Any Idea what is going on here?
Any Idea what is going on here?
Author
Discussion

s2art

Original Poster:

18,942 posts

284 months

satchbot

1,916 posts

227 months

Thursday 15th May 2008
quotequote all
He was tagged for a fairly serious bit of bad driving.

And? confused

s2art

Original Poster:

18,942 posts

284 months

Thursday 15th May 2008
quotequote all
satchbot said:
He was tagged for a fairly serious bit of bad driving.

And? confused
AFAICT he wasnt driving badly, just failing to report an accident that had already been reported. Anyway when are people tagged for bad driving?

satchbot

1,916 posts

227 months

Thursday 15th May 2008
quotequote all
If you're involved in an accident YOU have to stop and provide your details to anyone who has reasonable cause to have them.

He failed to do this and obviously the magistrates have taken a very dim view on his antics.

Fantango

208 posts

222 months

Thursday 15th May 2008
quotequote all
it doesn't state what part he played, but he should have stopped and given details if involved.

s2art

Original Poster:

18,942 posts

284 months

Thursday 15th May 2008
quotequote all
satchbot said:
If you're involved in an accident YOU have to stop and provide your details to anyone who has reasonable cause to have them.

He failed to do this and obviously the magistrates have taken a very dim view on his antics.
AFAICT he didnt have an accident. Just didnt report one.

Hooli

32,278 posts

231 months

Thursday 15th May 2008
quotequote all
he was bloody daft not to exchange details & got punished. the fact he served in the army 300years ago has no bearing on it.

mattley

3,039 posts

253 months

Friday 16th May 2008
quotequote all
s2art said:
Any Idea what is going on here?
Er no:?

Typical poor half reporting from the BBC, and pretty poor legal advice if he had actually confirmed with a witness that 999 had been dialed. It also seems strange that he could drive away from an accident that was so severe the victim suffered life threatening injuries.

I wonder if he pulled out on another veichle or similar and unwittingly caused another car to crash, once he'd confirmed that the emergency services had been called he just drove off assuming that as his car hadn't been hit he wasn't involved in the accident.

It's happened to me, I was in the OS lane of an otherwise empty DC because a car was at a juction and obviously if I move into the OS lane the other car can join the DC safely. I watched him pull onto the DC and then without any acceleration straight into the OS lane right in front of me. I braked hard and swerved violently into the NS lane, lost it, bounced of the NS kerb and ended up facing him bonnet to bonnet, that's how slowly he was going. I was fine and gave him the palms up WTF gesture and he just reversed a few feet moved into the NS cariageway and just drove off. Having looked him in the eye just after the accident and again as he drove past me I swear he had no idea he'd just caused a serious crash.


Whatever actually happened that last paragraph as a justification for the sentance is just bizarre when the offender is seventy something.


Burrow01

1,989 posts

223 months

Friday 16th May 2008
quotequote all
Quotes from the BBC

The family of the woman involved in the accident, who suffered life-threatening injuries, said they did not think the sentence was lenient.

So it sounds like he did something fairly serious.

Cannot understand this part though, for a pensioner....

"Curfews introduce regularity into what are often chaotic lifestyles. They enhance supervision and can disrupt the pattern of offending behaviour."

Sounds like a standard line for a teenager


streaky

19,311 posts

280 months

Friday 16th May 2008
quotequote all
This is Bristol said:
A great grandfather, aged 73, is believed to have become the oldest person in Bristol to be fitted with an electronic tag.

A judge has ordered veteran soldier Peter Ogden not to leave his home in Stockwood between 4pm and 11pm for the next three months.

Mr Ogden had only been expecting to be punished with points on his driving licence and a small fine after he admitted failing to report a road accident.

But the curfew imposed by a district judge means the former Grenadier Guard will be forced to miss a Regimental Remembrance Day march in London later this month and Saturday night mass at St Bernadette's Church in Whitchurch.

The electronic tag has been fitted to Mr Ogden's leg so his movements can be monitored. If he is away from home during his curfew, he could face arrest.

The pensioner believes the punishment, which he received on top of a one-year driving ban, does not fit his crime.

Mr Ogden, a father of three married to Sylvia, said: "The tag means I won't even be allowed into my garden. It all sounds so crazy when I've never been in trouble before.

"I'm being made to feel like a major criminal. If I went out and stabbed someone I would probably walk out of court with a suspended sentence. I'm astounded. At my age, this sentence only makes me want to defy the law.

"This is going to cause major upset. It's well over the top for what appears to be a minor offence and I want to embarrass the system and the people concerned."

Mr Ogden says he arrived at the scene of an accident in Durley Hill, Keynsham, as he travelled home following a night out on November 25 last year.

Although he noticed a woman injured at the side of the road, he believed he was not involved and says he only drove away after confirming with another witness that she had dialled 999.

Police arrested Mr Ogden, who suffers from memory loss and heart problems, and impounded his car after he voluntarily visited a police station the next day to check if the victim was OK.

Forensic tests on Mr Ogden's red Daewoo Nexia, which was held by police for 55 days, revealed it had come into contact with the injured woman. But Mr Ogden insists he was not aware of the collision, which is believed to have taken place after the pedestrian stepped out into the road and was initially struck by the vehicle travelling in front of Mr Ogden's.

The victim, thought to be in her mid 20s, suffered life-threatening injuries but was discharged from hospital earlier this year.

It is understood that no charges were brought against any of the drivers involved apart from Mr Ogden. Following four appearances at Bath Magistrates' Court, Mr Ogden was finally sentenced on Friday by District Judge David Parsons for failing to report a road accident. An earlier charge of failing to stop for an accident was dismissed.

The judge took into account that Mr Ogden accepted he was returning from an ex-serviceman's club where he had had a drink, although he was not drunk. He also noted that the pensioner only contacted police the following day after he was advised to by his priest.

Mr Ogden, who spent more than 50 years working in the flooring industry in Bristol, says he left the scene of the accident to allow the emergency services more room.

He said: "When I was arrested it was the worst day of my life. My wife does very little driving and is not in the best of health. Now she will have to do all the driving. She is disgusted by the whole thing."

Mr Ogden says he will now ask the courts to remove the tag because he suffers from eczema and dermatitis and claims the device is worsening his condition.

The pensioner's solicitor has lodged an appeal against the driving ban, but not the tagging and curfew.

Mr Ogden, a member of the Grenadier Guards Association, is thought to be one of the oldest people in the country to be wearing an electronic tag. He follows a 75-year-old man from North Wales who was ordered to wear a tag for two months in 2004 after being convicted of drink-driving.

In May last year, an 82-year-old man from Stockton-on-Tees was electronically tagged after being caught driving while disqualified twice in the space of seven weeks.
Streaky

Chrispy Porker

17,763 posts

259 months

Friday 16th May 2008
quotequote all
He was on local telly last night moaning because he could not do his gardening FFS.
Here's an idea mate.
Do it before 4.00pm.
I have no sympathy, Sorry.

Jasandjules

72,695 posts

260 months

Friday 16th May 2008
quotequote all
He effectively failed to stop at a serious accident.

So he shouldn't get away with it - it's old people with the reaction times of a p***ed snail who need to be better drivers IMHO. WOuld like to know the circs of the accident though.

DSM2

3,624 posts

231 months

Friday 16th May 2008
quotequote all
Hooli said:
he was bloody daft not to exchange details & got punished. the fact he served in the army 300years ago has no bearing on it.
Yeah, the punishment really fits the crime doesn't it? FFS!

Chrispy Porker

17,763 posts

259 months

Friday 16th May 2008
quotequote all
DSM2 said:
Hooli said:
he was bloody daft not to exchange details & got punished. the fact he served in the army 300years ago has no bearing on it.
Yeah, the punishment really fits the crime doesn't it? FFS!
Well if the punishment keeps him from driving home from the legion after he's had a drink, it would seem appropriate to me.

s2art

Original Poster:

18,942 posts

284 months

Friday 16th May 2008
quotequote all
Chrispy Porker said:
DSM2 said:
Hooli said:
he was bloody daft not to exchange details & got punished. the fact he served in the army 300years ago has no bearing on it.
Yeah, the punishment really fits the crime doesn't it? FFS!
Well if the punishment keeps him from driving home from the legion after he's had a drink, it would seem appropriate to me.
It seems completely bizarre. The accident had been reported by someone else, he wasnt drunk, he wasnt the driver who had the initial accident, no-one else prosecuted etc etc.
It appears the 'forensic evidence' was some DNA on his car (which showed no signs of damage) which matched the girl who had been hit.
Something really strange with this one.

Number 7

4,113 posts

293 months

Friday 16th May 2008
quotequote all
So its reasonable to assume that he wasn't the driver to have first contact with the victim. What have the BIB done to trace the real culprit, because this just looks like the easy option yet again?

I'd also suggest he received poor advice if it was to plead guilty.

7.

Chrispy Porker

17,763 posts

259 months

Friday 16th May 2008
quotequote all
Number 7 said:
So its reasonable to assume that he wasn't the driver to have first contact with the victim. What have the BIB done to trace the real culprit, because this just looks like the easy option yet again?

I'd also suggest he received poor advice if it was to plead guilty.

7.
They did as much as anyone could in the circumstances.
This was a serious accident that took place within yards of my house.
Please explain how this is the easy option.

Mr_annie_vxr

9,270 posts

242 months

Friday 16th May 2008
quotequote all
Number 7 said:
So its reasonable to assume that he wasn't the driver to have first contact with the victim. What have the BIB done to trace the real culprit, because this just looks like the easy option yet again?

I'd also suggest he received poor advice if it was to plead guilty.

7.
I think he was not drunk when they spoke with him, reading between the lines on this one (the fact he was not spoken with until some time after the crash, that he left the scene having made contact with the injured person and that he had ben drinking in the club) I would guess based on experience the view of the officers was that matey boy may well have been over the limit at the time of the crash.

The actual rtc it appears was investigated and no other charges brought, however this chap hit the victim again possibly due to his bad memory or heart condition or another factor. It would appear he caused the most injuries alhough another person indeed the victim may have caused the crash.


We don't have al the facts. I doubt the family of the girl would be so angry at the lenient punishment if all he did was not stop.

All guess work... Although odd that he would plead guilty.

s2art

Original Poster:

18,942 posts

284 months

Friday 16th May 2008
quotequote all
Chrispy Porker said:
Number 7 said:
So its reasonable to assume that he wasn't the driver to have first contact with the victim. What have the BIB done to trace the real culprit, because this just looks like the easy option yet again?

I'd also suggest he received poor advice if it was to plead guilty.

7.
They did as much as anyone could in the circumstances.
This was a serious accident that took place within yards of my house.
Please explain how this is the easy option.
Superficially it looks like someone being heavily punished for a minor
technical transgression (not even sure if is that if he confirmed with someone that 999 had been called, what is the legal position?).
I still do not understand the tagging, what for?

Number 7

4,113 posts

293 months

Friday 16th May 2008
quotequote all
Chrispy Porker said:
Number 7 said:
So its reasonable to assume that he wasn't the driver to have first contact with the victim. What have the BIB done to trace the real culprit, because this just looks like the easy option yet again?

I'd also suggest he received poor advice if it was to plead guilty.

7.
They did as much as anyone could in the circumstances.
This was a serious accident that took place within yards of my house.
Please explain how this is the easy option.
In none of the reports that I've read does it even mention that BIB were interested in any other driver, let alone trying to find one. If it was such a serious accident, which it appears to have been given that the victim was in hospital for at least a month, and given that there was at least 1 other witness, I would have thought (expected actually) that there would be some mention of an investigation or attempt to find the other driver. But there seems to be none. Either there was no other driver, in which case this guy should have been charged with more than failing to report, or there was another driver, but its too difficult to investigate, especially since they already have a fall-guy.

7.