Contract Law - Advice Needed
Contract Law - Advice Needed
Author
Discussion

BMWBen

Original Poster:

4,906 posts

232 months

Monday 12th May 2008
quotequote all
Just need a little advice from people that know regarding formation of a contract.

Situation is:
We saw a house on the market (lettings) that we wanted - move in date 1st June. We paid a deposit and fees (the documentation for which stated a move in date of 1st June) which were subject to references and contract. We have since cancelled our tenancy on the current house, to end on the 1st, ordered furniture, made other payments with regards to moving in. We have negotiated the full tenancy agreement, which was finally decided on saturday, and we have signed our part, but the landlord has yet to sign theirs.

The new landlord has now said that we can't move in until the 20th.

This is really not possible for us, and I foresee this turning nasty given my conversation with the agent.

My understanding would be:
1. We paid fees on the basis of a tenancy agreement that would start on the 1st June. A contract was formed at that point.

2. Regardless of the above, the tenancy agreement was finalised but not signed, and we incurred expenses on it's basis. The contract was therefore formed in law.

Can anyone clarify what our situation is?

Edited by BMWBen on Monday 12th May 19:49

Plotloss

67,280 posts

301 months

Monday 12th May 2008
quotequote all
Full and complete refund of all monies paid.

Find a new house.

Take it from me, if a Landlord is a pain in the arse before taking possession, they're going to be a 'kin nightmare once you've moved in.

If they get stty, try to remain civil, give them all the opportunity you reasonably can for them to make it right, if they still expect to keep some of your cash then a moneyclaim should sort it.

Though if you've got an ex SAS man or a couple of mates with shotguns it doesnt half expedite matters.

BMWBen

Original Poster:

4,906 posts

232 months

Monday 12th May 2008
quotequote all
I know, but to be honest, if this doesn't go through I'm totally fked. It's not going to be possible to find somewhere decent at this notice with our strict requirements to move in on the 1st June.

If the contract was indeed legally formed at the weekend, then we do actually have the right to forcefully take entry I believe...

Plotloss

67,280 posts

301 months

Monday 12th May 2008
quotequote all
It can be done, you just need to find the right agent to facilitate matters.

I saw a flat at 3pm on a Friday. We moved in Saturday morning. The only delay was in getting the bundle of notes converted into a bankers draft as the agent wouldnt take cash.

You've got 18 days, dont be so defeatist!

JustinP1

13,364 posts

261 months

Monday 12th May 2008
quotequote all
BMWBen said:
I know, but to be honest, if this doesn't go through I'm totally fked. It's not going to be possible to find somewhere decent at this notice with our strict requirements to move in on the 1st June.

If the contract was indeed legally formed at the weekend, then we do actually have the right to forcefully take entry I believe...
From what you have said, I don't think you have a legal leg to stand on. As you have mentioned your discussions were subject to references and contract.

You of course could just get your money back, as it was subject to contract, and there is no contract agreed.

That said, if you need to be in on the 1st, I would explain to the agent that unless you can do this you will need to walk away. They in turn should want to get the landlord to change his mind.

If not, get your money back and walk away, and find another place.

BMWBen

Original Poster:

4,906 posts

232 months

Monday 12th May 2008
quotequote all
JustinP1 said:
From what you have said, I don't think you have a legal leg to stand on. As you have mentioned your discussions were subject to references and contract.
Well yes, but both of those have been agreed. We both tabled ammendments to the contract and we signed and posted it before we were contacted and told that they wanted to change the date.

Does the postal rule specifically not apply to tenancy agreements?

The Black Duke

1,642 posts

224 months

Monday 12th May 2008
quotequote all
You say the contract hasn't been signed by the landlord but has the agent signed on behalf of the landlord?

BMWBen

Original Poster:

4,906 posts

232 months

Tuesday 13th May 2008
quotequote all
No unfortunately not - the contract was neogtiated with the landlord, we reached agreement and we signed and posted.

So I guess that it depends whether them agreeing with the tenancy agreement sent to us to sign constitutes an offer.

JustinP1

13,364 posts

261 months

Tuesday 13th May 2008
quotequote all
BMWBen said:
No unfortunately not - the contract was neogtiated with the landlord, we reached agreement and we signed and posted.

So I guess that it depends whether them agreeing with the tenancy agreement sent to us to sign constitutes an offer.
I see your angle.

The difficulty you may have is that I am guessing that there is clearly a space for the landlord to sign. It sounds like the agent has written up the contract and sent it to you to sign two copies? Then the landlord would sign.

It might be argued later that it was implicit in the 'subject to contract' stipulation and the fact that the landlord was not the agent that both parties were aware that there would not be a binding contract until both parties had signed.

Either way it is bad form from the landlord or agent, whoever has messed you around. I would dig my heels in, threaten to walk away, and hope this would bring some action from them. Apart from that, if you really like the place, maybe put your stuff in storage and live out of a case at the local travellodge for three weeks. I would have thought in the circumstances that the landlord if he couldn't house you as agreed would at least make a contribution to the cost.

From his point of view that will probably cost him less than his property standing empty when he looks for another tenant, as you could be in on day one which is pretty rare!

BMWBen

Original Poster:

4,906 posts

232 months

Tuesday 13th May 2008
quotequote all
Yeah I see that as the possible flaw too - advice from the legal team at the missus' place of work is that there was verbal agreement on the written contract, and therefore it was formed when the landlord agreed for the agent to enter the negotiated clauses. We have proof of what was verbally agreed as the contract was then sent to us and we signed it and posted it.

So their advice is if the landlord won't budge, stay in a hotel, put stuff in storage and sue them. :P

Not the best way to start off a tenancy is it...

But we can't really walk away as we've got strict criteria for the new place, we really like the one we've found, and we've only got a couple of weeks if we need to find somewhere else that matches what we need. Given our previous experiences of trying to find suitable places that's just not possible.

Edited by BMWBen on Tuesday 13th May 09:53

Ean218

2,046 posts

281 months

Tuesday 13th May 2008
quotequote all
If the new landlord doesn't immediately change his mind and let you in on the 1st you need to demand your money back and look for another property.

You don't have a leg to stand on legally. Why bother having a written contract that needs signatures of both parties, if you are actually relying on a verbal agreement?

I would also be very surprised if your current landlord did not agree to an extra month's extension to your current lease, if you ask very nicely....

JustinP1

13,364 posts

261 months

Tuesday 13th May 2008
quotequote all
BMWBen said:
Yeah I see that as the possible flaw too - advice from the legal team at the missus' place of work is that there was verbal agreement on the written contract, and therefore it was formed when the landlord agreed for the agent to enter the negotiated clauses. We have proof of what was verbally agreed as the contract was then sent to us and we signed it and posted it.

So their advice is if the landlord won't budge, stay in a hotel, put stuff in storage and sue them. :P

Not the best way to start off a tenancy is it...

But we can't really walk away as we've got strict criteria for the new place, we really like the one we've found, and we've only got a couple of weeks if we need to find somewhere else that matches what we need. Given our previous experiences of trying to find suitable places that's just not possible.

Edited by BMWBen on Tuesday 13th May 09:53
He he...

Solicitor's advice is usually the most legally ballsy but least amicable and practical advice!

IMHO, from what you have said, albeit from not seeing the documents, I would not be as confident as a legal way forward. OK, I see their point, and it could be argued that the landlord or his agent had made an offer, and you had considered and accepted it. However, in practical terms I would not be 100% confident. Either way legal action without informing the landlord of the fact that you were going to run up a considerable bill you would be asking him for may be frowned upon, secondly it may be argued that you should have mitigated your loss by informing him that this is what you were going to do and given him the option of proceeding as planned.

That would be my advice. Put it in writing (so you can prove this later) that you have taken advice that a contract has been formed, you want to be polite and have a good relationship with the landlord, you still want to move in, but unless you can move in on the date planned it will cost you X. You could then give him the choice to reconsider you moving in when planned, give him the option of covering your costs directly, or through reduced rent though the letting period, or let you know that you need to find somewhere else.

Jasandjules

72,694 posts

260 months

Tuesday 13th May 2008
quotequote all
Sorry, land law rules are totally different to contract law rules. I have a very hazy memory of it as I hated land law but unless I am mistaken there is no agreement wrt property until it's been signed on the dotted line.

JustinP1

13,364 posts

261 months

Tuesday 13th May 2008
quotequote all
Jasandjules said:
Sorry, land law rules are totally different to contract law rules. I have a very hazy memory of it as I hated land law but unless I am mistaken there is no agreement wrt property until it's been signed on the dotted line.
Thats right, it is definitely written contracts only for the purchase of land.

Not 100% sure that it applies to letting though.

Edited by JustinP1 on Tuesday 13th May 11:35

BMWBen

Original Poster:

4,906 posts

232 months

Tuesday 13th May 2008
quotequote all
JustinP1 said:
BMWBen said:
Yeah I see that as the possible flaw too - advice from the legal team at the missus' place of work is that there was verbal agreement on the written contract, and therefore it was formed when the landlord agreed for the agent to enter the negotiated clauses. We have proof of what was verbally agreed as the contract was then sent to us and we signed it and posted it.

So their advice is if the landlord won't budge, stay in a hotel, put stuff in storage and sue them. :P

Not the best way to start off a tenancy is it...

But we can't really walk away as we've got strict criteria for the new place, we really like the one we've found, and we've only got a couple of weeks if we need to find somewhere else that matches what we need. Given our previous experiences of trying to find suitable places that's just not possible.

Edited by BMWBen on Tuesday 13th May 09:53
He he...

Solicitor's advice is usually the most legally ballsy but least amicable and practical advice!

IMHO, from what you have said, albeit from not seeing the documents, I would not be as confident as a legal way forward. OK, I see their point, and it could be argued that the landlord or his agent had made an offer, and you had considered and accepted it. However, in practical terms I would not be 100% confident. Either way legal action without informing the landlord of the fact that you were going to run up a considerable bill you would be asking him for may be frowned upon, secondly it may be argued that you should have mitigated your loss by informing him that this is what you were going to do and given him the option of proceeding as planned.

That would be my advice. Put it in writing (so you can prove this later) that you have taken advice that a contract has been formed, you want to be polite and have a good relationship with the landlord, you still want to move in, but unless you can move in on the date planned it will cost you X. You could then give him the choice to reconsider you moving in when planned, give him the option of covering your costs directly, or through reduced rent though the letting period, or let you know that you need to find somewhere else.
True, I think that's probably how we'll proceed. Hopefully the landlord has some sense and will see it as the cheapest option.

SJobson

13,921 posts

295 months

Tuesday 13th May 2008
quotequote all
Something similar happened to me back in 1998 - my g/f and I saw a flat we liked, signed the tenancy agreement, paid the deposit and first month's rent, then waited until the agreed moving in date. We even gave out our new address to people. The agent went quiet - we went round to the flat, knocked on the door and found some other people had actually been allowed to move in, had their own tenancy agreement etc. Ridiculous!

There was obviously no way the landlord or agent could honour our tenancy, no matter that everything was signed and paid for, and that legally our tenancy already existed (commencing about a week away). We did what we had to - got a refund the very same day from the agency (who tried to argue that they could not do this; in the circumstances, where they were at fault, they were glad to find a way to assist us to avoid being sued for more than just a refund).

We found a lovely house (not flat) closer to the tube station and with parking, though, for about the same rent, so it all turned out OK in the end.

BMWBen

Original Poster:

4,906 posts

232 months

Tuesday 13th May 2008
quotequote all
SJobson said:
Something similar happened to me back in 1998 - my g/f and I saw a flat we liked, signed the tenancy agreement, paid the deposit and first month's rent, then waited until the agreed moving in date. We even gave out our new address to people. The agent went quiet - we went round to the flat, knocked on the door and found some other people had actually been allowed to move in, had their own tenancy agreement etc. Ridiculous!

There was obviously no way the landlord or agent could honour our tenancy, no matter that everything was signed and paid for, and that legally our tenancy already existed (commencing about a week away). We did what we had to - got a refund the very same day from the agency (who tried to argue that they could not do this; in the circumstances, where they were at fault, they were glad to find a way to assist us to avoid being sued for more than just a refund).

We found a lovely house (not flat) closer to the tube station and with parking, though, for about the same rent, so it all turned out OK in the end.
Wow, that kinda puts my current problems into perspective!

RichBurley

2,432 posts

284 months

Wednesday 14th May 2008
quotequote all
To the OP: The other half's legal term are full of crap. If you took this matter to the Court, a District Judge would say you are wasting their time. The Contract has not been signed by the owner or the agent, so there is no binding contract.

Best bet is to negotiate to the 1st of possible, and then decide if you want to seek a refund etc. How much more expensive than 20 days of house rental, would 20 days in a local B&B be?


SJobson

13,921 posts

295 months

Wednesday 14th May 2008
quotequote all
BMWBen said:
SJobson said:
Something similar happened to me back in 1998 - my g/f and I saw a flat we liked, signed the tenancy agreement, paid the deposit and first month's rent, then waited until the agreed moving in date. We even gave out our new address to people. The agent went quiet - we went round to the flat, knocked on the door and found some other people had actually been allowed to move in, had their own tenancy agreement etc. Ridiculous!

There was obviously no way the landlord or agent could honour our tenancy, no matter that everything was signed and paid for, and that legally our tenancy already existed (commencing about a week away). We did what we had to - got a refund the very same day from the agency (who tried to argue that they could not do this; in the circumstances, where they were at fault, they were glad to find a way to assist us to avoid being sued for more than just a refund).

We found a lovely house (not flat) closer to the tube station and with parking, though, for about the same rent, so it all turned out OK in the end.
Wow, that kinda puts my current problems into perspective!
Sorry I didn't provide an answer though! No matter what the legal rights and wrongs are (and I believe they're in your favour, though I would run Mr Burley's argument if I were the landlord), you haven't got time to go sueing anyone. Find somewhere else and get everything you've paid back off them a.s.a.p.

JustinP1

13,364 posts

261 months

Wednesday 14th May 2008
quotequote all
SJobson said:
BMWBen said:
SJobson said:
Something similar happened to me back in 1998 - my g/f and I saw a flat we liked, signed the tenancy agreement, paid the deposit and first month's rent, then waited until the agreed moving in date. We even gave out our new address to people. The agent went quiet - we went round to the flat, knocked on the door and found some other people had actually been allowed to move in, had their own tenancy agreement etc. Ridiculous!

There was obviously no way the landlord or agent could honour our tenancy, no matter that everything was signed and paid for, and that legally our tenancy already existed (commencing about a week away). We did what we had to - got a refund the very same day from the agency (who tried to argue that they could not do this; in the circumstances, where they were at fault, they were glad to find a way to assist us to avoid being sued for more than just a refund).

We found a lovely house (not flat) closer to the tube station and with parking, though, for about the same rent, so it all turned out OK in the end.
Wow, that kinda puts my current problems into perspective!
Sorry I didn't provide an answer though! No matter what the legal rights and wrongs are (and I believe they're in your favour, though I would run Mr Burley's argument if I were the landlord), you haven't got time to go sueing anyone. Find somewhere else and get everything you've paid back off them a.s.a.p.
I agree.

Legal action should be the final, final option if all else fails - just like a solicitor to advocate it as an opening gambit!

As I mentioned before, the legal argument for action is shaky at very very best. In to take action successfully anyway you would have had to put the situation in writing and how it has affected you and the costs involved.

If he has any heart or is a decent businessman with the right knowledge he might change his mind, or offer a discount off the first months rent for the inconvenience. After all, he is in the same financial position if he has to wait a month for another tenant anyway.