all because he is too lazy to pull up immediately and tend to her properly,even though he might stop in an in appropriate place but at least he might get the chance to explain to a human who would stop (T.O.)if it was that dangerous. So, perhaps the authoritys know that this is the case and are trying to prevent it by speed fine. Imagine what you would say if he turned around for a split second and drifted across the road into the bus stop or into you or a loved one head on.
The police are not here to make friends they are here to serve and protect although you wouldnt think so sometimes if we listen to others .
He will get his day in court and hopefully it will be sorted in a way that he know what to do in future.
Stefluc

carrotchomper

18,334 posts

235 months

Wednesday 7th May 2008
quotequote all
Come on, does anyone else think the defence "I turned around to see my wife and hit the accelerator" sounds a little pony? I suspect this fit will be on the video, if replayed..

Jasandjules

72,695 posts

260 months

Wednesday 7th May 2008
quotequote all
Soton Pug said:
Surely time could be better spent dealing with more serious issues?
What's more serious than speeding in the UK these days?!?!?!

Mg6b

6,649 posts

294 months

Wednesday 7th May 2008
quotequote all
scratchchin

So he notices wife having a fit because she is thrashing about in the passenger seat and his attention and concern is about making sure his wife is not in danger. Whilst all this is occurring which is also a regular occurrence, he hits the accelerator and at that very unfortunate moment happens to ping a speed camera!

Call me cynical......

Most people in a situation like that would go for the brake!

WildCat

8,369 posts

274 months

Wednesday 7th May 2008
quotequote all
Mg6b said:
scratchchin

So he notices wife having a fit because she is thrashing about in the passenger seat and his attention and concern is about making sure his wife is not in danger. Whilst all this is occurring which is also a regular occurrence, he hits the accelerator and at that very unfortunate moment happens to ping a speed camera!

Call me cynical......

Most people in a situation like that would go for the brake!
WIth respect .. fits do not "come to order"./ They just happen Liebchen love

But regardless of how "used to" the carer may be.. it still UN_NERVES und UNSETTLES.

I suggest you try living like that for 6-9 months. I think you soon changey tuney herewink

It NOT easy to care for any person with disability.

Fits.. episodes occur. They do not occur to order und given we now have forests of the darned things .. plus any old van here .. it can be very possible for driver to be confronted with a distraction which will unsettle -even if he "accustomed"wink

But live with it. Then spit venom. I can assure you that venom will be aimed at "so called social helpers" though whistle But please .. find someone in this situation und swap place for a week. I think you might meet reality.

bcnrml

2,107 posts

241 months

Thursday 8th May 2008
quotequote all
WildCat said:
Mg6b said:
scratchchin

So he notices wife having a fit because she is thrashing about in the passenger seat and his attention and concern is about making sure his wife is not in danger. Whilst all this is occurring which is also a regular occurrence, he hits the accelerator and at that very unfortunate moment happens to ping a speed camera!

Call me cynical......

Most people in a situation like that would go for the brake!
WIth respect .. fits do not "come to order"./ They just happen Liebchen love

But regardless of how "used to" the carer may be.. it still UN_NERVES und UNSETTLES.

I suggest you try living like that for 6-9 months. I think you soon changey tuney herewink

It NOT easy to care for any person with disability.

Fits.. episodes occur. They do not occur to order und given we now have forests of the darned things .. plus any old van here .. it can be very possible for driver to be confronted with a distraction which will unsettle -even if he "accustomed"wink

But live with it. Then spit venom. I can assure you that venom will be aimed at "so called social helpers" though whistle But please .. find someone in this situation und swap place for a week. I think you might meet reality.
Agreed, Wildcat, especially with your last two sentences - so I'm looking forward to seeing the sceptics volunteering to drive around epileptics for a few days (never mind a few months or years). biggrin

There was a thread on here about a person caring for a family member getting issued a ticket (FPN) whilst administering such (unpaid) care. This case reminds me of it. Totally unreasonable and utterly destructive, whilst wasting taxpayers' money.

The Count

3,417 posts

294 months

Thursday 8th May 2008
quotequote all
R5GTTgaz said:
Sounds like a fitting punishment.
I noticed Gaz hehe

Mr_annie_vxr

9,270 posts

242 months

Thursday 8th May 2008
quotequote all
WildCat said:
Mg6b said:
scratchchin

So he notices wife having a fit because she is thrashing about in the passenger seat and his attention and concern is about making sure his wife is not in danger. Whilst all this is occurring which is also a regular occurrence, he hits the accelerator and at that very unfortunate moment happens to ping a speed camera!

Call me cynical......

Most people in a situation like that would go for the brake!
WIth respect .. fits do not "come to order"./ They just happen Liebchen love

But regardless of how "used to" the carer may be.. it still UN_NERVES und UNSETTLES.

I suggest you try living like that for 6-9 months. I think you soon changey tuney herewink

It NOT easy to care for any person with disability.

Fits.. episodes occur. They do not occur to order und given we now have forests of the darned things .. plus any old van here .. it can be very possible for driver to be confronted with a distraction which will unsettle -even if he "accustomed"wink

But live with it. Then spit venom. I can assure you that venom will be aimed at "so called social helpers" though whistle But please .. find someone in this situation und swap place for a week. I think you might meet reality.
If they are that dangerous a passenger they have no place in your car. If this chap looked away from the road and accelerated thats careless driving.

Personaly I think he is trying to be clever and may be causing himself problems or is trying to argue autonomism type defence.

I have dealt with numerous epileptics some severe some not but if you take a severe epileptic in your car uor first obligation is to the safety of the car and other road users. If you cannot concentrate on driving and remain calm then you have no place on the road. Looking behind you whilst driving forward is not a great way to keep safe.