Why do they do it (the Police that is)
Why do they do it (the Police that is)
TOPIC CLOSED
TOPIC CLOSED
Author
Discussion

NIKAIYO

Original Poster:

35 posts

229 months

Tuesday 13th May 2008
quotequote all
The initial message has been deleted from this topic.

Plotloss

67,280 posts

301 months

Tuesday 13th May 2008
quotequote all
Well firstly a copper doesnt need any reason to stop you whatsoever.

But you should have just said 'Its a limit, not a target' and remained civil and trite.

Seems to work for them.

10 Pence Short

32,880 posts

248 months

Tuesday 13th May 2008
quotequote all
Better that a real officer is able to stop people and breathalyse them than just have cameras which won't catch them.

I don't see what your problem is? Apart from the "do you know who I am" sized chip on your shoulder.

Let the PC get on with her job instead of dealing with petty complaints from people who should be glad the Police are out there doing their job.


Mr Trophy

6,811 posts

234 months

Tuesday 13th May 2008
quotequote all
Why do people have such a problem about getting stopped? Fair enough it can take 5 to 10 minutes out of your time. However there only doing their job.

In Tua Nua

71 posts

230 months

Tuesday 13th May 2008
quotequote all
So the police are doing their job and you disagree with it?

jdw1234

6,021 posts

246 months

Tuesday 13th May 2008
quotequote all
With the utmost respect.

If you lose your temper, anyone is bound to dig their heels in.

From other thread you will notice that I got stopped (I feel unfairly).

At no point did I lose temper or talk down to policeman. Its just not worth it.

From the officer's point of view, you could have been over the drink drive limit or on drugs and trying to drive home extra carefully.

I wouldn't take offence for a random pull, especially if late at night.

P.S. I got pulled over once, purely so a trainee officer could do a breathtest!!

Robatr0n

12,362 posts

247 months

Tuesday 13th May 2008
quotequote all
I agree with everyones responses here so far.

Fortunately (touch wood) I have yet to be stopped by the police but if I was to be pulled over I would have absolutely no issue with them doing their job. Perhaps if you hadn't of failed the attitude test she wouldn't have accused you of driving erratically! rolleyes

As someone highlighted above, would you rather have cameras monitoring your every movement or an actual police officer using their judgement instead?

Jasandjules

72,694 posts

260 months

Tuesday 13th May 2008
quotequote all
I've been stopped for driving AT the speed limit - apparantly it's suspicious when people do, they think there must be a problem with the car/you've just nicked something etc..

Funny world, isn't it...

will_

6,035 posts

234 months

Tuesday 13th May 2008
quotequote all
I got stopped a few times in my youth driving late at night/early morning and quite right too. I'd rather spend 5 minutes having a chat with plod than have the police being too scared of a harrassment claim to stop anyone.

HRG

72,863 posts

270 months

Tuesday 13th May 2008
quotequote all
Good job you never had a FSIEwink

andy400

11,853 posts

262 months

Tuesday 13th May 2008
quotequote all
Not sure I'd be very upset if I was stopped in the same circumstances, can't really see the problem.

Mg6b

6,649 posts

294 months

Tuesday 13th May 2008
quotequote all
Out late at night. Did your dad know?

Grow up. Stop throwing your toys about!

Getting your dad to make a complaint for you.... rolleyes

Chrispy Porker

17,763 posts

259 months

Tuesday 13th May 2008
quotequote all
Jasandjules said:
I've been stopped for driving AT the speed limit - apparantly it's suspicious when people do, they think there must be a problem with the car/you've just nicked something etc..

Funny world, isn't it...
Often the only people driving at 28MPH in the small hours are drunks, trying not to be noticed.

andmole

1,594 posts

242 months

Tuesday 13th May 2008
quotequote all
The OP behaved like a tit, no doubt about it.

However, the BiB concerned was asked to provide their name and number, and REFUSED!!!!

How often are we told that if we have nothing to hide we have nothing to fear?

What did the BiB in question have to hide?

Refusal to provide the information requested should be grounds for complaint in itself, even if there were no other grounds for complaint, (as in this case).

And now I await the ill informed flaming from posters who can't be bothered to read my posts carefully, and think carefully about the details I have mentioned. The sort of response that has caused me to virtually withdraw from posting anywhere on PH.

Dwight VanDriver

6,583 posts

275 months

Tuesday 13th May 2008
quotequote all
By your own admission you were

committing a moving traffic offence (35 in a 30)

which gave Plod the legal excuse to demand a specimen of your breath.

Name dropping (QC and foreign royalty) does not impress.

dvd

Edited by Dwight VanDriver on Tuesday 13th May 14:20

XMG5

1,082 posts

258 months

Tuesday 13th May 2008
quotequote all
NIKAIYO said:
I was doing some freelance work last night, and was driving home at about 1am. I looked in my rear view mirror and noticed a Police Fiesta pulling across a roundabout and onto the road I was travelling on.
When I noticed the police car I check my speed, about 35mph in a 30 limit, as I was going up a steep hill I eased off the gas to just under 30 and proceeded on my way safe in the knowledge that I was under the limit.
The police car speed up on joining the road cruised about 2meters off my bumper and stopped me at the next bus stop.
So I am thinking, oops bulb gone or something. No she stopped me because I was driving to slowly for the road so that gave her reasonable suspicion that I had committed an offence! I asked her what speed she had registered me doing her response 28mph!!
This kind of made me mad :-(. She said she was going to breathalyse me (not a problem as I had not been drinking I work for the Saudi Royal Family so I don’t drink a lot) this made me really loose my temper.
I demanded that she wrote down her name and number, the exact reason she had stopped me so that in future when I drove up the road above the speed limit and was stopped I would be able to prove that I was simply trying to avoid harassment. She refused.
She again insisted that I was breathalysed, again I asked her to justify why she had stopped me, and she changed her story that my driving was erratic. So I complied and was negative. I will be making a formal complaint against her, my father is a QC so will get him to do it, should get a written apology I hope.

So back to title, why? I am a law abiding member of society, I am "middle class" have never been in trouble with the police yet because of the way we are now policed I do not trust them, do not respect them in fact I have no time for them what so ever.
Look at how the Afro Caribbean community feel about the BIB, now translate that to all of us who drive a car. Good luck in the future because boy you are going to need it.

P.S Even in Saudi the police do not stop people for NOT breaking the law.
I think the fuse in this account was relating the reason for the 'Stop' to the poster's speed, or lack of it. Speed has become the focal point of the government, Road Safety Panels, BiB (perceived and debatable I know) and Scamera Partnerships. It is the justification for scameras and revenue gathering on an unprecedented and irreversible scale.

Rightly or wrongly it's a subject likely to generate a heated debate over the quality of policing in this country and the police will continue to attract the bad press for the seemingly relentless pursuit (pun not intended) of the speeding public.

BiB and government better get dug in, it's going to be a v-e-r-y l-o-n-g programme of restoring faith and credibility to the policing of the UK.

Whether or not the police agree that they have a problem is irrelevant as they stood by, at the highest levels, and watched the government and self serving activists neuter law and order over recent decades.

Had the officer in the above example been able to point out any moving traffic offence as justification for requiring a breath sample, with appropriate explanation, I suggest the poster may have been inclined to cooperate. But speed as a trigger for the BT was a trigger for the "is that all you deal with" response. Understandable and one the BiB will have to learn to accept. It's the result of ineffectual policing by unseen BiB's to blame.

if you want someone to blame, blame ACPO for p*ss poor support in pursuit of their own ambitions. Blame the government for sticking their fat grubby fingers into matters they have no understanding of, blame the activists for having the power to turn the Justice System to cr*p over the last 2-3 decades because Society took their eye off the ball and let Politically Correct 'reform' spread like cancer through every walk of life. BUT don't blame those of us for the p*ss poor service we encounter. And NO it isn't always a forgone conclusion that we are to blame through attitude or prejudice.

Sorry lads but sometimes, the service really is p*ss poor. Blaming it on our attitude towards you as a stock answer is not the answer nor is it likely to restore our faith and much needed co-operation in the future.

Edited for clarity.

Edited by XMG5 on Tuesday 13th May 14:33

^Slider^

2,874 posts

280 months

Tuesday 13th May 2008
quotequote all
andmole said:
The OP behaved like a tit, no doubt about it.

However, the BiB concerned was asked to provide their name and number, and REFUSED!!!!

How often are we told that if we have nothing to hide we have nothing to fear?

What did the BiB in question have to hide?

Refusal to provide the information requested should be grounds for complaint in itself, even if there were no other grounds for complaint, (as in this case).

And now I await the ill informed flaming from posters who can't be bothered to read my posts carefully, and think carefully about the details I have mentioned. The sort of response that has caused me to virtually withdraw from posting anywhere on PH.
From what i have read, the OP refused to provide a specimin of breath untill the officer provided details.

When the requirement is made it is required then and there, not "i wanna speak to by solicitor first or i want your details first"

I would have done similar given the curcs as it is a delaying tactic for some drink drivers.

However if requested then they should be given, even after the breath sample.

Sometimes the person stopped can make it difficult. Had he just given the sample and requested the details i am sure they would have been provided. Arguing the toss when the requirement is made is not a good idea.

Personally if i require a specimin of breath and they refuse or argue the toss then ill just arrest them for fail or refuse to provide.

TTwiggy

11,884 posts

235 months

Tuesday 13th May 2008
quotequote all
while I can understand why the OP has failed to garner much support on here, the fact remains that there are times when it does seem to be a personal vendetter out there. I had a case in point last night. Driving back from seeing my mum, I was enjoying some roof down motoring in the the Elise. I came to a mini roundabout where ther was a plod (non-traffic) car indicating to turn right, and I had the right of way to pass it. As I did so, I noticed (perhaps becasue I'm suspicious) that the indicator suddenly changed to 'left' and after that I 'enjoyed' the personal attention of this police car all the way to the turn-off for my block of flats.

This was at 10.30pm (so hardly unusual hours), I look old enough (sadly) to own the car I drive and I don't think they would really need 2 miles to get a pnc check completed.

Did it make me froth at the mouth with anger? No. In fact I would not have posted this if it was not for the OP's tale.

Did it make me raise my eyes to the heavens in a 'dear god lads, that was a predictable move' way - yes...

NIKAIYO

Original Poster:

35 posts

229 months

Tuesday 13th May 2008
quotequote all
10 Pence Short said:
Better that a real officer is able to stop people and breathalyse them than just have cameras which won't catch them.

I don't see what your problem is? Apart from the "do you know who I am" sized chip on your shoulder.

Let the PC get on with her job instead of dealing with petty complaints from people who should be glad the Police are out there doing their job.
Really I don’t have a "do you know who I am" sized chip on my shoulder. I see that all day every day and i cant stand it, if i go out for a meal and my food is cold, I tell the waiter its fine. If you think by my orig post I am some stuck up little rich boy.... way off the mark.
The general argument from those responding seems to be that if you are out late at night, you might have something to hide so getting stopped for NO reason is ok.... I thought this was a free country. The polices job is NOT to interfere with random law abiding citizens because they MAY have committed on offence!

What I can’t reconcile is the messages we are being sent... going over the limit is bad and must be punished.
Driving under the limit marks you out as a potential criminal!
I just can’t think of any other situation where not breaking the law is reason to be stopped by the police.

I have the suspicion that most of the responses so far are from BIB.

And in response to the 1st reply :
Part 1 of the Police and Criminal Evidence Act 1984 (PACE) empowers any constable acting with reasonable grounds for suspicion to stop, detain and search you or your vehicle, or anything in or on your vehicle for certain items, which may be seized.


OperationAlfa

2,014 posts

228 months

Tuesday 13th May 2008
quotequote all
I was stopped a couple of weeks ago.. young guy (22) high performance car... just a routine check..

Didn't bother me at all.. Nice gents city police. smile
TOPIC CLOSED
TOPIC CLOSED