what should the speed limits be?
what should the speed limits be?
Author
Discussion

Gold Rolex

Original Poster:

38 posts

222 months

Saturday 10th May 2008
quotequote all
Seeing as it's some kind of mantra on here to preach that speed plays no part in any accident, what do people think the speed limits should be on our roads?

Should we even have speed limits at all? Should we try and keep peoples speed down? should we try and reduce the seriousness of injuries in accidents? after all, hitting somebody at 30 mph in a 30 mph zone will result in 80% of the pedestrians living, but hitting them at 40mph in a 30mph zone will result in only 20% of them living... so, should we have speed limits to try and protect innocent people, or should we allow everybody to drive at what ever speed they feel is safe for them?

Jon Ison

1,304 posts

264 months

Saturday 10th May 2008
quotequote all
IMHO,

Built up areas, schools, hospitals housing estates, yes sure we should have limits and yes they should be enforced, for example anyone speeding by a school should have the book thrown at them, end of.

Now, the problem I have is when speed limits are enforced on a 2 lane duel carriageway for example, 30 miles from any built up area on a stretch or road so straight you could land a jumbo on it but with a solitary tree to hind behind with a tax van.

Jasandjules

72,694 posts

260 months

Saturday 10th May 2008
quotequote all
People not strolling in the roads would reduce their chances of being hit by quite a lot as well...

However, speed limits - I'm happy with 30 limits in built up areas, I'd be happy to reduce it to 20 around schools (during school term and times) I'm happy with 60 on some single lane roads, though it could be increased to say 70 if it is like half of the Norfolk roads I've driven on, long, straight, no junctions for miles etc..

Motorway I can't see why 80-90 isn't a problem, realistically if we could improve the driving of the MLMs etc.. then 100 for a 3 lane road shouldn't be the end of the world either.

Most of my problems come from stupidly slow limits on the roads that exist rather than a need to increase the limits (i.e. the raft of 40s and 50s which have appeared on DCs with no houses for miles, yet the requisite scamera appears as well, by coincidence).

So, if we had speed limits which were "sensible" then most people would obey them. And I think the preponderance of most people to ignore them shows the majority of limits are not sensible (plenty of old fogies cruise along at 42mph in 30 limits).

Gold Rolex

Original Poster:

38 posts

222 months

Saturday 10th May 2008
quotequote all
I understand what you're saying, but don't you think that having roads with speed limits that are specific to that particular road will just lead to mass confusion? what if you miss the sign at the start of a particular road... people won't have a clue what the speed limit is on that particular road, then you'll get people complaining that it's not their fault they got done for speeding as they didn't catch the sign as they entered that stretch of road and they wasn't sure what the limit was

the only solution is to have single speed limits for each type of road, which we have right now

Jon Ison

1,304 posts

264 months

Saturday 10th May 2008
quotequote all
Gold Rolex said:
the only solution is to have single speed limits for each type of road, which we have right now
Do we ?

Charlieromeo

153 posts

261 months

Saturday 10th May 2008
quotequote all
I think the problem with speed limits is that if set too high then the minority abuse at the expense of other sensible 'fast' drivers. My recent experiences of speaking to so called 'speedy drivers' include:

  • A Mini Cooper S being followed by a Impreza - approximately 2 inches from it's chuff
  • A Civic Type-R again driving merely inches from the backside of a Aston DB7 in some expression of this sort of thing being 'sporty' and merely an expression of his driving 'skill'.
Needless to say the same old excuses came out "I wasn't really going that fast" and "I wasn't really that close" well 90 mph and a stopping distance of approximately 2 feet are far too stupid to even contemplate..... I did add that I wasn't really concerned for their own lives, far from it, and far more concerned about the family wagons in the left hand lane they would wipe out as they crumpled into each other.

As such we have a low limit in this country due to having to deal with the lowest common denominator - drivers (in crap and expensive metal) that haven't got a clue.

twister

1,595 posts

267 months

Saturday 10th May 2008
quotequote all
Jon Ison said:
Gold Rolex said:
the only solution is to have single speed limits for each type of road, which we have right now
Do we ?
Mmm, I thought the current situation with limits was far closer to the confusing muddle the shiny timekeeping one mentioned as being a bad thing... In the last few years I've noticed an increasing disconnect between the look and feel of a road and the limit being applied to it, especially when you travel between different parts of the country or even just adjacent counties - there might be a bit more consistency within a county, but when you don't need one of those "Welcome to Wibbleshire" signs to tell you you've changed counties because there's a completely arbitrary change of limit marking the border despite no change whatsoever in the nature of the road, then you know something has gone wrong with the whole limit setting process.

Granted, what GR might have meant is that we do still have a simple set of national limits for each type of road, but the days when you could reasonably rely on using these as a guide to the actual limit on a given stretch of road in the apparent absence of any signage to the contrary are long gone.

Brett928S2

1,504 posts

246 months

Saturday 10th May 2008
quotequote all
Hi smile

30 mph in Town

Unlimited elsewhere

IMHO....

All the best Brett smile

Vaux

1,558 posts

247 months

Saturday 10th May 2008
quotequote all
Gold Rolex said:
....hitting somebody at 30 mph in a 30 mph zone will result in 80% of the pedestrians living, but hitting them at 40mph in a 30mph zone will result in only 20% of them living... so, should we have speed limits to try and protect innocent people, or should we allow everybody to drive at what ever speed they feel is safe for them?
Hitting someone at 40 in a 60 will hurt too, but at least it's legal.
How about teaching people how to cross roads and maybe have a jay walking law?
The anti speed propaganda is working.
I observe for the IAM and I'm hearing more and more from new Associates "Why is this road NSL? You can't possibly do 60 round this bend, why don't they (the council) reduce the speed limit?" It's a struggle.

Jasandjules

72,694 posts

260 months

Saturday 10th May 2008
quotequote all
Gold Rolex said:
the only solution is to have single speed limits for each type of road, which we have right now
Which country do you live in?

F i F

49,036 posts

282 months

Saturday 10th May 2008
quotequote all
Well I put my views on page 7 of this thread.

Back in the time I am talking about on one of those posts, the unofficial situation seemed to be, and was certainly the one I applied to myself then was, red ringed limit, obey 100%. It was there for a reason, councils did not spend money for the sake of it, oh the irony of that comment I know.

NSL well a little more flexibility without taking the pee. If I had been stopped or nicked for speeding in an NSL hen I believe I would have taken it like a trooper and stiff upper lip, if guilty. I was never so nicked, or even stopped, for speeding in an NSL, only time stopped for alleged OPL was for 40 in a 40. Yes you did read that right, 40 in a 40, the copper had made a genuine mistake and missed the 40 sign exiting the roundabout from a 30. No acrimony no hard feelings on my side, though he was a bit miffed when he found he'd also confronted a 3 pipper.

I'd like to go back to the situation where all limits are reviewed, and training levels are such that people can make sensible appropriate speed decisions. Local DCs which were NSL and are now 40/50 limits have SC roads subject to NSL leading off them. Everything from wide open roads where very fast speeds are safe and appropriate if not legal, down to little nadgery lanes where 15-20mph can be pushing it at times.

If I can be trusted to drive appropriately on those roads why can I not be trusted to drive appropriately on the wide 40 mph DC now reduced by paint to 1 lane each way. No houses, very few junctions, open views, wtf???

I'd also like to see tiered licencing but that is another argument.

I'd also like to see some sense coming back into the system. In Sweden you can have a NSL SC, to explain it in UK terms, where there is a high ksi rate due to poor overtaking decisions mainly. Road is then dualled and the limit goes up. Here in UK even if the road were dualled, or even a new road built, the limit is always brought down and a camera installed.

FFS!!! I sometimes wonder if the people in charge are able to do those join the dots diagrams, unfortunately I also wonder it about too many of my fellow road users which is the real problem.

/rant=off

Gold Rolex

Original Poster:

38 posts

222 months

Saturday 10th May 2008
quotequote all
Brett928S2 said:
Hi smile

30 mph in Town

Unlimited elsewhere

IMHO....

All the best Brett smile
and would you like that 30 in town to be policed?

Are you wishing me all the best, or some other person called Brett?

Guybrush

4,364 posts

237 months

Saturday 10th May 2008
quotequote all
Gold Rolex said:
Seeing as it's some kind of mantra on here to preach that speed plays no part in any accident, what do people think the speed limits should be on our roads?

Should we even have speed limits at all? Should we try and keep peoples speed down? should we try and reduce the seriousness of injuries in accidents? after all, hitting somebody at 30 mph in a 30 mph zone will result in 80% of the pedestrians living, but hitting them at 40mph in a 30mph zone will result in only 20% of them living... so, should we have speed limits to try and protect innocent people, or should we allow everybody to drive at what ever speed they feel is safe for them?
Study as much of http://www.safespeed.org.uk/ as you can.

sniff petrol

13,128 posts

243 months

Saturday 10th May 2008
quotequote all
F i F said:
I'd also like to see tiered licencing but that is another argument.
Got any ideas on how that would work?

rs1952

5,247 posts

290 months

Saturday 10th May 2008
quotequote all
Gold Rolex said:
the only solution is to have single speed limits for each type of road, which we have right now
scratchchin

Dual carriageways with 30, 40, 50, 60 or NSL

20 or 30 or 40 or 50 in built up and semi built up areas

Limits changing at a county boundary for no obvious reason

We don't even have single NSL! That white circle with a diagonal black band across it means:

60 on SC roads
70 on dual carriageways
70 on motorways

Unless you're driving a van, or a truck, in which case the sign means something else.

And introducing a better system would be confusing? confusedrolleyes

Edited by rs1952 on Saturday 10th May 18:49

Gold Rolex

Original Poster:

38 posts

222 months

Saturday 10th May 2008
quotequote all
Guybrush said:
Gold Rolex said:
Seeing as it's some kind of mantra on here to preach that speed plays no part in any accident, what do people think the speed limits should be on our roads?

Should we even have speed limits at all? Should we try and keep peoples speed down? should we try and reduce the seriousness of injuries in accidents? after all, hitting somebody at 30 mph in a 30 mph zone will result in 80% of the pedestrians living, but hitting them at 40mph in a 30mph zone will result in only 20% of them living... so, should we have speed limits to try and protect innocent people, or should we allow everybody to drive at what ever speed they feel is safe for them?
Study as much of http://www.safespeed.org.uk/ as you can.
Ahhh yes, the site that has been created to put accross the the view that speed does not play a part in ANY accidents. It's not the bible you know

F i F

49,036 posts

282 months

Saturday 10th May 2008
quotequote all
sniff petrol said:
F i F said:
I'd also like to see tiered licencing but that is another argument.
Got any ideas on how that would work?
The short answer is "with difficulty."

The more considered answer would be some reward for taking extra training subject to regular retests and training courses with the ability to display something, special number plates issued only by HMG maybe?

Some discount on tax though not much hope of that with this lot. Likewise some leeway on NSL? Again not much hope with this lot but would be an idea.

The aim is that like it or not a fair proportion of the public is a real one upmanship nation, thus get people taking extra instruction to gain the ability to have a special plate and show the size of one's schlong. (only kidding with that naturally)

Problem is the real problem drivers, ie the do nothing have nothing don't give a sh.. part of the nation might not be motivated because they don't give a sh..

However there are many problems eg what about multiple drivers for a car, one approved one not?

DonnyMac

3,634 posts

234 months

Saturday 10th May 2008
quotequote all
Motorway -
100 mph dry
70 mph wet

Dual Carriagways -
Back to NSL

Urban -
stay as they are during the day
+20 mph 10pm-6am on A roads (lower posted limits around entertainment venues, high streets etc.)

I hate scammeras, but if we must have them limit to urban areas and have the speed limit flash up on them as you're approaching (if you are exceeding) to limit panic breaking of those who are unfamiliar with the area; thus if the speedlimit isn't shown on the unit you don't need to break or take yours eyes off the road where there is a potential black-spot.

Thoughts?


jaf01uk

1,943 posts

227 months

Saturday 10th May 2008
quotequote all
Guam said:
Gold Rolex said:
Guybrush said:
Gold Rolex said:
Seeing as it's some kind of mantra on here to preach that speed plays no part in any accident, what do people think the speed limits should be on our roads?

Should we even have speed limits at all? Should we try and keep peoples speed down? should we try and reduce the seriousness of injuries in accidents? after all, hitting somebody at 30 mph in a 30 mph zone will result in 80% of the pedestrians living, but hitting them at 40mph in a 30mph zone will result in only 20% of them living... so, should we have speed limits to try and protect innocent people, or should we allow everybody to drive at what ever speed they feel is safe for them?
Study as much of http://www.safespeed.org.uk/ as you can.
Ahhh yes, the site that has been created to put accross the the view that speed does not play a part in ANY accidents. It's not the bible you know
Let me borrow this phrase from Plotloss who sums up my feelings perfectly (from your first post you may recall)smile

"Your largely pointless trolling is both tiresome and loathesome".


Cheers


Edited by Guam on Saturday 10th May 19:09
<<----Gold Rolex

Damn you beat me to it, was reading through and just thinking exactly the same myself, heard a reasonable answer to this same question posed to Stirling Moss years ago and his answer was, 2/3's of the vehicles' top speed,
Gary

mark69sheer

3,906 posts

233 months

Sunday 11th May 2008
quotequote all
I am not going to suggest huge increases to speed limits since human nature will push these again.

I would suggest 90mph on motorways but rigidly enforced.

What I would prefer to see rather than an increase in speed limits is active penalising of dawdlers.

Yesterday I was working and it meant driving around on NSL trunk roads from Job to job.

I was extremely frustrated by being held up by sub 40mph drivers leading gaggles of three or four cars.

You would clear one of these groups by overtaking them only to soon catch up to another of the same.

sub 40mph on trunk roads should in the light of increased road congestion and a lack of roadbuilding be as penalised as speeding.